PVP and newbies - What to do?
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I like the idea of a new account being flagged for so long (10hrs was mentioned)
But I'd go with 24hrs and a warning message at intervals, when the account is created they get a message saying (You have created a new account, you will be shielded from player killing for 24hrs, if you attack someone during this 24hr period you will lose your shield)
Then a reminder at 12hrs that they have 12hrs before they lose their shield
Then a final 1hr reminded that shield will drop
I know someone will say, well people will just create a new account and transfer their alts to it to be protected
Easy fix, make it so a new account still shielded from nopk cant not transfer or recieve transfers from other accounts.
Problem solved. 24hrs is plenty of time for them to learn how the world works and with the warning messages at the intervals, they cant say they weren't warned.
I love this.
All the people that have played for 24 hundred hours will still cry about being pked. its part of the game, but its really not if you don't pk. people don't understand that other people like to pk. its what I used to enjoy before I left. it was one of the only reasons I joined the game to begin with. what fun is it to just pve in a game with 30 people online, with no feeling of risk that you might be attacked or anything. I guess ill never understand.
Im with these ideas I have already mentioned:
The level difference one (10 as Thi suggested seems good or the you can only get pk'd from 16th onwards from Folder. Esp, since as NH pointed out the best healing spell for level 15 is Jurgen).
With the level difference idea. There could be a way to make it work without being exploited... sorta.
Make it so that you cannot use any abilities on someone out of the level range.
/nopk is also a good idea (from Metzger) but I would suggest making it so that they gain less exp (since there is less danger for them - think arenas).
A cooling of period is also a good idea (not sure if this one was mentioned specifically, if not it is an adaptation of KILLA's maximum amount of times a person can be pk'd idea... or was it the pk'er can only kill x amount of time a day? meh whatever). Basically a person can only be pkd once an hour (or some such) then their immune (god protects blah blah message maybe).
The level difference one (10 as Thi suggested seems good or the you can only get pk'd from 16th onwards from Folder. Esp, since as NH pointed out the best healing spell for level 15 is Jurgen).
With the level difference idea. There could be a way to make it work without being exploited... sorta.
Make it so that you cannot use any abilities on someone out of the level range.
/nopk is also a good idea (from Metzger) but I would suggest making it so that they gain less exp (since there is less danger for them - think arenas).
A cooling of period is also a good idea (not sure if this one was mentioned specifically, if not it is an adaptation of KILLA's maximum amount of times a person can be pk'd idea... or was it the pk'er can only kill x amount of time a day? meh whatever). Basically a person can only be pkd once an hour (or some such) then their immune (god protects blah blah message maybe).
It's already been changed to lvl16 before you can be PKd and I think it was a pretty good compromise. Any more cessations and Killa is 100% right the game feels dull.
It's already been changed to lvl16 before you can be PKd and I think it was a pretty good compromise. Any more cessations and Killa is 100% right the game feels dull.
I agree, most of us won't pk people over and over without some reason and I wouldnt want to see restrictions other then nopk level 16 and under. For arguments sake lets say a level 17 is sitting on your space waiting for you to kill Mendel so he can steal your drop. You can't attack him cause he's out of your range, what do you do to get rid of the ninja looter?
It's already been changed to lvl16 before you can be PKd and I think it was a pretty good compromise. Any more cessations and Killa is 100% right the game feels dull.
I agree, most of us won't pk people over and over without some reason and I wouldnt want to see restrictions other then nopk level 16 and under. For arguments sake lets say a level 17 is sitting on your space waiting for you to kill Mendel so he can steal your drop. You can't attack him cause he's out of your range, what do you do to get rid of the ninja looter?
Drop stealing is a good point. That could be exploited now by 15th level alts. Although it is more problematic with random spawn times and stuff.
Not sure that drop stealing would be much of an issue, but maybe who knows. The game needs PK action is more my point. We can't all hold hands and be carebears all day.
Not sure that drop stealing would be much of an issue, but maybe who knows. The game needs PK action is more my point. We can't all hold hands and be carebears all day.
I do not have a problem with pking, but some people apparently do, and I think the 3 options I listed are the better ones. Drop stealing however complicates things. I do not mind drop stealing either, but it sure would be annoying if I couldn't do anything about it because of their level.
It worked in rok just fine.
If you don't want to be PKed, lvl in the safety of arenas.
Problem solved.
If you don't want to be PKed, lvl in the safety of arenas.
Problem solved.
It worked in rok just fine.
If you don't want to be PKed, lvl in the safety of arenas.
Problem solved.
Exactly..and drop the pk level back to 9. People need to harden up.
It worked in rok just fine.
If you don't want to be PKed, lvl in the safety of arenas.
Problem solved.
Exactly..and drop the pk level back to 9. People need to harden up.
Worked when everyone was 12 and there was enough people to deal with this, plus having a guardian character alt really helped things go by.
If you guys can't come up with anything better, then it's staying at the moment. Regardless, we lost alot of new players because of it. You can say 'fuck em' and whatnot, but they are important to the survival of the game.
It worked in rok just fine.
If you don't want to be PKed, lvl in the safety of arenas.
Problem solved.
Exactly..and drop the pk level back to 9. People need to harden up.
Worked when everyone was 12 and there was enough people to deal with this, plus having a guardian character alt really helped things go by.
If you guys can't come up with anything better, then it's staying at the moment. Regardless, we lost alot of new players because of it. You can say 'fuck em' and whatnot, but they are important to the survival of the game.
What about some more NPCs out of town that advise players to level in the safety of town guards and offer safe passage rides to the next town? Maybe that can be provided for the low and medium level areas.
And perhaps lower the exp needed for the lower levels.
Yea I feel like the solution we have keeps new players somewhat safe while only limiting pking a bit. I wouldn't mind maybe lowering it to say 12-13 instead of 16 but that's just me.
Yea I feel like the solution we have keeps new players somewhat safe while only limiting pking a bit. I wouldn't mind maybe lowering it to say 12-13 instead of 16 but that's just me.
I mean the first 15 levels is pretty much nothing though. If you base it off their time in game it's probably 2-3% of their whole leveling time. That's a newbies time either, I'm pretty sure a vet can get to level 15 in a couple hours. It's only about 2.5-3.5mil EXP, they still have an average of 295-315mil where they can die.
To me the EXP is already pretty low though overall.
Just my 2 gold here.
I seldom play this game, mainly because I don't really have the time.
I made a crit the other day and leveled it up to 5 or 6 before I said fuck it and did something else with my time. I don't s ee myself putting in hours of repetitive grinding to not even get close to having a high level character... The dilemma here is that 25ers shouldn't be a cakewalk to have either.
But if I had to guess, the whole process of spending hours and hours doing the same exact thing over and over again is what makes non-RoKers leave. Like you said, one of are 12.
The solution? Maybe have other ways to level up besides hitting the same monsters ove and over again. Perhaps some little quests that give exp and gear. Idk if you guys are already doing that or not, I didn't make it that far.
I seldom play this game, mainly because I don't really have the time.
I made a crit the other day and leveled it up to 5 or 6 before I said fuck it and did something else with my time. I don't s ee myself putting in hours of repetitive grinding to not even get close to having a high level character... The dilemma here is that 25ers shouldn't be a cakewalk to have either.
But if I had to guess, the whole process of spending hours and hours doing the same exact thing over and over again is what makes non-RoKers leave. Like you said, one of are 12.
The solution? Maybe have other ways to level up besides hitting the same monsters ove and over again. Perhaps some little quests that give exp and gear. Idk if you guys are already doing that or not, I didn't make it that far.
There's a ton of quests to do man. Of course they are mostly mob killing but they serve as good mini distractions. If you lack any interest in the game it will seem dull no matter what though, can't really fix that.
Skimming through the various suggestions here i think what can be done relatively quickly that would help:
- New Account "No PK" flag, for up to 24 hours. This will help new players to survive a bit until they learn their stuff
- More NPC interactions warning of the dangers of PKs.
- lvl 15 immunity to exp loss and item loss, specifically from PK kills.
Anything more.. and we start getting into the "soft kitty" part.
- New Account "No PK" flag, for up to 24 hours. This will help new players to survive a bit until they learn their stuff
- More NPC interactions warning of the dangers of PKs.
- lvl 15 immunity to exp loss and item loss, specifically from PK kills.
Anything more.. and we start getting into the "soft kitty" part.
Yea even though this is already in I think something that would help would be not allowing items to drop off characters up to level 16 or whatever the protection level is. I think it's somewhat of a problem seeing no one has money at those lower levels to an stuff (I get the starter equip is bound but anything good you find after usually isn't)
Yea even though this is already in I think something that would help would be not allowing items to drop off characters up to level 16 or whatever the protection level is. I think it's somewhat of a problem seeing no one has money at those lower levels to an stuff (I get the starter equip is bound but anything good you find after usually isn't)
We should raise the SB'd gear to level 15 stuff at least on stores.
Level 1-15 store bought = SB.
Level 1-8 monster drops = SB.
Not level 15 monster drops. They need to learn sometime. By level 16+ you should be making enough gold.
Random idea; not sure how practical it is in implementation.
How about making all shop bought gear come unsb'd.
However all items 15th level or lower (maybe just white items) on a 15th level or lower alt will not drop. Does that make sense?
Basically Alts <= level 15 will not lose <= 15th level gear (could include potions and foods etc, maybe not gold?).
Or is this too care bear?
Eh... wait... Jadefalcon already said something similar...
How about making all shop bought gear come unsb'd.
However all items 15th level or lower (maybe just white items) on a 15th level or lower alt will not drop. Does that make sense?
Basically Alts <= level 15 will not lose <= 15th level gear (could include potions and foods etc, maybe not gold?).
Or is this too care bear?
Eh... wait... Jadefalcon already said something similar...