Bard/Minstrel Mechanics
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Rogue - Bard - Minstrel
Requirements: 16 Str, 12 Int, 16 Agi, 16 Chr
Experience points to level 25: 330 million exp
Skills and Features
Rob - Bards may attempt to rob gold from both players and monsters. Their chances at success are not as high as that of a Thief.
Play Instruments - A musical instrument, such as the Lute, is required for Bards to play a song.
Song - Ballad of Belzur
Much like Illuminatus, this song allows the performer to create an orb of light that follows them for a short period of time.
lasses: Bard (8)
Mana Cost 15
Requirements: 16 Str, 12 Int, 16 Agi, 16 Chr
Experience points to level 25: 330 million exp
Skills and Features
Rob - Bards may attempt to rob gold from both players and monsters. Their chances at success are not as high as that of a Thief.
Play Instruments - A musical instrument, such as the Lute, is required for Bards to play a song.
Song - Ballad of Belzur
Much like Illuminatus, this song allows the performer to create an orb of light that follows them for a short period of time.
lasses: Bard (8)
Mana Cost 15
I think this class in general should be entirely reworked to be an aid to Priests during oads. They should be a support song based class with different songs that aid the party. Such as auras that affect the entire party, but significantly reduced for PvP interactions. They should have like song buffs that slightly increase some of the following: hit/dodge rate, healing over time, slightly increase AC, damage buff, etc. They should have a cycle of songs, but they can only play one song to buff at once and a player can only receive 2 or 3 buffs at once. So now minstrels become insanely useful for PvE, but be careful for PvP. I don't think they should have damaging spells period, but that's up for debate. I think playing songs should consume mana over time instead of a flat amount so they can't just reap the aura benefits with one cost. Having 2-3 minstels in an oad group would almost be necessary to help take a load off the priest and give additional effect.
TL;DR Make them aura supports with light single target healing, maybe one damage spell.
TL;DR Make them aura supports with light single target healing, maybe one damage spell.
I think this class in general should be entirely reworked to be an aid to Priests during oads. They should be a support song based class with different songs that aid the party. Such as auras that affect the entire party, but significantly reduced for PvP interactions. They should have like song buffs that slightly increase some of the following: hit/dodge rate, healing over time, slightly increase AC, damage buff, etc. They should have a cycle of songs, but they can only play one song to buff at once and a player can only receive 2 or 3 buffs at once. So now minstrels become insanely useful for PvE, but be careful for PvP. I don't think they should have damaging spells period, but that's up for debate. I think playing songs should consume mana over time instead of a flat amount so they can't just reap the aura benefits with one cost. Having 2-3 minstels in an oad group would almost be necessary to help take a load off the priest and give additional effect.
TL;DR Make them aura supports with light single target healing, maybe one damage spell.
I fully agree with minstrels being a heavy support role. That is exactly how I pictured it too, one song 'active' at a time giving passive bonuses to the group itself. I don't think they should be a damage class at all. Mana being consumed is an okay way of doing it. Passive 'same' spells should not stack. What about attacking? Does attacking stop a song? Should it just be a passive thing that consumes a attack to change and then you can stop it whenever afterwards? They would require the main weapon to actually be an instrument i'd say, right? Or should this be an additional item?
They should still have healing spells. I would say low amounts though, maybe only 'curel' (as we'd call it.)
Think up 4-5 SIMPLE 'songs' too. Start off very small and smart. As you stated.
Damage Buff
AC Buff
Dodge Buff
are the three typical ones. The next onces could be:
'INT buff' (would be simple to add this way.), would boost spells in general though.
or what you said, a simple passive healing over time.
War song could be a spell...but this could make bards awesome supper In pvp aswell. I like where this is going bard is the only class I refused to lvl. Now they might be worth looking ito.
I agree with the support role. The class should have a specific instrument required to play the songs and it should be equipped in the weapon slot in order for them to be able to cast the song. Having a small group heal over time (10-15hp per 10 seconds?) would be a good start. Should the song drain mana over time or require a large bulk of mana (51%?) to cast so that they had to wait until playing another song if they needed to switch to a defensive song.
Maybe a small DoT song for usage to damage a group of monsters (terrible music hurts the ears of every opponent in the room)
Maybe a small DoT song for usage to damage a group of monsters (terrible music hurts the ears of every opponent in the room)
I agree with the support role. The class should have a specific instrument required to play the songs and it should be equipped in the weapon slot in order for them to be able to cast the song. Having a small group heal over time (10-15hp per 10 seconds?) would be a good start. Should the song drain mana over time or require a large bulk of mana (51%?) to cast so that they had to wait until playing another song if they needed to switch to a defensive song.
Maybe a small DoT song for usage to damage a group of monsters (terrible music hurts the ears of every opponent in the room)
A different item per song could work too. It depends on how people feel on that. As we get more people we will adjust stuff.
Changing spells should probably 'exhaust' you. Aka take all your turns. I think that requiring 51% of mana is getting a bit too difficult to process. I would say changing spells has an initial mana fee, then a slow drain if anything. So rapid changing spells would hurt your mana.
I think a different instrument being needed per song might be overkill a bit. Something more like a divinity amulet might be more in order, where the song in question isn't as effective without the right amulet, so switching between them would be slower.
I think a different instrument being needed per song might be overkill a bit. Something more like a divinity amulet might be more in order, where the song in question isn't as effective without the right amulet, so switching between them would be slower.
Like the amulet idea or it being tied to an ammy as well.
I think a different instrument per effect is overkill, but the idea of a small mana cost then drain over time to continue the song is awesome. Bards were the only ones I couldn't think of a reason to play other than RP'ing, which was completely gone by the time I started doing that. Making them important in PVE is a great idea. Also, on a sort of side note, I can't offer any art or anything, but I can definitely can write descriptions. If you guys want me to do some of that, please let me know. This is so cool!
I think a different instrument per effect is overkill, but the idea of a small mana cost then drain over time to continue the song is awesome. Bards were the only ones I couldn't think of a reason to play other than RP'ing, which was completely gone by the time I started doing that. Making them important in PVE is a great idea. Also, on a sort of side note, I can't offer any art or anything, but I can definitely can write descriptions. If you guys want me to do some of that, please let me know. This is so cool!
Feel free to help with writing 8)
I like the idea of an accessory slot for a musical instrument and the ability to have a weapon equipped as well. I think with the slot empty you can't sing/play and once equipped give a bonus to song power with different tier instruments as the bard progresses. I think they should be able to attack and play at the same time or else they won't be able to survive solo if we stick with them having support spells instead of direct damage. I'm curious how hard it would be to implement a song for them to inflict a stun or daze effect on a mob because a dungeon I'm trying to write currently could use this as a weapon proc or perhaps a song scroll.
You should make the instrument being used generate a party stat buff. IE Drums = +1 STR, Harp = +1 WIS, ect.
Songs should keep a spell duration/effect like Belzur did.
1) Weak Combat Health Regen Song
2) A charm song similiar to /tame, but doesn't have an infinite duration
3) A light song. CAUSE I"M SCARED OF GRUES
4) Weak AoE pulse damage song
5) Weak Combat Mana Regen Song
Change Mana into Voice, and have the songs drain x amount every so often while playing the song. Run out of voice, and you can't sing. lolol (Don't allow mana regen song to regen "voice"
Make bards/minstrels thirsty after every song, and make them be thirsty twice as often as any other class.
Allow them to wear helmets but remove the ability to equip swords and staves.
Songs should keep a spell duration/effect like Belzur did.
1) Weak Combat Health Regen Song
2) A charm song similiar to /tame, but doesn't have an infinite duration
3) A light song. CAUSE I"M SCARED OF GRUES
4) Weak AoE pulse damage song
5) Weak Combat Mana Regen Song
Change Mana into Voice, and have the songs drain x amount every so often while playing the song. Run out of voice, and you can't sing. lolol (Don't allow mana regen song to regen "voice"
Make bards/minstrels thirsty after every song, and make them be thirsty twice as often as any other class.
Allow them to wear helmets but remove the ability to equip swords and staves.
2) A charm song similiar to /tame, but doesn't have an infinite duration
Make bards/minstrels thirsty after every song, and make them be thirsty twice as often as any other class.
I like the idea of a charm song - pied piper style, but would they only remain tamed while the song was active?
The thirsty thing is just so on the nose for RP that we should do it.
They need some sort of damaging ability to make them possible to level - remember we aren't doing alts now, so we have to allow to some degree solo style play. Maybe we create some weaponized instruments that are specific to the class? Axe guitar or Dagger flute
I feel like cancelling the song on attack would be overly punishing - the instrument should only really be necessary to start the song, the bard/minstrel voice would be able to continue it.
Maybe on being hit, there is a chance to disrupt/stop the song?
I think you make bards into a dual wielding class. A dagger and an instrument. Lore suggests that bards were often used as assassins, so I feel like they should definitely be able to attack. Instruments attack value should indicate the potency of the songs and the songs should generate status effects. Increased damage, increased AC, a sleep song, a tame song, the trick here is to give them songs that would actually be useful in specific situations. If you make them into a weak healing class, nobody will use it for the healing.
If they have healing, it should be party based. Make it not use their attacks to trigger, but instead they cast lifetap once a turn or something.
If they have healing, it should be party based. Make it not use their attacks to trigger, but instead they cast lifetap once a turn or something.
I think you make bards into a dual wielding class. A dagger and an instrument. Lore suggests that bards were often used as assassins, so I feel like they should definitely be able to attack. Instruments attack value should indicate the potency of the songs and the songs should generate status effects. Increased damage, increased AC, a sleep song, a tame song, the trick here is to give them songs that would actually be useful in specific situations. If you make them into a weak healing class, nobody will use it for the healing.
If they have healing, it should be party based. Make it not use their attacks to trigger, but instead they cast lifetap once a turn or something.
You have some fire ideas man. I've been talking about posting on this for a while seeing as Bard is what I'm making now.
NiteHawk and I talked some and I think he decided on weapon/instrument.
Some points to note and remember:
Should be Charisma based for strength of spells.
Wisdom could be mana or (voice) like someone suggested as an alternate resource depending on how you make the songs work mechanically.
Do not make them full support or else people will not want them - Clerics heal better and have more ac, etc.
Should be a HYBRID CHARACTER- Bards are known for this! They should be able to do a little of everything..including fighting!
Suggestions:
Mage-Blade type of character..Jack of All Trades.
Keep slots as medium armor, weapon, instrument. (will go into detail later)
Songs should be usable one at a time. It makes logical sense(though I know this is a game), but by doing so you can increase the power of the songs as seen fit. I disagree with draining the mana per song though. It seems rather punishing to someone who probably isn't going to have tons of mana since they are multiple attribute dependent like PALADINS.
Let them literally do a little of everything! Bards are generally well versed in travel and knowledge as well, even if they aren't the smartest people! They hear stories/etc and pass them forward etc. How about giving the bards a special /lore ability that with enough Charisma they have a chance to figure out certain puzzles? You could add /lore in to certain squares that they are in and stuff like that. Think of them like..being able to investigate a room!
Do -not- make them unviable in pvp. Clerics at least get Ray and tons of heals and tons of armor. Make sure that bards can do comparable melee damage but not have insane the survivability of a healer.
Do they REALLY need to steal anymore? Give Rob back to thieves, don't let it take away from their class.
Instruments could be "weapons" also or like was suggested earlier instruments could "unlock" certain songs when worn or they could power up certain songs (This would be amazing for balance issues) depending on rarity/etc.
Do NOT get too complicated with Instruments. It does NOT make a sense a bard can play a lute and swing a sword at the same time. It seems more of an "extra" thing than anything. Bards SING and melee, or they play instruments and do other stuff. Logically that just seems right.
Group Songs
Song of Healing - Cost X - You begin to sing a song of tranquility, soothing the souls of your party per round. (Heal 15-40, more with instrument?)
Lament of Sadness - Cost X - You sing a song of unfortunate loss, your enemies sob emotionally. (armor reduction 5-15, can't hide, more with instrument-think AOE FaerieFire)
Lead the Charge - Cost X - You sing a song that inspires all of those around you. (Haste like party spell, half the value of regular haste - I think you said it was 2 for druids/1 for others in another post)
Sound of Silence - Cost X - You recite an ancient lullaby, passed down from ancient Tunyeran assassins. (Autosneak for your party while active, autosneak passive to get stuck in square still counts for leader)
Solo Songs Because you have to give them the ability to solo!
Song of Fury - Cost X- You chant an angry war call, infusing your weapon with magical energy. (Every 3 attacks, like Monk and Barbarian, if you hit the first 2 your 3rd attack emits a burst of (whatever divinity) dmg at x1.75 rate. Whatever is between monk and barbarian rage/RH dmg. Make it litreally in the middle of those 2 values to make it average)
Siren Song- Cost X - Your song is so alluring that you now command (insert creature, limit 1)
Wail of the Banshee - Cost X - Your terrifying wail makes the enemy reel in pain. (Deals X MAGIC damage based on divinity per round, higher number since its single target but not GODLY, resistable based on MR, acts as spell)
Don't forget - all of these could be powered up by instruments as well.
They deserve to be viable in PVP, group, AND solo.
ALSO - NO HIDDEN STATS. No songs that gives stats. It is uber boring and hidden stats and their values suck.
Hope you like some of my ideas. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Oh and I forgot to add. Armor song for group seems it'd be a tad too good, but also a tad too bad for soloing. Could Instrument provide armor as well so that wearing medium armor doesnt make them cannon fodder? Or give them naturally higher dodge rates like you did for monk? Something to consider. Finding their sweet spot with survivability is going to be the hard thing.
Ive always thought of a bard as more of a group character so i like the songs and how they would work. I think a moving aoe ff is a little overpowering tho maybe just armor reduction? others sound good <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Song of Fury - Cost X- You chant an angry war call, infusing your weapon with magical energy. (Every 3 attacks, like Monk and Barbarian, if you hit the first 2 your 3rd attack emits a burst of (whatever divinity) dmg at x1.75 rate. Whatever is between monk and barbarian rage/RH dmg. Make it litreally in the middle of those 2 values to make it average)
I kinda feel like the 3rd hit is a bit over used but do think they should have some sort of damage
Siren Song- Cost X - Your song is so alluring that you now command (insert creature, limit 1)
im not sure id want them to spawn creatures but maybe it would be cool if they had a spell that could "tame" a humanoid for a few mins type thing?
Wail of the Banshee - Cost X - Your terrifying wail makes the enemy reel in pain. (Deals X MAGIC damage based on divinity per round, higher number since its single target but not GODLY, resistable based on MR, acts as spell)
sound good but wouldn't want it doing too much damage.
Song of Fury - Cost X- You chant an angry war call, infusing your weapon with magical energy. (Every 3 attacks, like Monk and Barbarian, if you hit the first 2 your 3rd attack emits a burst of (whatever divinity) dmg at x1.75 rate. Whatever is between monk and barbarian rage/RH dmg. Make it litreally in the middle of those 2 values to make it average)
I kinda feel like the 3rd hit is a bit over used but do think they should have some sort of damage
Siren Song- Cost X - Your song is so alluring that you now command (insert creature, limit 1)
im not sure id want them to spawn creatures but maybe it would be cool if they had a spell that could "tame" a humanoid for a few mins type thing?
Wail of the Banshee - Cost X - Your terrifying wail makes the enemy reel in pain. (Deals X MAGIC damage based on divinity per round, higher number since its single target but not GODLY, resistable based on MR, acts as spell)
sound good but wouldn't want it doing too much damage.
For the armor reduction song, it wasn't meant as an AOE faeriefire, more so the -armor effect it gives. That way it helps increase dmg for each PHYSICAL dmg character in the group. Thats why I kept ac low 5-15 (that adds up per person you know?)
Maybe the third hit is overused but how about something else? Every hit leading up to the 4th, you can "crescendo" in to stronger hits. So for instance, if you hit one time, you do 110, if you hit another, 150, if you hit another , 190, if you hit another 230. How about something like that?
Siren Song IS a tame song, sorry for not clarifying. Sirens typically attract people through singing right? I thought it was fitting.
Wail of the Banshee is kind of a different spell. Instead of it doing dmg per attack or anything, just ONE TIME DAMAGE PER ROUND WHICH -CAN- BE RESISTED. Just ideas to help give them dmg. So for instance, round starts: "You wail like a banshee, your scream makes the enemy reel in pain doing 160 damage" Then attack attack attack attack. Keep in mind, they have NO defense other than MEDIUM armor. Thats why I suggest the instrument ALSO give armor/other abilities.
Thanks for the input, Im starting my bard within the next day so hopefully we can get the testing going! <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> Still looking for more!
Thanks in advance guys!
Maybe the third hit is overused but how about something else? Every hit leading up to the 4th, you can "crescendo" in to stronger hits. So for instance, if you hit one time, you do 110, if you hit another, 150, if you hit another , 190, if you hit another 230. How about something like that?
Siren Song IS a tame song, sorry for not clarifying. Sirens typically attract people through singing right? I thought it was fitting.
Wail of the Banshee is kind of a different spell. Instead of it doing dmg per attack or anything, just ONE TIME DAMAGE PER ROUND WHICH -CAN- BE RESISTED. Just ideas to help give them dmg. So for instance, round starts: "You wail like a banshee, your scream makes the enemy reel in pain doing 160 damage" Then attack attack attack attack. Keep in mind, they have NO defense other than MEDIUM armor. Thats why I suggest the instrument ALSO give armor/other abilities.
Thanks for the input, Im starting my bard within the next day so hopefully we can get the testing going! <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> Still looking for more!
Thanks in advance guys!
I like the thoughts. Always appreciate the bard class.
I like the idea of building intensity on consecutive hits rather than the 3rd hit critical type deal. It makes a little more sense as well. The song of battle intensifies with each successful strike.
I'm not sure that I think bards should be able to tame. Torn on that issue.
I do think that they should be able to lull enemies into having their stamina replenish slower, lower AP, or a light DoT.
For party assistance, my five thoughts are:
AP Boost
light HoT
slight stamina recovery boost (but this could be OP when looking at a large group. maybe it has only a 15% chance of "inspiring" group members?)
Light mana over time
attack boost.
Aside from that, I think daggers, swords, and light armor. Bards are performers, they don't walk around in mail.
I like the idea of building intensity on consecutive hits rather than the 3rd hit critical type deal. It makes a little more sense as well. The song of battle intensifies with each successful strike.
I'm not sure that I think bards should be able to tame. Torn on that issue.
I do think that they should be able to lull enemies into having their stamina replenish slower, lower AP, or a light DoT.
For party assistance, my five thoughts are:
AP Boost
light HoT
slight stamina recovery boost (but this could be OP when looking at a large group. maybe it has only a 15% chance of "inspiring" group members?)
Light mana over time
attack boost.
Aside from that, I think daggers, swords, and light armor. Bards are performers, they don't walk around in mail.