← Forum archive

King of the Hill Rules and Clarification

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Vindal
During this weeks King of the Hill match players were allowed to join the competition after it had already begun. In this case the admitted late contestant eventually went on to WIN .

Based on the rules of King of the Hill someone being admitted late to the competition (as in warped in after the first round is over) gives them an unfair advantage as the later someone is admitted the less people they have to face in order to go against the champion

I know events are tough to keep track of, and everyone is still a bit new, but this is something I don't feel should be allowed in the future. An even playing field for everyone is important in order to maintain the integrity of these events.

Thanks event staff for working hard to keep us entertained!
Folder
<a class="postlink" href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appearance_of_impropriety">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appearance_of_impropriety</a>

Please be mindful event staff!
Cerebrus
The rules are posted here on the boards. Can't remember for sure, but it doesnt say once warps are closed thats it. It's just something I broadcast.

As said in game, I have allowed people who make it home late from work to join in when the majority of the participants are still in the waiting room as it does NOT effect the fights.

I believe Lightning was late one time last week, Scytso one other week.

It's rather hard pinning this down to the right time where everyone can join in. Since this is a 1 vs 1 event, them being brought in to sit in the waiting room has no effect on the fight in progress.

As for what %playersname% said about if you lose just log another 25er and join late. Wouldnt happen or be advisable. We can see your alts and ip's.

As to the page about Dyer being in my guild. When I am on Cerebrus I hold no affiliations to any person or guild. I dont pay attention or take into account what guild each person is in since this is not a guild event.

I ask for everyone to page me. If 12 people are there and only 10 page with a number, the 2 who didnt page gets randomly inserted into the list of names pages I go off of. Same with late comers.

Had either of the people who paged me about this paged me a couple fights in saying "Hey man I just got home from work, can I join?" I would have warped you in as well.

This event is to see who is the best of the best. Not who's guild is better. I like to see new class builds, I like to see match ups of different classes. It's purely a this class/build beat out everyone else and is King.

Between the silly pages I get during the event, making sure everyone paged me, watching to make sure rules are followed (2 heals only, etc), broadcasting each fight, healing the fighters, warping in the new opponent. etc....I dont have time to note or care about who's facing who or whch guilds are rivals.

I'll just be blunt, if the whining continues about why this person did this or why this or that happened I just wont run KotH anymore. Which is sad because I rather enjoy running it. It's structured and allows you guys to try out new things with your alts, new match ups, etc...(to be honest I would love to participate)

If I changed the way It's been ran for the past few weeks, then the people who work late and get home 5mins after it starts will complain that I allowed it last week. It's a never ending thing. Not everyone is going to be pleased with what goes on and everyone is going to ask for rule changes, which wont happen.
Cerebrus
Based on the rules of King of the Hill someone being admitted late to the competition (as in warped in after the first round is over) gives them an unfair advantage as the later someone is admitted the less people they have to face in order to go against the champion



What about the people in there already who are last to page me with a number? They have to fight less people, no? Since I go by that list of pages for the order, the last person to page me would be last to fight.

The way I see it, it kind of evens out

If player A goes first and fights down the list killing 4-6 players then gets wiped out, They are more than likely going to win the longest streak prize
If player B goes last they have NO CHANCE of winning longest streak prize.

It's all a game of chance.
Folder
Cere, please just understand that people are sensitive to things like this. I don't think anyone actually thinks there's anything devious going on but it's something to be mindful of.

All you have to say is that you're doing everything as fair as possible and move on. This isn't whining, it's a sincere concern. Please don't threaten to quit running an event because of this - that's not going to help anyone feel better.

For the record I think you do a fine job and are as fair as you can be, this is not an attack on you. Appearances are strong and we all have experienced our share of poor staff behavior in the past so there's a lot of trust to be earned. I think we can all agree on that.

KoTH is fun man, keep doing it.
Vindal
I don't recall ever saying anything about you favoring your guild I even purposely left out bringing up the shitty page you sent me after the only thing I sent you was "Consider this a second vote for not letting people warp in late."

I don't think you were purposely being devious, but when you give the appearance of letting people join late, and then change this weeks rules about splitting PP for the streak winners, then get overly defensive when it is pointed out ... it is hard to think overwise.

I made absolutely no mention about you showing guild favoritism because I don't believe that to be the case, so feel free to hash that out directly with whomever sent it to you. If my original thought was that you were being devious I would not have minced words, I would have told you that you were being devious.

My turn to be blunt, I don't consider asking for an event to be ran fairly for everyone as whining, and you lashing out in anger is inappropriate for a staff/moderator of any event/game/forums/etc. If you are unable to handle the stress of running an event for 10 people and keeping it fair and organized. maybe you shouldn't do it anymore. What are you going to do if the game grows and two months from now you have a 30 person KotH? If you are struggling but want to continue it (And I really hope you do.) maybe you should recruit an extra set of hands. Hell I will even volunteer my own. Don't even gotta make me staff, just say what you need help with and I am more than willing.
Lateralus
Yea as folder said seems no one is accusing you of anything just pointed it some things could look fish.

Two things that could fix anyone ever having doubts:

1: No one in after last call and especially after the event has already started. (should be the same with any event)

2: Order is done by randomizing the players in the room and displayed in the room. (Might take a few mins to code on Chris part Kaos bot did this in rok so can be done.)

With those 2 changes no one could complain ever. Love the community but don't give them a reason to even think something is unfair or people will take it and run.

People seem to love your event I know I don't get that many for any of my events <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" />
Cerebrus
((( PLAYER))) is paging you from Linwood City (Linwood): its cool doesnt affect me just might seem weird to others seeing hes in your clan and he came in after 4 people were dead and you just slotted him wherever was best
Folder
Well whoever said that is just salty, it happens all the time man. Do your best, be fair, move on. That's it.
Vindal
((( PLAYER))) is paging you from Linwood City (Linwood): its cool doesnt affect me just might seem weird to others seeing hes in your clan and he came in after 4 people were dead and you just slotted him wherever was best



I mean, that person wasn't wrong. It definitely seems weird. Sounds to me like you should talk to that person directly.
Cerebrus
Theres two reasons Ive allowed it
1.) was because I had allowed it in previous weeks and I try to stay consistant.
2.) I've changed the times so many times I've lost count. Im trying to be fair so that everyone has a chance to participate. I cant remember everyones work schedules, so yes I've been a little lax on allowing late comers to join, but I've never allowed it after midway. (10-12 normally join, if they've paged me after about the 5-6th fight I've told them no, but if it's early on I allow it. Dyer was warped before the 2nd or 3rd fight even started.)

As said, it's not a mosh. Him being warped in later had no effect on any of the fights. He was just placed randomly in the list.

THE RULES WERE NEVER CHANGED, GO LOOK AT THE KING OF THE HILL POST. EVERY WEEK IF THERE IS A TIE BETWEEN THE KING AND THE LONGEST STREAK, BOTH GET THE 20pp. THE PP IS NOT SPLIT UP, REASON BEING THE RULES HAVE ALWAYS STATED LONGEST STREAK GETS 20PP, IN THE EVENT OF A TIE, BOTH GET 20PP

Not sure where you seen the rules for PP were changed.

FOR NOW: If someone is running late and pages me before the end of the 1st fight, I will allow them to join and randomly place them in the line up.


This event has ALWAYS been fairly ran. I've even bent to peoples demands (originally healers only got 1 heal, but people complained so I allowed 2. Same thing with some other stuff)

I take offense to this because I take my position very seriously. I dont care who you are, what guild you're in, etc...I try to be fair and nice to ALL. Even on my norms I have no beef with anyone, I try to be civil and even invite rivals to level with me.

Normally I do have help, tonight I did not. Dustin had kids to put to bed.
Cerebrus
And I agree Randy, something like Kaos bot to randomly feed me names from the waiting room would make it SO MUCH easier.

In the spirit of transparency I will explain how it works

I ask a staff member not participating in the event to give me a number between 1-100 and 1-50 (in the event 2 people page with same number)

I then ask everyone to page me a number

Person with closest number is first to the hill

Then I go down he list of pages IN ORDER bringing people in. (The order I receive pages is the same order you fight in)

If someone fails to page me a number or is LATE, I randomly stick them in that list. Sometimes I make them go first, sometimes last, sometimes in the middle, it's random

To keep with the transparency, starting saturday with JR. King of the Hill, I will start copy/pasting the order I received the pages and the broadcasts so that everyone can compare and make sure Im doing it how I say Im doing it. This will stop anyone from saying Im placing people wherever I want in the fight.
Vindal
See? Explanations provide clarification. Every week you have let people warp in late consistency shows that there is not in fact an act of favoritism. That is a much better reply than you did originally.

Now let me provide a counter explanation to provide more clarity. The winner of your KotH event is determined by whomever is the last man standing. Sure biggest streak also gets points ... but the King gets the Tshirt and the glory. Allowing someone to join late after fights have started give them an unfair advantage to those who made it a priority to be on time. Here is why -

Lets say Vindal, Folder, Kawasaki, NiteHawk, and Lavelia all are on time for KotH. Random numbers are assigned and the first fight is Vindal vs NiteHawk.

As we all know in this scenario NiteHawk would lose and Vindal would progress. This leaves Vindal with his first victory and three more to win. Next up is Vindal vs Kawasaki and Vindal wins again. Vindal has now earned two victories but two more to go to win!

BUT WAIT - Cerebus received a late warp in and is added to the mix to fight Vindal next. This means that Cerebus being allowed to join late only has to fight Vindal, Folder, and Lavelia. Which means regardless of how many people were in the event to start that he at maximum would only have to conquer three people for his title. While it doesn't make a difference to Lavelia and Folder because they haven't fought yet, what about Vindal and NiteHawk who would have had to conquer five others for their victory while at MOST Cerebus would have only had to conquer three ... assuming he didn't get an even later spot of course.

It makes for an uneven player experience. Once the event has started whoever is in should be in and that's it. Your current stance of allowing people to join late is punishing those of us who make a point to show up on time and showing favor to those who are late to the party.
Cerebrus
And Vindal to be honest, this isnt me lashing out at all. Sometimes I have a hard time conveying what I want to say and it all just spills out. I in no way was lashing out at you. Just trying to get all the facts straight.

When you paged me in game, it was right after I had just got done receiving 12+ pages from the person who had said that so I was a little upset.

Yes it was only 10 people, but look who we're talking about lol, these are all old Rokers, they are a rowdy bunch of people. I should show you the pages I receive when Im trying to organize this. A lot being x rated. lol

People tend to forget we are people/players too volunteering to build everyone a kickass game while offering to take time out of our nights to run events so the game doesnt get stagnant.

We have feelings, emotions, stress, etc too. Sometimes we react to those things. It's going to happen, this is a new game, we're still molding and shaping things. This is MY first true event, that I designed, I made the rules and I run. Im still learning. I thought on the rules a LOT to make it fair for all. I make sure it's ran fairly.

So I apologize if my emotions came through. Im human, not a robot like Nitehawk lol
Cerebrus
I do see what you are saying

The way you're making it sound though is like Im warping people in second to last fight. As stated above, the latest I have warped someone who is late in is 2-3rd fight. NEVER towards the end. I have in fact turned people away who have paged me that late.

Another thing, normally I ask everyone if it's okay if someone can still come in even though they paged late. Im sure there's a few who witnessed it a week or two ago.

Everyone there said sure or yeah thats cool. It wasnt until the person who was late just happened to be in the same guild as my norms that people said somthing (Not the reason you said it) but others.

Since we're being civil and discussing, how do you explain the last person paging with a number going last and not having to fight as many people? Thats fair but someone coming in 2-3 fights in isnt? It's the same concept and Ive said it a couple times now, They dont fight last. Most of the time I make them go first, sometimes in the middle. Dyer was warped in around the 3rd fight. Dyer didnt go last he went 3rd from last. He still had to fight through 3 people PLUS the king.
Folder
<3 it's way past my bedtime now but I'm glad this turned out well. I was a little worried! I do think it's maybe worth changing the rules to not allow late warps, because that's sorta the point of closing warps. Sucks to miss out though, I know.

I do get both sides of the point here. Ehhh no matter what you decide you can't make everyone happy with this one I think.
Cerebrus
[8:19pm] >>> Dyer <<<: any of you guys in there want to ask Cereburs nicely for a late entry7 ?

Thats 8:19 cst time, 9:19 server time. I didnt even start the first fight until quarter after 9.
Vindal
I do see what you are saying

The way you're making it sound though is like Im warping people in second to last fight. As stated above, the latest I have warped someone who is late in is 2-3rd fight. NEVER towards the end. I have in fact turned people away who have paged me that late.

Another thing, normally I ask everyone if it's okay if someone can still come in even though they paged late. Im sure there's a few who witnessed it a week or two ago.

Everyone there said sure or yeah thats cool. It wasnt until the person who was late just happened to be in the same guild as my norms that people said somthing (Not the reason you said it) but others.

Since we're being civil and discussing, how do you explain the last person paging with a number going last and not having to fight as many people? Thats fair but someone coming in 2-3 fights in isnt? It's the same concept and Ive said it a couple times now, They dont fight last. Most of the time I make them go first, sometimes in the middle. Dyer was warped in around the 3rd fight. Dyer didnt go last he went 3rd from last. He still had to fight through 3 people PLUS the king.



If 10 people join a KotH they each have a 10 percent chance of being the one to fight ten people a 10 percent chace to fight nine people etc. They also specifcally have a 10 percent chance of being the person that only has to fight one other.

If three fights happen that means three are out and a single person joins late. Now there is only 8 competitors and they are added to the order randomly. This means they have a 0 percent chance of having to fight ten others, a 0 percent chance of having to fight nine. A 12.5 percent chance of fighting 8 7 6 .... etc etc.

In a game where RNG is everything, even a slight advantage can make a big difference in the long run.
Cerebrus
Yeah, well thats fine by me. Will solve a lot of headaches.

NO MORE LATE WARP INS

Question though, I try not to do this event with anything less than 10 people

If I have 6 and say screw it and close warps, and someone pages me after the first fight "Hey just got home from work may I still join" "Hey was afk laying kids down, can I join" "Hey My porn movie just got over can I join"

Wouldn't you want more players envolved?

I guess Im seeing it from the staff position, you guys from the players position.

Staff: Wants lots of participants, the more the merrier
Player: Less players = better chance at winning

Lol me personally though, I dont like winning an event with only a handful of people participating. Feels like free loot. I'd rather earn it by being challenged by as many as possible in this type of event.
Cerebrus
<a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=31&t=902&p=6218#p6218">viewtopic.php?f=31&t=902&p=6218#p6218</a>

Anyone reading this, please look at event post for KotH. There is a big bold red warning against late warp ins. Also made is clear about ties for longest streak.