Huge HP mobs
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Why? What's the reasoning for them? I'm talking about:
Undertaker - His HP is way high for his level, especially considering he can only be healed to death.
Flame Salamander - Plz. I made another topic about this, but the boss hp is just excessive. Not to mention you are looking at, at best, killing 60 mobs to get the keys to let 1 group in to fight him.
Plushies - I...why. These take 1 hour to solo. Hourly spawn mobs. 1 hour to kill. We did these tonight with a group of 3-4 and it took an hour and a half to kill them all. It's hard to motivate people for that, you know? The 350k killshot XP is fine, but zero xp for the rest of it leaves people rather unmotivated to dedicate all that time. The killshot XP just means people want to relog to an alt when it's crit, which I think is goofy gameplay.
Giant Plushie - Yeah, it's a boss I get it. A boss that takes half an hour to kill. It's not hard or healing intensive, it's half an hour of pushing F1. Please up the damage and lower the health so it doesn't take so long.
I love the game and I like these areas in all regards except some mob HP. I can even deal with the Sally keys because you can farm them and get xp at the same time, so whatever. But pressing F1 for half an hour is not fun, it's tedious. Please consider this guys. This is all meant as constructive criticism and I hope it's taken as such.
Bosses and keys need to be somewhat entertaining in my opinion, or at the very least they shouldn't feel like pure chores or time sinks. I love that Sally does a lot of damage and I could even see raising it a little. Make it enrage, or spawn more adds, make it interesting not just long. Bosses/mobs shouldn't be hard because of the time needed (as in the hard part is simply getting people together that want to commit to 20-30 minute fights), they should be hard because of damage or mechanics involved.
Undertaker - His HP is way high for his level, especially considering he can only be healed to death.
Flame Salamander - Plz. I made another topic about this, but the boss hp is just excessive. Not to mention you are looking at, at best, killing 60 mobs to get the keys to let 1 group in to fight him.
Plushies - I...why. These take 1 hour to solo. Hourly spawn mobs. 1 hour to kill. We did these tonight with a group of 3-4 and it took an hour and a half to kill them all. It's hard to motivate people for that, you know? The 350k killshot XP is fine, but zero xp for the rest of it leaves people rather unmotivated to dedicate all that time. The killshot XP just means people want to relog to an alt when it's crit, which I think is goofy gameplay.
Giant Plushie - Yeah, it's a boss I get it. A boss that takes half an hour to kill. It's not hard or healing intensive, it's half an hour of pushing F1. Please up the damage and lower the health so it doesn't take so long.
I love the game and I like these areas in all regards except some mob HP. I can even deal with the Sally keys because you can farm them and get xp at the same time, so whatever. But pressing F1 for half an hour is not fun, it's tedious. Please consider this guys. This is all meant as constructive criticism and I hope it's taken as such.
Bosses and keys need to be somewhat entertaining in my opinion, or at the very least they shouldn't feel like pure chores or time sinks. I love that Sally does a lot of damage and I could even see raising it a little. Make it enrage, or spawn more adds, make it interesting not just long. Bosses/mobs shouldn't be hard because of the time needed (as in the hard part is simply getting people together that want to commit to 20-30 minute fights), they should be hard because of damage or mechanics involved.
I think the only way to fix this is to allow an alt. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":-D" title="Very Happy" />
I think the only way to fix this is to allow an alt. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":-D" title="Very Happy" />
Lol. I admire your tenacity <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Granted the plushie area is a fun area. It also drops some of the higher end stuff for players. It is not meant to be a solo area, it's meant to be a party area. You shouldn't probably be soloing it anyways. It's only here for a few more days and it's gone anyways, and it has high drop rates. Same for the other plushies too. If you don't really want to do it, you don't have too. But if your soloing it, eh. It's like soloing a OAD to get a purple 25 shield for minimal work. Actual harder OAD areas will have puzzles and whatnot so the boss doesn't need to be typically so long to fight, just overall hard.
Yeah the flame sally can be looked at. The undertaker too.
Yeah the flame sally can be looked at. The undertaker too.
P.S. The undertaker is pretty straight forward to look at but the salamander I'd need actual proper data. I.E> what classes you take, how long it took (time it using timestamps or clock it.) etc. I assume they are all 25'ers anyways. Hoping for more than once too, (and possible if others have run it their data or run it and gather data which will give me better info).
Re: The plushies.
The solo comment is a point of reference, I would never in my entire life solo one of those. 1.5 hours for a group of 3-4 to kill all of them seems very very long to me. The drop rate for KEYS is high yes but as far as weapons, well you have that data, but I've never seen one drop after having killed about 30 plushies. In itself that is fine, but that's 30 hours / # of party members.
You're also excluding anyone who is not in a very active guild. What about the guilds that only have a few members? For them to do something like this is really not fun, if they even bother to try at all.
Obviously no one has to to do anything in the game, but I like to do everything and some of it feels not fun to do simply because of mob HP. That's why I started this.
Re: Salamander
I do have a separate thread going for this. It took us 25 minutes with 2 priests, guard, chanter, 2x ninjas. Granted the chanter was night which is unfortunate, but 25 minutes is a long time. We have killed it 2x with that comp and time results were roughly the same. We have also tried with 1x slayer (ice), 1x zerker (ice), guard, chanter, priest (ice), and a 24 bard (night). The idea there was to try and save time by having a bard instead of a priest, but seeing as our bard is night he ended up dying when the Salamander was severe. We did end up killing it with 3 party members alive, but it ended up taking about the same amount of time.
You could argue that we need more ice characters, but half the party in that last group is ice and the fight is still obnoxiously long. It's a good fight, fast paced and the healing is intense. We all like that, it just also takes far too long and becomes not as fun. 10 minutes? Sure. 15 minutes? Ok. 25+ minutes? Ehhhh...
The solo comment is a point of reference, I would never in my entire life solo one of those. 1.5 hours for a group of 3-4 to kill all of them seems very very long to me. The drop rate for KEYS is high yes but as far as weapons, well you have that data, but I've never seen one drop after having killed about 30 plushies. In itself that is fine, but that's 30 hours / # of party members.
You're also excluding anyone who is not in a very active guild. What about the guilds that only have a few members? For them to do something like this is really not fun, if they even bother to try at all.
Obviously no one has to to do anything in the game, but I like to do everything and some of it feels not fun to do simply because of mob HP. That's why I started this.
Re: Salamander
I do have a separate thread going for this. It took us 25 minutes with 2 priests, guard, chanter, 2x ninjas. Granted the chanter was night which is unfortunate, but 25 minutes is a long time. We have killed it 2x with that comp and time results were roughly the same. We have also tried with 1x slayer (ice), 1x zerker (ice), guard, chanter, priest (ice), and a 24 bard (night). The idea there was to try and save time by having a bard instead of a priest, but seeing as our bard is night he ended up dying when the Salamander was severe. We did end up killing it with 3 party members alive, but it ended up taking about the same amount of time.
You could argue that we need more ice characters, but half the party in that last group is ice and the fight is still obnoxiously long. It's a good fight, fast paced and the healing is intense. We all like that, it just also takes far too long and becomes not as fun. 10 minutes? Sure. 15 minutes? Ok. 25+ minutes? Ehhhh...
Well, that will have to be looked at next year. You only need one party to deal with it though. I'll see about changing the plushie HP a little bit but yeah, it is a party area really. We really generally only had a week to do it, and I think it's fine overall. The game isn't honestly friendly to solos and it's a high reason why I'm trying to push out alot of changes within the next month or two to ensure new players get into guilds fast and helping them understand the game better. Because PVP is tougher to them, they will find it's really rough to play the game solo, in any aspects. Most of the plushies will get about 40% HP reductions anyways, though it won't happen until they respawn (unless they are already dead), which I think will put them more in line based on what I've been seeing.
Not all 'events' will be like this though. But yeah, some will favor parties, some will favor solo.
I do agree about 12-15 minutes is a better base for most 'boss fights'. 25 is a bit on the high end because you do need to get keys and other things.
Not all 'events' will be like this though. But yeah, some will favor parties, some will favor solo.
Re: Salamander
I do have a separate thread going for this. It took us 25 minutes with 2 priests, guard, chanter, 2x ninjas. Granted the chanter was night which is unfortunate, but 25 minutes is a long time. We have killed it 2x with that comp and time results were roughly the same. We have also tried with 1x slayer (ice), 1x zerker (ice), guard, chanter, priest (ice), and a 24 bard (night). The idea there was to try and save time by having a bard instead of a priest, but seeing as our bard is night he ended up dying when the Salamander was severe. We did end up killing it with 3 party members alive, but it ended up taking about the same amount of time.
You could argue that we need more ice characters, but half the party in that last group is ice and the fight is still obnoxiously long. It's a good fight, fast paced and the healing is intense. We all like that, it just also takes far too long and becomes not as fun. 10 minutes? Sure. 15 minutes? Ok. 25+ minutes? Ehhhh...
I do agree about 12-15 minutes is a better base for most 'boss fights'. 25 is a bit on the high end because you do need to get keys and other things.
I think the only way to fix this is to allow an alt. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":-D" title="Very Happy" />
Ability to use one extra alt would be appealing to play more then an hour or two a week. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
I am adjusting the flame sally and undead, but they both need looking into. I do not know if it will happen today or tomorrow after reset though, depends if their spawn has been triggered somehow already. Based on your statements and some more in my PM box, I think he needs about 40% less HP and a slight less amount of armor, which is around 25minutes down to 13-15 minutes. In exchange, his max damage (not minimum) is a little higher. So more intense fights, but less time.
The Undertaker should have more HP overall but it was way to high. 20k-25k HP for a level 15 monster is a bit extreme since it's supposed to be in a low level area. I've nerfed that to 5-6k HP, which should be more fair at that level, since it's generally not really useful at higher levels anyways. It is however, keeping a little more then average HP though which is OK.
The Undertaker should have more HP overall but it was way to high. 20k-25k HP for a level 15 monster is a bit extreme since it's supposed to be in a low level area. I've nerfed that to 5-6k HP, which should be more fair at that level, since it's generally not really useful at higher levels anyways. It is however, keeping a little more then average HP though which is OK.
... The game isn't honestly friendly to solos ...
What? That is discrimination against solo levelling loners, like me, who have no friends!
Thank you for looking into this. Will post more feedback when I have the chance to kill these things again, but this sounds like a good change.
I personally agree with how hard the plushies are. I don't think they should be soloed unless there is solid effort in it. If you are going to lower their hp 40% I recommend way more damage because I've seen non 25ers solo them
It just takes a while.
It just takes a while.
They aren't "hard" though, they simply take forever. It's not fun gameplay for a mob to take that long to die. If it's a very special mob, say the dragon, then awesome that's fine. But for daily and hourly mobs it feels way too grindy to be fun past the 1st time you kill them.
100% fine with them doing more damage though, I agree with that.
100% fine with them doing more damage though, I agree with that.
They aren't "hard" though, they simply take forever. It's not fun gameplay for a mob to take that long to die. If it's a very special mob, say the dragon, then awesome that's fine. But for daily and hourly mobs it feels way too grindy to be fun past the 1st time you kill them.
100% fine with them doing more damage though, I agree with that.
yep hit the nail on the head for sure. I htink if you are going to lower hp 40% damage should go up 50-75% and hitrate rate or something because like you said they are not hard just long and kinda boring.
Yeah, I'd say something like 50-75% dmg increase is fair. Even 100% would work to be honest.
Talking only about plushies here.
Talking only about plushies here.
The experation on keys need to be upped 2to 3 days for a key to expire. Kinda screws people who work through out the week 4 to 5 days expI ration seems fair enough for people to get together and plan.
The experation on keys need to be upped 2to 3 days for a key to expire. Kinda screws people who work through out the week 4 to 5 days expI ration seems fair enough for people to get together and plan.
I would be okay with three day keys rather then one day keys too in general for the entry way. After entrance the keys can still be 1day though. (Aka the running the OAD bit.)
Plushies have a script that take a percent of your health each time. It was meant so that everyone gets a more even set so that lower levels can still do it. I'll see about adjusting the values though on dmg too.
Oh, did not know the damage worked that way. That's pretty interesting but yea I'd still say they could do more since the HP was lowered.
Rodeo was referring to plushie keys which are 1 day, frankly now that they have much lower HP I think this is less of an issue. A group of 6 will clear these pretty painlessly now.
Rodeo was referring to plushie keys which are 1 day, frankly now that they have much lower HP I think this is less of an issue. A group of 6 will clear these pretty painlessly now.
Oh, did not know the damage worked that way. That's pretty interesting but yea I'd still say they could do more since the HP was lowered.
Rodeo was referring to plushie keys which are 1 day, frankly now that they have much lower HP I think this is less of an issue. A group of 6 will clear these pretty painlessly now.
I raised damage a little on the plushies next spawn (from 10-15% to 15-25%), though giant plushie is a bit more of an asshole with a low chance nuke attack that is about triple the damage since he already had 15-25% and I didn't want to go higher, so more specuals for him.
And yeah HP was reduced from 40m to 25m on them, and to 125m to 100m on giant plushie
GL.
We did Flame Sally tonight:
Earth ninja, Fire ninja, Storm stalker, Ice zerker, Ice priest, Earth priest. Stalker used a VERY tanky reindeer pet. Fight took about 13 minutes and was moderately healing intensive. I think the reindeer pet took a lot of load off heals as it absorbed an awful lot of hits.
Fight felt a lot better time wise, it wasn't so draining. Healing wise didn't feel harder even with the higher damage but I think this was because of Raindear (yes that's how he spells it, smh) the tank god.
All in all it felt much better, and we also had a better comp for it which helped even more.
Re: Plushies
They feel so much better now, thank you. Didn't get a chance to fight the giant as he was already dead, oh well.
Earth ninja, Fire ninja, Storm stalker, Ice zerker, Ice priest, Earth priest. Stalker used a VERY tanky reindeer pet. Fight took about 13 minutes and was moderately healing intensive. I think the reindeer pet took a lot of load off heals as it absorbed an awful lot of hits.
Fight felt a lot better time wise, it wasn't so draining. Healing wise didn't feel harder even with the higher damage but I think this was because of Raindear (yes that's how he spells it, smh) the tank god.
All in all it felt much better, and we also had a better comp for it which helped even more.
Re: Plushies
They feel so much better now, thank you. Didn't get a chance to fight the giant as he was already dead, oh well.