← Forum archive

Change to Fade spell.

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

daedroth
How about changing the fade spell so it works until you attack?
So it will be good for first strike. Also how about it having an effect like blind on attackers while it is up (-2 AGL to attackers or +2 AGL to the invisible peeps - until they attack off course, obviously blind and fade effects do not combine).
Folder
I agree that Fade should break on attack. I'm not a fan of the full group fade meta, it seems out of place to me and makes pvp a bit weird when you can't see anyone.

Surprise attack +agi is an interesting idea, maybe just +1 though.
Sicx
Sweet, I guess Rogues will be getting that bonus as well then. Fade should break on attack, or if you drop or pick up an item.
Lateralus
I kind of like how it is to be honest. If it was changed you would have to make it so you can't be hit while you are in fade.
Folder
The thing that I dislike about it most is one of usability. You are forced to type "a XXXX" to attack someone. It breaks the ability to click attack, and like it or not a lot of people click attack. It's fine for a sneak attack but when entire 6v6 battles are happening while faded it's a little out of hand imo. Thinking way ahead to a tablet client this not being able to target someone easily is fairly game breaking.

Why would you have to change it so you can't be hit while faded? I don't see the connection there. If you take any offensive action it breaks, that's all. Just being hit doesn't break it. At least that's what is being proposed anyway.
Sicx
Or even make it so you can't be attacked invis...so what. But multiple people faded attacking would be ..uh...ridiculous.. I've yet to experience it yet, didn't even know it was a thing.
Lateralus
As I said before I like how it is now but back in rok you couldn't be attacked while invis but once you did attack it broke invis. It worked like hide but you couldn't even be searched out so you always got the first attack. I think it's a lot more fair in its current state.
Folder
You like full groups fighting while faded? Stealth overload isn't good or fun gameplay imo. It also just plain makes no sense lore wise - ok you can attack someone who is faded if you type it out, but they are otherwise completely invisible and free to attack as they please?

Any input on the tablet client issue? If that's a serious idea that's going to happen at some point then this needs to be looked at because this will be a huge disadvantage for anyone playing like that.
Sicx
So..yeah, If I get PK'd by 6 invisible people and they stay invis the whole time then I'm quitting, lol. I'll not be a part of that meta. In what game would that ever be fun/fair?
Deehok
I was just talking about this with a buddy and we feel a good counter would be to let FF take you out of fade and keep you from fading again for the duration. It breaks stealth so why not fade? Personally I like fade but the full invisible party fights are goofy as hell.
Styx
If I have fade and hover both why am I dragging monsters sometimes. I think it happened long while back but don't remember, not using golem either to drag
NiteHawk
Ok just thought if I was invisible and no tracks, not attacking, how can they follow or see me


Magic.

It's a game in the end. There is no real way to adjust this without heavy coding that I can't be bothered to do.

Fade does prevent them from following you now but they will attack you regardless.
Aftershock
Let me in your code and i will do it for you.


Sorcs altogether need fixing not just Fade. They are ridiculously OP towards Melee classes.
Folder
Towards melee? No. Towards low WIS? Yes, they are brutal.

To survive the sorcs you need to sacrifice str and end for more wisdom. Or you can keep the damage stats and lose against casters. I think it's mostly fine, although I'll concede that perhaps flattening the curve a bit is needed. Just keep in mind this is a sorc's niche - low wis. When you start fighting 20+ wis your effectiveness drops off.
Terron
aside from goblin dark elf and ling make the fights pretty close to a 4-5/10 hit rate each way. gnome monks would be hardcore the other way, but lose 90% to saurians lol. i think the real problem is people wont take the hit and be weak to saurians and the hardcore dps races cant even get decent mr with a +1 on wis they'd still be blown to smitherines in 2-3 rounds. i think that was the reason they had so many more hit points before.

if mages had 10 agility it would be the other way but they all have decently high agility. hardcore dps has to fight against hardcore flaws in both mr and hit rate. mages get 4 max stats or close and it covers all their flaws and power, melees dont.
NiteHawk
Let me in your code and i will do it for you.


Sorcs altogether need fixing not just Fade. They are ridiculously OP towards Melee classes.


No.


aside from goblin dark elf and ling make the fights pretty close to a 4-5/10 hit rate each way. gnome monks would be hardcore the other way, but lose 90% to saurians lol. i think the real problem is people wont take the hit and be weak to saurians and the hardcore dps races cant even get decent mr with a +1 on wis they'd still be blown to smitherines in 2-3 rounds. i think that was the reason they had so many more hit points before.


Well yeah, combat classes are meant to be stronger then all rounders. We did talk about MR needing a change though. With a small adjustment to HP and looking at how MR works and tweaking it I think it would be fine.

Regardless though, you will often lose if you are a saurian or HO against a spell caster who has high int cause they cannot get wisdom to begin with. Other races it's really your call to add wisdom or not though. Rather then +1ing str or whatever you throw the points into wisdom etc. You probably shouldn't lose to the point on where it is at though, and very seldom can survive if you start off with lucky hits, but if people are getting slaughtered simply because they can't be bothered to put MR on a character and would rather do something else, that's bad/pointless data.
Terron
yeah i understand its pretty balanced if you look at the entire spectrum. i mean a saurian monk would likely kill every other monk the majority.

it just isnt playing out the way it would in a fake world with every possible character in a round robin. horc/saurian drake would kill almost every melee elf/gnome/elemental every single fight, but those builds aren't being used. which also entails why mages are immensely OP atm. noone is maximizing MR to fend off a mage. for instance i think the extremes of each build type are horc/saurian melee> gnome/elf/elemental MR > gnome elf caster> horc/saurian. the problem with mages atm is the hit rates in my opinion even fighting crap wis hitting so often is too much. and the fact that ling gobby and d/e are halfway mr halfway dps and its the furthest players are going to go atm. i mean maybe it would change if a gnome monk cut down 10 chanters in a row in koth or something, but i think the general thought is there's already so many huge DPS characters it would be suicide to run around on a gnome fighter lol. then the damage...
Honzo
yeah i understand its pretty balanced if you look at the entire spectrum. i mean a saurian monk would likely kill every other monk the majority.

it just isnt playing out the way it would in a fake world with every possible character in a round robin. horc/saurian drake would kill almost every melee elf/gnome/elemental every single fight, but those builds aren't being used. which also entails why mages are immensely OP atm. noone is maximizing MR to fend off a mage. for instance i think the extremes of each build type are horc/saurian melee> gnome/elf/elemental MR > gnome elf caster> horc/saurian.


It seems pretty balanced for the most part. Just like you said, people aren't using those builds...therefore it is on THEM if they lose. They shouldn't complain, they should make characters to work the way in which they intend for them to! You say no one is going to make a Gnome Fighter but that is also horribly wrong. My Elder Druid is a Gnome and regardless of their power level he still does well all-around, I doubt many would disagree.

The problem isn't that the answers aren't out there, the builds are out there. It's about people creating characters wisely according to what they want them to excel at. Not one class/race in this game will be superior to every other, they all have strengths and weaknesses.

I'm not saying that Caster classes aren't powerful and I do agree they could probably use some tweaking but there is not a major issue with them dominating because they are overpowered. It's the players for not bringing the correct tools to challenge their opponents, or maybe just being unlucky! <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />

Maybe Stoneskin is too powerful? I don't think I've seen many people talking about that though. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />