← Forum archive

Ugliness and obesity

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Terron
hollywood is all bards rangers and 13 chr half orc builds....sad

anyway, i think the char stat is underutilized, i like the bonus hp/mp thing but what about having charisma add 1/4 -1/2 as much MR as wisdom(this would only count charisma over 10 so no bonus at all for 10 chr)

also why isn't heal power charisma based, it makes more sense to seperate a clerics heal power vs their damage spells power. a "harming" cleric would not heal for as much as a healer. even the gods wouldn't want a cleric hurting people and even if they did that deity wouldn't be focusing on heal power...
Man
hollywood is all bards rangers and 13 chr half orc builds....sad

anyway, i think the char stat is underutilized, i like the bonus hp/mp thing but what about having charisma add 1/4 -1/2 as much MR as wisdom(this would only count charisma over 10 so no bonus at all for 10 chr)

also why isn't heal power charisma based, it makes more sense to seperate a clerics heal power vs their damage spells power. a "harming" cleric would not heal for as much as a healer. even the gods wouldn't want a cleric hurting people and even if they did that deity wouldn't be focusing on heal power...


Clerics don't really 'heal' to level. Not entirely true, they heal undead for a very short period of time (I did it for 2 levels). At level 1 clerics get a damage spell which doesn't heal anything, the damage goes up slightly over time and is efficiently costed (3 mana). The first healing spell on the other hand you get a couple levels later and they only deal damage at 50% or so to monsters at the cost of 5 mana, not only that but the damage spell does more damage. This makes the damage spell better than the 1st heal at all points. You at some point get the spell Heal which costs 10 mana, which I found did slightly less damage than the damage spell, however on the higher graveyard monsters fizzled more often than heal, so I went with that. Then came Aid, the first and only real viable point to heal monsters, as it was a spell that finally dealt more damage than Ray (the damage spell) at the cost of 20 mana. 2 levels later you get smite which deals about the same damage to undead as Aid but at 8 damage (though its damage is greatly reduced against regular monsters making ray better).

For reference
Damage spell lvl 1: You cast ray at a roadside bandit for 87 points of damage!
Heal spell cure lvl 4: You healed a risen for 43 points of damage!
Heal spell Heal lvl ?: You healed a risen for 62 points of damage!
Heal Spell Aid lvl 18: You healed a risen for 135 points of damage!
Damage spell lvl 20: You call down a storm of holy ice on a risen for 158 points of damage!


All in all, in this game, the gods want you to to kill snakes and boars <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Man
I would have to agree though, charisma seems like a stat thats missing. This whole game is kind of all in though with the way you make your character. Most races in the game can't have 5 perfect stats (I believe Half-Orcs are the only race that can) which puts you at an odd spot during class creation as you're always going to be missing a stat. Most classes normally need 4/5 stats too. I.E. pretty much every single character is going to have max Agility and max Endurance, that pretty much now gives us only 2 stats to work on depending on the class.

With fighting classes, one can argue you only need str and everything else can be debated, however bards need charisma for their spell power, thieves need intelligence to not get caught stealing or to be seen while hiding... paladins use charisma for their taunt and have spells. It's all a bit subjective though on the hitting class I think though.

The problem is with the spell casters, which use both intelligence (fizzle rate?) and wisdom (spell power). This leaves spell casters 0 available free stats for customization, they'll pretty much always be max END, AGI, INT, WIS as I understand it. And spell caster's don't have the same type of glass cannon races that attackers get.

It would be nice though to see charisma be more important in the game... i.e. rather than bards using strength maybe they could have just used Charisma for their attacking as well.
Terron
my first character was a paladin then a cleric and leveling by far was easier with healing undead even with the seemingly half damage, heal spells just don't unaffected like the damage spells and melee and cure was 30% faster in leveling than heal was. because the 10 mana ate up my mana so fast i spent far more time regenerating with waterskins than training. but i understand that i couldnt afford mana orbs and stuff at that time which would likely give heal a much nicer edge.


besides chr affecting heal power would affect PvP the most but also since its a "sole" governing skill the charisma based damage can be altered so that a healer can do more damage through undeads MR , which im sure at the time int is governing all spell damage so raising heal power is clumped in the same category as raising other spells damage. in a PvP setting a harming cleric would be using its tutelage and time developing power into harm spells while a healer would practice and seek knowledge about healing, the two shouldn't be the same. but at the same time both types of clerics should still be useful ingame.
Man
my first character was a paladin then a cleric and leveling by far was easier with healing undead even with the seemingly half damage, heal spells just don't unaffected like the damage spells and melee and cure was 30% faster in leveling than heal was. because the 10 mana ate up my mana so fast i spent far more time regenerating with waterskins than training. but i understand that i couldnt afford mana orbs and stuff at that time which would likely give heal a much nicer edge.


besides chr affecting heal power would affect PvP the most but also since its a "sole" governing skill the charisma based damage can be altered so that a healer can do more damage through undeads MR , which im sure at the time int is governing all spell damage so raising heal power is clumped in the same category as raising other spells damage. in a PvP setting a harming cleric would be using its tutelage and time developing power into harm spells while a healer would practice and seek knowledge about healing, the two shouldn't be the same. but at the same time both types of clerics should still be useful ingame.


I would agree, in the beginning I spent more time using wines and such and sitting in temples than I did training. Eventually I decided to take the hit and but mana, which has made me somewhat poor, to fix that though, might want to post on the 'gold and you' topic.

I would have to agree though, I feel like Charisma should be utilized a bit more, it's an interesting idea. I feel like bards, since they have musical instruments and songs are their spells, would have been the perfect class to toss out the status quo and have charisma be their damage rather than str. I feel intelligence and Wisdom do go hand in hand with a cleric however.
Terron
which is precisely why a cleric is more like a warlock on here than a healer. im not suggesting changing ray or smites governing stat, which should be left as int. changing the heals only to chr. this would be optimal especially in 1v1s vs clerics. a cleric wouldn't be the pwn every monster pwn every event pwn at every boss crit , atleast you're dividing clerics into 3 categories the ones designed for pvp the ones designed for healing and the ones who dabble in both.

without changes like this the game is left with so few optimized characters that players don't use 80%(or more) of the content in the game. the game will have the same handful of builds beat to death over and over. might aswell have set stats and eliminate classes for races cuz they underperform.
the reason for this is to keep people playing over a long long time, cuz as it sits it takes like 10 days to 25 a character and after u do that 12? times you have every good build 1x or multiple divs of the great ones.
Man
which is precisely why a cleric is more like a warlock on here than a healer. im not suggesting changing ray or smites governing stat, which should be left as int. changing the heals only to chr. this would be optimal especially in 1v1s vs clerics. a cleric wouldn't be the pwn every monster pwn every event pwn at every boss crit , atleast you're dividing clerics into 3 categories the ones designed for pvp the ones designed for healing and the ones who dabble in both.

without changes like this the game is left with so few optimized characters that players don't use 80%(or more) of the content in the game. the game will have the same handful of builds beat to death over and over. might aswell have set stats and eliminate classes for races cuz they underperform.
the reason for this is to keep people playing over a long long time, cuz as it sits it takes like 10 days to 25 a character and after u do that 12? times you have every good build 1x or multiple divs of the great ones.


In all fairness, this game already has 3 clerics.

Paladins are more pvp I would say. They have heavy armor and they have an armor increasing spell, they can blind their opponent, they have heal, they do 16% extra damage with blunt weapons (so almost certainly more than swords).
Clerics are more for pve as they heal for close to 300 per stamina but have spells that don't stand up damage wise pvp. They wear lioght armor but have an armor increasing spell.
Bards dabble in both they have cure which heals for about 100, have a party heal song that constantly heals the party, they wear medium armor, have songs that boost stats to entire party like +3 str, they also attack for damage with most weapons in game dealing a nice amount of damage. I would say they do kind of what you're asking for.
Man
@Man Necromancers have a blind spell. I do not think paladins do.


You're right, for some reason I turned Sight in to Blind in my head...
daedroth
@Man Necromancers have a blind spell. I do not think paladins do.


You're right, for some reason I turned Sight in to Blind in my head...


Ah good! I was doubting myself for a little there <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
NiteHawk
Still listening on this topic but I disagree with charisma being the base on CHR or granting a bonus to healing. Healing is already for me at it's 'max'. We lowered healing recently because no one was dying in PVP combat.

Making healing charisma based to me feels weird overall for just those spells only. Perhaps there is another way to deal with charisma though, but I don't think making clerics/pallies/etc 'REQUIRE' charisma on top of the other 5 stats is a good idea though.
Terron
you wouldn't need to do anything. thats like saying paladins and clerics already need chr for hp/mp boost already but they do not. its optimization only. you had to lower heals in pvp because they are directly influenced by the same stat as damage spell. hence a pvp cleric will always optimize dex int and con and forgo chr regardless if heal power is moved to charisma or not. if they chose this path the heals would have been lower regardless of your nerf. let the stats do the work for you <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" /> if they chose the other path they wouldn't be very optimal in pvp but be hard to kill pve and better bossers.

min/maxing is always a game mechanic that is most utilized, just don't let it remove 80% of the other game content like on every other game. every class should find all 6 statistics useful. as it sits charisma is more like a luck stat for a few hp/mp with the penalty that 96% of the characters ingame are ugly to average looking. it hasn't been optimal as a stat because nothing is coded to it. being ugly consistently is a huge deterent for me, i cant stand it. makes me only want to play half orcs and goblins. the HORDE!!!

and what about the charisma affecting MR at a decreased rate compared to Wisdom? noone has touched on that?
Folder
I like the idea of CHR increasing MR in some small amount. Partially just because I think casters are OP in general though.

What you're talking about makes me think of having different specs for the classes. A cleric that can spec INT and do damage, or a cleric that can spec CHR and heal more. That's not a bad idea, but it does change a lot of things about how the game works. That cleric needs to be distinct from a sorc or else it's redundant, and I assume it can still heal for SOME amount and we don't want something that can damage like a sorc and heal. Do we want respecs to be cheaper at that point too? Leveling is a big commitment and if we have distinct "specs" it sounds a bit ehhhh to have to commit to one forever.

Also, in the case of paladins, if CHR is healing then what do they do with INT? INT would be the new dump stat because as the game stands you NEED a dump stat or else your character would be shit at one role or another.

Anyways I definitely like the idea of working with CHR, it's a pretty bland stat.
Terron
its all in the definition of the stats. if a character with 20 str 10 agility and 20 con is doing 300 damage per round then a crit that is 10 str 20 dex and 20 con should be doing the same. the stats should offset completely. it may seem stagnant to let the constitution value for itself, but the real trick to overcoming the con factor is ability damage and luck. so incase of a paladin taking int over chr they would smite for more damage but heal less. but it will be exactly offset by the reciprocal paladin.

im not saying a cleric taking 10 chr and 20+int should heal for 0. the class should have inherent power gathered by each level gain, it just shouldn't be as powerful as a cleric that devoted 25 levels to healing if chr was the factor. and vice versa a cleric optimizing heal shouldn't be using ray/smite as efficiently. and on top of that there should be a melee variant of cleric. its a benefit to the game to offer all 3 builds and also a character that meddles in 2 or all 3 aspects. it opens up alot more options. also makes variant races that are not and will not ever be used on this game currently. wheres the half orc or saurian clerics at? it is needed because this game is endgame rather fast - couple weeks is a max character, after a year there is no reason to keep going. some of the classes may overlap and be similar with such stat variants, but variety is the spice of life and at the moment there isn't many variants its all the same builds beat to death.

i like ability damage being based off int, just seems backwards for healing only
daedroth
Some interesting ideas here. I think I will sit and watch though since I cannot think of anything to contribute, and I'm tired right now.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />

Deleted my gibberish. I will go back to sitting and watching.
NiteHawk
I like the idea of CHR increasing MR in some small amount. Partially just because I think casters are OP in general though.

What you're talking about makes me think of having different specs for the classes. A cleric that can spec INT and do damage, or a cleric that can spec CHR and heal more. That's not a bad idea, but it does change a lot of things about how the game works. That cleric needs to be distinct from a sorc or else it's redundant, and I assume it can still heal for SOME amount and we don't want something that can damage like a sorc and heal. Do we want respecs to be cheaper at that point too? Leveling is a big commitment and if we have distinct "specs" it sounds a bit ehhhh to have to commit to one forever.

Also, in the case of paladins, if CHR is healing then what do they do with INT? INT would be the new dump stat because as the game stands you NEED a dump stat or else your character would be shit at one role or another.

Anyways I definitely like the idea of working with CHR, it's a pretty bland stat.


I think though the issue then with pallies or clerics is that it becomes a nightmare to level because smite and ray will do such minimal damage that it will be odd to deal with though too.

Wisdom could help out but I mean, are you saying this as a saurian slayer, or proper MR race/class? Slayers are going to have weaknesses for example, spells are one of them. The highest MR races with a decent class will have between 60-80 MR.

<a class="postlink" href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ypDKONHfJW-xVEyDiOonnwOLjZzBAaYYV5OuuIlqqB0/edit?usp=sharing">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing</a>

Alot of people have been going big guns with low wisdom and low MR races obviously because they think they are OP but will get a quick death against magical classes.
Terron
what im trying to get at is that a build that is 20 20 20 20 16 10 a 20 20 20 15 16 15 and a 20 20 20 10 16 20 should all be equally viable in comparison to each other. the damage(int) user will hit a hypothetical 100 with spells while heal for 50, the middle of the road will do 75 /75 and the healer will do 50/100. in the end its your personal preference and creates a world in which min maxing is less possible because a 18 20 20 17 16 14 might be better that the previous 3 i stated but worse than a 20 20 20 10 20 15 if you catch my drift.

this opens up a far more vast character creation system to where 8/10 things you make and the entire player-base sees it and says "wtf you thinking".
w/o this set up on every class structure the game wont see any rarity builds. also w/o there is no reason to make one because the possibility that a 14 22 19 14 15 14 saurian for example, can never win at anything is off the table because it would become useful in some shape or form.

the idea is to have any combination of character class/race/stat be useful. someone could roll a complete middle of the road character like 17 21 17 17 17 17 elf and still have a good character that could edge out other builds. or we can just talk bout str/hps vs dex and mr vs spells in endless repetition. bob likes lings they should win all, corey likes horcs they should win all, darcy loves mages they should be indestructible...yep thats a yawn.
Folder
someone could roll a complete middle of the road character like 17 21 17 17 17 17 elf and still have a good character that could edge out other builds.


I get all that you're saying except this part. How could you possibly make a character that doesn't have max stats equivalent to a character with max stats?
Terron
because there are no max stat characters.

in reference to a 17 21 17 17 17 17 elf, that elf would lose in a pvp match as a knight vs an 18 22 18 x x x but at the same time as a paladin it may fair better than a 18 23 18 21 15 10 because of the mana pool or in a hypothetical event where u had to face every possible character build, it may be better overall. im not saying make 0 stats as a premium choice by any means but viable because the stats in relative areas cancel out. when its left up to you to choose a vast number of things on creation like do i want my pally to have melee power/dodge/hp/smite damage/heal(if it was chr)/large mana pool/ or an even distribution/ or a variant that fits my liking the most. opposed to min maxing all the time.

after i started my first character and logged on and joined a clan, i asked for players input on every class. there are 12 races and 12 classes. the responses i got were to use 2 or less races for each class(there was a 3 way split of a couple melee oriented classes) in light of this the seemingly 144 characters that are able to be created only 24-30 are deemed "ok" by the entire playerbase. that in itself is flawed. the players have, in other words, told me that 79 to 84% of the character build content is worthless and that only counts the min/max builds. if i was to factor in possibilities of every stat composition you're left with over 99% worthlessness.

makes me wonder why there isnt just set stats and only certain classes each race can be, oh because that's lame. so lets make reasons to use all the content