← Forum archive

PVP Dodge/Hitrate/Damage/HP

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
Interested in what people feel about it so far.

Some people have stated to me that alot of people have migrated to strength/endurance over AGI because they feel like AGI doesn't perform enough. I'm wondering how valid this is and what the solution can be if it exists.

Two people with the same AGI will have 40% hit rate, so that is the base. Right now 19 agi vs 24 agi would be a 5 AGI difference, or 10%. So this means in this scenario 19 agi would hit 30% of the time, and the 24 agi player would hit 50% of the time. (40% is PVP base.). So the difference out of 100 hits would be 30/100 hits with 19 AGI, or and 50/100 hits with 24 agi.

Is the above enough? Should it impact more? Maybe 3% instead of 2%? That would mean that it would be a 15% difference. So in the above scenario it would now be 25% hit rate vs 55% hit rate. Maybe that would be better.

Remember the above does not have any class bonuses added. Typically for most classes you can add or remove an AGI point, or 2% more dodge or hit rate. (monks dodge for example).

However, I also wonder if AGI is truly the problem now. Perhaps the damage multiplier is too high as a whole. Maybe the damage multiplier is too high. Maybe the per END point is too high, etc. AKA instead of a ling having lets say, 180 damage and a saurian having 230 damage, it would be better off at lets say 15% less, so 153 damage and 195 damage. Not sure if this is the real case solution though yet too but it would help average out the damage more, obviously because higher damage races would get more of a percentage off then lower races.

Maybe it's simply that the HP variance is too high, so that high HP classes have far too much HP so those extra hits in the end are the same as having less AGI. For example:

-I have 24 AGI and 800 HP. I get hit with 4x200 damage. So 800 damage. I'd die.
-I have 19 AGI and 1200 HP. I get hit with 6x200 damage. So 1200 damage. I'd die.

Both could be considered the same, because the AGI vs HP gain. However it might be seen right now something like this

-I have 24 AGI and 800 HP. I get hit with 4x200 damage. So 800 damage. I'd die.
-I have 19 AGI and 1200 HP. I get hit with 5x200 damage. So 1000 damage. I'd not die.

Meaning the HP gain is more useful in this scenario, which could be the case currently.

Maybe all races require the same kind of bonuses that lings might give to give them an edge, aka the stamina wait timer being quicker. I don't think this is a good idea though, probably far harder to balance anyways.

Need input though. Ideas, suggestions, etc. Balancing is tough work, and I WANT to ensure that high end/low agi/high str chars are useful, low str/high agi/low end chars are useful, etc.
Terron
in my opinion a ling with 18 24 17 x x x shouldn't beat a half orc 25 19 22 x x x in a melee duel on the mere principle that the str/dex should offset period. the ling should hit more often for less damage. when it comes down to it, saying both had the same hps the half orc still has an edge because the values in str/dex combined are 44 where a lings are 42. that slight edge is only empowered by the fact the half orc actually has significantly more hps. this is all basing the fight on the same gear and no skills. if someone made a half orc with 24 str and 18 agility the damage it does per round should be equal to the ling with the opposite values, in which case HPs wins the fight. You have the option to play other races that bring the fight to a closer range, perhaps a drakeblood 21 22 21(+1) x x 15 or a 21 19 24 x x 16 dwarf has what it takes to dethrone a half orc. guess youll have to see <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />

the strengths and weaknesses come into play with abilities. say it was the same fight but with 2 paladins the ling will still be edged out on hps overall damage, but mana pool, ability damage. and heal power are in the halflings favor. in most cases saying that the pally could heal itself til its out of mana the half orc is at a serious handicap because the total life in the fight is putting the halfling far above the half orc. the half orc wont win unless it hits a perfect round, and at 30% it doesn't seem very likely.

the same should hold true for wis vs int on spells.

the strengths of the halfling class are supreme dodge rate and avg ability damage and avg mana pool with subpar melee and hit points. dont make 23-28 points in dex devalue 47-52 points a half orc puts in str and end.

EDIT: alot of games institute a pvp damage penalty like -25% total damage to players, in most cases on a mud that is severely crippling to most min/max builds. that being cuz percentile would affect a horc warrior or gnome mage for more than a less viable build. at the same time it could be whats needed. seeing as the environmental pvp/pk element is not favoring low hps. but on the other side group pking is favoring dexterity imo.
Folder

Two people with the same AGI will have 40% hit rate, so that is the base. Right now 19 agi vs 24 agi would be a 5 AGI difference, or 10%. So this means in this scenario 19 agi would hit 30% of the time, and the 24 agi player would hit 50% of the time. (40% is PVP base.). So the difference out of 100 hits would be 30/100 hits with 19 AGI, or and 50/100 hits with 24 agi.

Is the above enough? Should it impact more? Maybe 3% instead of 2%? That would mean that it would be a 15% difference. So in the above scenario it would now be 25% hit rate vs 55% hit rate. Maybe that would be better.


In my experience so far Orcs beat everything else in melee, nearly all the time. Going against div can of course alter that. The huge STR and HP on orcs gives than en edge over pretty much everything else in melee. I think they should have an edge because that's all they are good for, but it's not so much an edge right now as it is a guaranteed victory. Let's compare ling and orc. 23 agi v 19 agi, 18 v 24 str. This puts us at 32% v 48% dodge. 16% difference, but an orc has 450HP more and an extra 6 STR. I don't know the numbers for STR scaling but I do know orcs hit waayyyy harder, as they should.

Halfling = 825 hp, 18 str, 23 agi, 48% dodge against the orc
Orc = 1275 hp, 24 str, 19 agi, 32% dodge against the ling

Orcs should be better in melee than lings, right? I'm sure we all agree on that but they are SO MUCH better that it's not really even close imo. The orc will get eaten by magic, yes, but how then do we balance melee? Surely we want some balance there too. I don't think it's fair to say Orcs win all melee and lings will do better against casters and leave it at that.

There are some races in the middle, goblins and dwarves for example. I think dwarves are nuts too especially since they have good MR. Gobslins just feel meh and still get rather eaten by magic.

All of this is to say AGI doesn't feel like it means enough. When you're trying to fight something with nearly 1300hp it's just like...welp cya later lol. You just don't beat that if you have ~1k or less hp.



However, I also wonder if AGI is truly the problem now. Perhaps the damage multiplier is too high as a whole. Maybe the damage multiplier is too high. Maybe the per END point is too high, etc. AKA instead of a ling having lets say, 180 damage and a saurian having 230 damage, it would be better off at lets say 15% less, so 153 damage and 195 damage. Not sure if this is the real case solution though yet too but it would help average out the damage more, obviously because higher damage races would get more of a percentage off then lower races.


Eh, maybe. Are those numbers real? I still think the problem is simply not dodging enough on lower HP bros.



Maybe it's simply that the HP variance is too high, so that high HP classes have far too much HP so those extra hits in the end are the same as having less AGI. For example:

-I have 24 AGI and 800 HP. I get hit with 4x200 damage. So 800 damage. I'd die.
-I have 19 AGI and 1200 HP. I get hit with 6x200 damage. So 1200 damage. I'd die.

Both could be considered the same, because the AGI vs HP gain. However it might be seen right now something like this

-I have 24 AGI and 800 HP. I get hit with 4x200 damage. So 800 damage. I'd die.
-I have 19 AGI and 1200 HP. I get hit with 5x200 damage. So 1000 damage. I'd not die.

Meaning the HP gain is more useful in this scenario, which could be the case currently.


There are multiple ways of balancing this out, but I think the easiest is just tweaking the dodge rates a bit. Orcs/Dwarves should have a lot of health, I don't think bringing the HP pools closer "feels" as good as tweaking dodge.



Maybe all races require the same kind of bonuses that lings might give to give them an edge, aka the stamina wait timer being quicker. I don't think this is a good idea though, probably far harder to balance anyways.


I could see this in the future but it's not needed for this balance discussion.


edit: in regards to the -25% damage penalty. Not a fan because PKing needs to be fast and furious or else everyone just runs away. Blech. I do understand that it helps balance in a way, but I'd rather find a different way.
Terron
atm i don't think the dodge rates should be altered until there's viable evidence that a half orc crushes every possible 25 while having more than 425 hps left. which i know isn't true. controlled environment tests would show that the agi classes are only dieing because they have less hps but at the same time ling druids/clerics etc be crushing it in events to. and to point a fact half orc knights are basically only killing other knights/barbs/assassins and monks, which is nothing in comparison to a ling druid or cleric being competitive vs any character. also when it comes to avoiding pks the horc is almost impossible to kill by yourself without it running, but against a group its almost impossible it doesn't die.

so it seems its all preference, personally, i don't see how a 28 pound halfling equips a 100 pound plate-mail and retains 23-24 dex anyway, where a 320 pound half orc in 150 pound platemail would atleast be semi mobile. its like asking whos scarier bill gates or chuck lidell, david or goliath? you'd shit your pants if that snaggle toothed monstrosity tried to cut you in half with a sword, while you'd just kick the ling like a stray dog. the ling should have to use cunning (abilities) to win like david, in the case of ingame it just isn't clashing steel to steel. lings have superb agility that does not entail speed, there is no way a halfling will out run a human or anything else. I love halflings but gd give it a rest.
Honzo
Does this mean that Gnomes can get an Agi or End buff to since they are at 17 end and only 21 agi? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> They get rocked by lots of melee. I honestly thought that it was 4% per point of agi difference so obviously I've been mistaken. 3% seems okay but 4% is what I already thought it was lol. I do think that horc has too much strength now personally and but i guess if you want more mr you can go less str more wisdom as a dwarf instead.
Agi vs End is avoidance vs hp. I do not think that halflings or gnomes should get a damage nerf though. Thatd hurt even worse. Anyone with 19 or 20 agi shouldnt dodge that much, 21-22 okay, 23 good, 24 excellent right? something like that? I think maybe closing the gap between hp would be better. I even remember in RoK when gobs went from 22 to end 20 end. That fixed the problem real quickly. Maybe adjusting the stats of the races would help and then lift the efficiency to 3-3.5% per agi point difference? I think 25% of the time hits with 19 agi is good considering that you are going to only have to hit 4 times to kill someone as classes hoc would be, less if slayer!
Folder
@Terron

Sorry what?

Bringing "realism" into this throws everything off. It's a fantasy world lol. We can't balance around whether an Orc or a Halfling should win in some kind of real environment x.x

At the end of the day this is a game in which simplicty is part of the charm. Not sure what you mean by use cunning to win because, frankly, there is no cunning in the basic melee classes. I don't believe the design intent is to go some MMO path where classes have dozens of abilities. Nothing wrong with adding things here and there, and that'll happen, but at its core the game won't be very complex.

I also don't know what you mean by "its all preference". Is your preference that Orcs win all melee and thats that? That seems against most of what you're saying because you also seem to want balance, but I'm rather confused by the Orc being bigger/stronger bit.
Folder
Does this mean that Gnomes can get an Agi or End buff to since they are at 17 end and only 21 agi? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> They get rocked by lots of melee. I honestly thought that it was 4% per point of agi difference so obviously I've been mistaken. 3% seems okay but 4% is what I already thought it was lol. I do think that horc has too much strength now personally and but i guess if you want more mr you can go less str more wisdom as a dwarf instead.
Agi vs End is avoidance vs hp. I do not think that halflings or gnomes should get a damage nerf though. Thatd hurt even worse. Anyone with 19 or 20 agi shouldnt dodge that much, 21-22 okay, 23 good, 24 excellent right? something like that? I think maybe closing the gap between hp would be better. I even remember in RoK when gobs went from 22 to end 20 end. That fixed the problem real quickly. Maybe adjusting the stats of the races would help and then lift the efficiency to 3-3.5% per agi point difference? I think 25% of the time hits with 19 agi is good considering that you are going to only have to hit 4 times to kill someone as classes hoc would be, less if slayer!


Right, well, gnomes don't make great melee statwise. Do we want them to since they make such strong offensive casters? Maybe, but then do we want orcs to be viable casters as well? I don't see a problem with having some races strong at one thing and weak at another. I would, as I already have, argue that Orcs (and probably dwarves) are simply too good at melee right now because there's not enough of a dodge difference to overcome the HP/STR difference.

Elves make viable casters, humans, half elves, lings, gnomes obviously. Even Ele and dark elf to some point. But the difference between them and the difference between Orcs and other melee is huge. You don't see a caster race that has +6 end and +6 int over another caster race, do you?
Terron
my preference is that a halfling is a 10x better race and well rounded in every class, and that a half orc knight is greater than a halfling knight(or any warrior w/o skills involved) the realism is just frustration that on every game in existence there is no penalty for a ling to be a warrior and that players consistently think a character with less invested (59 points) and lower HPs should beat a character that has 66 points invested and superior str and hps. in every game the general description is fighter: primary stat: strength. not dexterity

lets flip this for a second i want to complain in why my half orc mage cant destroy halfling mages at will? oh that's right because half orcs are dumb and drool on their spellbooks. halflings have their strengths its just not in the str and con firelds they have by far one of the best stat compositions ingame, str and con are their lowest maxstats hence they should suck as a skill-less melee unit.

FTR i made a halfling knight and im not saying all should die by my superb dexterity. im not even saying my warrior should win 5% vs a half orc cuz it just doesnt seem right to me.

dexterity should be the primary damage stat of backstabs not hammer smashes aswell as likely ranger damage to an extent (25% str 75% dex.) i would 100% agree that a halfling assassin should outclass a half orc.

perhaps knights need a different factor on a non sequential stat, perhaps int or wis to influence shield technique(blocks and parrys)


EDIT: folder u are classifying a halfling as a melee class when its only weaknesses lie in strength and con, thats about like me saying a drake blood is a caster and then in that case the difference is 10 int 10 wis for +3 endurance vs a ling being down 6 str 5 end while being up 5 dex 6 wis 6 int and up to 8 chr to a half orc.
Folder
Ehh this isn't DnD :/. I get the things you're saying but you kinda want an entirely different game it sounds like.

I think the game is mostly fine now with the exception of high HP characters being too hard to kill 1v1 (and a LOT of events are 1v1, there HAS to be balance).

I'm using halflings in this example but Orcs (and probably dwarves) trump everything in melee right now. This conversation isn't specifically about halflings. Orcs/Dwarves can be better than other races at melee, they SHOULD be in fact. But they shouldn't be SO much better that you don't have a shot at beating them 1v1.
Terron
perhaps dropping the pvp standard to 33%ish and adding a significant bonus to dodge for a +1? like a stotic 5% bonus? sacrificing stats for a significant dodge bonus seems more proportionate imo. but just remember when u start swinging and hitting 2/10 its just another character stuck in the junk column.


also if you're saying "its only half orcs and probably dwarves" that is implying agility has nothing to do with this entire arguement its end/hps only.

yes there is 1v1 events yes there are team events where horcs suck cuz they cant dodge for nothing. im pretty sure the half orcs have a race chat and conspired to eliminate all other races first. just sayin.
Folder
I say orcs/dwarves because both are 19 agi, 23 end for dwarves 22 for orcs. They are similar in melee because the HP outweighs the low AGI. There just aren't as many dwarves running around cause orcs hit harder I guess? I feel like dwarf is better than orc on paper but we haven't seen that manifest much yet.

In practice 19 agi dodge isn't so bad that those characters suck in group battles. I think orcs are often targeted by chanters no matter what and yeah they get roasted, but in my experience we will nearly always go for the low HP targets over anything unless we have a chanter and a low MR target.

Targets in group fights are based on 1) Div, 2) Magic Resist if a chanter is involved, 3) HP. From my perspective I've never ever thought "hit that 19 agi dude with 1300hp because he will dodge less", that character will nearly always live longer than an 8-900HP character.

I'm PvPing every day, I feel like I have a decent grasp on how its playing out.

Anyways an extra bonus to dodge is...maybe. +1 is hard for some classes though so I kinda think the better idea is a more balanced AGI stat.
Thi
This conversation is being derailed honestly, Terron you're rounding your every answer around the "halfling" argument.

I've put over 30 fights into test fighting Orcs (Killa/Mike) using Goblins (Slayer and Ninja) and Saurians (Zerker) on neutral div and 85% if not more of the fights the Goblins/Saurians lost and it wasn't a close fight, they usually end up with 300-500 HP.

I'd argue that agility is broken right now because it doesn't scale in the same pace as end/str gains do, meaning that the trade-off right now is so significant that equal strength fighters and a swing of 5 agi between endurance and agility makes the endurance player win likely 90% of the fights, this isn't a racial thing per say, it's stat balancing, HOs are not the only race ruling around, so are dwarves, people just realized that those two races are the "winners" by default on any 1v1 fight/event, so now there's a rush/craze of people leveling those races.

Now going back to NH initial post, I'd balance it out of agility, seems the "quickest" way to throw things into place, I don't think strength needs a change, it seems decent to me now, although I'd argue that some classes right now feel too overpowered, I think Cavaliers for example hit too hard considering the usefulness they already provide with Taunt / Shield Bash / HP Bonus.

As for HP Scaling, I kinda like the way it is and the diversity of the spectrum cause you can have anywhere from 850 to 1300 HP, meaning you can create classes for heavy hitting bosses, moshes, etc.

I'd also argue that agi needs a look into because for example the bonus right now is so small that a Dark Elf in pretty much all situations is a better everything than a Halfing, that +1agi meaning 2% extra dodge isn't anywhere worth the loss of 1 end and 2 str. So halfings have lost a niche unless for their high charisma, which would be very limiting to what they can be, thus why a couple months ago I said that anything above 23 agi might deserve an "edge" into dodge, otherwise it's worthless to have it in the first place, as well as it is to roll lings.
Terron
nitehawks formula showed that the lings dodge/hit rate is equivilent to 1.66 hits per a horcs 1, its an easy test and since ive been a game tester on multiple games i highly doubt its agi on this matter compared to relative hps. u want agi to be better but usually that entails horc users to endure miss miss miss miss miss POW! miss miss miss miss miss miss miss miss miss miss POW! POW! etc and thats lame as shit for a gamer to watch. thats why i mostly play lings/high dex lol im just not siding with the dex>all theory. i love lings but they arent built for melee like a half orc and on the flip side a horc cant cast spells or be as diverse as a ling. have staff make a "fake test race" with 19 str 25 dex and 22 con and i bet the horc wont win them all or stat items to test it with another horc that elects 19 str , +6 dex ring just a thought.


edit: in most games ive tested the agility stat is the only constant because it doesn't matter because hps scale against magic users aswell, in this case im about 100% positive it is entirely the power of the str stat or the hps from end. also a 5 point dex spread hitting 1.66x to 1 is more than most games ive seen. it could also be how the damage scales per level per str or other str variables but it isnt agility.

if the str is scaling proportionately a ling would hypothetically hit 18 damage per swing while a half orc does 25 multiplied out by the hit rate and the ling is doing 29.88 damage for every 25 an orc does. the 17 con fails as the race isnt melee hardy. thus 1200 /30 means the ling needs to hit 40x to kill a horc. 800/25 is 32. advantage horc with only 1 variable HP
NiteHawk
miss miss miss miss miss POW! miss miss miss miss miss miss miss miss miss miss POW! POW!


That is the difference. It's the difference between having a race that should be more 'random' but deal heavy damage on those hits vs a race you know that will often hit, but not as much difference. It's not just half orcs that are in question though obviously. You may not like that method of miss/miss/miss/POW but others might prefer heavy damage and random chances over a more steady characters. That is what choice is all about, that's what I do want. I for one prefer the heavy cannon type race for some scenarios, like slayers.

I don't want to make +1 points confusing and make them do different things, nor do I think they should either. It gets confusing that way. Changing the PVP value from 40% to 33% doesn't really solve the issue with AGI. It just means the battles will last longer, but overall the result of the fights will be the same.

But overall guys we are talking about AGI as a whole, not just two classes anyways.

This is the values that will be in place with the div changes. This is AGAINST DIVINITY so it's your bonus. 15% (which would be the max after the changes we talked about()

24 STR
Barbarian: 201-271 not DW... 221-298 DW
Assassin: 492-681 not DW,.. 541-749 DW
Knight: 195-264
Monk: 172-207.. RH is 2x.

18 STR
Barbarian: 151-203 not DW... 166-224 DW
Assassin: 368-511 not DW,.. 404-562 DW
Knight: 146-198
Monk: 129-155.. RH is 2x.


I am relaying this simply for data crunching . Looking at the damage formula it's not too terrible, though 24 str assassins and barbs seem to do some high damage. Though I guess its 15% more cause of div too. Maybe the classes themselves need a little change but thats for another topic I'd say as alot of these fights often are the same classes from what I can see. I can see that as a whole we might need to look at the damage values on a couple classes though.

I agree that they wouldn't win against 25 agi/22 end. We're coming to that point where I'd say END would make them too powerful (obviously) because having the dodge and alot of HP would make them overall too powerful.


And generally yeah, I also kind of wonder myself (and agree with the AGI). It's 30% HR vs 50% hr. This means that a ling will hit them half the time, or about 2/4 while a HO will do around 1.2/4. Lowering it further might make HOs miss too often too. I can understand increasing it a little if that is the case, but I wouldn't go as far as doing 4% per agi point for example, people are saying then you want HO to hit 20% of the time and lings to hit 60% of the time. That to me is a CRAZY difference.

Maybe it's simply the fact that HO has that 24 STR and it should be lowered again to 23 STR. But that only removes about 8 average damage, or 16 average damage on a slayer (due to /hide then attack is two turns.). I don't really think 8 damage is going to fix the problem but it would be a help on 'fixing things'. Something else would also have to be adjusted on top of it. But I feel that 23STR/19AGI isn't worth it VS 23STR/22AGI class, reason we gave HO 24STR/19AGI. Obv eamples here use the +1 in STR.. SO maybe it's okay and other things need adjusting as I stated.


I do want to see if there is another way though. I want HOs to obviously miss more, but missing ALL THE TIME is bad. I'd rather solve this another way if possible. 30% to 50% is a good difference I feel.. If I HAVE too, maybe 2.5% or 3% maximum, but somethin else I think needs to be in place so that the AGI loss isn't great. People NEED to feel like they are hitting... People WILL complain they miss alot. Even though they might deal tons more damage and in reality, they might be a better race, but alot of negatives is bad. Obviously though the 24 vs 19 agi scenario is not a common one, and It would most likely be around 21-22 AGI for alot of races vs the HO, which I can understand why 3% would be 'ok'.

It's like the whole quest system where it's better to have quest require 10 items that drop at 20% droprate vs 1 item that drops at 2% droprate. You feel the progression with the first one, yet they will typically both require the same amount of time on average to run.
Thi
Well, honestly tweaking the agi seems like a quick way to go around it and doesn't seem overly complex to do or rollback if necessary, we have been at the current system for a couple months now, so change it and lets see how it reacts for the upcoming weeks and assess the results?
Terron
i agree with you on the agility i think its fine. at this point balancing stats/altering the hp scale seems almost more effective. but at the same time mage bait becomes even more so. people are pushing for a balance to push 35-38 in stat points(combined str/end) to be more equal to a high 47, which on the flip side is as ignorant as a saurian caster user pushing to make his 14 int closer to a gnomes 22 in relative output.

i mean there is an option to run mage heavy in events so you know the half orcs will likely be toast, but instead you equip and send in the almighty toddler with his sharpened toothpick sword and enchanted turtle shell plate-mail, donning his sea shell shield. which is completely fine, because it might be a mage/caster you fight and not a horc warrior, just atm it isn't.

my only real discrepancy is in the fact players are wanting races in which they are trying to utilize the worst 2 stats(1 or both being under 20) and want them to compete vs a race that is utilizing its best 2 stats. i would say it should never go above a 25/75 doesn't seem right seeing as a half orc sucks at everything else.
Folder
Let's use zerkers here. No +1, dodge reduction evens out.

Orc
24 STR, 22 END. 1320HP.
236 AD, 259.5 when DW

Ling
18 STR, 17 END. 907HP
177 AD, 195 when DW

The ling will need to hit the orc 8 times to kill it. 7 times if dual wielding. The orc needs to hit the ling 4 times to kill it, with or without DW. On average it will take 17 attacks for the ling to kill the orc. 15 if dual wielding. On average it will take the orc 13 attacks to kill the ling. The orc can wear a shield and still kill the ling in the same number of attacks, which further skews things a bit and I don't really have the math for that one unfortunately. This is discounting all absorbs and such, but those likely favor the orc a bit as they will require more hits to kill. This is also not taking into account FLURRY, which should benefit the ling more because of higher hit rate.

That actually sounds decent on paper, so what's going on ingame? I feel like something isn't translating here when it should be. In these averages the orc is winning, which is correct imo, but it's also fairly close and in my experience so far we aren't seeing that. What am I missing here guys?
Terron
i'm not implying the whole system is perfect by any means. the fact that if the characters were set at 1 million times normal life, the half orc would lose by a massive amount. that in itself proves the dodge is working quite admirably. the hp scale is too vast, or the relative power of str is too great, or armor doesn't cut enough damage but that's separate entirely.

i'm leaning towards the endurance on this one cuz after playing multiple classes and races the half orcs are not putting out the same DPS as a dexy race, they miss alot. they tend to excel on monsters below their own level which is slower exp.

when a 17 con race gets 30 hps and a 24 con barb is recieving 57-60 its a little too vast. i think the cause and effect would be better if 17 con(non barb) pushed to about 35 hps and a 24 con barb pushed a max of around 53-55. this also lightens the grapplehold endurance has as a stat and players may opt for a -1 if the scale is less.

but you also have to realise that changing hp scale, drastically influences mages power and then will need a boost in MR which entails more and more innaffects.

edit:@ NH dropping the relative pvp hit rate to 33 does more than just let the fight last longer. the relative breakpoints and rounding numbers are less of a factor. orcs killing an enemy in 4 stam is lowered aswell. considering the 20 point difference in % would render 19 agi with approximately 25% chance to hit the 24 agi character. .25*.25*.25*.25 is extremely low odds. allowing factors like potions to be more effectual. im not really for changing it because you can move it 100's of time but sooner or later you have to cement it down and look at different factors.
Atticuz
I'm totally down with any agi/hitrate/dodge buff's <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> Do it NH do it <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />

Give monks their hit rate back and all will be right in the world

You guys crunch the numbers and ill mooch the buff's
NiteHawk
Let's use zerkers here. No +1, dodge reduction evens out.

Orc
24 STR, 22 END. 1320HP.
236 AD, 259.5 when DW

Ling
18 STR, 17 END. 907HP
177 AD, 195 when DW

The ling will need to hit the orc 8 times to kill it. 7 times if dual wielding. The orc needs to hit the ling 4 times to kill it, with or without DW. On average it will take 17 attacks for the ling to kill the orc. 15 if dual wielding. On average it will take the orc 13 attacks to kill the ling. The orc can wear a shield and still kill the ling in the same number of attacks, which further skews things a bit and I don't really have the math for that one unfortunately. This is discounting all absorbs and such, but those likely favor the orc a bit as they will require more hits to kill. This is also not taking into account FLURRY, which should benefit the ling more because of higher hit rate.

That actually sounds decent on paper, so what's going on ingame? I feel like something isn't translating here when it should be. In these averages the orc is winning, which is correct imo, but it's also fairly close and in my experience so far we aren't seeing that. What am I missing here guys?


Remember that the damage I gave it lower than what it is currently since we are changing things, and is based on DIV. The higher the damage right now, the more the HO will benefit from it over a Ling. We do also need to take into regard ARMOR eventually. Not sure if we should just ignore armor for now, suppose we can.. But I do think it plays a part.

Anyways, The values I get are:

HO attacking LING
907HP / 236 = 3.8 successful attacks
907HP / 259.6 = 3.5 successful attacks

Ling attacking HO
1320HP / 177 = 7.5 successful attacks
1320HP / 195 = 6.8 successful attacks

Already double the amount of attacks. However this would be incorrect to say these are the proper values. I made a small program that took my dodge formula and ran it 1mil times to get a sure 'average'. Now to add in dodge. Ling has 24 agi with default 18 STR as an example, and HO will use its default 19 AGI with 24 STR.


HO attacking Ling with above stats:
Not DW = 13.5 attacks to kill
DW = 13.3 attacks to kill.

Ling attacking HO with above stats:
Not DW = 16 attacks to kill
DW = 14 attacks to kill


Buuuuut, armor should play a part! This is OAD level armor around for med classes.


HO DW attacking Ling with shield:
Not DW = 17.9 attacks to kill
DW = 16.2 attacks to kill.

HO DW attacking Ling with no shield:
Not DW = 16.97 attacks to kill
DW = 14.92 attacks to kill.

Now we start seeing the effects of armor! Because of the half negations or full negations, it starts to vary a little bit more. Let's see what lings can do.

Ling attacking HO with shield:
Not DW = 19.54 attacks to kill
DW = 17.9 attacks to kill

Ling attacking HO without shield:
Not DW = 18.24 attacks to kill
DW = 16.71 attacks to kill


----

You can see that lings are normally under here. 2-3+ attacks goes a long way I feel... HOWEVER, with big damage and lower AGI comes more randomness. Though the above are the averages, it more looks like this:

HO DW attacking Ling with shield:
Not DW = 13-21 attacks to kill
DW = 12-20 attacks to kill

HO DW attacking Ling with no shield:
Not DW = 12-20 attacks to kill
DW = 11-19 attacks to kill

Ling attacking HO with shield:
Not DW = 17-21 attacks to kill
DW = 15-19 attacks to kill

Ling attacking HO without shield:
Not DW = 16-20 attacks to kill
DW = 14-18 attacks to kill


---

The answer to 'why it feels that HO are better'. They obviously are even without the randomization, but because they can actually kill lings in alot lower hits sometimes, it means that you get the false idea that HOs are WAY better. Those these two random fights as an example (not related to anything)

Out of 1mil fights, I killed you between 12-20 attacks to kill.
Out of 1mil fights, You killed me between 15-17 attacks to kill.

They are BOTH the same in terms of average, however, I 100% believe that people would FEEL that HOs are far better because they sometimes dish out those 12 round kills. I can't really change that feeling, these are actual numbers and actual formulas though.

However, we can OBVIOUSLY see why lings are worse with these formulas, even without the randomness.


Lower the AGI further (to me) would mean that battles woudl feel like you NEVER hit. So lowering it from 40% to 33% I think is a bad idea. It already is generally on average, higher than normal.


I will come up with something next post though, bear with me, separating this cause its long as shit.