← Forum archive

PVP Dodge/Hitrate/Damage/HP

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Dan
NH, i think to make hit chance less luck based is good.

But in the long run lings would be eaten by drakes anyway, because of the str end factor.

BUT

You could make lings (and probably gnomes, less effectively) have a passive agi based dodge bonus. What would make sense since they are phisically small and fast.

And would balance things without make them op.
Folder
Well if they are that terrible we best change that eh, they shouldn't be as bad as you claim 8)


We've discussed this quite a lot before. 1v1 they are not that bad, mathematically. But the problem lies in group fights - when there are 5 DPS hitting a target it is much, much easier to drop 900hp than it is to drop 1200hp. AGI does not save lings/gnomes here.

I have a ling guard and a gnome chanter and frankly I wish I never leveled either of them as they are not at all good in group fighting, which is what I enjoy most.

Is the answer make agi better? Maybe but this skews 1v1 and we don't want that either. Lings should be at a disadvantage (not HUGE of course) 1v1 vs the strong melee races. If we simply up agi then we easily risk making lings good at 1v1 AND group fights.

Meh I only play 20+end races in group fights now, and I lurves my dwarf cav when it comes to surviving <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> .
Dan
Why lings should be weak vs "strong melee races" while elders can take out casters and still do good against melee?

I think every class should have a decent chance on 1v1.

In the case of lings, passive agi based dosge bonus could do the job and still make sense imho.
Folder
You're comparing apples to oranges there. Elders is a different topic.

Lings need to be weaker vs strong melee because lings also have MR. There's zero reason to make a lizard/drake/orc if lings are just as competitive in straight melee fights because the other races get BBQd by casters.

This isn't just halflings, it's gnomes as well. Lower HP in group fights is the issue...but balancing it is not easy because 1v1 is also a thing. I don't have a perfect answer here I'm just trying to spur some discussion.

edit: for a quick touch on the elder issue - they are THE 1v1 class basically. But an elder in group fights is borderline pointless. No group buffs, which I'll keep arguing for, means they don't bring haste utility. They need to be unmorphed to FF which means they will be taking high amounts of damage if targeted. Their damage is nothing special, it is outshined by ninjas and slayers (and zerkers but who uses those huehue).
Dan
I bring elders to the discussion because they have the same advantage as lings do: MR. And stkll do ok against other melee.

When NH change MR to be less effective, elders wont be op, and lings will be worst than they are atm.

This rock scissor paper meta is too simplistic to this game. It doesn't feel right.

Its ok to have advantage, but make it not too great will give the game diversity, and diversity is very entretaining.
Lateralus
I bring elders to the discussion because they have the same advantage as lings do: MR. And stkll do ok against other melee.

When NH change MR to be less effective, elders wont be op, and lings will be worst than they are atm.

This rock scissor paper meta is too simplistic to this game. It doesn't feel right.

Its ok to have advantage, but make it not too great will give the game diversity, and diversity is very entretaining.


Even after mr gets changed they will still be tops against casters that's not going to go away. It's not like nitehawk is going to make it so caster destroys everything.


Elders are the top 1v1 pvp class by far (they have no weakness and are strong against everyone) I am not just making this up the stats show it. I believe up until the last koth they won the last 6 koths in a row. An elder this last koth won 12 matches in a row. The elder finally died to well another eldeR. While 1v1 shouldn't matter too much I'd say most events ran are 1v1 based so it is kind of a big deal. Koth and jr koth are ran weekly. Cycle down and gamblers luck are also 1v1 events.

It's not like druids are bad at group pvp either. I'd say they are top tier in that too with healing, buffs and debuffs.

Tldr: make an elemental elder if you want all the pp
NiteHawk
They'll still be hard to take down as it is, but just not as strong. Because they often have high wisdom you'll have his resists. I'm mainly making it easier to deal with and making the min/max range less erratic. Plus giving a chance for lower INT spell casters to be useful too. I won't be adjusting too much dodge/etc wise this next update coming, so theres probably going to be a little unbalance until we sort that out next too.
Miach
One thing I want to add:

So the focus isn't on AGI, so what? +1 that strength and move on.

I'm tired of people thinking 23-24 agility gonna make them a god, it ain't gonna save you! 2% one way or the other is meaningless.

Max out your race's natural agility and move on! Not all races are going to be equal, everything has its niche.

you want something well-rounded go human
JadeFalcon
Trying to sort this out. Its a bit of a draft, so if anyone points out anything, ill change
Edited once, blame folder.

b]Enchanters:[/b]
Strong points:
Support spells
Extremely good versus Low MR races
Weak Points:
Reduced damage versus High MR Races


Death Mages:
Strong points:
Better combat spells
Extremely good versus Low MR races
Weak Points:
Reduced damage versus High MR Races


Elder Druids:
Strong points:
Better combat spells
Good damage potential
Weak Points:
Highly vulnerable unmorphed.


Priests:
Strong points:
Support spells
Good versus Low MR races
Weak Points:
Reduced damage versus everyone


Minstrels:
Strong points:
Support spells
Weak Points:
Reduced damage versus everyone


Guardians:
Strong points:
Can Protect
Support spells
Weak Points:
Low offensive potential

Stalkers:
Strong points:
Have pets
Weak Points:
Low offensive potential


Slayers (High MR races)
Strong Point:
Hide/Sneak
High Damage
Can conceivably one round an enemy
Weak Points:
Inferior to Low MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes
Elder Druid Fodder


Slayers (Low MR races)
Strong Point:
Hide/Sneak
High Damage
Can conceivably one round an enemy
Superior to high MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes
Weak Point:
Enchanter fodder
Elder Druid Fodder


Ninjas (High MR races)
Strong Point:
High Damage
AC Bonus
Can conceivably one round an enemy
Weak Point:
Inferior to high MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes


Ninjas (Low MR races)
Strong Point:
High Damage
AC Bonus
Can conceivably one round an enemy
Superior to high MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes
Weak Point:
Enchanter fodder


Cavaliers (High MR races)
Strong Point:
High HP
Good damage
Weak Points:
Inferior to Low MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes


Cavaliers (Low MR races)
Strong Point:
High HP
Good damage
Superior to high MR Races in Comparable rogue/fighter classes
Weak Point:
Enchanter fodder


Berzerkers (High MR races)
Strong Point:
High HP
Good damage
Weak Points:
Inferior to Low MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes


Berzerkers (Low MR races)
Strong Point:
High HP
Good damage
Superior to high MR Races in Comparable rogue/fighter classes
Weak Point:
Enchanter fodder


Brigands (High MR races)
Strong Point:
Hide/Autosneak/Steal
Weak Points:
Inferior to Low MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes


Brigands (Low MR races)
Strong Point:
Hide/Autosneak/Steal
Superior to high MR Races in Comparable rogue/fighter classes
Weak Point:
Enchanter fodder
Miach
List is real linear. I feel like it's missing some nuances of certain classes.

Of course I make weird character combinations, sometimes...
Dan
One thing I want to add:

So the focus isn't on AGI, so what? +1 that strength and move on.

I'm tired of people thinking 23-24 agility gonna make them a god, it ain't gonna save you! 2% one way or the other is meaningless.

Max out your race's natural agility and move on! Not all races are going to be equal, everything has its niche.

you want something well-rounded go human


Its not about be a god, agi just should be as important as any other stat, and currently its not.

Its an important part of the core, its cool to have niches, but with no agi, the game makes low end characters worthless.

And make gnomes and lings have more endurance or str is not a good solution imo.

They should be weaker phisically as they are, but they should be harder to hit as well. That is what to make them unique, that is their strong point.

That would make them worth both in 1v1 as in group fights, bc they should live enough to do their part.

And not less imporantly, make sense in the lore.
Tucker
Trying to sort this out. Its a bit of a draft, so if anyone points out anything, ill change

Enchanters:
Strong points:
Natural AGI

Death Mages:
Strong points:
Natural AGI

Slayers (High MR races)
Natural AGI

Cavaliers (High MR races)
Weak Points:
Lower natural AGI

Brigands (High MR races)
Weak Points:
Inferior to Low MR Races in comparable rogue/fighter classes
Lower natural AGI



What are you talking about with this natural agi stuff?

So the focus isn't on AGI, so what? +1 that strength and move on.

I'm tired of people thinking 23-24 agility gonna make them a god, it ain't gonna save you! 2% one way or the other is meaningless.

Max out your race's natural agility and move on! Not all races are going to be equal, everything has its niche


If agi is meaningless then why even bother maxing it <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />. Oh, because it's by definition not meaningless...

You can argue its underwhelming compared to points in str or end (mathematically it isn't) but that seems to be the general consensus no matter the math. As Folder mentioned the real problem is that lower end classes (ling, gnome, elf, drow) have trouble surviving in group fights. You can help this with a slight buff to Agi (2 --> 2.5 seems very reasonable and has been proposed). However the easy way to balance this is to simply buff/nerf the natural bonuses of the races without touching the stats unless needed. You could give the least popular classes reasonable buffs- for example (just spitballing) giving lings and gnomes a 4% dodge buff (just like monks get but less than their 7.5%) You could throw +4 ac to Gobby's and remove the +4 ac from dwarves.

You can't really balance races by tweaking stats and I'd imagine the community would be much less happy about tweaking the races stats rather than adding or removing racial mods.

Edit: Folder why would you say Elder's are bad in group fights? They usually have solid hp (except gnomes/elf), incredible MR, high dodge and hitrates, and strong damage. Sure Zerkers, Ninjas, and Slayers will have more deeps but they all have major weaknesses that makes them easy targets to focus down first.
JadeFalcon
Tucker, i was under the impression (mind you, unconfirmed) that because certain classes require more exp to lvl, they have a better dodge rate.
Folder
JF where did you come up with that lol. No such thing as "naturai AGI" <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> .

@Tucker - I think I outlined it but in case I didn't...

REAL group fight optimization leaves no room for a druid. 1) They won't be hasting as there are no group buffs. 2) Ninjas/slayers do more damage (and more importantly higher BURST damage). 3) Most of the time they will not be FFing as this leaves them vulnerable and doing zero damage.

Basically ninjas/slayers/chanters/priests are all you need to be the best in group fights. Everything else is niche / could be done better by one of these classes.
Miach
What do you guys mena? Agi certainly makes a difference right now. Lings already get a ton more agi potential than most other races.

I don't understand the argument now. Are you just talking to talk?

Maybe the thread is too large at this point to really understand the entirety of the conversation and its ultimate goal.

Agility is a thing, you get more dodge and hitrate per point. The races are already setup that way.

You're saying it's not enough? When will it be enough? I can predict most of the fights right now in KoTH and JrKoTH and agility is one of the factors along with class comparison.

Bottom line, agility does currently matter, saying it doesn't make much difference is silly. A lot of people who comment on the matter (including myself sometimes, sorry Chris <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /> ) do not have a big enough sample size to consider their facts accurate.

Why a Ling will NEVER beat an Orc in melee: Strength matters, HP matters, Agility does not compensate for this because even with a 15% extra dodge, the Strength and Endurance alone will overwhelm the Ling a majority of the time. RNG tho, anything CAN happen, but in large scale comparisons one stat will never outweigh two.
NiteHawk
Why a Ling will NEVER beat an Orc in melee:


If it's never thats' an issue. Lings should be able to kill Orcs, but orcs will have a higher chance of winning. It's not gonna be 90%/10%. I'm thinking more like 60/40, or 70/30 max. Same when it comes to magic vs ho
Miach
Well they're gimped on two of the main stats that matter, so balance the HP or balance the Strength.

Agility is seemingly fine as is.
Folder
No one is saying AGI is broken or doesn't do anything. It's just not as good as other stats.

For group fight situations there's no reason to purposefully use a low END character over a high END character. Balancing it is not easy though because it skews 1v1, unless we come up a better solution than a flat AGI buff.
JadeFalcon
JF where did you come up with that lol. No such thing as "naturai AGI" <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> .


I honestly thought that classes that demanded a higher experience to lvl to 25 had a sort of bonus versus other classes. If not, what is the point of having different exp requirements?



Basically ninjas/slayers/chanters/priests are all you need to be the best in group fights. Everything else is niche / could be done better by one of these classes.


Well i think this replies partially my reply to your comment above, i think you are right. However i think then its legitimate to suggest (you do it >P) that all classes should have similar exp requirements, and should be balanced to usefulness.