PVP Dodge/Hitrate/Damage/HP
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
on the topic of warmage i dont think a warmage would require max wisdom, a smaller mana pool really wouldnt matter. however it is probably easier to create this as a class with cure/beam and a bunch of self buffs, basing the self buffs on int would ultimately serve no purpose tho as ud be left with the same races as a real mage w/o the real benefits. id probably guess the equation could be run with '(int + end)/2' istead of the normal int in the formula for spells. would make it interesting to have a viable class that can be every race. also sounds fun tbh.
If INT is revamped it would generally be same damage at max (lets base max on 23 int), but scaling would be lower. Calculator making time:
BEAM
23 INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
88.1 / 102
With Min / With Max
101.3 / 117.3
Against Min / Against Max
74.9 / 86.7
22INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
84.2 / 98
With Min / With Max
96.8 / 112.7
Against Min / Against Max
71.6 / 83.37
21INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
80.4 / 93
With Min / With Max
92.5 / 107
Against Min / Against Max
68.3 / 79.1
20INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
76.6 / 89
With Min / With Max
88.1 / 102.4
Against Min / Against Max
65.1 / 75.7
18INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
68.9 / 80
With Min / With Max
79.2 / 92
Against Min / Against Max
58.6 / 68
16INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
61.3 / 71
With Min / With Max
70.5 / 81.7
Against Min / Against Max
52.1 / 60.4
PER INT POINT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
3.8 / 4
With Min / With Max
4.4 / 4.6
Against Min / Against Max
3.2 / 3.4
Looking at Man's values, he was basing it off against div, and I mean, even 23 int against div does pretty bad damage, but that is an obvious. The spell is a weak spell, and it caps out at level 14 for sorcs, and level 15 for necros (same ending damage). 4 points of damage on average per INT point at level 14/15 seems fair to me.
Per point is the last value here, shows what each INT gives... Going to post another example.
BEAM
23 INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
88.1 / 102
With Min / With Max
101.3 / 117.3
Against Min / Against Max
74.9 / 86.7
22INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
84.2 / 98
With Min / With Max
96.8 / 112.7
Against Min / Against Max
71.6 / 83.37
21INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
80.4 / 93
With Min / With Max
92.5 / 107
Against Min / Against Max
68.3 / 79.1
20INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
76.6 / 89
With Min / With Max
88.1 / 102.4
Against Min / Against Max
65.1 / 75.7
18INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
68.9 / 80
With Min / With Max
79.2 / 92
Against Min / Against Max
58.6 / 68
16INT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
61.3 / 71
With Min / With Max
70.5 / 81.7
Against Min / Against Max
52.1 / 60.4
PER INT POINT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
3.8 / 4
With Min / With Max
4.4 / 4.6
Against Min / Against Max
3.2 / 3.4
Looking at Man's values, he was basing it off against div, and I mean, even 23 int against div does pretty bad damage, but that is an obvious. The spell is a weak spell, and it caps out at level 14 for sorcs, and level 15 for necros (same ending damage). 4 points of damage on average per INT point at level 14/15 seems fair to me.
Per point is the last value here, shows what each INT gives... Going to post another example.
Let's do BLAST. Max cap is at level 25.
INT 23
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
129 / 192
With Min / With Max
148.4 / 220.8
Against Min / Against Max
109.7 / 163.2
INT 22
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
123.4 / 184
With Min / With Max
141.9 / 211.6
Against Min / Against Max
104.9 / 156.4
INT 21
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
117.8 / 175
With Min / With Max
135.5 / 201.3
Against Min / Against Max
100.1 / 148.8
INT 20
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
112.2 / 167
With Min / With Max
129 / 192.1
Against Min / Against Max
95.4 / 142
INT 18
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
101 / 150
With Min / With Max
116.2 / 172.5
Against Min / Against Max
85.9 / 127.5
INT 16
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
89.8 / 134
With Min / With Max
103.3 / 154.1
Against Min / Against Max
76.3 / 113.9
PER INT POINT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
5.6 / 8
With Min / With Max
6.4 / 9.2
Against Min / Against Max
4.8 / 6.8
The minimum could be a little better, but overall eh. When I look at a knight for example with the new changes 20 str, they get 150-202 damage on divinity. obviously in general often magic pierces better right now, but not terrible.
Sorc 18 INT:
116.2 / 172.5
Sorc 23 INT:
148.4 / 220.8
----
Knight 18 STR
135 / 182
Knight 23 STR
172 / 232
INT 23
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
129 / 192
With Min / With Max
148.4 / 220.8
Against Min / Against Max
109.7 / 163.2
INT 22
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
123.4 / 184
With Min / With Max
141.9 / 211.6
Against Min / Against Max
104.9 / 156.4
INT 21
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
117.8 / 175
With Min / With Max
135.5 / 201.3
Against Min / Against Max
100.1 / 148.8
INT 20
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
112.2 / 167
With Min / With Max
129 / 192.1
Against Min / Against Max
95.4 / 142
INT 18
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
101 / 150
With Min / With Max
116.2 / 172.5
Against Min / Against Max
85.9 / 127.5
INT 16
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
89.8 / 134
With Min / With Max
103.3 / 154.1
Against Min / Against Max
76.3 / 113.9
PER INT POINT
Neutral Min / Neutral Max
5.6 / 8
With Min / With Max
6.4 / 9.2
Against Min / Against Max
4.8 / 6.8
The minimum could be a little better, but overall eh. When I look at a knight for example with the new changes 20 str, they get 150-202 damage on divinity. obviously in general often magic pierces better right now, but not terrible.
Sorc 18 INT:
116.2 / 172.5
Sorc 23 INT:
148.4 / 220.8
----
Knight 18 STR
135 / 182
Knight 23 STR
172 / 232
Seems like magic damage is pretty solid, based on those numbers at least. I don't have a chanter though so i can't really comment on resist rates except from the other side. That being that at my 16 wis gobln ninja is chanter food, which I think seems a little excessive but I also don't think a buff to magic resist at the high end is at all needed. So ehhh...I should lvl a chanter one of these days and have better input.
Seems like magic damage is pretty solid, based on those numbers at least. I don't have a chanter though so i can't really comment on resist rates except from the other side. That being that at my 16 wis gobln ninja is chanter food, which I think seems a little excessive but I also don't think a buff to magic resist at the high end is at all needed. So ehhh...I should lvl a chanter one of these days and have better input.
16 wis gobby is about 43% resists.
my necro has great solid damage. its level 20 and pretty good at hitting now, i only seen a small problem of it being slightly hard with inaffects lvls 4 -18 mostly. this is talking solo, cuz hoping in a party and leeching exp of barb and ninja kills isn't a good measure. other than that i dont think they need changed atm.
@folder w/o exactly knowing how MR works i sit here wondering why youd think a 16 wis goblin should standout in MR
8% for race
10% for class
and im sure atleast 1% per wisdom
just looks to me like ud take 145-160 damage every blast( again im just guessing)
seems like in the situation where u face mages it is more viable to use dark elf or elf/helf or even the stunner with an occasional gnome.
as an outsider reading wiki/forums i never pegged a goblin for magic resistance at all figured the 8% was just there to make them die in a similar number of casts as a horc. that being said i think casters should kill as many builds as ninjas/slayers or the exp of 350m shouldn't be as high or monk/assassin isnt high enough.
@folder w/o exactly knowing how MR works i sit here wondering why youd think a 16 wis goblin should standout in MR
8% for race
10% for class
and im sure atleast 1% per wisdom
just looks to me like ud take 145-160 damage every blast( again im just guessing)
seems like in the situation where u face mages it is more viable to use dark elf or elf/helf or even the stunner with an occasional gnome.
as an outsider reading wiki/forums i never pegged a goblin for magic resistance at all figured the 8% was just there to make them die in a similar number of casts as a horc. that being said i think casters should kill as many builds as ninjas/slayers or the exp of 350m shouldn't be as high or monk/assassin isnt high enough.
my necro has great solid damage. its level 20 and pretty good at hitting now, i only seen a small problem of it being slightly hard with inaffects lvls 4 -18 mostly. this is talking solo, cuz hoping in a party and leeching exp of barb and ninja kills isn't a good measure. other than that i dont think they need changed atm.
@folder w/o exactly knowing how MR works i sit here wondering why youd think a 16 wis goblin should standout in MR
8% for race
10% for class
and im sure atleast 1% per wisdom
just looks to me like ud take 145-160 damage every blast( again im just guessing)
seems like in the situation where u face mages it is more viable to use dark elf or elf/helf or even the stunner with an occasional gnome.
as an outsider reading wiki/forums i never pegged a goblin for magic resistance at all figured the 8% was just there to make them die in a similar number of casts as a horc. that being said i think casters should kill as many builds as ninjas/slayers or the exp of 350m shouldn't be as high or monk/assassin isnt high enough.
Goblins are meant to be decently resistant to magic. They aren't the best overall PVP choice for damage and such, they are meant to be kind of the lower end for physical classes but having some sort of magic resistance. By 'resistant' I'm talking about half way at least with a goblin monk.
I could see raising their MR for race though, cause max is 16 wis, mayeb give them another 5% or so its around 48-50% with a goblin monk. goblin assassin would be around 40%.
The MR scales alot when it comes to race/class and wisdom. 20 wisdom with 8% race bonus would overall win the MR battle vs someone who has 16 wisdom and 15% bonus. That's why I can see raising MR on goblins a bit.
i thought 17 was max goblin wis :O
i thought 17 was max goblin wis :O
Oh right, it probably is <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> It's probably another 4% with gobbies then.
You right max is 17, just going off memory from work <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />.
I didn't say I think a gobby should stand out with MR, I said they are food. Mostly as a point of reference, not necessarily a complaint or saying it needs to change but pointing out the difference between 16 and 20 wis seems super big. Just food for thought.
I didn't say I think a gobby should stand out with MR, I said they are food. Mostly as a point of reference, not necessarily a complaint or saying it needs to change but pointing out the difference between 16 and 20 wis seems super big. Just food for thought.
Can we look at experience to level also?
Assy 350 mill
Monk 350 mill
Etc
Barb 275 mill
Thief 275 moll
Should consideration be adjusted so the hardest to level in exp be thought about
Could we adjust barb experience to 400 mill since barbs are now being used as a one of the higher damage dealer
Thief is one of the worst things for pvp, and same experience as barb, yes comparing experience to level.
Always thought the most experienced fighter should have best in the end game
And I tried a Thief. I saw worse or no change in drop rates thinking it would help chance against monsters. Could Thief drop rate be upped more. I did this after it was supposed to help a party of 6 in fighting.
Not many is going to want a Thief in party cause they need to steal gold for experience, but if the actual chances were good of getting a item then people would want them.
Assy 350 mill
Monk 350 mill
Etc
Barb 275 mill
Thief 275 moll
Should consideration be adjusted so the hardest to level in exp be thought about
Could we adjust barb experience to 400 mill since barbs are now being used as a one of the higher damage dealer
Thief is one of the worst things for pvp, and same experience as barb, yes comparing experience to level.
Always thought the most experienced fighter should have best in the end game
And I tried a Thief. I saw worse or no change in drop rates thinking it would help chance against monsters. Could Thief drop rate be upped more. I did this after it was supposed to help a party of 6 in fighting.
Not many is going to want a Thief in party cause they need to steal gold for experience, but if the actual chances were good of getting a item then people would want them.
You right max is 17, just going off memory from work <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />.
I didn't say I think a gobby should stand out with MR, I said they are food. Mostly as a point of reference, not necessarily a complaint or saying it needs to change but pointing out the difference between 16 and 20 wis seems super big. Just food for thought.
Yes and no. For example Human Knight. 39% with 16, 53% with 20. I think that's OK.
Can we look at experience to level also?
Assy 350 mill
Monk 350 mill
Etc
Barb 275 mill
Thief 275 moll
Should consideration be adjusted so the hardest to level in exp be thought about
Could we adjust barb experience to 400 mill since barbs are now being used as a one of the higher damage dealer
Thief is one of the worst things for pvp, and same experience as barb, yes comparing experience to level.
Always thought the most experienced fighter should have best in the end game
And I tried a Thief. I saw worse or no change in drop rates thinking it would help chance against monsters. Could Thief drop rate be upped more. I did this after it was supposed to help a party of 6 in fighting.
Not many is going to want a Thief in party cause they need to steal gold for experience, but if the actual chances were good of getting a item then people would want them.
I think barbs should be at least 300 or 330.. 400mil is way to much though.. They are overpowered and they are getting a nerf to damage still. Obviously they are still the hardest hitters but it won't be as it is now with regular hits of crazy.
Thieves bonus drop chance is 20%. ATM that means if a item drops at 50%, then the item will drop at a bonus of 60%. I could go a little higher but I don't think it should be too crazy. Regardless that ITEM will drop 20% more then if the thief has not been in the party in any case atm. I could see going to 30% or even 45%.
So with 30% a item that drops 50% of the time would drop 65% of the time instead.
35% would be 67.5%.
On a item that drops at lets say 15%, which is a standard blue drop at higher levels, it would become 20%. (with 35% bonus)
Please don't make anything 400. We tried that already, blech.
I could see thief drop rate being higher. My use case is on bosses where 20% of 10% is pretty small.
I could see thief drop rate being higher. My use case is on bosses where 20% of 10% is pretty small.
Ok thx, was just thinking if I was stealing gold it would give incentive for a Thief. If I steal 6k gold from monsters but get a drop then others would be happy. And guess my poor Thief had a bad day lol
I'm not saying barbs arnt op in theory but I've yet to really see one dominate in pvp event wise or anything. I guess prob more so in pve is what you guys are looking at.
Ok seeing as night hawk wants no immediate changes to magic and focusing on melee
Calling all Rangers, Bards, Druids out there for your input.
Could either class be added to more utilized as pve cause some classes are just mainly pvp
Calling all Rangers, Bards, Druids out there for your input.
Could either class be added to more utilized as pve cause some classes are just mainly pvp
I'm not saying barbs arnt op in theory but I've yet to really see one dominate in pvp event wise or anything. I guess prob more so in pve is what you guys are looking at.
Barbs don't dominate 1v1 in my experience. They can get lucky flurrys but since they are guaranteed to get hit more / take more magic damage they tend to die fairly quicky.
They do crazy pve damage though, to be sure.
I'm not saying barbs arnt op in theory but I've yet to really see one dominate in pvp event wise or anything. I guess prob more so in pve is what you guys are looking at.
Barbs don't dominate 1v1 in my experience. They can get lucky flurrys but since they are guaranteed to get hit more / take more magic damage they tend to die fairly quicky.
They do crazy pve damage though, to be sure.
Well, my lvl 24 barbarian has done pretty well, including winning an event filled with 11 25s and me. My barbarian with 3 stamina often does around 500-700 a round.
As well, the build of the class matters. My barbarian has 24 agility and 20 wisdom. Rarely gets hit and spell casters fizzle like crazy.
maybe you can achieve complete balance if melee classes can attack with 2 stam and then have to unequip there weapons for the rest of the stam that round. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />
seems to me most people just use monks, mostly saurian atm, and a sparatic amount of other classes, usually a couple knights few barbs a ranger a druid, and those who have toughed out a chanter tend to take those. mages just aren't scary. you may not want to face one but at the same time u arent picking a melee gnome/elf anything cuz you suck vs 15 melee characters to have a bonus vs 4-5 chanters. atm it just isnt optimal to go super MR. from what ive seen the furthest people go are using a dark elf instead of a saurian but still using monk or a barb like mans above. but also chanters are on the rise and may balance it out, but im just guessing we will see more d/e monks because going anything under 20 str 22 agility is making you weak vs hardcore melee builds.
staff told me the healing rules and set up of events was to make the fights fair. fair for what? monk vs chanter? those are the premium choices from what ive seen. ive done info on every character ive seen die in the events, sometimes i miss the beginning cuz 6 pm is a hard deadline to make, im usually not on til 620 to catch the event. unless the bards paladins clerics thieves are annihilated in the first 10 minutes i just don't see them compete.
p.s. make a thief event worthy by giving a great dodge and hit bonus 10% on both may make a character with a slow and steady chance at a win. just keep the average damage per round about 10-15% less than an assassin (comparing same race vs same race) and try to let the classes dodge rate carry them. most may not agree with a monk having less of a dodge bonus than a thief, i will say to them, ive been in martial arts for over 10 years, in which case dodging becomes dangerous it leaves yourself open for anyone that's anticipating your next "dodge". a monk would be more apt to parry/ check block an attack and hold ground opposed to heavy dodges. especially when using 2 sticks, since ur trained to attack your opponents joints to nullify their attacks and movements regardless. however a thief is an untrained combatant doing anything to avoid getting hit its something a scared person would do, maximizing that flight response.
sorry for the essay, i better get an A- lol
p.s. the entire race/class scenario may balance out but i just don't see it.
seems to me most people just use monks, mostly saurian atm, and a sparatic amount of other classes, usually a couple knights few barbs a ranger a druid, and those who have toughed out a chanter tend to take those. mages just aren't scary. you may not want to face one but at the same time u arent picking a melee gnome/elf anything cuz you suck vs 15 melee characters to have a bonus vs 4-5 chanters. atm it just isnt optimal to go super MR. from what ive seen the furthest people go are using a dark elf instead of a saurian but still using monk or a barb like mans above. but also chanters are on the rise and may balance it out, but im just guessing we will see more d/e monks because going anything under 20 str 22 agility is making you weak vs hardcore melee builds.
staff told me the healing rules and set up of events was to make the fights fair. fair for what? monk vs chanter? those are the premium choices from what ive seen. ive done info on every character ive seen die in the events, sometimes i miss the beginning cuz 6 pm is a hard deadline to make, im usually not on til 620 to catch the event. unless the bards paladins clerics thieves are annihilated in the first 10 minutes i just don't see them compete.
p.s. make a thief event worthy by giving a great dodge and hit bonus 10% on both may make a character with a slow and steady chance at a win. just keep the average damage per round about 10-15% less than an assassin (comparing same race vs same race) and try to let the classes dodge rate carry them. most may not agree with a monk having less of a dodge bonus than a thief, i will say to them, ive been in martial arts for over 10 years, in which case dodging becomes dangerous it leaves yourself open for anyone that's anticipating your next "dodge". a monk would be more apt to parry/ check block an attack and hold ground opposed to heavy dodges. especially when using 2 sticks, since ur trained to attack your opponents joints to nullify their attacks and movements regardless. however a thief is an untrained combatant doing anything to avoid getting hit its something a scared person would do, maximizing that flight response.
sorry for the essay, i better get an A- lol
p.s. the entire race/class scenario may balance out but i just don't see it.
If other races wanted to be used more, maybe lizards should be nerfed.
Maybe less HP.
Maybe less HP.