PVP Dodge/Hitrate/Damage/HP
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Why should lings be only a tiny bit worse in combat than half orcs? They have a great difference in MR...
Why should lings be only a tiny bit worse in combat than half orcs? They have a great difference in MR...
Good point, you gotta compare orcs to lizards.
Why should lings be only a tiny bit worse in combat than half orcs? They have a great difference in MR...
Good point, you gotta compare orcs to lizards.
'
There is very little different in the two though.
I am comparing them because MR won't be as bad as it is now either when we fix it. You should still have a chance to kill a magic user without getting face stomped 100% of the time. It's one extreme to another, that is.
Also, with randomness in effect people prefer HO's/dwarfs/saurians/etc most of the time because you can get higher chances to kill them at lower rounds, but obviously has the effect that it can take longer too.
I.E. if half orcs to kill a target take 8 to 18 rounds, and lings are 12 to 14 rounds. They equally are the same average wise. However, when your in lets say,a group of 3 half orcs, theres far higher chance that you'll get rounded and at least one of the half orcs will hit that shiny 8-10 rounds, etc. And that alone is probably a reason why you don't need to make a huge AGI difference when it comes to physical attacking.
Actually, I fucked up. For some reason I was thinking HO's had 22 str. It's 24str obv, so that's 164-211 without div.
HO vs Ling:
HO Wins: 624577 (62.5%)
Liing Wins: 375423 (37.5%)
HO killing Ling
Ling killing HO
HO vs Ling:
HO Wins: 624577 (62.5%)
Liing Wins: 375423 (37.5%)
HO killing Ling
6 attacks to death: 92 (0.01%)
7 attacks to death: 557 (0.09%)
8 attacks to death: 1685 (0.27%)
9 attacks to death: 4046 (0.65%)
10 attacks to death: 7577 (1.21%)
11 attacks to death: 12334 (1.97%)
12 attacks to death: 18293 (2.93%)
13 attacks to death: 24839 (3.98%)
14 attacks to death: 31583 (5.06%)
15 attacks to death: 37857 (6.06%)
16 attacks to death: 43134 (6.91%)
17 attacks to death: 47327 (7.58%)
18 attacks to death: 49301 (7.89%)
19 attacks to death: 49478 (7.92%)
20 attacks to death: 48145 (7.71%)
21 attacks to death: 44533 (7.13%)
22 attacks to death: 40216 (6.44%)
23 attacks to death: 34953 (5.6%)
24 attacks to death: 29829 (4.78%)
25 attacks to death: 24570 (3.93%)
26 attacks to death: 19576 (3.13%)
27 attacks to death: 15233 (2.44%)
28 attacks to death: 11564 (1.85%)
29 attacks to death: 8502 (1.36%)
30 attacks to death: 6185 (0.99%)
31 attacks to death: 4294 (0.69%)
32 attacks to death: 3047 (0.49%)
33 attacks to death: 2048 (0.33%)
34 attacks to death: 1337 (0.21%)
35 attacks to death: 894 (0.14%)
Ling killing HO
6 attacks to death: 0 (0%)
7 attacks to death: 0 (0%)
8 attacks to death: 0 (0%)
9 attacks to death: 0 (0%)
10 attacks to death: 6 (0%)
11 attacks to death: 92 (0.02%)
12 attacks to death: 458 (0.12%)
13 attacks to death: 1564 (0.42%)
14 attacks to death: 3660 (0.97%)
15 attacks to death: 7360 (1.96%)
16 attacks to death: 12290 (3.27%)
17 attacks to death: 17987 (4.79%)
18 attacks to death: 23902 (6.37%)
19 attacks to death: 28815 (7.68%)
20 attacks to death: 32772 (8.73%)
21 attacks to death: 34671 (9.24%)
22 attacks to death: 34931 (9.3%)
23 attacks to death: 32556 (8.67%)
24 attacks to death: 29617 (7.89%)
25 attacks to death: 26265 (7%)
26 attacks to death: 21656 (5.77%)
27 attacks to death: 17563 (4.68%)
28 attacks to death: 13758 (3.66%)
29 attacks to death: 10300 (2.74%)
30 attacks to death: 7695 (2.05%)
31 attacks to death: 5509 (1.47%)
32 attacks to death: 3896 (1.04%)
33 attacks to death: 2810 (0.75%)
34 attacks to death: 1826 (0.49%)
35 attacks to death: 1289 (0.34%)
HO vs Saurian. I was half asleep when I wrote the above comment, I get yee for comparison.
HO Wins: 436309 (43.6%)
Saurian Wins: 563691 (56.4%)
HO killing Saurian
Saurian killing HO
HO Wins: 436309 (43.6%)
Saurian Wins: 563691 (56.4%)
HO killing Saurian
7 attacks to death: 121 (0.03%)
8 attacks to death: 631 (0.14%)
9 attacks to death: 1890 (0.43%)
10 attacks to death: 4165 (0.95%)
11 attacks to death: 7783 (1.78%)
12 attacks to death: 12408 (2.84%)
13 attacks to death: 18450 (4.23%)
14 attacks to death: 24282 (5.57%)
15 attacks to death: 30010 (6.88%)
16 attacks to death: 34551 (7.92%)
17 attacks to death: 37845 (8.67%)
18 attacks to death: 38713 (8.87%)
19 attacks to death: 37788 (8.66%)
20 attacks to death: 35652 (8.17%)
21 attacks to death: 31738 (7.27%)
22 attacks to death: 27410 (6.28%)
23 attacks to death: 22574 (5.17%)
24 attacks to death: 18374 (4.21%)
25 attacks to death: 14384 (3.3%)
26 attacks to death: 10935 (2.51%)
27 attacks to death: 8224 (1.88%)
28 attacks to death: 5856 (1.34%)
29 attacks to death: 4199 (0.96%)
30 attacks to death: 2844 (0.65%)
31 attacks to death: 1962 (0.45%)
32 attacks to death: 1286 (0.29%)
33 attacks to death: 868 (0.2%)
34 attacks to death: 527 (0.12%)
35 attacks to death: 355 (0.08%)
Saurian killing HO
7 attacks to death: 0 (0%)
8 attacks to death: 13 (0%)
9 attacks to death: 232 (0.04%)
10 attacks to death: 1225 (0.22%)
11 attacks to death: 3867 (0.69%)
12 attacks to death: 8491 (1.51%)
13 attacks to death: 15588 (2.77%)
14 attacks to death: 24179 (4.29%)
15 attacks to death: 33412 (5.93%)
16 attacks to death: 42221 (7.49%)
17 attacks to death: 48741 (8.65%)
18 attacks to death: 52757 (9.36%)
19 attacks to death: 53112 (9.42%)
20 attacks to death: 51115 (9.07%)
21 attacks to death: 47009 (8.34%)
22 attacks to death: 40797 (7.24%)
23 attacks to death: 34291 (6.08%)
24 attacks to death: 27684 (4.91%)
25 attacks to death: 22073 (3.92%)
26 attacks to death: 16633 (2.95%)
27 attacks to death: 12393 (2.2%)
28 attacks to death: 9105 (1.62%)
29 attacks to death: 6275 (1.11%)
30 attacks to death: 4326 (0.77%)
31 attacks to death: 2932 (0.52%)
32 attacks to death: 1867 (0.33%)
33 attacks to death: 1249 (0.22%)
34 attacks to death: 812 (0.14%)
35 attacks to death: 472 (0.08%)
The problem with adjusting AGI though is probably because races like Saurians really are already good when it comes to PVP due to both high STR and high AGI. Making AGI worth more helps lings out to where they should be, but then Saurians are OP and destroy.
The problem with adjusting END / HP per point lets say to counter high AGI so that HOs can combat saurians then, ends up being that lings get obviously left out, and then lings are being messed up.
I'm still not saying HO's should lose to Lings, there should be a gap where HOs kill em, but it doesn't need to be huge cause HOs' get the benefit of being able to chance kill much quicker. Aka you pick lower AGI and high STR, you pick a race that is random in fights more or less.
Honestly, though AGI per point could be maybe higher, I feel like it's the stats themselves causing the issues and an unbalanced races.
The problem with adjusting END / HP per point lets say to counter high AGI so that HOs can combat saurians then, ends up being that lings get obviously left out, and then lings are being messed up.
I'm still not saying HO's should lose to Lings, there should be a gap where HOs kill em, but it doesn't need to be huge cause HOs' get the benefit of being able to chance kill much quicker. Aka you pick lower AGI and high STR, you pick a race that is random in fights more or less.
Honestly, though AGI per point could be maybe higher, I feel like it's the stats themselves causing the issues and an unbalanced races.
Someone mentioned giving halflings a flat +X to dodge.
Introduce size. Smalls get a +X to dodge (gobby, ling, gnome). Could even be a variable individual to each race to increases chance of dodging and or chance of being hit (probably best with just the one though)?
But meh... I think this is already factored into AGL?
Possibly. Hard to balance though.
How to fix though... revise the races and increase variance of their stats?
Keep AGL as is, but add AGL to certain races?
Introduce size. Smalls get a +X to dodge (gobby, ling, gnome). Could even be a variable individual to each race to increases chance of dodging and or chance of being hit (probably best with just the one though)?
But meh... I think this is already factored into AGL?
Honestly, though AGI per point could be maybe higher, I feel like it's the stats themselves causing the issues and an unbalanced races.
Possibly. Hard to balance though.
How to fix though... revise the races and increase variance of their stats?
Keep AGL as is, but add AGL to certain races?
Someone mentioned giving halflings a flat +X to dodge.
Introduce size. Smalls get a +X to dodge (gobby, ling, gnome). Could even be a variable individual to each race to increases chance of dodging and or chance of being hit (probably best with just the one though)?
But meh... I think this is already factored into AGL?
Over complicated. It needs to be simple and easy to follow, having hidden variables suck. Lings aren't the only one that get the shaft, they are the extreme case though out of all of them.
How to fix though... revise the races and increase variance of their stats?
Possibly what I was thinking to help.
Ive skimmed this (long thread) so apologies if this has been asked:
What are your objectives in terms of battle outcomes? I mean, we know the results of any given stat combination, but what are the results that we would want? This isnt clear to me.
To give an example: I would say that a gnome ninja with normal stat allocation should lose 75% to a human ninja. Gnomes should win 75% if we are talking about enchanters.
Can we get such a matrix, of % victory, for different Classes/races?
Then we could work backwards to match stats to the outcomes we want.
What are your objectives in terms of battle outcomes? I mean, we know the results of any given stat combination, but what are the results that we would want? This isnt clear to me.
To give an example: I would say that a gnome ninja with normal stat allocation should lose 75% to a human ninja. Gnomes should win 75% if we are talking about enchanters.
Can we get such a matrix, of % victory, for different Classes/races?
Then we could work backwards to match stats to the outcomes we want.
I mean tbh the race balance here is a lot closer than it ever was in rok and that showed. It would be great to actually see what 25ers there are and what people have gotten to 25 recently.
Even with mr being touchy it caused somewhat of a rock paper scissor. Pure melee with under 15 wis usually beats melee with 19+ wis. Anything with -19 wis usually loses to caster. Caster loses to any melee with +19 wis.
With that said there are a few outliers.
Dwarf has highest hp pool and great mr so it's has an edge in melee while it also almost always beats casters (not only do casters struggle with the 20wis mr but they have to beat 1250+ hp). with huge amounts of hp pools my caster even struggles with half orc hp pool so dwarf is pretty impossible.
Halfling has the lowest hp / str of melee classes. it only has +1 agi on de and since agi is somewhat worthless there is not much point to make them for anything.
That said I don't think we are too far off maybe a slight agi increase or maybe an extra agi point for halfling and maybe take a look at dwarf wisdom?
As for mr I hope it doesn't become a 55/45 type thing. I admit now it's prob a 90% win over 10wis while it's a 10% win over 20wis which is a bit too much . I do feel if you put 0 points in wis you should lose most the time however maybe with 14 wis you should stand some chance but not much. Same with 23 wis I agree you should win most the time but with 20 wis you should probably lose sometimes.
I'd love to see the breakdown wis point wise. Say a 22int caster fighting a human knight with 10 to 23 wis and see % fight outcomes.
Hopefully we can find balance without losing too much of that rock paper scissor feel.
Even with mr being touchy it caused somewhat of a rock paper scissor. Pure melee with under 15 wis usually beats melee with 19+ wis. Anything with -19 wis usually loses to caster. Caster loses to any melee with +19 wis.
With that said there are a few outliers.
Dwarf has highest hp pool and great mr so it's has an edge in melee while it also almost always beats casters (not only do casters struggle with the 20wis mr but they have to beat 1250+ hp). with huge amounts of hp pools my caster even struggles with half orc hp pool so dwarf is pretty impossible.
Halfling has the lowest hp / str of melee classes. it only has +1 agi on de and since agi is somewhat worthless there is not much point to make them for anything.
That said I don't think we are too far off maybe a slight agi increase or maybe an extra agi point for halfling and maybe take a look at dwarf wisdom?
As for mr I hope it doesn't become a 55/45 type thing. I admit now it's prob a 90% win over 10wis while it's a 10% win over 20wis which is a bit too much . I do feel if you put 0 points in wis you should lose most the time however maybe with 14 wis you should stand some chance but not much. Same with 23 wis I agree you should win most the time but with 20 wis you should probably lose sometimes.
I'd love to see the breakdown wis point wise. Say a 22int caster fighting a human knight with 10 to 23 wis and see % fight outcomes.
Hopefully we can find balance without losing too much of that rock paper scissor feel.
I mean tbh the race balance here is a lot closer than it ever was in rok and that showed. It would be great to actually see what 25ers there are and what people have gotten to 25 recently.
Even with mr being touchy it caused somewhat of a rock paper scissor. Pure melee with under 15 wis usually beats melee with 19+ wis. Anything with -19 wis usually loses to caster. Caster loses to any melee with +19 wis.
Hopefully we can find balance without losing too much of that rock paper scissor feel.
This.
I feel very strong in my saurian slayer, but enter a bloody chanter, and i scream like i panicked child.
However, same enchanter versus my miserably guardian.. and guess what, i will bet on my guardian. Which would be toast versus my slayer.
Well I want to try what was talked about in MR which uses only wisdom to base your affect rate. Their INT wouldn't effect it but instead would effect damage more, making 20 int casters a thing. Instead all spells would be based on lets say the current 23int.
Right now if you have 20 int, you lose out on like 20% pierce rate lets say. That's why it's worthless. Not only do you fizzle more, you deal less damage, and you struggle to pierce.
I do agree though, but the variation is far too much. However, a 10-15 wisdom character is going to struggle regardless, though it shouldn't be near 90% pierce rate, its too high. Right now its between 10% to 75% (23 wis gnome sorc, gets more the elemental at 24 wis by a 1%).
Basing it off AGI, 40% is the average obviously. Typically it goes 30%-50% at max for dodging or hitting.
Probably spells can start around 20% and go up to maybe around 60%.. So your resist would be based on your class, wisdom, and staff itself. It's not going to be using the same formula I think, just a tweaked version of the current. Some classes might be adjusted though in terms of MR. I think theres a problem currently that its hard to balance when theres too many variables. I.E. gnomes have lets say 20% MR and then 25% for the class itself. 45% total for a gnome sorc as the max, its kind of lacking on others there. from 45% bonus to -7.5% is a varation and too much to balance.
Right now if you have 20 int, you lose out on like 20% pierce rate lets say. That's why it's worthless. Not only do you fizzle more, you deal less damage, and you struggle to pierce.
I do agree though, but the variation is far too much. However, a 10-15 wisdom character is going to struggle regardless, though it shouldn't be near 90% pierce rate, its too high. Right now its between 10% to 75% (23 wis gnome sorc, gets more the elemental at 24 wis by a 1%).
Basing it off AGI, 40% is the average obviously. Typically it goes 30%-50% at max for dodging or hitting.
Probably spells can start around 20% and go up to maybe around 60%.. So your resist would be based on your class, wisdom, and staff itself. It's not going to be using the same formula I think, just a tweaked version of the current. Some classes might be adjusted though in terms of MR. I think theres a problem currently that its hard to balance when theres too many variables. I.E. gnomes have lets say 20% MR and then 25% for the class itself. 45% total for a gnome sorc as the max, its kind of lacking on others there. from 45% bonus to -7.5% is a varation and too much to balance.
Well I want to try what was talked about in MR which uses only wisdom to base your affect rate. Their INT wouldn't effect it but instead would effect damage more, making 20 int casters a thing. Instead all spells would be based on lets say the current 23int.
Right now if you have 20 int, you lose out on like 20% pierce rate lets say. That's why it's worthless. Not only do you fizzle more, you deal less damage, and you struggle to pierce.
I do agree though, but the variation is far too much. However, a 10-15 wisdom character is going to struggle regardless, though it shouldn't be near 90% pierce rate, its too high. Right now its between 10% to 75% (23 wis gnome sorc, gets more the elemental at 24 wis by a 1%).
Basing it off AGI, 40% is the average obviously. Typically it goes 30%-50% at max for dodging or hitting.
Probably spells can start around 20% and go up to maybe around 60%.. So your resist would be based on your class, wisdom, and staff itself. It's not going to be using the same formula I think, just a tweaked version of the current. Some classes might be adjusted though in terms of MR. I think theres a problem currently that its hard to balance when theres too many variables. I.E. gnomes have lets say 20% MR and then 25% for the class itself. 45% total for a gnome sorc as the max, its kind of lacking on others there. from 45% bonus to -7.5% is a varation and too much to balance.
Does this new MR system you mention mean effectively that INT will only affect spell damage and not penetration/affect?... Therefore a 10 INT spellcaster will penetrate/affect with non-damage related spells (eg FF, Sap, Blind etc) approx as much as as a 23 INT spellcaster casting against the same enemy of X wisdom (apart from slightly higher fizzle rate being born by 10 INT spellcaster)? ... If so I can see a lot of low INT Druids being made lol.
Apologies if I have misunderstood your MR description... And/or if I should be posting this Q in the MR thread instead... It all seems to be blurring into 1 issue lol
Well I want to try what was talked about in MR which uses only wisdom to base your affect rate. Their INT wouldn't effect it but instead would effect damage more, making 20 int casters a thing. Instead all spells would be based on lets say the current 23int.
Right now if you have 20 int, you lose out on like 20% pierce rate lets say. That's why it's worthless. Not only do you fizzle more, you deal less damage, and you struggle to pierce.
I do agree though, but the variation is far too much. However, a 10-15 wisdom character is going to struggle regardless, though it shouldn't be near 90% pierce rate, its too high. Right now its between 10% to 75% (23 wis gnome sorc, gets more the elemental at 24 wis by a 1%).
Basing it off AGI, 40% is the average obviously. Typically it goes 30%-50% at max for dodging or hitting.
Probably spells can start around 20% and go up to maybe around 60%.. So your resist would be based on your class, wisdom, and staff itself. It's not going to be using the same formula I think, just a tweaked version of the current. Some classes might be adjusted though in terms of MR. I think theres a problem currently that its hard to balance when theres too many variables. I.E. gnomes have lets say 20% MR and then 25% for the class itself. 45% total for a gnome sorc as the max, its kind of lacking on others there. from 45% bonus to -7.5% is a varation and too much to balance.
Does this new MR system you mention mean effectively that INT will only affect spell damage and not penetration/affect?... Therefore a 10 INT spellcaster will penetrate/affect with non-damage related spells (eg FF, Sap, Blind etc) approx as much as as a 23 INT spellcaster casting against the same enemy of X wisdom (apart from slightly higher fizzle rate being born by 10 INT spellcaster)? ... If so I can see a lot of low INT Druids being made lol.
Apologies if I have misunderstood your MR description... And/or if I should be posting this Q in the MR thread instead... It all seems to be blurring into 1 issue lol
Yeah no worries. The MR poll was mostly to do with two things, this idea with INT vs MR and just a revised MR. However, I really want to try this idea out and if it doesn't work I'll rollback and try something different.
Most druids made aren't really made for being able to penetrate with ray anyways or in care with int. 10 int sap/blind/etc would probably only last 5 seconds, Your damage would be extremely low though, and your fizzle rate would be generally higher even with lower spells, probably around 10% for cure/beam/etc. Blast and the like however with 10int you're looking at 25-35% fizzle rate, that alone is pretty bad but the system isn't designed and won't be for picking the lowest INT. Most spells themselves are lower damage then the high physical damage classes but it will still allow 20 int to be decent at their roles.
Right now lower INT characters is like putting -2 AGI on a character per point loss in relations. Even if that were to be lowered it's still a loss and no one would want to do it. No one makes -1 AGI characters even if its 2% less agi only, same applies for most sorcs/necros.
I do not think WIS working as a kind of mental AGL would work so well.
Have WIS act like a shield/armour when it comes to magical damage (as in it deflects magical attacks; spell has no effect, but it is rare) it will however reduce damage more.
But... not sure how the status effect magic works to make that idea suitable.
So if the WIS reducing damage more than unnafecting is what your saying, then I am for that.
Anyway, thats my opinion.
Have WIS act like a shield/armour when it comes to magical damage (as in it deflects magical attacks; spell has no effect, but it is rare) it will however reduce damage more.
But... not sure how the status effect magic works to make that idea suitable.
So if the WIS reducing damage more than unnafecting is what your saying, then I am for that.
Anyway, thats my opinion.
Well I want to try what was talked about in MR which uses only wisdom to base your affect rate. Their INT wouldn't effect it but instead would effect damage more, making 20 int casters a thing. Instead all spells would be based on lets say the current 23int.
Right now if you have 20 int, you lose out on like 20% pierce rate lets say. That's why it's worthless. Not only do you fizzle more, you deal less damage, and you struggle to pierce.
I do agree though, but the variation is far too much. However, a 10-15 wisdom character is going to struggle regardless, though it shouldn't be near 90% pierce rate, its too high. Right now its between 10% to 75% (23 wis gnome sorc, gets more the elemental at 24 wis by a 1%).
Basing it off AGI, 40% is the average obviously. Typically it goes 30%-50% at max for dodging or hitting.
Probably spells can start around 20% and go up to maybe around 60%.. So your resist would be based on your class, wisdom, and staff itself. It's not going to be using the same formula I think, just a tweaked version of the current. Some classes might be adjusted though in terms of MR. I think theres a problem currently that its hard to balance when theres too many variables. I.E. gnomes have lets say 20% MR and then 25% for the class itself. 45% total for a gnome sorc as the max, its kind of lacking on others there. from 45% bonus to -7.5% is a varation and too much to balance.
Does this new MR system you mention mean effectively that INT will only affect spell damage and not penetration/affect?... Therefore a 10 INT spellcaster will penetrate/affect with non-damage related spells (eg FF, Sap, Blind etc) approx as much as as a 23 INT spellcaster casting against the same enemy of X wisdom (apart from slightly higher fizzle rate being born by 10 INT spellcaster)? ... If so I can see a lot of low INT Druids being made lol.
Apologies if I have misunderstood your MR description... And/or if I should be posting this Q in the MR thread instead... It all seems to be blurring into 1 issue lol
Yeah no worries. The MR poll was mostly to do with two things, this idea with INT vs MR and just a revised MR. However, I really want to try this idea out and if it doesn't work I'll rollback and try something different.
Most druids made aren't really made for being able to penetrate with ray anyways or in care with int. 10 int sap/blind/etc would probably only last 5 seconds, Your damage would be extremely low though, and your fizzle rate would be generally higher even with lower spells, probably around 10% for cure/beam/etc. Blast and the like however with 10int you're looking at 25-35% fizzle rate, that alone is pretty bad but the system isn't designed and won't be for picking the lowest INT. Most spells themselves are lower damage then the high physical damage classes but it will still allow 20 int to be decent at their roles.
Right now lower INT characters is like putting -2 AGI on a character per point loss in relations. Even if that were to be lowered it's still a loss and no one would want to do it. No one makes -1 AGI characters even if its 2% less agi only, same applies for most sorcs/necros.
Ah ok so if I understand you correctly - with non-damage related spells (eg Faeriefire) under the new system you want to try... these may still penetrate just as often (apart from fizzle) regardless of higher or lower INT but the duration of say a 20 INT faerie fire will still be notably longer than a 10 INT faerie fire?
I wasn't really concerned re Blast/Ray etc cos their damage will be reduced for lower INT... It was more for the whether higher INT has any difference on the effect (ie either penetration or duration) of non damage spells where the enemy either gets their status modified or not
Does this new MR system you mention mean effectively that INT will only affect spell damage and not penetration/affect?... Therefore a 10 INT spellcaster will penetrate/affect with non-damage related spells (eg FF, Sap, Blind etc) approx as much as as a 23 INT spellcaster casting against the same enemy of X wisdom (apart from slightly higher fizzle rate being born by 10 INT spellcaster)? ... If so I can see a lot of low INT Druids being made lol.
Apologies if I have misunderstood your MR description... And/or if I should be posting this Q in the MR thread instead... It all seems to be blurring into 1 issue lol
Yeah no worries. The MR poll was mostly to do with two things, this idea with INT vs MR and just a revised MR. However, I really want to try this idea out and if it doesn't work I'll rollback and try something different.
Most druids made aren't really made for being able to penetrate with ray anyways or in care with int. 10 int sap/blind/etc would probably only last 5 seconds, Your damage would be extremely low though, and your fizzle rate would be generally higher even with lower spells, probably around 10% for cure/beam/etc. Blast and the like however with 10int you're looking at 25-35% fizzle rate, that alone is pretty bad but the system isn't designed and won't be for picking the lowest INT. Most spells themselves are lower damage then the high physical damage classes but it will still allow 20 int to be decent at their roles.
Right now lower INT characters is like putting -2 AGI on a character per point loss in relations. Even if that were to be lowered it's still a loss and no one would want to do it. No one makes -1 AGI characters even if its 2% less agi only, same applies for most sorcs/necros.
Ah ok so if I understand you correctly - with non-damage related spells (eg Faeriefire) under the new system you want to try... these may still penetrate just as often (apart from fizzle) regardless of higher or lower INT but the duration of say a 20 INT faerie fire will still be notably longer than a 10 INT faerie fire?
I wasn't really concerned re Blast/Ray etc cos their damage will be reduced for lower INT... It was more for the whether higher INT has any difference on the effect (ie either penetration or duration) of non damage spells where the enemy either gets their status modified or not
All spells will probably penetrate the same as they are, except there won't be such a low min and a high max. It'll be easier to balance and make all races useful as casters, you'll probably get interesting race/class combos, but still a gnome sorc will have high resistance to any spell, or a druid since they have high wis, etc etc. But yeah, low int also means faster durations etc. So that's no good for spells, but having 20int is still acceptable.
However, with the change too, I can actually make debuff spells have a harder penetration if need be with no worries, so FF/etc can have proper resists, lets say they could be 5-15% harder to penetrate overall. It's still up for debate on those spells but that will probably come after the MR changes and we see how everything fairs.
INT effects alot of things and I don't think it needs to do penetration. It effects, damage, duration, the effect on buffs, debuffs, etc. Unless they are static debuffs, which most spells aren't, you will have lower durations and lower effects. So that SS with 23 int might be 5 minutes and 50 armor, or with 20 int might be 4 minutes 40 seconds and 47 armor. etc.
I think the game can very much be balanced with these changes, and make alot of interesting setups we don't see now.
HO vs Ling:
HO Wins: 624577 (62.5%)
Liing Wins: 375423 (37.5%)
HO vs Saurian. I was half asleep when I wrote the above comment, I get yee for comparison.
HO Wins: 436309 (43.6%)
Saurian Wins: 563691 (56.4%)
I think this is about right, when you take in consideration the fact that HOs and lizards are magic food, but I would like to see HOs have a slight edge over lizards or else why would you pick a HO?
HO vs Ling:
HO Wins: 624577 (62.5%)
Liing Wins: 375423 (37.5%)
HO vs Saurian. I was half asleep when I wrote the above comment, I get yee for comparison.
HO Wins: 436309 (43.6%)
Saurian Wins: 563691 (56.4%)
I think this is about right, when you take in consideration the fact that HOs and lizards are magic food, but I would like to see HOs have a slight edge over lizards or else why would you pick a HO?
HO and lizard are equally magic food however HO have about 200 more hp that casters have to burn through. So they would have an edge on lizard in the sense. I'm not sure then why you would give them the head to head edge as well?
HO vs Ling:
HO Wins: 624577 (62.5%)
Liing Wins: 375423 (37.5%)
HO vs Saurian. I was half asleep when I wrote the above comment, I get yee for comparison.
HO Wins: 436309 (43.6%)
Saurian Wins: 563691 (56.4%)
I think this is about right, when you take in consideration the fact that HOs and lizards are magic food, but I would like to see HOs have a slight edge over lizards or else why would you pick a HO?
HO and lizard are equally magic food however HO have about 200 more hp that casters have to burn through. So they would have an edge on lizard in the sense. I'm not sure then why you would give them the head to head edge as well?
But what good is that 200 hp against chanters if they still lose? They are both chanter food.