← Forum archive

The current "meta" for endgame PvP

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Folder
DOnt mess up fade, its nice as it is.

Read, a scary thing.


You are killing the game's future on tablet/mobile client if you leave fade as is. This really needs to be considered.
Cerebrus
1) Fade: I already posted on Fade. I do not like it. I think attacking should break the effect. It just makes the combats silly.

2) Zombie Attack: An alternative solution would be "injuries" or "weakened state". Some games have this. Basically you can run back to the fight after being templed, but until you are inactive for X amount of time you have a -2 to all stats (or some such - could be capped at X amount of injuries). And have it accrue.


I agree with #1

Do not FULLY agree with #2, but I do like it. My problem with it is PvE. You die in a OAD and want to run back to the group, you would be at a severe disadvantage.

Perhaps there's a way for Chris to code this so the server recognizes when a player is killed by an npc vs. a player.

If player is killed by npc, the server would ignore it.
If player is killed by player, server would see it and adjust stats

Would like to offer a 3rd option. Not sure if it would be easier or not, but breakable armor/weapons.

Give armor and weapons a 10pt quality stat. Everytime you die, those points go down by 1pt. You would need to hit a repair shop to repair your armor/weapon. Better armor/weapons means higher cost of repair. Make it expensive to repair, every point of repair that is done could cost 10k per piece of gear.

So somone with 4 pieces and 1 death would cost 40k to repair to full. If you let them get all the way down to 0/10 then it would cost 400k to repair all items to full.

This could eventually tie into guilds, guild banks and guild ranks.

Owner could set the number of free repairs using money from the guild bank each rank would get
Member 1 free repair a day
Officer 2
Leader 3

The repair shops would have different buttons. Repair All(would subtract from gold on your alt), Guild Repair All (would subtract from guild bank)

This would get pretty costly after a few times. So if players want to pvp, they better have the funds to repair lol

This also creates a gold sink, which from what i've heard gold is pretty useless atm.

p.s. this would require a way for us to build arena's that dont allow armor to break. Maybe tie it into the no exp loss room type? Or leave it alone all together lol You want to enter events then you risk breaking your gear
daedroth
The repairing weapons/armour is an interesting idea. The cost is a little high though.
If it was to be done then it should be based on about money you get from selling it / max durability * damage. So something that sells for 4000gp and had 2/10 damage would cost 800 gold to fix.
If you want it to take time, you could make it so that it took damage * 3 in seconds or some such.
Gold would have an extra use (and it has so little use right now - agreed)!

My durability idea was not met with approval, esp. since my idea was that eventually the item would need to be replaced. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />
Cerebrus
The repairing weapons/armour is an interesting idea. The cost is a little high though.
If it was to be done then it should be based on about money you get from selling it / max durability * damage. So something that sells for 4000gp and had 2/10 damage would cost 800 gold to fix.
If you want it to take time, you could make it so that it took damage * 3 in seconds or some such.
Gold would have an extra use (and it has so little use right now - agreed)!


Yeah I mean I just went with 10k as a base and basing it off best armor/weapons in game.

If you have store boughts, then it would obviously be cheaper to repair them.

Would definitely have to sit down and figure out the costs. 10k is probably to high, but then again I dont think it should be as cheap as running into a temple and healing

Armor and weapons that take damage would also have to offer less protection, then more they are damaged. 10/10 would be 100% of their stats, 9/10 would be 90% of their stats, etc...So if a chest piece offered 100ac, one that is damaged 9/10 would only give you 90ac and so on and so on.

I really like this idea (not just because I suggested it either)

I feel there needs to be more risk to the game, little stuff like needing to repair your items offers a whole new feel and dynamic to the game.
Terron
might aswell make death permanent, and a secondary alt pays XXk for a scroll of resurrection to revive your dead alt(sarcasm). all these choices confirm a 1 and done anyway.

why complicate a mud with degrading armor/items? prices would have to degrade, guild leaders will hoard items for their closer friends/staple guildies, items will sell even less often, people will chain pk noobs to break their gear when they cant even afford anything. complicated just chases the casual off your game. do i need to continue?

games too small, make dozens more areas, make dozens more bosses, make more oads, than after thats completed worry about fade and other complications. just cant see fade as that much of a problem when its the same 14 people fighting over and over. simply /who and watch player swap alts(for now)
Folder
The person who codes and changes game systems =/ the people who build areas. Both can be worked on.

I'm glad Fade doesn't bother you, but it does bother other people.

IMO armor degradation is adding a level of complexity not needed in this game. I think part of the charm is the simplicity. There are just a few things going on right now that result in less than great gameplay.
Terron
fade does bother me, but it isn't as annoying as other stuff. waiting around 2-3 hours to have fun for 10 minutes is more of a problem imho.
yes builders can work on both, i wasn't implying to stop, but the area and content is more of an issue atm. clicking is hard anyway especially when people are popping out of "sneak/hide" changing the screen order anyway. macros don't mess up. id much rather have a /clanattack off toggle added before click attack wars are even thought of.

actions and search should just break fade, it wont be a "crap" spell, the surprise element is still there. support/healers can remain faded throughout the conflict until party moves and heals, and get refaded. search breaking fade is almost exactly the same thing as dispel magic because only wizards have int anyway.

You guys want "endgame" but the game part isn't finished.
Rodeo
Yea I think the degrade system has been brought up before. It's a bad idea with a game that has such a small population. If items were being farmed and auctioned on a website around the clock so people can buy when they wear one out fully it would be a different story but as the game stands it would only be an annoyance that would drive casual players away. The game needs more content and I know people have been taking about fade and tablet use. Can you even get the client legit on a tablet without using a cloud type program to remotely play it from a pc? I would worry about fade when it's officially on a tablet.
Folder
No there is not tablet client now. I'm talking about future plans for that client. You can quickly type "a fadedbro" on your PC but that's gonna be a huge disadvantage for some future guy sitting on his tablet.

Still even on PC it's annoying as hell and makes no thematic sense.
Terron
you can use the onscreen keyboard(accessibility settings) on some tablets/surface pros and custom microsoft drivers to set ever letter as "a space letter" to be able to stylus/touch attack any letter in the alphabet, but multiple same letter names will be problematic. not to mention typing other things wont work w/o using all caps as a work around.

by the time youre done with that you will say "i should have just used my pc".

personally i don't see why tablets/mobile are even a conception thought of with the game so tiny.
Styx
Why go into tablets and phones? " Keeping up with the jones" as an old saying goes. Otherwise it could happen the game will fade away

Go ask your kids, where you find the game you play? It's an app to play game etc

One must change in order to keep ahead or face what happened to the buggy whip production etc
Terron
mobile apps keep you continually busy, or limit your time to a few tries and a wait period for new attempts. this game hasn't made it that far yet. future sure, as of now nope. youll have 135 d/ls 105 will be an oops, the other 30 will be current players trying to kill raiders or check a mort on lunch-break.
Styx
Basic Google play search. Top 3rd mud mmorpg game, total text based. , 50k downloads

Yes correct, areas must be finished then development of clients etc then we can be the top dogs

We have the artwork, design, and graphics needed to be truly unique from others. Rok started small but from it and other games we played we learned how to get the name out.

The hardest part truly is getting it all running but always work for the future.
NiteHawk
So proposed changes for a couple things I've seen and been working on.

Combat Timer Logoff:
If you have a combat timer and log off you will not be able to log another character in until the character is fully logged off. You can log in the character in question to move it/run to a safe area, or simply just wait out the combat timer. It's the same timer you see at the bottom right (purple one). Logging off in a non-safe square will give you a minimum of 10 seconds regardless of combat. Logging off in a city area or safe area will give you no timer.


Fade:
-Fade is removed once you attack, does not remove if someone else attacks you.
-Duration increased by 40%
-Fade gives +2 agi and +2 int while hidden. It only grants the bonus to pierce, not damage. (It is removed before the damage check applies but after the pierce check.). Removed once you use a spell/command/attack. So first attack in a group should give you a edge on hitting.
-FF stops fade and prevents refading.


Death Sickness:
-If you die you will have a temp sickness that lowers stats.
-In PVP
--Lose -2 stats for 3 minutes first death, -3.5 stats for 5 minutes second death, -5 stats for 7 minutes third death, and -10 stats for 9 minutes fourth death and up in PVP.
-In PVE
--Lose -2 stats for 20 seconds, any situation.
-Does not occur in game rooms (and arenas hopefully)

I am not sure if 3 minutes is too high in PVP or should I lower it to 2 minutes. I am trying to take into account running there/fighting/etc. If you wait the 3 minutes you will not get stacking (I.E: you will never see -3.5, -5, etc at increase times.)
Thi
This is awesome, properly addressed most of the "broken mechanics" that we have up right now.

My only concern would remain on fade, you're making it so it's the get away spell for anything, meaning it buffs up stats can't be removed (except for having a druid) which means if you do it to a priest, he is very unlikely to die when moving and running carrying keys and dropable items, I kinda understand the purpose, but maybe being hit 2-3 times should make it "fade away", that way whenever someone is giving chase to a faded character it isn't impossible to kill him.

As for the timers I'd say you got most of them spot on.
Folder
My only concern would remain on fade, you're making it so it's the get away spell for anything, meaning it buffs up stats can't be removed (except for having a druid) which means if you do it to a priest, he is very unlikely to die when moving and running carrying keys and dropable items, I kinda understand the purpose, but maybe being hit 2-3 times should make it "fade away", that way whenever someone is giving chase to a faded character it isn't impossible to kill him.


That could be interesting gameplay though. I think I kinda like it. Besides it's removed if, in this example, said priest casts a heal. In theory you could dump an item on a cav and heal them, but honestly if your group is that coordinated you're likely winning the fight anyway.

My suggestions:
-Maybe 2 minutes for the debuff timer to start, 3 seems kinda long to me. Obviously not seeing it in action yet but just my gut feeling on it.
-Is there a way to make the stat debuff only affect lvl25s? If so that would be best I think so people who get PKd while leveling aren't have an extra punishment added.
Terron
every key fight ive been on is only 2 skirmishes long, 1 team will win and the losers regroup and comeback for the final chance, waiting 3 minutes to get your stats back will make it too late. i don't really see the logic here. penalize the guys that are outnumbered 5:1 for running back and trying.

fade seems better, initial surprise hits, or fade blast fade blast for ultra heavy MR enemy characters.

now remove the dodge penalty from druids so they can actually cast ff (they will be morphed for battle), they don't need the double penalty for agi loss to begin with.(its double because they lose the morphed dex and lose more unmorphed on top of it.) its horrible. i wouldn't mind using a support druid but not with that insane hit to agility. druids aren't OP enough to all have parkinsons disease.

sight should also work to reveal fade, just not the recast penalty added to it
Lateralus
DOnt mess up fade, its nice as it is.

Read, a scary thing.


You are killing the game's future on tablet/mobile client if you leave fade as is. This really needs to be considered.



This is the first time I'll agree to a fade change. I could see how that would be a problem typing the name on an iPad wouldnt be fun. However if it's changed so you come out on combat I think it should be reverted to how
It was in rok where you couldn't be hit until you revealed yourself by fade wearing off or you attacking. That way there wouldn't be a advantage to being on a computer over tablet.

Also I wouldn't mind seeing shorter times for players who have it casted on them (not the caster).
NiteHawk
My only concern would remain on fade, you're making it so it's the get away spell for anything, meaning it buffs up stats can't be removed (except for having a druid) which means if you do it to a priest, he is very unlikely to die when moving and running carrying keys and dropable items, I kinda understand the purpose, but maybe being hit 2-3 times should make it "fade away", that way whenever someone is giving chase to a faded character it isn't impossible to kill him.


That could be interesting gameplay though. I think I kinda like it. Besides it's removed if, in this example, said priest casts a heal. In theory you could dump an item on a cav and heal them, but honestly if your group is that coordinated you're likely winning the fight anyway.

My suggestions:
-Maybe 2 minutes for the debuff timer to start, 3 seems kinda long to me. Obviously not seeing it in action yet but just my gut feeling on it.
-Is there a way to make the stat debuff only affect lvl25s? If so that would be best I think so people who get PKd while leveling aren't have an extra punishment added.


That is now a tough call. PVP needs to really effect as a whole. What happens when I add more levels, Does it mean that they don't get a penalty at all?

One way I could see is if the first death doesn't debuff you at all, but imposes a larger timer on you, lets say 10 minutes. Then you start losing more stats, so people could ghost once before suffering stat losses.

I don't necessarily want to distinguish it so it effects level 25s only, as it seems weird to me. It is like stating a level 24 and under will never PK, though uncommon, it's untrue.


Fade doesn't need to effect stats, but I think it's good as it is. Would be interested on other peoples says too.