← Forum archive

DISCUSSION for 2v2/3v3 Tournament

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Honzo
The rules are simple.
9 pm server
2v2 Tournament
Tournament Bracket Style
No Pots
All skills/spells (except Fade)
No hiding on last stamina(for thieves/assassin)
Unique Classes(No Class Stacking)
Buffs beforehand



This is a thread for discussion and comments related to the 2v2/3v3 tournament events.
Vindal
There should be heal limits in a 2v2. Any pure DPS team will get chipped to death by a DPS/Priest. Unless you have perfectly synced attacks and a snoozing Priest you just can't overcome those heals.
Folder
Heals are rough. Pure DPS is definitely boned, but I guess one could argue that's taking a bad comp. If you limit heals too much priest is useless, maybe there's a middle ground somewhere?

Double elim is rougher. Both of the last two teams forfeited cause people had to go <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" />. I quite like the style, it just needs to be shorter.
Honzo
There should be heal limits in a 2v2. Any pure DPS team will get chipped to death by a DPS/Priest. Unless you have perfectly synced attacks and a snoozing Priest you just can't overcome those heals.


Last time I did a 2v2 event I limited the heals and the dps teams CRUSHED the priest teams and I don't believe there were ANY guardians then. I am trying to find a good balance to where the person feels they can play their class but it's not TOO limited. I will be putting a cap back on next week but I've not yet decided how many heals.

Heals are rough. Pure DPS is definitely boned, but I guess one could argue that's taking a bad comp. If you limit heals too much priest is useless, maybe there's a middle ground somewhere?

Double elim is rougher. Both of the last two teams forfeited cause people had to go <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" />. I quite like the style, it just needs to be shorter.


Finding that middle ground is the difficult part but I am certain with some community assistance we can come to what feels appropriate and fair to most people. Two teams did have to forfeit because people had to go, and I do agree that sucks. That being said, I explained at the beginning how it was going to be done. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> It's error on my part for it taking 1hour40minutes total to run but again, just a trial to test things. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />

If people feel like committing 2hours or if I can get another Staffer to run it with me I can probably tighten a double elim up to 1hour-1hour15m.

Thank you to everyone that joined and played(16 total! huge turnout). Please, keep the discussion rolling! Let's try to find a fair middle ground.

The changes that I am proposing right now are 3 heals per character(6 per team total) and shortening it to a Single Elimination bracket rather than double. I am also going to be allowing Fade to test it's strategic use again.

Thoughts?
Folder
3 heals isn't enough imo, and doing it per character is a bit goofy. I was guard/zerker and our first match against 2 ninjas had me use half my mana (aka a LOT more than 3 heals!). I'd not think, for example, a guard is of any value if I can only heal myself 3 times. The problem is this - quite a lot of rounds I needed to use all 4 heals, so if you limit heals too much then all that happens is guard/priest runs out of heals and then what? They are nigh useless.

Maybe 2 per round is better? Can't be limited to which person you heal because strategic healing/guarding should be a thing imo.

Fade is whatever, it provides no real advantage in 2v2.
Honzo
3 heals isn't enough imo, and doing it per character is a bit goofy. I was guard/zerker and our first match against 2 ninjas had me use half my mana (aka a LOT more than 3 heals!). I'd not think, for example, a guard is of any value if I can only heal myself 3 times. The problem is this - quite a lot of rounds I needed to use all 4 heals, so if you limit heals too much then all that happens is guard/priest runs out of heals and then what? They are nigh useless.

Maybe 2 per round is better? Can't be limited to which person you heal because strategic healing/guarding should be a thing imo.

Fade is whatever, it provides no real advantage in 2v2.


It is 3 heals per head, meaning 6 per team any number of casts per person but only that many total. It's just a LOT to keep track of amidst all the chaos with a limit. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> It's a wild situation. The problem is more so with Priests than Guardians(due to inherently needing many stats to work). Maybe the answer is...bring a priest if you want heals! However in practice it seems much more damning not to and that if you don't then you are screwed due to lack of counterplay.

Maybe there could be a class with a MANA BURN type ability? Maybe lower priests Stamina to 3? I'm starting to think it might just be a PRIEST problem. We've seen this many times already. It's hard to balance right without people feeling cheated.

Now that I've said all that, I DO think there is counterplay to Priests but they require -VERY- good coordination and luck. Much more than your average player would have. As far as Fade goes, it's going back in to see how it messes with things(Slayers/Brigs) specifically and click-attackers.

The idea of 2 heals per round seems like it might be something we could try.
Does that seem to punishing?
Folder
Priests are of course the main "problem", but I think my guard did very well too. We couldn't have had a closer fight than we did with Horrid/Mallet.

Personally I think it's OK to just let healers be healers in this. They don't really get a chance to shine a lot of the time - when's the last time you saw a priest or guard in KotH? I may be alone here though so more opinions needed. In a 2v2 you want a healer...that's part of the gameplay right?

3 heals per team member gets wonky with guard. If I am guarding do I only get 3 heals? poop.
Honzo
3 heals per team member gets wonky with guard. If I am guarding do I only get 3 heals? poop.


No. Take it to the simplest level. You'd get 6 heals TOTAL. 3 per head. Meaning 6 total for 2v2 and 9 total for 3v3. You can cast them any way you wish.

I will be running this same format for 3v3 tournaments, too.

Personally I think it's OK to just let healers be healers in this. They don't really get a chance to shine a lot of the time - when's the last time you saw a priest or guard in KotH? I may be alone here though so more opinions needed. In a 2v2 you want a healer...that's part of the gameplay right?


Kind of what I was thinking earlier too..maybe you WANT someone on that class if you desire heals in your comp? Especially in a 3v3 it's easier to pop one healer, and there is no class stacking so it prevents multiple priests. I want every class to feel like they can be played. There are lots of things people haven't even tried yet. One of the perks of watching the fights is seeing how they actually work out so I have gathered data over the last several events I've been able to run. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />

Your Guardian did very well, no doubt. I was happy to see more priests and guards this time for sure. Again, the problem wasn't so much guards as it was Priests. Guards require many stats to be good so they come with more counterplay, whereas a Priest/Cleric is someone who can focus all of their stats strictly on int/agi/end/wis to allow a very tanky base char.
Folder


No. Take it to the simplest level. You'd get 6 heals TOTAL. 3 per head. Meaning 6 total for 2v2 and 9 total for 3v3. You can cast them any way you wish.


Oh, I gotcha that makes sense. I think if we decide to limit heals it should be per round, but the more I think about it the less I like limiting things. Just my opinion of course.
Thi
I thought it was quite fun, for once priests got included into it and played a cool role.

Now of we are going to start limiting classes, unlimited leech is insane as well 30ish per hit is a heal per round plus heals from a priest/guard make it insane and then they will become the "new priest problem"

The way I see it, this is a survival event, so you are expected to bring healers into equation and let it play out, surely it drags fights but it's the nature of the beast I guess, my suggestion is, maybe run it with 2 staffers, one doing upper bracket and one doing losers bracket.

That's to say I enjoyed the vent yesterday, pretty fun seeing priests trying to help their team fight.
Folder
Have to agree if you want double elim then we need 2 matches at once. 1.5-2 hours is a pretty big commitment.
Cerebrus
I've been seeing these people complain about how long an event took, yet those same people are the ones wanting more things to do or they idle all day long.

I dont see why it's a big deal when we're taking the time to hold these events, you guys cant sit and chat with everyone while you wait for your turn and you could win some pp from it.

Is sitting in a room shootin the shit with everyone for an hour or two really that bad? lol Im going to make a list of those complaining and then watch them to see what the do all day long. Are they truly active, busy leveling or are they idling all day anyways.

Im just happy that we got some new event staff who care about the game and the players enough to build these events and take their personal time to run them to give you guys something to do. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Folder
I mean I do think 1.5-2 hrs is a very big commitment. Too big for some of us. Event was tons of fun and I'd love to see more of them, I really enjoy team fights as opposed to 1v1.
Cerebrus
I mean I do think 1.5-2 hrs is a very big commitment. Too big for some of us. Event was tons of fun and I'd love to see more of them, I really enjoy team fights as opposed to 1v1.


I can see your point there, but how's it any different than sitting idle for 1.5-2hrs or leveling for 1.5-2hrs or farming dread keys for 2hrs?
Folder
I can only speak for myself here of course.

When I'm idle I'm either 1) playing a different game or 2) not at the computer. I think there's a large difference between idling for 2 hours and being committed to playing for 2 hours. When you don't know which team will go next you need to keep an eye on things constantly, and when it's your turn you have 1 minute to get rdy so you can't be jerking off in the bathroom when you're up.

I never sit idle and do nothing while staring at Ember, but that's just me of course.

And for the record farming dreads keys for 1-2 blows. We've had that discussion though!
Cerebrus
Yes it does, it's why I rarely do it. lol

If I had remembered and wasnt hung over from the super bowl I would have been on to help him out. Maybe with double elim we should do it with 2 staffers.

1 Running Winners Bracket
1 Running Losers Bracket
Then meet at the end with the winners from those brackets.

Would speed it up a bit. Either way though, there's still going to be some time investment needed from the players side of it.
Folder
2 staffers for double elims sounds good if it can be coordinated <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />.
Terron
priest problems lol
i think its only relevant in 1v1 and 2v2.

the problem lies in aid im sure and not cure/heal. removing aid use(without a change) will just make cleric never used.
in my opinion clerics don't need to heal 260s on non oad squares, i dont really see a fix w/o removal of aid, giving a cleric a bonus to heals over druid/guardian(possibly a flat 30 class bonus on any heal spell), and possibly making a long duration spell that prays to divinity for bonus heal power on oad squares only so aid isnt essential. or one last option of lowering aids fizzle rate and juicing the spell like making it a relative safe cast spell (next to nil on fizzles), cost 2 stamina to cast, 50 mana and heals for alot like 400-550 (2x normal) or a flat half of targets HP(player). either way it doesnt affect the game overall except in pvp.

in 3v3 3 hardcore dps will likely round someone enough heals dont matter as much. of course theres always the clerics that will tap all 3 heal macroes to heal whoever enemies are hitting, but it can be overcome by hitting all 3 enemies once then draining stam at 1 target. its just a tad harder to round is all. i recommend altering tactics to make a cleric stam late then try for rounding an enemy.