The present and future of Ember Online
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
i love long oad areas personally. but in the refinery's case its almost entirely key farming and key bosses. in areas that are generally that large the main boss should respawn with the damage on it much like crimson dragon. and the "key" bosses shouldnt always drop keys. theres no reason that a 9 boss oad cant end at boss 3 or even boss 1, where they drop loot instead of key. in that sense a trip could take 2+ hours or it could be done in 15 minutes.
in defense of the refinery its a nice area loaded with cool stuff to explore. i like it. its much appreciated.
refinery is a long oad, perhaps some quicker, smaller area, smaller reward, smaller party type oads could be added around the game to compliment it. that way it isnt every player ingame focused on 3 hr oad trips opposed to 4 or 5 15 minute ones throughout the day.
in defense of the refinery its a nice area loaded with cool stuff to explore. i like it. its much appreciated.
refinery is a long oad, perhaps some quicker, smaller area, smaller reward, smaller party type oads could be added around the game to compliment it. that way it isnt every player ingame focused on 3 hr oad trips opposed to 4 or 5 15 minute ones throughout the day.
I can appreciate long areas as well but fact is most do not like them. As the guy who coordinates all OaDs for Silh all I hear from the majority of members is that they take too long.
Obviously if we had 3x the playerbase we'd also have more people who can commit to long oad runs but as it is now they are a commitment of an entire evening. That is excessive for most people unfortunately.
Things to think about since we want people logging in and being active.
Obviously if we had 3x the playerbase we'd also have more people who can commit to long oad runs but as it is now they are a commitment of an entire evening. That is excessive for most people unfortunately.
Things to think about since we want people logging in and being active.
Correct, time wise very involved. I don't do dreads. And if the new town is just as bad no point in even looking at it. Most will never see it cause of multiple keys etc
I don't mind a 30 min or hour fight if it's a oad boss.
Let the players fight it out at the boss.
Keys are fine but multiple times spread out makes it insane to attempt and even then get to see the end.
Bring back simplicity till enough people to be able to start and finish in the same day
Oad areas can be revised later to suit more difficulty.
Why not multiple bosses instead of one boss holding it all
If they want a sword go kill the one with a sword, armor etc, that way leveling areas are increased etc
If a person isn't in the big clan they will never get to explore or find out
I don't mind a 30 min or hour fight if it's a oad boss.
Let the players fight it out at the boss.
Keys are fine but multiple times spread out makes it insane to attempt and even then get to see the end.
Bring back simplicity till enough people to be able to start and finish in the same day
Oad areas can be revised later to suit more difficulty.
Why not multiple bosses instead of one boss holding it all
If they want a sword go kill the one with a sword, armor etc, that way leveling areas are increased etc
If a person isn't in the big clan they will never get to explore or find out
I'm fine with OADs and generally large OADs but I do agree that OADs should be an hour max when you know what you're doing. I'm not saying they should be easy to complete, but ROK had a simple system where one key would grant one party a day to run an area. TOTD for example took 2-3 months to figure out by players, but it only was about 45-60 minutes to actually run, and they'd obviously often fail. You might get closer to the goal, but you'd die in the process.
I kind of don't mind it that way. I disagree with a party fighting at the end boss for the content. I'm fine with competition at the keys, which would suffice for now.
Don't wanna have the best gear, don't do it. The scaling is fine. Theres a max AC, and it's based off that, lower AC is based off the max AC. Not saying that some other gear doesn't need adjusted, but level 25 blue/purple is meant to be tougher to get. In ROK people did it for the +1 AC, and often that didn't grant much in terms of OADs only. The problem really isn't the gear to me, it's how the OADs are setup and how they are to run. It shouldn't be a whole day of grinding thing.
I kind of don't mind it that way. I disagree with a party fighting at the end boss for the content. I'm fine with competition at the keys, which would suffice for now.
-Gear scaling is not as big as it should be imo. By this I mean you can either, as an example, 1) easily get an Onyx Plate or 2) spend an enormous amount of time getting a Devil's Plate for 3AC more. That 3AC gives .3% damage reduction and 1.5% greater chance to absorb. It's very difficult to convince people that it's worth the effort to actually get OaDs. Weapons are a different story as they do in fact make a bigger difference. Does this make sense?
Don't wanna have the best gear, don't do it. The scaling is fine. Theres a max AC, and it's based off that, lower AC is based off the max AC. Not saying that some other gear doesn't need adjusted, but level 25 blue/purple is meant to be tougher to get. In ROK people did it for the +1 AC, and often that didn't grant much in terms of OADs only. The problem really isn't the gear to me, it's how the OADs are setup and how they are to run. It shouldn't be a whole day of grinding thing.
Gonna have a meeting soon about how OADs are handled though. Again, I don't have any quarrels if the OAD isn't completed, but there needs to be a sort duration per OAD. We 'want' the oads to be run every day. Having a large grind makes it tough to do, people will get bored/tired/etc. I have a few things in mind for things anyways.
The solution to OaDs really isn't so complicated. We could argue the "why" all day but the fact is anything lasting longer than an hour turns people off. 20+ minute boss fights turn people off (longer than MMO bosses where you have a slew of abilities as well as different boss phases, etc.). Gear that only results in a very very small benefit turns people off.
You can't really say "don't want it don't do it" and also say you want OaDs run every day. I'm quite sure I have put more effort into OaD running than anyone else in the game (not bragging at all, trying to validate my points) and my biggest struggle is the time commitments.
I still think gear scaling is something to consider. I'm not saying make characters more powerful, what I mean is making gear scale such that there is a bigger difference between 95 and 92ac. Right now there's almost none so people are unmotivated to put the effort in. Something like where AC above a certain threshold (different for each class) has a bonus? All that said if the time commitment for OaDs were lower people would be more inclined even for the small differences.
Again a small playerbase exacerbates all of this, so that's also worth keeping in mind.
You can't really say "don't want it don't do it" and also say you want OaDs run every day. I'm quite sure I have put more effort into OaD running than anyone else in the game (not bragging at all, trying to validate my points) and my biggest struggle is the time commitments.
I still think gear scaling is something to consider. I'm not saying make characters more powerful, what I mean is making gear scale such that there is a bigger difference between 95 and 92ac. Right now there's almost none so people are unmotivated to put the effort in. Something like where AC above a certain threshold (different for each class) has a bonus? All that said if the time commitment for OaDs were lower people would be more inclined even for the small differences.
Again a small playerbase exacerbates all of this, so that's also worth keeping in mind.
The solution to OaDs really isn't so complicated. We could argue the "why" all day but the fact is anything lasting longer than an hour turns people off. 20+ minute boss fights turn people off (longer than MMO bosses where you have a slew of abilities as well as different boss phases, etc.). Gear that only results in a very very small benefit turns people off.
You can't really say "don't want it don't do it" and also say you want OaDs run every day. I'm quite sure I have put more effort into OaD running than anyone else in the game (not bragging at all, trying to validate my points) and my biggest struggle is the time commitments.
I still think gear scaling is something to consider. I'm not saying make characters more powerful, what I mean is making gear scale such that there is a bigger difference between 95 and 92ac. Right now there's almost none so people are unmotivated to put the effort in. Something like where AC above a certain threshold (different for each class) has a bonus? All that said if the time commitment for OaDs were lower people would be more inclined even for the small differences.
Again a small playerbase exacerbates all of this, so that's also worth keeping in mind.
No to bonuses. You aren't understanding that the armor is based on the max values, I don't want to go higher at this time. If scaling were to change, what would basically happen is that armor for all classes would have to be lowered and then per point difference would be higher. Virtually what would happen is that lower AC would lose percentage while the max AC would have the same deflect/absorb rate. The armor max deflect and absorbed is based on those values. I don't want people running around with 70% absorption chance rates, that would be mental.
Agree about the OADs and time though.
I know how armor works <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />. Like I said it's not about going higher, it's about considering changing the scaling such that the top end is still the same but there's more of a gap between high-end items and easily obtainable items. The point is if, and I'm making numbers up here, that someone can be 90% as effective in gear obtained from stores/quests/orange minibosses as someone in full OaDs then they are less likely to want to spend the effort on OaDs.
As an actual example look at the AC of a Flaming Hakama and compare it to Spectral Robes or a Shark Fin Vest. No one does Salamander anymore. It's a PITA to farm blue shards and takes a non-fun amount of time, but more importantly the gear you get is either 1) a drum lul, 2) worse than gear off orange mobs, or 3) not sufficiently better than a void cloak which can be solo farmed.
Time to kill needs to be considered, and item rewards need to be considered as well. Also staves should affect penetration more because as it is now the difference is so small staves -always- go to ninjas first. You said yourself you want people doing OaDs every day - I'm giving you the reasons they aren't being done.
Our goals are the same here, we want people out and about enjoying the world people work so hard to build <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />.
As an actual example look at the AC of a Flaming Hakama and compare it to Spectral Robes or a Shark Fin Vest. No one does Salamander anymore. It's a PITA to farm blue shards and takes a non-fun amount of time, but more importantly the gear you get is either 1) a drum lul, 2) worse than gear off orange mobs, or 3) not sufficiently better than a void cloak which can be solo farmed.
Time to kill needs to be considered, and item rewards need to be considered as well. Also staves should affect penetration more because as it is now the difference is so small staves -always- go to ninjas first. You said yourself you want people doing OaDs every day - I'm giving you the reasons they aren't being done.
Our goals are the same here, we want people out and about enjoying the world people work so hard to build <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />.
I cant remember when we finish Totd in like 15 mins once? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />
I cant remember when we finish Totd in like 15 mins once? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />
Totd speed runs were great, I remember us getting pissed if someone ruined the run by going slow.
I also remember someone wiping tragically whilst attempting a totd speed run on a trap.
hahaha... good times <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
He has max armor set and don't want it changed.
The problem as far as store bought compared to a oad is the armor and weapon values need updated between canopia and bitryn , they are both level 8 armor and weapons and one of them has better level 8 stuff then the other, plus some of the oad level 8 items are better then the level 15 store bought.
And mendel armor drop should be level 15 with less ac. It's an easy monster at level 18. And is equal to scorpion, concerning light armor.
Basicly folder idea is items should be adjusted to fit the difficulty of the drop and hopefully this is not to increase the value of certain items.
Which is why I was more into more oad orange bosses spread out so each has only one drop. Compared to one monster with multiple drops.
If you want a drum go kill for a drum, if you want a sword go kill for a sword etc.
Ps the Forman in karnath whom is orange has no drop last I knew. Mini bosses should have drops
The problem as far as store bought compared to a oad is the armor and weapon values need updated between canopia and bitryn , they are both level 8 armor and weapons and one of them has better level 8 stuff then the other, plus some of the oad level 8 items are better then the level 15 store bought.
And mendel armor drop should be level 15 with less ac. It's an easy monster at level 18. And is equal to scorpion, concerning light armor.
Basicly folder idea is items should be adjusted to fit the difficulty of the drop and hopefully this is not to increase the value of certain items.
Which is why I was more into more oad orange bosses spread out so each has only one drop. Compared to one monster with multiple drops.
If you want a drum go kill for a drum, if you want a sword go kill for a sword etc.
Ps the Forman in karnath whom is orange has no drop last I knew. Mini bosses should have drops
24 agility and the lowest ac rating should take relatively the same damage per 100 attacks as the highest ac and 19 agility. without skills ofc.
im not sure which classes have which armor values because it really hasnt made a memorable impact in my head while playing the game.
i would assume a dwarf knight would have the most armor and be the mainline tank, and a halfling chanter would be the most agile with lowest armor (no Stoneskin).
in the scenario 100 attacks should be proportionate damage wise vs both these set ups.
I don't think that is translating to game, but i may be wrong. i don't have a plethora of high levels to test so im unsure. just seems like armor is sort of irrelevant and anything 21 and under on agi is hurting outside of party. high hit points aren't worth the agi loss unless you wanna survive a double tap at oads. currently the agi and dodge rate bonus of monks surpasses the higher armor of cavaliers in the tank roll. im sure monks take harder hits, but armor should count for something.
maybe it could be balanced out with shields. a shield tier system small, large, and tower shields that offer a flat DR% maybe 2.5% 5% 10%. also may help with how bad it is to taunt and protect at oads currently. tanks need to be tanks
im not sure which classes have which armor values because it really hasnt made a memorable impact in my head while playing the game.
i would assume a dwarf knight would have the most armor and be the mainline tank, and a halfling chanter would be the most agile with lowest armor (no Stoneskin).
in the scenario 100 attacks should be proportionate damage wise vs both these set ups.
I don't think that is translating to game, but i may be wrong. i don't have a plethora of high levels to test so im unsure. just seems like armor is sort of irrelevant and anything 21 and under on agi is hurting outside of party. high hit points aren't worth the agi loss unless you wanna survive a double tap at oads. currently the agi and dodge rate bonus of monks surpasses the higher armor of cavaliers in the tank roll. im sure monks take harder hits, but armor should count for something.
maybe it could be balanced out with shields. a shield tier system small, large, and tower shields that offer a flat DR% maybe 2.5% 5% 10%. also may help with how bad it is to taunt and protect at oads currently. tanks need to be tanks
I can appreciate long areas as well but fact is most do not like them. As the guy who coordinates all OaDs for Silh all I hear from the majority of members is that they take too long.
Obviously if we had 3x the playerbase we'd also have more people who can commit to long oad runs but as it is now they are a commitment of an entire evening. That is excessive for most people unfortunately.
Things to think about since we want people logging in and being active.
This is the reason I stray from Ember right now and don't play it anymore, bottom line is:
[list][*]We have artificially long OADs cause of traps, seriously stop, this is exhausting / boring / annoying.[/*:m][*]OADs require insane amounts of time meaning from preparation (key gathering) to execution (killing bosses) it's only viable if you don't have a life or life commitments and be 30% or more of your time online.[/*:m][*]Time invested doesn't translate into "lasting or rewarding experience" meaning you get no sense of accomplishment, rather you feel like your time was wasted.[/*:m][*]I'll say this and I'm sure people will bitch like "You are ungrateful", OAD areas needs to improve, like drastically from conception into testing, the number of bugs or breaking mechanisms found in the last one are too high for a game intending to attract a new player base, from rollbacks to items returned that spawn from the floor on /search, or mechanisms taking too long (we spent 1.5 hour feeding a dragon crystals to open a door to a bugged boss that took 20 mins to die and didn't drop loot) this is too much at once, people will frown and walk away. I'm not ungrateful, I'm thankful that people invest their free time to make this a better game/environment, but testing has to be taken more seriously.[/*:m][/list:u]
that oad area was probably rushed to keep us happy. bugs expected, going over every aspect takes a long time. I think there just needs to be more smaller area oads/bosses added to keep players busy while working on the big content releases.
theres no reason u cant add a key to forest witches and throw a 30 square cave in the ground with a coven in it for example. make gy mobs drop a rare key or replace spectral stone or alter it to be a key itself to an area south of GY that contains a lich. lich could even be like dragon, only able to take 10% of its hps per trip and it leaves to keep people interested in going and limiting drops.
endless options, doesnt have to be a taxing 2000 square area. cuz i know that oad was taxing for staff aswell.
theres no reason u cant add a key to forest witches and throw a 30 square cave in the ground with a coven in it for example. make gy mobs drop a rare key or replace spectral stone or alter it to be a key itself to an area south of GY that contains a lich. lich could even be like dragon, only able to take 10% of its hps per trip and it leaves to keep people interested in going and limiting drops.
endless options, doesnt have to be a taxing 2000 square area. cuz i know that oad was taxing for staff aswell.
Lots of good things to look forward to but one thing worries me. You said "a new client". Does that mean we have to start all over again when you get it or can you transfer us over to the new client? I leveled MoonFire the hard way before the double exp/gold before the wipe. I got her to guardian again and my next crit I'm leveling is level 23(almost level 24). I love this game, but the thought of starting all over again is daunting. I was wondering how this is going to work out. By the way, the game really is awesome and thank you so much for going to all the trouble you go through. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" />
Lots of good things to look forward to but one thing worries me. You said "a new client". Does that mean we have to start all over again when you get it or can you transfer us over to the new client? I leveled MoonFire the hard way before the double exp/gold before the wipe. I got her to guardian again and my next crit I'm leveling is level 23(almost level 24). I love this game, but the thought of starting all over again is daunting. I was wondering how this is going to work out. By the way, the game really is awesome and thank you so much for going to all the trouble you go through. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" />
Character information, item information and everything like that is information stored on the server.
When they're speaking about a client update they only mean the program you use to play the game.
i.e. they might change how the interface is laid out, with the map being bigger, a visual indicator for things like stoneskin wearing out, etc.
This shouldn't involve the loss of any characters or items?
OADs require insane amounts of time meaning from preparation (key gathering) to execution (killing bosses) it's only viable if you don't have a life or life commitments and be 30% or more of your time online.
Agreed.
In RoK, there were decent OaDs that one could solo, and many more that only required minimum help like one extra person. All but the top tier could be done solo or as a duo.
But that was because we had alts...
I think it will be a challenge finding the right balance when people can play only one character.
Lots of good things to look forward to but one thing worries me. You said "a new client". Does that mean we have to start all over again when you get it or can you transfer us over to the new client? I leveled MoonFire the hard way before the double exp/gold before the wipe. I got her to guardian again and my next crit I'm leveling is level 23(almost level 24). I love this game, but the thought of starting all over again is daunting. I was wondering how this is going to work out. By the way, the game really is awesome and thank you so much for going to all the trouble you go through. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" />
Character information, item information and everything like that is information stored on the server.
When they're speaking about a client update they only mean the program you use to play the game.
i.e. they might change how the interface is laid out, with the map being bigger, a visual indicator for things like stoneskin wearing out, etc.
This shouldn't involve the loss of any characters or items?
Correct.
As a quick update, I am working on the script system document and also the script system itself (making it work again). Recent crash again yesterday was due to the script system, obviously it's one of the reasons I am redoing it.
I know it's going to take a longer time, and I apologize for it, once I get it out of the way I'll probably advertise again while the more common things can be released to keep people entertained. I'll also be hiring new people soon, just gathering all the applications atm.
Ember players, a game plan was announced with what all plans for the future, but can't rush everything.
Nighthawk, you are trying your best along with others help, don't get discouraged worrying about advertisement etc. Yes people would love to see 1k on server etc if it comes. But gotta follow your plan so stuff comes out in order.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Nighthawk, you are trying your best along with others help, don't get discouraged worrying about advertisement etc. Yes people would love to see 1k on server etc if it comes. But gotta follow your plan so stuff comes out in order.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Ember players, a game plan was announced with what all plans for the future, but can't rush everything.
Nighthawk, you are trying your best along with others help, don't get discouraged worrying about advertisement etc. Yes people would love to see 1k on server etc if it comes. But gotta follow your plan so stuff comes out in order.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
1k on server! By the Gods! *faints*