Upgrading items?
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
ive been thinking about a way to make the replayability of oads a little more interesting and while the +1 system is great once an oad is out for a while supply kind of takes over demand and people stop being interested in the oad. Well what if you had a simple system of upgrading those oads to +1 versions yourself. I played a game a while back and this kept the economy in check.
Here's how it would work.
You would need an upgrade item (humming orb or something) and you would apply that to the item. Thing is you would have say a 25% if succeeding and if you failed you broke the item and lost the stone as well.
Things like cost of stone maybe even level of stone need more costly for higher level items? Or just keep it simple and 1 stone. The chance to succeed or fail all that crap could be changed but this is just a general idea for a gold sink and supply and demand control.
For those who want to run an oad over and over they in the long run have a better chance at getting a better item type deal.
Here's how it would work.
You would need an upgrade item (humming orb or something) and you would apply that to the item. Thing is you would have say a 25% if succeeding and if you failed you broke the item and lost the stone as well.
Things like cost of stone maybe even level of stone need more costly for higher level items? Or just keep it simple and 1 stone. The chance to succeed or fail all that crap could be changed but this is just a general idea for a gold sink and supply and demand control.
For those who want to run an oad over and over they in the long run have a better chance at getting a better item type deal.
How about combining duplicates of the item to upgrade it
i.e. combine 3 dracoskins to get a +1 dracoskin, combine 7 to get a +2 draco, and combine 12 to get a +3 draco
The lore reaosning could be something about combining the best parts of the armours to produce 1 improved version.
You could also include a gold requirement if you wanted it to be a gold sink, or potentially include a quest/oad item, like the stone you described, as a way to limit it further if you wanted
Edit to add:
If this did go ahead you'd have to think how each item would be impacted by this, i.e. if you combine a buncha crap swords do you end up with something better than the best oad sword? does this lead to most people not running the top end oad any longer?
You could always limit it so only certain items could be combined?
I think one of the best parts of this, is it could be introduced quickly through the current quest system without any additional coding required?
Edit 2:
You could always turn it into a more fuller crafting system using the quest system
4 * dracos + one special quest stone + 40k gold + an onyx plate = +1 dracos?
then 4 * "+1 dracos" + 3 special quest stones + 120k gold + 3 onyx plates = +2 dracos?
i.e. combine 3 dracoskins to get a +1 dracoskin, combine 7 to get a +2 draco, and combine 12 to get a +3 draco
The lore reaosning could be something about combining the best parts of the armours to produce 1 improved version.
You could also include a gold requirement if you wanted it to be a gold sink, or potentially include a quest/oad item, like the stone you described, as a way to limit it further if you wanted
Edit to add:
If this did go ahead you'd have to think how each item would be impacted by this, i.e. if you combine a buncha crap swords do you end up with something better than the best oad sword? does this lead to most people not running the top end oad any longer?
You could always limit it so only certain items could be combined?
I think one of the best parts of this, is it could be introduced quickly through the current quest system without any additional coding required?
Edit 2:
You could always turn it into a more fuller crafting system using the quest system
4 * dracos + one special quest stone + 40k gold + an onyx plate = +1 dracos?
then 4 * "+1 dracos" + 3 special quest stones + 120k gold + 3 onyx plates = +2 dracos?
yasssss. We've brought this up before!
Keep it simple though. I like the idea of combining multiple OaDs as it gets rid of a large number of them and promotes farming.
Keep it simple though. I like the idea of combining multiple OaDs as it gets rid of a large number of them and promotes farming.
While they basically accomplish the same thing (an item and gold sink). What I'm suggesting has a random factor and the other has a set amount of items to "upgrade". I prefer the random factor just because I've seen it in play and enjoyed it more (im a gambling man) than the other but they pretty much do the same thing.
Your right the giving multiple to a quest giver could be done now but I feel like that's a mess if you would do it for every item plus as far as I know you can't make humming items so it would still need a bit of code? Also if you give a decked item the game would know to give you a decked back so there is coding on both sides?
Your right the giving multiple to a quest giver could be done now but I feel like that's a mess if you would do it for every item plus as far as I know you can't make humming items so it would still need a bit of code? Also if you give a decked item the game would know to give you a decked back so there is coding on both sides?
Decking is kinda irrelevant, it's cheap and easy.
Either way requires code to make a humming item as far as I know.
I think the progression of going +1/+2/+3 with a great number of items combined is healthier for the game because it means people will be out there farming longer. If you just do the random chance thing people might get an upgrade first time and be done with it. Of course you could make the stone itself hard to obtain, but then I think it just feels bad if you try and fail. I'm faaaar more inclined to enjoy knowing that I am making progress on something, even if it requires 12 void blades. If obtaining an upgrade item is hard, and you use it on a difficult oad, and then you lose both? No. Just no lol.
Either way requires code to make a humming item as far as I know.
I think the progression of going +1/+2/+3 with a great number of items combined is healthier for the game because it means people will be out there farming longer. If you just do the random chance thing people might get an upgrade first time and be done with it. Of course you could make the stone itself hard to obtain, but then I think it just feels bad if you try and fail. I'm faaaar more inclined to enjoy knowing that I am making progress on something, even if it requires 12 void blades. If obtaining an upgrade item is hard, and you use it on a difficult oad, and then you lose both? No. Just no lol.
I for sure wouldn't have you toss in a bunch of items and still have a chance to lose them but here is a few points to why I like the 1 item thing.
Less storage needed. Like you were saying for the top tier it might make sense to have to trade in 12+ items for the next tier plus a stone. While it would suck storing them in vault you would also run into at a point inability to trade them inn from you inventory while you could always just lower the success rate and never run into that.
Also i like the gambling side meaning you could just take your chances and with one 1 get lucky and upgrade then again it can always go the other way as well.
Moving off that last point you could have stones change the chance. Meaning maybe a minor humming stone would give you a 10% chance to succeed while a major might be 25% ther would be cost difference and stuff.
Also for moving to +2 or +3 tiers and collecting you might end up with 20 some items in your vault before you get a chance with all the combos of reg and +1 items in your vault before you get a chance.
With all that said anything would be Cools
Less storage needed. Like you were saying for the top tier it might make sense to have to trade in 12+ items for the next tier plus a stone. While it would suck storing them in vault you would also run into at a point inability to trade them inn from you inventory while you could always just lower the success rate and never run into that.
Also i like the gambling side meaning you could just take your chances and with one 1 get lucky and upgrade then again it can always go the other way as well.
Moving off that last point you could have stones change the chance. Meaning maybe a minor humming stone would give you a 10% chance to succeed while a major might be 25% ther would be cost difference and stuff.
Also for moving to +2 or +3 tiers and collecting you might end up with 20 some items in your vault before you get a chance with all the combos of reg and +1 items in your vault before you get a chance.
With all that said anything would be Cools
My grandpaw always said, give it a kiss, keep it simple stupid...
3 gives you plus one
3 plus one give your plus 2
Store would have to be built for it to work
Not to mention the programing required to implement it
Current amount online isn't worth the trouble atm
3 gives you plus one
3 plus one give your plus 2
Store would have to be built for it to work
Not to mention the programing required to implement it
Current amount online isn't worth the trouble atm
Just thought of something
how about you /salvage an item which would always destroy the item, but you have a chance of obtaining the materials needed to upgrade another set of dracos to +1, etc.?
i.e. you /salvage in an armour shop or weapon shop to break the item into parts, i.e. breaking apart a void blade would give you a random chance of getting a void blade hilt, void blade pommel, void blade edge, or just destroying the item without getting a part
you'd then need all 3 of those void blade parts plus another void blade to upgrade a void blade?
Would promote trade, introduce crafting, give reasons to keep running oads, etc.
The idea might need some refinement as i wrote this in a rush
how about you /salvage an item which would always destroy the item, but you have a chance of obtaining the materials needed to upgrade another set of dracos to +1, etc.?
i.e. you /salvage in an armour shop or weapon shop to break the item into parts, i.e. breaking apart a void blade would give you a random chance of getting a void blade hilt, void blade pommel, void blade edge, or just destroying the item without getting a part
you'd then need all 3 of those void blade parts plus another void blade to upgrade a void blade?
Would promote trade, introduce crafting, give reasons to keep running oads, etc.
The idea might need some refinement as i wrote this in a rush
Or salvage into embers, green weapon green ember, purple weapon purple ember, to upgrade your favorite weapon.
Just thought of something
how about you /salvage an item which would always destroy the item, but you have a chance of obtaining the materials needed to upgrade another set of dracos to +1, etc.?
i.e. you /salvage in an armour shop or weapon shop to break the item into parts, i.e. breaking apart a void blade would give you a random chance of getting a void blade hilt, void blade pommel, void blade edge, or just destroying the item without getting a part
you'd then need all 3 of those void blade parts plus another void blade to upgrade a void blade?
Would promote trade, introduce crafting, give reasons to keep running oads, etc.
The idea might need some refinement as i wrote this in a rush
I like this but I feel like it overly complicates things. You would need to create a salvage part for every equipment in game. Then not only that but players would have to store all those parts and keep track of them :/
Or salvage into embers, green weapon green ember, purple weapon purple ember, to upgrade your favorite weapon.
I like the salvage to embers but i think you are missing how embers currently work. Maybe you could combine the two.
Let's say there is a forge delvar and by using the Salvage command it can turn your equipment into embers on succeed and coal on fail.
examples here:
You salvage a level 15 green it's got a 5% chance at random div extinguished ember 95% at coal.
You salvage a level 15 blue it's got a 10% chance at random div extinguished ember 90% at coal.
You salvage a level 20 green it's got a 5% chance at random div dim ember 95% at coal.
You salvage a level 25 purple it's got a 15% chance at random div reg ember 85% at coal.
The forage also allows you to use the Upgrade command.
You attempt to upgrade an item and it has a 10% chance to +1 it and 90% chance to turn to coal.
Now the reason I say just a chance at at upgrade/break instead of just giving 10 items and giving an upgrade is space. These two options are statically the same but really who wants to carry around 10 items of each type in your vault until you have enough room to upgrade one? It seems much better when you get an item that you already have or don't plan on using to head to the forge right then and give it a shot than to save up or trade for 10 of that type. It's just not really logical and the same thing could be accomplished using a more simple approach.
They aren't statistically the same <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />.
Having a 10% chance at something and doing it 10x does not mean you have a 100% chance to succeed. You just have a 10% chance 10 times - the % doesn't change in this instance because each attempt is not related to the last one. This is assuming there is not a system where your % to succeed goes up if you fail and try the same item multiple times in a row.
That said I definitely agree that carrying around, in this example, 10 items is cumbersome and not very efficient. Make it 3-5 and it's more appealing and realistic imo. Not at all a fan of % based unless the % increases with failed attempts.
Having a 10% chance at something and doing it 10x does not mean you have a 100% chance to succeed. You just have a 10% chance 10 times - the % doesn't change in this instance because each attempt is not related to the last one. This is assuming there is not a system where your % to succeed goes up if you fail and try the same item multiple times in a row.
That said I definitely agree that carrying around, in this example, 10 items is cumbersome and not very efficient. Make it 3-5 and it's more appealing and realistic imo. Not at all a fan of % based unless the % increases with failed attempts.
They aren't statistically the same <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />.
Having a 10% chance at something and doing it 10x does not mean you have a 100% chance to succeed. You just have a 10% chance 10 times - the % doesn't change in this instance because each attempt is not related to the last one. This is assuming there is not a system where your % to succeed goes up if you fail and try the same item multiple times in a row.
That said I definitely agree that carrying around, in this example, 10 items is cumbersome and not very efficient. Make it 3-5 and it's more appealing and realistic imo. Not at all a fan of % based unless the % increases with failed attempts.
Nerd.
They aren't statistically the same <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />.
Having a 10% chance at something and doing it 10x does not mean you have a 100% chance to succeed. You just have a 10% chance 10 times - the % doesn't change in this instance because each attempt is not related to the last one. This is assuming there is not a system where your % to succeed goes up if you fail and try the same item multiple times in a row.
That said I definitely agree that carrying around, in this example, 10 items is cumbersome and not very efficient. Make it 3-5 and it's more appealing and realistic imo. Not at all a fan of % based unless the % increases with failed attempts.
Nerd.
I don't agree that you should get a pity counter to increase % on fails, there's PLENTY of green items going around right now. So many that their worth is negligible.
The easter eggs did not have a pity counter, they had about a 10% chance to drop (based on my math from searching) and I got plenty of eggs, it would be about the same results on a large sample.
Right, but there's a huge difference between dropping 10 green items and 10 purple items into the magical maybe-you-get-an-upgrade machine. I don't see anyone plopping down a ton of voide blades in the hopes they get +1 eventually. Green farmable items? Sure I guess, who cares. You could make it so that there's a scaling # of items required based on their base color, maybe?
Right, but there's a huge difference between dropping 10 green items and 10 purple items into the magical maybe-you-get-an-upgrade machine. I don't see anyone plopping down a ton of voide blades in the hopes they get +1 eventually. Green farmable items? Sure I guess, who cares. You could make it so that there's a scaling # of items required based on their base color, maybe?
That just needlessly complicates stuff too much imo. 10% chance of on every item if you don't wanna risk it I guess sell it elsewhere. Trading in 4 to upgrade to +1 isn't fair (way to easy). Even if that were the rate having to hold 4 of each item rasies space issues.
Think about it you go on a boss run and get a few items everyone in the clan already has. You cold bank them and wait til you have 10 of each or just chance it and forge 1 and hope to upgrade.
Same with as you are leveling. Say you get 2 forestry axes while level. You really wanna hold those until the next 4 characters you level to get 10 or just roll the dice right there with the 2?
I just think it's much more simple and way easier on the vault / storage characters.
I know you don't like the risk envolved but over time it's going to even out. You may not get any after doing 10 items but you may get 5. This game is full of random it's what makes it fun imo.
I guess we will have to agree to disagree on this one.
That +1 Void Blade would be amazing though. Worth 10-15 blades especially if they're overfarmed.
What other ways are there to attain such a bonus? How much PP does it cost?
I'm all about the math guys. If it's 400PP to get an equivalent, and the OaD is farmable, then you're essentially farming a chance at the equivalent.
I'd have to sit down and write it all out to figure out what's what, but you see what I'm saying.
So what if I just destroyed normal items, the +item will be worth!
What other ways are there to attain such a bonus? How much PP does it cost?
I'm all about the math guys. If it's 400PP to get an equivalent, and the OaD is farmable, then you're essentially farming a chance at the equivalent.
I'd have to sit down and write it all out to figure out what's what, but you see what I'm saying.
So what if I just destroyed normal items, the +item will be worth!
I mean I'm not ever gonna drop 10-15 purple items in the trash to hope for a +1, but maybe that's just me. It's pretty much impossible in the current state of the game to obtain 10+ purple items for 1 person, unless your guild is funneling them to you specifically for this purpose. But the likelihood of that, I mean...let's be real here guys.
I mean I'm not ever gonna drop 10-15 purple items in the trash to hope for a +1, but maybe that's just me. It's pretty much impossible in the current state of the game to obtain 10+ purple items for 1 person, unless your guild is funneling them to you specifically for this purpose. But the likelihood of that, I mean...let's be real here guys.
Yea it would be tough to part with 10 void blades at once but say you have 1 bound to you and you just got a new sword to upgrade to. Now would you rather vendor the bound void blade for the 10k or take a 1:10 chance of turning it into a very valuble +1 void blade? That's kind of where I'm coming from.
I mean I'm not ever gonna drop 10-15 purple items in the trash to hope for a +1, but maybe that's just me. It's pretty much impossible in the current state of the game to obtain 10+ purple items for 1 person, unless your guild is funneling them to you specifically for this purpose. But the likelihood of that, I mean...let's be real here guys.
Yea it would be tough to part with 10 void blades at once but say you have 1 bound to you and you just got a new sword to upgrade to. Now would you rather vendor the bound void blade for the 10k or take a 1:10 chance of turning it into a very valuble +1 void blade? That's kind of where I'm coming from.
Not sure that changes anything. Then you would have 1 (or maybe 2) sbd swords and 9 or 8 unsbd.