Drop Stealing
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I am unlocking this because players need to discuss it. If this goes wild again it's gonna receive another lock and edit. Please guys act like adults.
I actually thought this idea wasn't a bad way of solving one of the longstanding "problems" of rok/ember.
However after seeing the below comment in the midst of a discussion about this I'm not so sure where i stand any longer:
However after seeing the below comment in the midst of a discussion about this I'm not so sure where i stand any longer:
the conflict is what makes the game interesting, regardless of which side you're on
no one is ever like
hey man remember that time 10 years ago we grinded on some mobs for xp?
no
they remember the fights, the drop steals, the wars, etc. because that's what makes the game interesting. there's a million games i can go pve on, and they do it far better
I think there is a problem with world bosses like this and drop stealing. I don't mind it in other locations, but for such a high valued item I think theres some sort of problems with it. Dunno. This won't be a common thing, but for mobs that take a month or two to kill, I'm not sure how fair it is that the level 25 hider who does nothing just steals it. It's not hard as the names are all the exact same anyways.
What's the difference between your example of someone who did no work and spams a /get macro, and someone who comes in and hits the mob once and gets the lucky killshot?
You can't make this perfectly "fair". Fair doesn't exist, there is only effort and playing smart. No matter what you do to try and force "fair" it can not happen, it's a pointless endeavor.
Strongly opposed to items going straight to inventory. This is of course only my opinion.
You can't make this perfectly "fair". Fair doesn't exist, there is only effort and playing smart. No matter what you do to try and force "fair" it can not happen, it's a pointless endeavor.
Strongly opposed to items going straight to inventory. This is of course only my opinion.
What's the difference between your example of someone who did no work and spams a /get macro, and someone who comes in and hits the mob once and gets the lucky killshot?
You can't make this perfectly "fair". Fair doesn't exist, there is only effort and playing smart. No matter what you do to try and force "fair" it can not happen, it's a pointless endeavor.
Strongly opposed to items going straight to inventory. This is of course only my opinion.
At least the attacker is actually attacking the monster and not spamming the /get macro. The person attacking is always going to have a worse delay than the person just getting the item.
-
Also, what about what people talked about, the most damage thing. Probably do most damage would be crimson weapon, then the next 2-5 peeps could get something like PP or something.
I don't think there's going to be any perfect solution here.
The current system leads to a possibility of drop stealing, which could go to someone who's done no work, but there are ways this can be mitigated if the people attacking the monster take reasonable precautions
Giving to to killshot could lead to someone getting a lucky shot and taking the item despite contributing next to nothing.
This would also discourage support classes from taking part as why would you wanna play a priest if you had no chance of getting the killshot?
Giving it to most damage would also discourage support classes from taking part and reward people spending 24/7 on the game.
There's no ideal solution to all of this, but the current system seems to allow many different tactics and complexities...
The current system leads to a possibility of drop stealing, which could go to someone who's done no work, but there are ways this can be mitigated if the people attacking the monster take reasonable precautions
Giving to to killshot could lead to someone getting a lucky shot and taking the item despite contributing next to nothing.
This would also discourage support classes from taking part as why would you wanna play a priest if you had no chance of getting the killshot?
Giving it to most damage would also discourage support classes from taking part and reward people spending 24/7 on the game.
There's no ideal solution to all of this, but the current system seems to allow many different tactics and complexities...
There's no ideal solution to all of this, but the current system seems to allow many different tactics and complexities...
Winner.
Any system based on damage done or killshot = you are gutting the fun of this world boss. People won't play priests, there won't be as much PvP, and everyone will just bring ninjas and zerkers and hope to get lucky with a killshot. You might as well set up a bot that spawns once a month and /randoms a winner in the room to receive a dragon weapon.
It would be -BORING-. It kills support classes. It kills PvP. It kills fun.
I recently started playing FFXIV and there's a PvP map on there in which the objective is to shatter as many NPC crystals as possible, the more damage you do the more points your side is awarded. The maps are filled with people saying "don't pvp you are wasting your time, only do damage to the crystals". Would be the same here. It's bad PvP design, and this is inherently a PvP game. Please don't kill that.
You can say someone hiding and hitting a macro is the same as someone walking in and getting a lucky ks is the same but it is not really. If the npc showed how much life it had left that would be true "bandit has 300 hp remaining') ok ive been waiting this whole time im going to show my self and backstab once and hope it lands but that is not the case.
Everyone in game for the most part worked on killing the dragon and everyone worked together till it hit crit then the pvp started. We had a member ask should we try and grab it no matter what and we had leaders say no we are going by ks just keep fighting the dragon. our mistake i guess?
I think if the roles were reversed Folder and you got ks and i grabbed it you might wanna see at least the subject looked at on these big items.
I have never drop stole a single item in rok or ember, and maybe that is why i never got all that ahead in either game thats my choice tho. But next crimson item might be mine and i may never lay a finger on the dragon lol.
Everyone in game for the most part worked on killing the dragon and everyone worked together till it hit crit then the pvp started. We had a member ask should we try and grab it no matter what and we had leaders say no we are going by ks just keep fighting the dragon. our mistake i guess?
I think if the roles were reversed Folder and you got ks and i grabbed it you might wanna see at least the subject looked at on these big items.
I have never drop stole a single item in rok or ember, and maybe that is why i never got all that ahead in either game thats my choice tho. But next crimson item might be mine and i may never lay a finger on the dragon lol.
If you don't want the item drop stolen, then kill all your opponents.
There is no skill in getting a lucky kill shot; but it does take coordination to clear an area.
There is no skill in getting a lucky kill shot; but it does take coordination to clear an area.
I know everyone not in Silhouette will just call me an asshole, whatever ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
No one has an answer so far to the point about this idea killing PvP and support classes. Does someone have a counter argument to this? I haven't thought of anything yet, and I think this is a valid argument to not doing items based on damage done.
And I'll say this, no, you're wrong Rael. I wouldn't have complained to staff about that scenario where I got KS and someone else grabbed it. What I would have done is analyzed the situation and thought to myself about how we should have taken care of the competition first, or sought to devise another strategy. If you look at my post history I think you'll see I've spent an enormous amount of time talking about overall game balance and trying to improve things, but I don't come whining on here when I don't get my way.
Believe it or not I actually care about the health of the game, far more than the average player I'd wager. That said, I play to win and so should you (and everyone else!).
No one has an answer so far to the point about this idea killing PvP and support classes. Does someone have a counter argument to this? I haven't thought of anything yet, and I think this is a valid argument to not doing items based on damage done.
And I'll say this, no, you're wrong Rael. I wouldn't have complained to staff about that scenario where I got KS and someone else grabbed it. What I would have done is analyzed the situation and thought to myself about how we should have taken care of the competition first, or sought to devise another strategy. If you look at my post history I think you'll see I've spent an enormous amount of time talking about overall game balance and trying to improve things, but I don't come whining on here when I don't get my way.
Believe it or not I actually care about the health of the game, far more than the average player I'd wager. That said, I play to win and so should you (and everyone else!).
I never complained to staff once about that or made a post about it. Its not against the rules so why would complain to staff? You made the post i just posted my side and what i thought.
only staff i talked to was cowboy while he was on sage right after and we shot the shit he got me the specs of the sword.
Btw you can say clear a area but how when its 20 squares from town and you can be back in 10 seconds after dieing lol.
This is my last post concerning the sword but would be game to discuss the future and if any changes should be made.
only staff i talked to was cowboy while he was on sage right after and we shot the shit he got me the specs of the sword.
Btw you can say clear a area but how when its 20 squares from town and you can be back in 10 seconds after dieing lol.
This is my last post concerning the sword but would be game to discuss the future and if any changes should be made.
Btw you can say clear a area but how when its 20 squares from town and you can be back in 10 seconds after dieing lol.
That's actually a really good point. I think during the instance where this 2nd Crimson Dragon died Silhouette were actually trying to kill off the other clans nearby, but where it was so close to the town the other clans were able to run back in seconds.
I'm not sure if you yourself died a few times during this Rael?
In future it might be worth spawning the dragon further from town to prevent this?
Previously I liked the proposed changes to KS getting the item, but after the discussion above I've changed my mind.
At this stage i think my personal preference is the item drops from the Crimson Dragon remain as is so there's no affect on the PVP aspects and other issues that have been discussed above.
I would however support the creation of some sort of statue or memorial in game that commemorates the person who got KS on the dragon, i think this would fit well lore wise and would be a badass reward in itself.
I'm not sure if you'd have a separate statue on each individual square that the Crimson Dragon died saying something like:
"Here is the spot where the great Crimson Dragon fell after the great warrior Rael landed the killing blow. ELITE_KILLER6969 was able to cause the most damage to the dragon"
Alternatively you could do one big statue in like a Capital city that commemorates all the Dragon Killers?
Edit:
But would this then screw over the support classes and mean noone wants to priest/minstrel/etc. because they won't get their name in game? ARGH!
Fuckit, I give up, no toys for anyone!
I never complained to staff once about that or made a post about it. Its not against the rules so why would complain to staff? You made the post i just posted my side and what i thought.
only staff i talked to was cowboy while he was on sage right after and we shot the shit he got me the specs of the sword.
Btw you can say clear a area but how when its 20 squares from town and you can be back in 10 seconds after dieing lol.
This is my last post concerning the sword but would be game to discuss the future and if any changes should be made.
I didn't mean to imply you were the one complaining to staff, but I can see how it came across like that. My apologies. My intent was simply to disagree on you saying I would feel different if the situation were reversed, because I wouldn't.
You can certainly run back quickly. I mean you'll end up with -10 stats if you die repeatedly but you can still be a pain in the ass if you really want to. Not much to do about that I think.
I would however support the creation of some sort of statue or memorial in game that commemorates the person who got KS on the dragon, i think this would fit well lore wise and would be a badass reward in itself.
I'm not sure if you'd have a separate statue on each individual square that the Crimson Dragon died saying something like:
"Here is the spot where the great Crimson Dragon fell after the great warrior Rael landed the killing blow. ELITE_KILLER6969 was able to cause the most damage to the dragon"
Alternatively you could do one big statue in like a Capital city that commemorates all the Dragon Killers?
Edit:
But would this then screw over the support classes and mean noone wants to priest/minstrel/etc. because they won't get their name in game? ARGH!
Fuckit, I give up, no toys for anyone!
I like the idea, but yes it does still leave supports out. I don't think it's the end of the world in this case though as the reward is purely for vanity.
Eh... change the death mechanics again, so once you die x amount of times you cannot move until x amount of time has passed? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
As for my funny alternative, I was only half joking about the top two (but it should only be done on major items if at all, and either way I do not really care, but the item going to kser... I really do not like that idea):
Picking up an item exhausts the person and they cannot be moved (even if in a party).
An item cannot be picked up for a round.
Hmmm... how about needing to "search" for an item, item remains invisible till found (be even funnier if you actually needed to pass an INT test... support classes ftw!)
There are flaws to that idea, as a clanny pointed out. I would find it annoying for one (extra hassle, extra time wasted). <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
I do not think there is a good solution to this, so my vote is keep as is (apart from the very top idea).
As for my funny alternative, I was only half joking about the top two (but it should only be done on major items if at all, and either way I do not really care, but the item going to kser... I really do not like that idea):
Picking up an item exhausts the person and they cannot be moved (even if in a party).
An item cannot be picked up for a round.
Hmmm... how about needing to "search" for an item, item remains invisible till found (be even funnier if you actually needed to pass an INT test... support classes ftw!)
There are flaws to that idea, as a clanny pointed out. I would find it annoying for one (extra hassle, extra time wasted). <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
I do not think there is a good solution to this, so my vote is keep as is (apart from the very top idea).
Yes i did die twice and ran back.
If we dont want mechanic's changed or how items are dropped, how about how we fight world walkers?
This is just a rough idea. All towns that the dragons land near has a battle station lets say. You grab the quest and you get a item that allows you to enter the area or attact the dragon.
You can get one of these per day per character. It stops the returning of characters over and over, promotes pvp. What ever town it lands near is where you have to get quest.
Something like that makes sense town folks and warrior's running out to protect there town and homes. This is still a very rough idea but does solve alot of problems.
If we dont want mechanic's changed or how items are dropped, how about how we fight world walkers?
This is just a rough idea. All towns that the dragons land near has a battle station lets say. You grab the quest and you get a item that allows you to enter the area or attact the dragon.
You can get one of these per day per character. It stops the returning of characters over and over, promotes pvp. What ever town it lands near is where you have to get quest.
Something like that makes sense town folks and warrior's running out to protect there town and homes. This is still a very rough idea but does solve alot of problems.
@Rael... not too bad an idea. If it was one a day though it would take a VERY long time to kill the walkers.
It just does not fit though, it would make it more like an event, as in a staff run event, not quite sure it meshes well.
That is my opinion though and I am sure plenty of people dislike my ideas given.
It just does not fit though, it would make it more like an event, as in a staff run event, not quite sure it meshes well.
That is my opinion though and I am sure plenty of people dislike my ideas given.
Taking into account previous arguments etc, perhaps a good solution would be to diversify the benefits/drops of a worldboss and make the worldboss recurring so the benefits can be cumulatively experienced....
For example, there is an arcane blacksmith NPC somewhere that can make a 'crimson blade' or 'crimson armor' etc out of say 70 'crimson scales'... then the crimson dragon drops X number of 'crimson scales' each time it lands and is attacked successfully (these can be dropstolen and will drop 100% of time if holder is killed)... and the total number of scales dropped b4 worldboss dies is say 100 (meaning effectively one item per worldboss spawn, but consolation 30 scales for ppl who put work in so they could still cash in next time it spawns).
A system like this could:
1. preserve the PVP competition element and the motivation to hit the worldboss even if it isnt on critical hp
2. continue to reward/incentivize people to participate in attacking it - because even if you don't reach the 70 scales to craft the weapon this time, you and your guild can still get something out of it to work towards complete your weapon/armor next time.
3. allow minor guilds or individual players the incentive to sill participate (eg if Guild A holds 60 scales, Guild B holds 30 scales, Guild C holds 8 scales and Individual D holds 2 scales... then there is economy for Guild A to offer gold etc to Guild C / Individual D to buy scales... or alternatively Guild C / Individual D could just hold their scales and work their way up to 70 over multiple spawnings)
The above numbers/scaling of drops etc are just for example... Am pretty new to EO but just thought id throw in a few thoughts that seem to me could result in more happy players without killing the PVP competitiveness or economy of the game. Basically the suggested idea is one where more people can experience fulfillment for their work in attacking a worldboss by sharing in a more diversified benefit than just a single item drop (and players feeling 'fulfilment' is essential to attracting and retaining playerbase)... Anyhoo... just my initial 2 cents... will defer to others to point out whether such an idea has large shortcomings.
For example, there is an arcane blacksmith NPC somewhere that can make a 'crimson blade' or 'crimson armor' etc out of say 70 'crimson scales'... then the crimson dragon drops X number of 'crimson scales' each time it lands and is attacked successfully (these can be dropstolen and will drop 100% of time if holder is killed)... and the total number of scales dropped b4 worldboss dies is say 100 (meaning effectively one item per worldboss spawn, but consolation 30 scales for ppl who put work in so they could still cash in next time it spawns).
A system like this could:
1. preserve the PVP competition element and the motivation to hit the worldboss even if it isnt on critical hp
2. continue to reward/incentivize people to participate in attacking it - because even if you don't reach the 70 scales to craft the weapon this time, you and your guild can still get something out of it to work towards complete your weapon/armor next time.
3. allow minor guilds or individual players the incentive to sill participate (eg if Guild A holds 60 scales, Guild B holds 30 scales, Guild C holds 8 scales and Individual D holds 2 scales... then there is economy for Guild A to offer gold etc to Guild C / Individual D to buy scales... or alternatively Guild C / Individual D could just hold their scales and work their way up to 70 over multiple spawnings)
The above numbers/scaling of drops etc are just for example... Am pretty new to EO but just thought id throw in a few thoughts that seem to me could result in more happy players without killing the PVP competitiveness or economy of the game. Basically the suggested idea is one where more people can experience fulfillment for their work in attacking a worldboss by sharing in a more diversified benefit than just a single item drop (and players feeling 'fulfilment' is essential to attracting and retaining playerbase)... Anyhoo... just my initial 2 cents... will defer to others to point out whether such an idea has large shortcomings.
Someone in clan had a simlar idea to anthriel's.
The issue with making the crimson items craftable without the dragon having to die is that you remove any motivation to kill him, since he takes a week from time of death to respawn. It would be much easier to keep farming him by beating him down while healers keep healing him back up. Everyone would get their scales, and since they don't need to kill him to get the weapons, he would never be killed.
Now, making him drop things that lead to craftable items that aren't as good as the crimson ones, but still give some kind of motivation to go seek him out? I can get behind that, because in order to get the good items you do still have to kill him and lose a week of scale farming.
Now, making him drop things that lead to craftable items that aren't as good as the crimson ones, but still give some kind of motivation to go seek him out? I can get behind that, because in order to get the good items you do still have to kill him and lose a week of scale farming.
The issue with making the crimson items craftable without the dragon having to die is that you remove any motivation to kill him, since he takes a week from time of death to respawn. It would be much easier to keep farming him by beating him down while healers keep healing him back up. Everyone would get their scales, and since they don't need to kill him to get the weapons, he would never be killed.
Now, making him drop things that lead to craftable items that aren't as good as the crimson ones, but still give some kind of motivation to go seek him out? I can get behind that, because in order to get the good items you do still have to kill him and lose a week of scale farming.
Yeah I take your point. Though I was suggesting a max of 100 scale drops per dragon anyway so after that it would stop dropping (no point healing)... but yes i do agree there would probably need to be a good incentive to go for the killshot too... perhaps PP... or a drop of a certain item that is required to finish the crafting (eg crimson blade hilt or crimson armor base etc)... or your suggestion of being able to craft slightly lesser weapons from the scales with a more unique weapon dropping upon kill could be workable too (but could still result in angry ppl who miss out the chance to get the unique item altogether rather than merely having that chance deferred until the next spawning or spawnings).