← Forum archive

pk ideas thread

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
:lol: <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" /> @ Losing a level for dying to a non-25er. That is just obscene.

I do like the wanted list/bounty board. The more a 25er a racks up kills in a day, the harsher the penalty for him and greater the reward for the person that finally takes them down.

Or even an active bounty board on 25ers only. So people who have been abused, the tender snowflakes that you are.. could place X amount of gold on Player A to get got.


It's easily abused though. I'd just kill myself with a mate once I have a high bounty. Bounty would have to be player based only, not auto rewarded by server. Specially cause they could generate gold this way and kill after etc. It would be hard to deal with .

I think alot of people run and its hard to kill unless you are lucky tbh Eld. I think alot more attempts are made, but thats ok IMO.
anthriel

I guess as a recent new player, my own experience/feeling was that there is literally NOTHING that someone can do to affect a 25er who is bullying them while they are leveling (hence probably why many cases result in damaging flame messages which further exacerbates more pking or counter productive bans happening) ...


Did you try talking to the pker?
Also I think you might be seeing being pkd as being bullied?
Or was the pker actually pk'ing you many times over a short period of time (as in breaking the ToS)?
Was the pker paging you with harrassment?
If you actually are being bullied, then report them.


I just wanted to clarify that i was not personally "harassed" by any PKers (as far as breaking ToS defines it). Hence i never bothered to talk to the pker.... my getting killed by a Pker so far does seem like a normal part of the game... But looking at past posts on this thread it does seem like there are some who do feel harassed by being followed from area to area and repeatedly targeted... and if their only recourse is to complain to staff - well isnt that the situation NH wants to avoid happening more?

What i was saying is that it is very easy for someone to FEEL harassed (apart from how ToS may define it) and stop playing the game we want them to be playing more of (either permanently if they have a bad experience when complaining to staff etc or temporarily while they wait until the PKers are no longer online) ---> because lets face it, most people are time-poor (have other uses of precious time) and most people dont really like leveling. I mean Adramelk and Jadefalcon's apparent dislike for having to potentially risk more leveling in order to engage in their favourite PKing past-time probably illustrates my case on this point. Most ppl play RPGs because they want a feeling of making progress, being social and because they want a character to be 'fulfilling' as to how they imagine it.... id hazard a guess that no new player imagines they want to play a character thats a total loser-gimp/bitch to someone else's 25er for the first 275-350m of grind.... even if they are to suck it up and accept being killed, they are going to want to have some reasonable/fair game mechanic that allows them the chance of striking back in some meaningful way. If you want a new player to say "GG, nice kill" to their Pker and somewhat-joyfully suck-it-up that they now have to spend more time leveling, then you really need to have given them some chance (even a small one) that the outcome could have gone the other way also.... otherwise even copping one PK can start feeling like some "immortal gods" are picking on mere mortals... and such a feeling is probably conducive to a new player wanting to play less rather than more (ie counterproductive to growth of the game)

I think as a community we are probably too blinded in perspective by our experience of ROK, that we've forgotten what a new player (who has never had the PK bastardisation initiation that Rok was) feels like. EO improves on ROK in one of its major flaws (i.e NH is far more active and open to suggestions than DM ever was) but it probably hasnt addressed the other major flaw (which is that the times have moved on, and hence why we cant even get back to ROK player numbers)... people today have far more alternative options for GMUD gaming... they are a far more instant-gratification culture... time is much more valuable as potential playerbase can be older with families/jobs/kids etc.... and therefore leaving a game mechanic the same as it was for ROK is nice for ex-ROK nostalgia players who are used to it, but is is at high risk of being out-of-touch with new players who have never played ROK. I'd be interested to see how many people who never played ROK or didnt have a friend dragging them through EO have actually stayed long enough to achieve having a 25er. My guess is quite few... and that might be saying something.

Basically EO right now can feel like a fish-farm with not enough fish. Existing/established players can assert their rights to fishing that farm as much as they enjoy but i doubt the new fish see it nearly as enjoyable (especially when there is no risk/penalty for the fisher). And un-like fish in the fish farm who have no choice but to be there, new players who realise that their only purpose in the game is to be someone else's victim can easily leave. At least if you introduce a mechanic where there is risk on both sides, the new player may feel its more like a boar hunt where they could potentially strike out with their tusks, rather than being a helpless fish at a fish farm.

Ultimately NH must make the game he sees fit. And both old and new players (consumers) must find the fulfillment they see fit (which may or may not be playing this one game). EO now is like an old nostalgia diner... it has a few regular patrons who make most of the suggestions and who's patronage keeps it going... and thats fine if thats what NH wants it to be. But if he actually wants it to grow into something of more scale like a global McDonalds business (which was my impression from threads about posting on Steam and advertising etc) then i think we existing patrons will need to expect that things cant just be ROK 2.0 but will need to change at some point for the betterment of the many potential new customers.
Styx
Personally I like the idea of a bounty Hunter system, this will increase pk which is supposed to be desired (unless it's me lol)

1. Bounty Hunter options, fee and bounty reward based the person making the bounty which can be added and increased in amount of people adding to total, would be if just killed recently within x min on server time.
2. Option 2, anyone can put up a bounty on a person to be killed, and total amount can accumulate to bounty total pk

I don't suggest bounty be server side cause it can bile easily abused, in ways I don't want to mention.

This can make the pkk aspect more involved and get a little reward on the side.

As well as the pk aspect of being the top number 1 on the most wanted list to be killed

DO YOU HAVE THE GUTS TO BE THE MOST WANTED CRIMINAL?

Most wanted to be decided by the most bounty placed on the pkers head. And yes there should be some sort of time limit on how long you are most wanted, after all people can forget how bad you were with time. So the most wanted is the one, running to make the kill.

Edit, pking up to what to tos allows without abuse
anthriel
Personally I like the idea of a bounty Hunter system, this will increase pk which is supposed to be desired (unless it's me lol)

1. Bounty Hunter options, fee and bounty reward based the person making the bounty which can be added and increased in amount of people adding to total, would be if just killed recently within x min on server time.
2. Option 2, anyone can put up a bounty on a person to be killed, and total amount can accumulate to bounty total pk

I don't suggest bounty be server side cause it can bile easily abused, in ways I don't want to mention.

This can make the pkk aspect more involved and get a little reward on the side.

As well as the pk aspect of being the top number 1 on the most wanted list to be killed

DO YOU HAVE THE GUTS TO BE THE MOST WANTED CRIMINAL?

Most wanted to be decided by the most bounty placed on the pkers head. And yes there should be some sort of time limit on how long you are most wanted, after all people can forget how bad you were with time. So the most wanted is the one, running to make the kill.

Edit, pking up to what to tos allows without abuse


I'm not quite understanding how this works. Can you please clarify what is the point in putting a bounty on someone if there's no consequence to a 25er dying? Say I spend 10k to post a bounty on Lvl 25 pker and someone kills him. Big deal... He loses nothing and is back to PKing in no time... I lose 10k gold.... Furthermore he probably has just had his friend kill him and split the gold.... It actually sounds like the pker ultimately gets more reward rather than actually having any risk/penalty imposed on them by the bounty being placed on them. The only way a bounty system or wanted list actually works is if there is some lasting consequence/drawback to the 25er I want killed... Otherwise it seems counterproductive to me as I may as well be donating the gold to them.
daedroth
Bounty system, as pointed out, will only be abused... UNLESS the money came from the pkers account - call it a fine. They were caught, charged and fined kinda thing.
How much they are fined for is based on how many people they initiated an attack on (and killed) in a set period of time (as in after X amount of time one kill dissapears, so if caught then they will be fined less). Repeat kills (on the same person) could optionally increase the fine a little more than a fresh kill.
Could be a % going to the pkd and a % just disapearing but most going to the killer.
Do not think a lot of people will like this idea.
Also what is done if the pker has no money? Clan fine? Then what if the pker is in no clan? Jail time for the alt pking or the player?
I wonder if people would then deliberatly set out to annoy someone... nah I am sure no one would ever do that <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
NiteHawk
The bounty system makes a lick of difference to deal with under level 25 pking. I know you might think 'OH BUT IF A LEVEL 25 HAS A HIGH BOUNTY ON THEM THEY WILL BE HUNTED THEMSELVES'. But he newbies aren't going to have tons of cash to bounty them. there is no way the system would give bounties based on kills, that would be insanely abused and it would only work using manual bounty adds by players.

In any case, it doesn't solve anything so it needs to be talked elsewhere.
NiteHawk
In terms of level 25'ers losing XP. I don't think it stops the harassment either because a level 25'er killing a newbie or new player in a group even has very little risk. If I were to even do that though, I'd allow EXP to climb up to a certain point. Being killed once and having to relevel even if it involves no gold to relevel is really rough and to me it would actually kill PKing completely. So you'd have to at least have a decent buffer of XP but I still feel like it just adds another layer that doesn't really solve it.


---


The whole damage reduction thing doesn't stop it either, but it at least prevents it after a certain period. But maybe simply the per death per hour needs to be adjusted too for example in the TOS. For example 3 kills per 2 hour per group, or 2 death per hour per group. It wouldn't stop the hunting though, and I do think its tough to nab someone unless you catch them with their pants down still.

The reason why I do like a damage reduction thing is that I think that it at least calms down players who been killed to many times. I think RUNNING and avoiding PKers is a part of the game, Losing XP is a part of the game. But imagine yourself in their shoes as a new player though, after a certain point it would get annoying. That way also it could be not moderated by staff anymore either.. Aka they die 3 times in an hour, they get immunity for a hour to at least feel safe and gain back the XP they lost and then some UNLESS they go hostile towards someone.

The three times a death thing is surely going to be exploited eventually anyways if its PER PLAYER that can do it. If we got 5 guys, separate clans, but hate one dude, each kills the dude 3 times, that would be rough on them. 15 deaths would be completely annoying. Surely a PKer' would be alright if a message came up saying that 'This person has been killed 3 times in an hour and has a immunity for the hour' or something like that. I think any decent person would say thats probably enough for them for now, yeah?

But again, the degree of how many kills and how long it would be is another. I honestly think 2 deaths per hour is actually enough, but that's just me.

--

Sides that, a level 25'er who dies to a newer player could get a heavier sickness that lasts longer too. Obviously the risk is if someone lower level gets a kill shot, but if thats the case I would assume that they were leveling and got jumped by said people, so fair game too. And I don't mean longer as in hours or anything, maybe a few minutes more per sickness level is all, or it starts at the second sickness level rather then the first level.
daedroth
The bounty system makes a lick of difference to deal with under level 25 pking. I know you might think 'OH BUT IF A LEVEL 25 HAS A HIGH BOUNTY ON THEM THEY WILL BE HUNTED THEMSELVES'. But he newbies aren't going to have tons of cash to bounty them. there is no way the system would give bounties based on kills, that would be insanely abused and it would only work using manual bounty adds by players.

In any case, it doesn't solve anything so it needs to be talked elsewhere.


Not if its a fee taken from the pkers account, as in my idea. You kill people the fine increases, time decreases the fine. If the pker is killed while there is a fine/bounty on their heads, then the pker pays that fine/bounty with his own money and if they have no money then they spend some time in jail; the length of time depending on the existing fine/bounty. All money goes to the pkk'er, some of the fine goes to the killer, some pays the administration fees of the law system.
The fine/bounty is only awarded if the person who does the killing also initiated the combat.
There could also be a criminal flag that can be seen when the person is looked over. This criminal flag could last longer than the fine, except there is no bounty, but they are free to be killed without recrimnation (this will allow pkk'ers to still attack pk'ers even when there is no fine/bounty). The criminal flag needs to be paid of by the pker on their own (but this can only be done after x amount of time)?
NiteHawk
The bounty system makes a lick of difference to deal with under level 25 pking. I know you might think 'OH BUT IF A LEVEL 25 HAS A HIGH BOUNTY ON THEM THEY WILL BE HUNTED THEMSELVES'. But he newbies aren't going to have tons of cash to bounty them. there is no way the system would give bounties based on kills, that would be insanely abused and it would only work using manual bounty adds by players.

In any case, it doesn't solve anything so it needs to be talked elsewhere.


Not if its a fee taken from the pkers account, as in my idea. You kill people the fine increases, time decreases the fine. If the pker is killed while there is a fine/bounty on their heads, then the pker pays that fine/bounty with his own money and if they have no money then they spend some time in jail; the length of time depending on the existing fine/bounty. All money goes to the pkk'er, some of the fine goes to the killer, some pays the administration fees of the law system.
The fine/bounty is only awarded if the person who does the killing also initiated the combat.
There could also be a criminal flag that can be seen when the person is looked over. This criminal flag could last longer than the fine, except there is no bounty, but they are free to be killed without recrimnation (this will allow pkk'ers to still attack pk'ers even when there is no fine/bounty). The criminal flag needs to be paid of by the pker on their own (but this can only be done after x amount of time)?


So then a PKer would store his gold on a separate account and buy stuff with said account. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " /> Jailing sounds abit silly as a punishment for literally pking, even worse then the XP thing <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
daedroth
The bounty system makes a lick of difference to deal with under level 25 pking. I know you might think 'OH BUT IF A LEVEL 25 HAS A HIGH BOUNTY ON THEM THEY WILL BE HUNTED THEMSELVES'. But he newbies aren't going to have tons of cash to bounty them. there is no way the system would give bounties based on kills, that would be insanely abused and it would only work using manual bounty adds by players.

In any case, it doesn't solve anything so it needs to be talked elsewhere.


Not if its a fee taken from the pkers account, as in my idea. You kill people the fine increases, time decreases the fine. If the pker is killed while there is a fine/bounty on their heads, then the pker pays that fine/bounty with his own money and if they have no money then they spend some time in jail; the length of time depending on the existing fine/bounty. All money goes to the pkk'er, some of the fine goes to the killer, some pays the administration fees of the law system.
The fine/bounty is only awarded if the person who does the killing also initiated the combat.
There could also be a criminal flag that can be seen when the person is looked over. This criminal flag could last longer than the fine, except there is no bounty, but they are free to be killed without recrimnation (this will allow pkk'ers to still attack pk'ers even when there is no fine/bounty). The criminal flag needs to be paid of by the pker on their own (but this can only be done after x amount of time)?


So then a PKer would store his gold on a separate account and buy stuff with said account. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " /> Jailing sounds abit silly as a punishment for literally pking, even worse then the XP thing <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />


Then they spend time in jail <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Also allow their account to go to a negative number, their charged anyway (to a max negative), then they cant buy anything. Also no character/item can be transfered while the account is at negative.
Off course that means it will need to be account wide.
So yeh they can still play on another account.
Styx
Regardless. This game is all about epic pk battle. One wins one looses , I was just thinking of a most wanted for pking. Gold not even used. So the pkers can gain fame and glory. And what better way then being the most wanted. Can be easily done just at fiïrst by listing the highest number of pk kill count, update it at reset, and each reset see who can be the most notorious killer.

One again no gold involed, fame, blood, guts and glory.

But on the same topic, everyone should not abuse the system.

Ohhh or even with a marshal standing in town center holding the posters, so all know

Could be a great way of getting people more involved killing each other off.

<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
NiteHawk
The whole paying to PK thing is a very bad idea, sorry. You aren't thinking anything through with it. So they end up with negative balance and then can't get items, or gold to fix it and have to go grind themselves. On top of that they cant buy potions and will have to sit and temple very time the HP is low. I dunno, it's a super wierd idea and at least with the XP loss that people brought up you lost XP which didn't actually break the gameplay for you.

The bounty system however is an OK idea, but thats nothing to do with what I'm talking about. Post it in suggestions and please don't post it here. It's more to do with getting people to actually be bounty hunters, which is fine, but I'm not going to talk about what it needs here. The only people that will use bounty systems are people who have cash.

The kill count per day I mean is okay, but I think you promote people killing newbies way more just to get a higher kill count. I can see X being 2 kills behind of Y, and killing extra to past Y which wouldn't help new players. The posters idea would work fine with the bounty system with gold anyways. Again, different topic. You pretty much just talked about increasing everyones deaths and that confuses me.
daedroth
Last thing im saying on this, since I have nothing against the current system. You are not paying to pk, you are only paying if you get pkk'd before the fine timer runs out. Also the criminal status you only pay for if you actually want it removed. Anyway, I am done commenting on this one, I bid you good day!
anthriel
In terms of level 25'ers losing XP. I don't think it stops the harassment either because a level 25'er killing a newbie or new player in a group even has very little risk. If I were to even do that though, I'd allow EXP to climb up to a certain point. Being killed once and having to relevel even if it involves no gold to relevel is really rough and to me it would actually kill PKing completely. So you'd have to at least have a decent buffer of XP but I still feel like it just adds another layer that doesn't really solve it.


---


The whole damage reduction thing doesn't stop it either, but it at least prevents it after a certain period. But maybe simply the per death per hour needs to be adjusted too for example in the TOS. For example 3 kills per 2 hour per group, or 2 death per hour per group. It wouldn't stop the hunting though, and I do think its tough to nab someone unless you catch them with their pants down still.

The reason why I do like a damage reduction thing is that I think that it at least calms down players who been killed to many times. I think RUNNING and avoiding PKers is a part of the game, Losing XP is a part of the game. But imagine yourself in their shoes as a new player though, after a certain point it would get annoying. That way also it could be not moderated by staff anymore either.. Aka they die 3 times in an hour, they get immunity for a hour to at least feel safe and gain back the XP they lost and then some UNLESS they go hostile towards someone.

The three times a death thing is surely going to be exploited eventually anyways if its PER PLAYER that can do it. If we got 5 guys, separate clans, but hate one dude, each kills the dude 3 times, that would be rough on them. 15 deaths would be completely annoying. Surely a PKer' would be alright if a message came up saying that 'This person has been killed 3 times in an hour and has a immunity for the hour' or something like that. I think any decent person would say thats probably enough for them for now, yeah?

But again, the degree of how many kills and how long it would be is another. I honestly think 2 deaths per hour is actually enough, but that's just me.

--

Sides that, a level 25'er who dies to a newer player could get a heavier sickness that lasts longer too. Obviously the risk is if someone lower level gets a kill shot, but if thats the case I would assume that they were leveling and got jumped by said people, so fair game too. And I don't mean longer as in hours or anything, maybe a few minutes more per sickness level is all, or it starts at the second sickness level rather then the first level.




I may not be seeing it, but i dont think death sickness is a viable risk/deterrent to PKers or an incentive/hope for new playing victims... especially if it is only a few more minutes. Definitely doesn't encourage anyone to stand up to a PKer on either a leveling character or a 25er (via alts or guild help) because there is no lasting gain for your effort.

I keep hearing a few people (including NH above) say that losing EXP to PKers "is a part of the game" ... except that it seems that this statement doesn't universally apply as true to all players of the game - only those who are under 25.... so to me it seems like abit of a double standard for those people who say "exp loss is a natural risk to the game" to then cry out that that the remote potential of losing EXP as a 25er seems really rough for the poor 25ers (esp since its only if you somehow manage to lose a fight you are the heavy favourite for after being added to a wanted list for having already succeeded in such fights several times in the last 24hrs)... i mean the 25ers are already the ones who have the majority of the resources and power in the game... so if the chance of losing EXP is really rough on the most experienced and established players in the community then its doubly or triply hard on the new players that EO is hopefully trying to attract and retrain.

Basically people can be sporting about being killed if there is actually a competition about it. Ie the worst ranked team in the league can congratulate the best ranked team for thrashing them in a game because they played fairly under the same rules and lost. But if 25ers have nothing to lose and sub-25ers do, then the sub-25er doesnt feel like they are in a fair competition, but rather like a hopeless slave condemned to die in gladiatorial amusement.... To summarise, basically fostering the feeling of fair competition promotes better feelings in an underdog than being made a sport of with no meaningful way of competing.

And to address NH's concerns about my suggestion effectively killing off PKing, here are the reasons why i disagree that it would kill off PKing:
1. Players only get put on the "wanted list" (where they risk EXP loss on a 25er) after X number of successful PKs of under-25ers in a 24hr period. Most 25ers would use the X to kill drop stealers or to enjoy PKing as is within this limit... it really only adds a risk people who choose to be excessive in Pking. So there would firstly still be Pking as is up to the current X per day
2. 25ers who exceed X still have the choice to continue Pking more if they like. This actually keeps more people playing the game actively. Because under the current system, after a PK happens usually 1 of the 2 parties ends up playing less... either the victim stops playing until the threat logs offline or the PKer must stop or risk breaking ToS (usually logging off or going idle)... either way you have a result where 50% of the people involved in a PK equation end up actively playing less of a game we want them to be playing/enjoying more of!
3. Players who really want to keep killing more than X with zero risk could just use a different 25er (e.g. not a slayer) to PK with or invest time in leveling a 2nd/3rd/4th slayer if they really must sneak around and do it (and hence rejoin the masses of mere mortals who are leveling)... Or they can just enjoy PKing in 'fair' fights vs other 25ers

Yes as NH pointed out, such a system doesnt 100% solve the issue of Pking harassment (ppl can still form gangs of 25ers to PK people etc) but it does naturally make it harder to do so for prolonged periods and adds an element of 'fairness' in the perception of new players... ie it is a solution that solves at least 80% of the problem naturally.

Now to me, the real question is what is the appropriate X number of PKs before being put on the 'wanted list' where the EXP loss risk applies. I think for a playerbase of our size it should start off small (my suggestion would be 1-3, keeping in mind that its a limit per 25er per day and many people have many 25ers) and be allowed to increase as the playerbase grows. Therefore everyone has the incentive to see the playerbase grow. Ppl who enjoy cultivating new players 'Defenders of Justice' style can do so more meaningfully knowing there is at least 1 way to scare a Pking 25er off (and inspire hope in those who are downtrodden that they might be able to defend themselves, "so keep playing and dont quit!")... and people who's main enjoyment of the game is in PKing can continue to Pk at their will (if thats what they choose to do, bearing the slight risk).

I guess like Daedroth, I too feel like ive reached the point that i've said all i have to say with my suggestion at this point (bar clarifications). I think i've logically laid out a viable solution as best that i can (not a 100% solve, but a natural deterrent for excessive Pking and a point of hope for newbie underdogs which is a big move in the right direction). Hopefully NH will give it more consideration in light of not many other viable ideas seeming to have arisen yet... but if not then all I can say is "best of luck to EO" and choose to play (or not play) as much as suits me under the current system.
Ardrahz
i still say a criminal system would help this alot <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_ugeek.gif" alt=":ugeek:" title="Uber Geek" />
Folder
I think the entire point of killing under 25s is that it's not a fair fight. This is in fact the basis for the power structure in this game (and basically every other leveling based game). You start out weaker, you work your way up. It's SUPPOSED to be unfair until you reach the top. That's why you level, and that's why leveling is rewarding.
Ardrahz
Yes but there is also risk/reward in almost all other games.. Crim status barring you from towns for X amount of time. Givees people reasons to pk/pkk. As Lat says, I hate to reference games like wow/uo allll the time, but there is a reason people so it. They set the standard to handle pvp based games by.
NiteHawk
Yes but there is also risk/reward in almost all other games.. Crim status barring you from towns for X amount of time. Givees people reasons to pk/pkk.


Crim status could be a thing but how long would that occur for, and it makes it super easy for someone who can hide to literally just hide until its over.
Ardrahz
The way this game is set up though, at least it gives a perimeter to get revenge. At least 2-3 mins. i.e. - "He got me between bit and turen!"
Ardrahz
Could even go as far as after a certain number of kills, they become a murderer and can not reenter town until they die? Just an idea to both let PKing continue, but gives people a chance to get their revenge. As it stands now, pking is all reward(loot/gold/fun) with very low risk of death. /i gemini and tyrargo if you dont believe me <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />