← Forum archive

Promoting guild diversity (to increase player activity/competition)

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Roc
I disagree with most (all?) of you.

One of the big aspects of this game is the social component - getting to talk with other people, and do stuff with them.
That is hard because there are so few of us, even in Silo at times.
It would be extra harder if people where spread out in more clans. This means in my opinion that we should be clustered together in one or two clans, not have our player base spread out like little butter on too much bread.


PS: Jake, ginvite the people i want damnit!


Clustered into one clan? You might as well as not have clans. The reasons for having guilds are to group together as individuals to achieve a common goal, yet remain separate as a player base to generate long-term competition. Agreed that guilds being too numerous and small presents its own challenges - mainly the inability to coordinate successful runs, and an over-abundance of PvP. With that however, I think we are far from having the player base for that being a probable issue.

As far as the inability to communicate and interact with others, I definitely think that the culture in this game over-emphasizes the need to do everything with a guild-mate. The current guild/PvP system definitely promotes that to a point. Regardless, there should be a means to talk to everyone in-game beyond simply paging. I agree with Eld - shit-talk would occur; some might see that as toxic. But given the number of active players, I think that it's almost needed. An easy means of combating overbearing negativity from being repeatedly broadcast is giving staff the ability to temporarily mute people after an infraction.
anthriel
I disagree with most (all?) of you.

One of the big aspects of this game is the social component - getting to talk with other people, and do stuff with them.
That is hard because there are so few of us, even in Silo at times.
It would be extra harder if people where spread out in more clans. This means in my opinion that we should be clustered together in one or two clans, not have our player base spread out like little butter on too much bread.


PS: Jake, ginvite the people i want damnit!


Clustered into one clan? You might as well as not have clans. The reasons for having guilds are to group together as individuals to achieve a common goal, yet remain separate as a player base to generate long-term competition. Agreed that guilds being too numerous and small presents its own challenges - mainly the inability to coordinate successful runs, and an over-abundance of PvP. With that however, I think we are far from having the player base for that being a probable issue.

As far as the inability to communicate and interact with others, I definitely think that the culture in this game over-emphasizes the need to do everything with a guild-mate. The current guild/PvP system definitely promotes that to a point. Regardless, there should be a means to talk to everyone in-game beyond simply paging. I agree with Eld - shit-talk would occur; some might see that as toxic. But given the number of active players, I think that it's almost needed. An easy means of combating overbearing negativity from being repeatedly broadcast is giving staff the ability to temporarily mute people after an infraction.


I agree with JF that the social aspect is a big part of the game. But what I think new players will find difficult is the inactivity of players... They may be able to join a big guild (numerically) but the members in that guild may already have enough 25ers and no longer levelling new ones... They may be idling 85% of the time and only chatting but not playing... Or showing up only when events are run... For whatever reason they may lack motivation to be active... And this will leave a bad taste in the mouth of the new player who we want to interact with a motivated community and keep playing (cos who wants to invest lots of time in progressing in a game where the end game players look demotivated?)

An incentive system like the one I proposed is to stimulate guild activity cos u only get points for doing active stuff (not idling)... My assumption is that it's much more enjoyable and better motivation to continue as a new player if you are in a smaller guild with 5 motivated/active players who are online doing stuff than in a bigger guild with most idling. I believe spreading out the active players could help foster that more active type environment across the whole game, which acts as a platform to promote this active/motivated culture (rather than idle/dead culture) to new players when they join.

And like Roc/Eld I do be live some way of worldchatting would be good for achieving that too ... But I also don't have any ideas as to how to prevent abuse of that (without adding to staff workload) at this stage.



Edit - btw I'm not really talking about adding new endgame stuff to keep existing players more active cos that usually is something the new players can't really participate in anyway... Getting ppl to keep motivated levelling new characters, farming keys and minor OADs that new players can participate with older players in is the crucial point of activity imho
Eld
In clash of clans they have global chat with a percentage of the online players, when i played a few years back it was a cluster fuck, and reporting people did nothing.
The only counter to this was /ignore or reconnect and hope you were connected to a different set of players.

In TagPro they have a reporting system for both chat (and gameplay)
The idea is players anonymously report people and if they have a certain amount of reports they're automatically muted for a period of time.
If they keep getting muted they might get a ban.
Staff can still interject and ban people outside of this system


Has anyone else got any ideas for how global chat might be feasible or any experiences of how other games have solved/not solved the problem?
daedroth
... Has anyone else got any ideas for how global chat might be feasible or any experiences of how other games have solved/not solved the problem?

Well... to be blunt, EO has a small player base. In the games I have saw public chat being used the player bases were HUGE, so it was harder to keep things under control. It would be far easier to monitor on EO because of the small player base. There is no need to come up with anything that remarkable.
Eld
... Has anyone else got any ideas for how global chat might be feasible or any experiences of how other games have solved/not solved the problem?

Well... to be blunt, EO has a small player base. In the games I have saw public chat being used the player bases were HUGE, so it was harder to keep things under control. It would be far easier to monitor on EO because of the small player base. There is no need to come up with anything that remarkable.


I'd argue it could be harder because a lot of people know each other and certain people dislike each other a lot.
In a big game it's anonymous and you can move on and not have to encounter the same people again.

If we did introduce some form of global chat i think we'd need to be careful it isn't a drain on staff to moderate it, and that it betters the overall player experience, not worsens it
daedroth
I'd argue it could be harder because a lot of people know each other and certain people dislike each other a lot.
In a big game it's anonymous and you can move on and not have to encounter the same people again.

I would counter argue that; that is kind of why it would be easier. It would be hard to hide behind anonymity, and easy to find the person being a muppet, and therefore easier to police.
As you mentioned a /ignore would be handy though.
Adramelk
Revelation: Lands of Kaldana had a global chat system. Every player online could see it and respond to it. And staff would just "squelch" people if they crossed the line in chat. i.e. political/religious chats that got out of hand and the randomly "OMG YOU FUKKR YOU PKD MEH" sort of thing. Here we could charge non-newbie flagged accounts a fee to chat in it. Something small, but significant enough to where people are just going to babble all damn day 25g or something. Then just have Staff monitor it and take said rights away for an hour or 24 hours depending on what line was crossed.

We could even introduce a /auction system to global chat to sell items live.
daedroth
... Here we could charge non-newbie flagged accounts a fee to chat in it. Something small, but significant enough to where people are just going to babble all damn day 25g or something ...

WTF!?! EXTORTIONATE! I WILL NEVER USE GLOBAL CHAT!
Styx
I agree about global chat however there was problems with it in the past and was removed so I heard. And i didnt think it would be done agaun. Chat filters can be a big part in dealing with issues of abuse, flag account and remove ability, however

If the global chat was allowed it could help with /lfg as an option, ie /ghat /lfg I'm looking to level at level 15, anyone interested?
/gchat /sell I got a big one club, it's made of wood, any takers
/gchat if it was set up it could do multiple functions. And have alias set up for options

But many filters would be needed with option to turn iff, alter tos so it includes this information along with a click box they understand etc if no filter etc
anthriel
I theoretically support most of the worldchat/friendchat suggestions here as a good support to being able to maintain friendships despite having guild diversity.

However the main topic of this thread is still about promoting guild diversity because it i think it is ultimately essential to giving new players a better gaming experience and therefore more likely to stay and keep playing.

Lets have a look at a case study:
When I first started EO it was a 2 guild scene. One dominant guild and one opposition guild... the competitive drama/history between the guilds had made it so that basically half the playerbase didnt like the other half of the playerbase (an all the worldchat/friendchat functionality in the world probably wouldnt help heal that kind of community division). As someone new joining the game, that meant i could really only meet and interact with half the community. This means out of an already small active playerbase, a new player is generally only going to befriend half the community and probably be mercilessly persecuted by the other half (who they will probably grow to resent)... then lets say the half that they have befriended grow embittered/discontented/discouraged etc and end up quitting/idling/going inactive etc... the new player is likely to lose the motivation to play also... and there lies the end of another new person trying EO or another old-time Rok player deciding that 'this isnt worth it'

But if the active/motivated players were spread out into different guilds (which i believe an incentive system like the one i suggested would help promote), then a new player could interact better with the whole community via such worldchat/friendchat functionality and not be forced into a dichotomy of "taking Side A vs Side B" and thus be effectively blocked from befriending half the EO community from day 1.

It's kinda like Basketball. If all we had were international competitions where its the USA vs other countries, it would probably be a very boring competition to watch and/or participate in. Sure you could argue that Team USA does occasionally get challenged and lose... but ultimately they have the most motivated/talented players etc and should win most games without even pulling out their full depth of talent. That's why the NBA competition is far more polarising/exciting than the international competition --> The best and most motivated players compete against each other! The players can still be friends and support different teams etc, but at the end of the day they compete well against each other in a friendly atmosphere and that kind of generated excitement draws people in.

Probably my last 2 cents on this if NH or other players don't really see things in similar light. If not then I suppose we will just have to see whether keeping a RoK guild system under these lower playerbase conditions can be sustained in the long run or not....

peace friends


Edit - one other thought... even if you don't implement guild activity points as an incentive for guild diversity, please at least do it for measuring the top 3 active guilds on /gtop ... otherwise all you get is newbies joining guilds with large populations of idling inactives who want to boost the appearance of guild activity (which is bad for expectations management, really)
Mujahideen
The first step to promoting guild diversity is to get a larger player base.

Many gangs split apart because well, who wants to divide X amount of booty amongst a bunch of people when you could do it solo or with a small group? In ROK you could solo a few top level OaDs, but that was scalable because alts were allowed, you can't really scale OaDs for solo without them being ridiculously easy for a group with no alts, but I digress.

So I would suggest a look at how OaDs are incorporated into the game. Put some good OaDs out there that don't require a bunch of players and allow alts. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mrgreen.gif" alt=":mrgreen:" title="Mr. Green" /> And people's greed will bring the big clans down to size.
anthriel
The first step to promoting guild diversity is to get a larger player base.

Many gangs split apart because well, who wants to divide X amount of booty amongst a bunch of people when you could do it solo or with a small group? In ROK you could solo a few top level OaDs, but that was scalable because alts were allowed, you can't really scale OaDs for solo without them being ridiculously easy for a group with no alts, but I digress.

So I would suggest a look at how OaDs are incorporated into the game. Put some good OaDs out there that don't require a bunch of players and allow alts. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mrgreen.gif" alt=":mrgreen:" title="Mr. Green" /> And people's greed will bring the big clans down to size.


Agree! (Except with the allowing of alts part)

But I feel like increasing player base and promoting guild diversity are abit like chicken and the egg... which comes first? .... By all means if we can increase and retain playerbase first that would be ideal... But if we are finding that we can't because the new influx of players have a less-than-encouraging initial experience then perhaps we have to start with guild diversity first....

Shrug I guess I'll leave it those who have been around longer than me and who know the history/trends and have more oversight on balance ebbs and flows etc to decide that....

And yes I know large game-dynamics changes are not easy or something to be rushed into either... It does require careful thought and consideration from the community etc so I do thank all who have participated in that process within this thread
NiteHawk
Friend system, yeah could see that.

Global chat, will never happen. At least not with the current player base. We had it for a short period and it was abused very fast. It was a joke.

If anything there can be something similar to IRC channels where you join channels as groups, but that's not really on my todo list right now.
daedroth
Friend system, yeah could see that.

Global chat, will never happen. At least not with the current player base. We had it for a short period and it was abused very fast. It was a joke.

If anything there can be something similar to IRC channels where you join channels as groups, but that's not really on my todo list right now.

I am sad, I never got the opportunity to abuse it <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cry.gif" alt=":cry:" title="Crying or Very Sad" />
I am still not sure whether to be amused or bemoan the state of (our mini) society with regards to the abuse of global chat (I still think it could be policed but meh).
daedroth
Babysitting is my life in EO now.. It's not a lot of fun, but someone has to keep y'all in line!

Uncle Adra!
TEACH ME HOW TO PK!