← Forum archive

Improving Zerkers

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
Barbarians are a high risk high damage class. They take in more damage, but they should deal more damage too. The claim is right now that even though they deal high damage, it isn't enough to use them vs lets say, ninjas which have similar damage with roundhouse BUT have MR and more dodge. I don't want to nyx the negative effects because I WANT them to be different. Otherwise they are just another ninja with face paint which is pointless, you might as well remove the whole class completely if that was the case.

We talked about this but I want to poll it now. Here are some options.

1. Leave it the same as it is.
2. As they lose health, they deal a little more damage. up to 6%. This means at 50% health they would have a 3% damage bonus. Not alot, but is would more be a 'small perk' in duels and other areas (Guardian protected low health zerkers for example dealing an extra 10-16 more damage)
3. Adjust rage scaling per successful rage attack. At the moment it is a set 40% 3 times. Instead, it could be 40% first time, 45% second time, and 50% third time. Or 40%, 50%, 60%. Obviously this isn't so common in PVP but if it happens it would help. (Ignoring option 4.)
4. Adjust rage scaling to a flat 50% rather then 40% (Ignoring option 3.)
5. Flurrying could break armor, removing a percentage for X seconds. Maybe stackable with each flurry.
6. Invalid with the other options, but a active system instead and add the ability to flurry when you want, and you can build up/save flurries (Though they would go down over time or when you move). For example check this:
[youtube]https://youtu.be/MDgDHmkQ7tM[/youtube].
If this is the way we go, we need to talk about what skillsets they would have, obviously Flurry, but they could have something else that maybe breaks a targets armor, the higher armor the more 'break' or a rage attack that lowers maybe AGI or AC for a little more damage. (Do not pick with any other option, this is a complete change.)



I'm interested in your votes and what you pick
Cyrus
I voted 3 and 6.
I wanted to go for 3 because right now flurries dont add much damage and it'll feel nice the 1 time out of 100 when that 3rd flurry connects.
Regarding 6, I purely chose it because right now zerkers are a F1 pushing class. No skill no nothing needed to play 1. So I chose it only because it adds a tiny bit of individual skill to an otherwise braindead class. But I don't think that option is the problem solver.
Folder
Chose #6 because I am a fan of more active systems in the longterm. I feel like numbers wise zerkers already hit pretty hard and they don't really need to have a flat dmg boost. If we did that you'd want /flurry or /rage (as examples) to be toggles - if you always had to type /flurry to flurry it would make macros a nightmare. Toggle on/off is fine though.
NiteHawk
By the way, by 'break armor' I mean reduced armor. Similar to FF, but based on total AC, higher AC, more AC reduced in a sense. So someone with cloth armor if they get flurried on, they might lose only 5 ac for 30 seconds while a knight might lose 20 ac for 30 seconds.
Styx
Breaking armor is a more interesting concept cause it will give a Barbarian a unique ability for their class.

Edit, could this percent be based on int or chr, one of the unused stats to give more choices of which stats to choose, ie do I need more int so it lowers ac longer, or should I go with more wis for magic resis. It will make lings and the balanced races more viable as an option.
Tucker
I like all of the options tbh haha

Option 2 and 3 together might be really good and get the class in good shape since theyre both small buffs alone but together would be enough to make the class scary again <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />

I love the idea of the rage cooldown and AC reduction as well as well as what Rodeo said that they could even proc a small duration stun on rage hits, however it might be wiser to balance the class first and then break out brand new innovative mechanics. Also I'm thinking that the Rage cooldown thing could be even potentially better suited on another class or a new one. Same with some of the on proc ideas like bashes, roots, DoT stuff, status effecting shit and unique attack modifiers like rage or roundhouse could all be worked on once the buff/debuff UI is implemented. There's a shitload of cool mechanics you can add but we definitely wanna see them spread out so that Zerkers aren't top DPS in game (as they should be - up there with Slayers) and have the only armor reduction feature or the only bash as well. The more spread out those unique features are the more class diversity we'll see and the more interesting the game'll be.
Lateralus
I think options 2 3 and 4 work best and would be easiest to implement. I think 2 sounds the most interesting and unique that also fits the class. It might not give them as much of an edge as 3 and 4. I wouldn't mind seeing it scale a bit more crazy like 2-10%. 2% at 50% health and say 10% at 10% health.
Cyrus
I think options 2 3 and 4 work best and would be easiest to implement. I think 2 sounds the most interesting and unique that also fits the class. It might not give them as much of an edge as 3 and 4. I wouldn't mind seeing it scale a bit more crazy like 2-10%. 2% at 50% health and say 10% at 10% health.


I just don't see the benefit in this. Based on personal experience, guardians are rarely used in fights nowadays.

Especially with the way pot timers work, keeping yourself at 50% hp to do 5% extra damage is just completely illogical. Sure it may be better for EXPing where you know how much damage the mobs do on average and when to drink a pot to stay at 50%, but PVP wise, guardians would need to become better for PVP. And then, why would you use the guard to protect Zerker when you have a priest or chanter to protect whose presence aids far more than an extra 5% damage?

And if you say, ok, make it 20% extra damage, then you have the problem that they would become absolute beasts at PVE. And zerkers already do very well at PVE...
Tucker
I think options 2 3 and 4 work best and would be easiest to implement. I think 2 sounds the most interesting and unique that also fits the class. It might not give them as much of an edge as 3 and 4. I wouldn't mind seeing it scale a bit more crazy like 2-10%. 2% at 50% health and say 10% at 10% health.


I just don't see the benefit in this. Based on personal experience, guardians are rarely used in fights nowadays. The only time I ever see 1 is when 2 OAD teams fight at flaming salamander where a guardian has to protect the priest to prevent stun.

Especially with the way pot timers work, keeping yourself at 50% hp to do 5% extra damage is just completely illogical. Sure it may be better for EXPing where you know how much damage the mobs do on average and when to drink a pot to stay at 50%, but PVP wise, guardians would need to become better for PVP. And then, why would you use the guard to protect Zerker when you have a priest or chanter to protect whose presence aids far more than an extra 5% damage?

And if you say, ok, make it 20% extra damage, then you have the problem that they would become absolute beasts at PVE. And zerkers already do very well at PVE...


That would give another purpose to Guardians and maybe see them used more which is cool. Also I don't think you have to leave yourself at low hp all the time, you can, but it's a high risk high reward play. I think that this is such a minor buff at proposed levels (0-6%) that you could safely pair it with another buff and still not be too strong.

I agree with your sentiment that 20% would be waaaay too much, but 8-10% might be still not too overpowered. I like the idea of two minor buffs like the lowered hp at 6% max or so and then adding option 3. Both are minor buffs that together make for a pretty strong change to the class.
NiteHawk
At the moment they do well in PVE but still have trouble in PVP. I was mucking around with them and also was testing a saurian one and the problem wasn't that he couldn't hit. The problem was that he couldn't flurry. He is literally a Knight without the AC or Shield Bash in PVP.

I really am for the active system, as I said again, being able to flurry at will would be helpful. There are other things we can do that would help. Let's state them all again though:

1. Active system. Only one additional attack, which would be /flurry. This would allow you to attempt a flurry if you had the rage points. Rage points can be build either by attacking, could be in a row (like it currently is) but allowing you to save the flurries instead. For example, I successfully attack twice in a row and gain one flurry point. I can use it as my next attack or save it. You could make it build up flurries up to maybe 3 (either it's a static value or can be based on something to gain more than 3 flurry saves). So for example. So any attack after two successful hits gains you a flurry point. You could even make a toggle between active and having the points being spent automatically so that it acts like the CURRENT system.


2. Not my favorite choice as it doesn't really show the flaunting of their flurry system, but increasing their base damage, and decreasing their flurry damage to be on pair. For example right now with 5 attacks.:
I hit for 170 damage.
I hit for 170 damage.
I flurry for 230 damage.
I flurry for 238 damage.
I flurry for 246 damage.
Totalling 1054 damage.

Instead it could be:

I hit for 190 damage.
I hit for 190 damage.
I flurry for 230 damage.
I flurry for 230 damage.
I flurry for 230 damage.
Totalling 1070 damage.


So the idea is that PVE would be the same but in PVP they'd do a little more damage. which will probably be the thing I would do if no other options are good.


3. The final idea is that your flurries buildup (aka to get to the point of flurry mode) does not get reset unless you move rooms. So misses won't remove flurries. I.E.
You hit for 170 damage!
You miss.
You hit for 170 damage!
You flurry for 230 damage!

or

You hit for 170 damage!
You miss!
You miss!
You hit for 170 damage!
You flurry and miss!

The idea is that after two successful hits, after the second one, you would attempt a flurry regardless of the miss count. I don't know how well this benefits in PVE, but in PVE most of the time they aren't missing so much anyways, and it would be the movement that resets them. This would at least allow them to flurry every now and than.


...

I was thinking that flurry could maybe have a higher hit chance, which IS possible, but getting flurries in PVP are pretty hard and I am not sure that even makes sense as a option 4.

What do people think? Where should we go. I am not exactly happy yet anyways and I'm sure they can be tweaked to be decent in PVP/PVE too.
anthriel
At the moment they do well in PVE but still have trouble in PVP. I was mucking around with them and also was testing a saurian one and the problem wasn't that he couldn't hit. The problem was that he couldn't flurry. He is literally a Knight without the AC or Shield Bash in PVP.
...

...

I was thinking that flurry could maybe have a higher hit chance, which IS possible, but getting flurries in PVP are pretty hard and I am not sure that even makes sense as a option 4.

What do people think? Where should we go. I am not exactly happy yet anyways and I'm sure they can be tweaked to be decent in PVP/PVE too.



Just a quick thought... why restrict yourself to tying flurries to a barb's hitrate at all? Sounds too much like copying the Monk model to me.

For example, you could easily tie the Barb ability to flurry to say the amount of times the Barb GETS hit instead (ie rage building up as he takes damage).... which im guessing would happen alot in both PVP and PVE ... such a thing might lead to new interesting builds (eg suddenly a low AGI barb may be a an OK idea as you could theoretically flurry more but still have lower hitrate than a high AGI one that flurries less cos of higher dodge but still hits more) and new strategies/possibilities ("dont group-attack the enemy party's barb first" or "hit and then heal our own party's barb so he builds up rage" etc)...

Shrugs will let the others pick it up from here... i dont really care too much for this issue anyways - there's prolly deeper things needing fixing imho
Inverno


For example, you could easily tie the Barb ability to flurry to say the amount of times the Barb GETS hit instead (ie rage building up as he takes damage).... which im guessing would happen alot in both PVP and PVE ... such a thing might lead to new interesting builds (eg suddenly a low AGI barb may be a an OK idea as you could theoretically flurry more but still have lower hitrate than a high AGI one that flurries less cos of higher dodge but still hits more) and new strategies/possibilities ("dont group-attack the enemy party's barb first" or "hit and then heal our own party's barb so he builds up rage" etc)...



Sounds good!
Lavelia
I like the idea of an active system. I wasn't around back then, so I didn't get a chance to vote. So. With that in mind. I'm voting for active system lol.
Cyrus
I like them now, the extra flurry damage is great in PVP for when you do finally land 1 of em, you can break priest-related deadlocks with high burst damage. I miss often, but when I do land the flurries it's 800+ damage in a round. Almost slayer like.

The idea of getting rid of misses cancelling flurry would help further improve this.

I do like the combination of 2 ideas: Getting hit builds up rage, and then using that in the active rage system. Makes sense from lore standpoint, the more you hit a zerker the more pissed off he gets.
NiteHawk
I like them now, the extra flurry damage is great in PVP for when you do finally land 1 of em, you can break priest-related deadlocks with high burst damage. I miss often, but when I do land the flurries it's 800+ damage in a round. Almost slayer like.

The idea of getting rid of misses canceling flurry would help further improve this.

I do like the combination of 2 ideas: Getting hit builds up rage, and then using that in the active rage system. Makes sense from lore standpoint, the more you hit a zerker the more pissed off he gets.


Well we talked about that too. It would shift them heavily out of PVE and into move PVP which also doesn't make much sense. I get that all classes get hit but its honestly pretty damn easy to rage on monsters right now due to the AGI difference of monsters vs players. While it would work from PVP standpoint, from a PVE one you would nerf their overall damage a good deal. From a PVP standpoint its nicer since you'll be hit rather. I don\t think I want to shift them completely out of PVE like that though.

Getting rid of misses is something that might work but its tough to say if that would be okay or if we'd have to go at least to 3 attacks to start flurries again. Maybe not though, might be okay as it is.

Can leave it for now, some people stay its fine too, need to test it more. I just don't feel like they do enough though. But eh.
Cyrus
I highly support any initiative to give them a hit rate bonus to flurries, which would impact PVP more without making them too powerful at pve.
Rael
Zerkers are good pve because they do alot of damage so they work well for farming but you do not see many go on main oads because they also take major damage aka priests nightmare lol.
Same goes for PvP it's possible to do big damage but way more likely to see a successful slayer then zerker atm. The down sides still out way positives atm.
I do like the idea of missing not resetting furry. I also like the idea of normal damage being upped because honestly a zerker should out hit a cav by a decent bit on a normal attack.
I have high hopes for zerkers it's a fun class but till then I'll stick with my high ac cav lol
Folder
i dislike this new change. zerker staying shelved till this changes.


This is probably a minor buff if anything though?