← Forum archive

Race Stat Changes

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
Interesting idea of rodeo's re out Agi affecting stam refresh - I like out of box thinking - tho I do agree it could make saurians abit scary

Alternatively why not put in a racial "little people" dodge bonus (similar to the monk class bonus) for Lings and gnomes. Biggest complaint re Lings I hear is ppl don't feel they dodge enough (which they attribute then to Agi not being worth it)... Biggest complain re gnomes is they die too easy... So it would help gnomes survive abit more too.... Shrug

Ps - I do like NH's ideas re making poison DoT better to make things more interesting with priests etc and I look forward to next topic regarding how magic works


Yeah that's the concern, the issue is saurians have those damn stats that are OK as it stands but the more you tweak it the better they become.

The little people bonus might be a thing but I would rather give them a agi point more instead of hidden stats, same with gnomes.

I.E.

16 22 17 23 22 20 and 18 24 17 20 20 22 .. Though obviously the concern is shadowing. Not sure it occurs here though. Looking at elves its 18 22 18 21 21 22 so for 1 end/2 str/2 chr you get 2 int/1 wis. Though the only real thing here for magic users is 50 HP for 2 int and 1 wis which might make gnomes far better for magic. Lings to me ain't a big deal if they get 1 AGI but it's the idear.

I am going to make proposal #15 and going to change the stats here and also some racial changes. If possible see how it shadows and if it makes races useless. We aren't throwing out #14 just throwing another idea in.
NiteHawk
Actually maybe something similar to classes dodge might work here.

I.E. gnomes and lings still have max of 21 agi and 23 agi, BUT when dodging they have +1 agi, similar to monks dodge bonus but for races. So similar to the small stat but kinda in formula I guess.

I.e. gnomes would have 21 agi when attacking but have the boost of 22 agi when dodging. A middle ground might be good cause 25 agi lings to me 'worries' me but a halver of what I talked about might be OK.
-Z-
Actually maybe something similar to classes dodge might work here.

I.E. gnomes and lings still have max of 21 agi and 23 agi, BUT when dodging they have +1 agi, similar to monks dodge bonus but for races. So similar to the small stat but kinda in formula I guess.

I.e. gnomes would have 21 agi when attacking but have the boost of 22 agi when dodging. A middle ground might be good cause 25 agi lings to me 'worries' me but a halver of what I talked about might be OK.



I like this NH
Lateralus
Yea I like that too tbh. I had avoided suggesting it just because I know you don't like giving racials that could be stats however this kind of seems like .5 agi and makes sense rp wise.

I think it's a lot more simple than giving them a faster stam refresh as well or having to write new agi systems etc.
daedroth
Actually I had half an idea a while ago about races having an "attack" and "defence" based on agility. Aggressive races +1attack, -1 defence etc. But eh... nm.
Terron
i posted about size modifiers before a page or two back under core i posted it with a dodge and damage which the damage can be ignored str is already an OP stat imo and blown out of proportion(level should grant more damage and str less, offsets half orcs/23 str saurians to stay the same and raises weak races by a little bit).

the small races need something, im not sure 50 hps is going to help. its an attempt atleast. think of the future, more oads pop out, more weapons, higher damage, more armor, higher mitigation. (future oad spellscrolls to raise caster damage after new higher damage melee weapons make it 1 sided all over again) . when you get to that point are you just going to keep raising 17 end by 50 hps at a time.

i think hps just need to be higher in general(because damage is so relatively high for horc/saurian and not so much for 20 str and under)
17 end should sit where 19 end does currently and each go up from there.

-just think of armor. armor lowers damage yay. then factor it at say 40 damage per stam it absorbs. ok. factor in half orc losing 40 damage vs a ling losing 40 damage. ling loses 25-30% of its damage half orc loses 15-20.(not saying this is bad, just currently everything favors strength and how OP it is)

-weapon damage is the same thing 25 str is getting more damage out of a weapon than a ling/gnome etc

i think the culprit for everything is STR being too effective on top of alot of oad additions, pp weapons etc. its a double edged sword. the hps and agi bonuses are needed to balance this because i wouldnt expect a str nerf.
-on paper nitehawk can see hp vs hp attack vs attack etc, but the fact is no-one has equipped a ling warrior to fight a horc etc its just mass str characters getting decked out making it even worse. i dont blame them, it isnt as effective. you are hoping player preference will outweigh results and it wont.
Dan
I dont like proposal #14 at all.

Saurian, drakes, hos already have limited max natural wis so they have a weakness to magic.

Why reduce it even more? It signs that MR formula should change then.

Are we back to rock , paper and scissor ?

Again, we have a 5 div system, rock , paper scissor its too simplistic to this game.

I agree that 25 str is too high, its op. I have hos, and i dont mind of saying it.

First thing to balance this game is -1 str hos.
Terron
paper, rock, scissors, lizard, Spock


its the exponential gain that has MR screwed. 20% bonus to goblins so they can fit in? elves with 0? clerics with mr penalties...? it looks awful. the problem lies spells should just be wisdom vs int. straight up more wis makes you get hit less, higher int makes you hit more often. identical to the agility theory. spell mitigation shouldnt be tied to wisdom at all(unless its a bonus for having over 20 wis). it should be added as racial bonuses (if your race has 5% mr it just receives 5% less damage from magic) and bonuses from armor . make armor have 2 stats AC and SR (i.e cloth adds 9 armor and 25 SR(spell resistance which offers mitigation identical to the way armor affects melee.)) melee characters can choose heavy armor which offers less SR or choose a lighter armor version which increases SR. im pretty sure ive posted this before..

agility has to be more powerful because it has to compete with 2 different statistics strength and endurance. people cant possibly believe a ling will be good with saurians and drakes running around. -1 agi +4 str+2 end...same reason humans dont beat horcs(-1 agi +4 str +2 end) or horc vs ling where you drop 5 agi and gain 7 str 4 end where the lings agi has to overcome 11 stats for the price of 5.

so until the game is heavily magic(magic/melee classes equally numerous), 20 wis warriors and anything similar will suck. 50 hps here -50 there and increasing gnome chanter damage isnt changing the problem.
Dan
Actually maybe something similar to classes dodge might work here.

I.E. gnomes and lings still have max of 21 agi and 23 agi, BUT when dodging they have +1 agi, similar to monks dodge bonus but for races. So similar to the small stat but kinda in formula I guess.

I.e. gnomes would have 21 agi when attacking but have the boost of 22 agi when dodging. A middle ground might be good cause 25 agi lings to me 'worries' me but a halver of what I talked about might be OK.


I like it.

That is what some of us suggested to make lings and gnomes get to the game.

Maybe +2 dodge agi pve and +1 dodge agi pvp?
NiteHawk
its the exponential gain that has MR screwed. 20% bonus to goblins so they can fit in? elves with 0? clerics with mr penalties...?

Literally goblins are really the only ones that really see a heavier effect of about +3 wisdom with 17 wisdom. Most other races have 0% to 5% is like adding a 2-3% overall percent resistance to wisdom. Doesn't change much IMO and it's mostly based on wisdom.

Goblins are meant to be a resistance type fighter race, and they will continue to be anyways. It does need lowering as I talked about though. Yeah there will be class MR, classes like druids for example are simply too OP as they obviously focus Wisdom to maximum, making them really good at physical but then also magical. Granted, there could be some changes, but they'll continue to exist.

it should be added as racial bonuses (if your race has 5% mr it just receives 5% less damage from magic) and bonuses from armor . make armor have 2 stats AC and SR (i.e cloth adds 9 armor and 25 SR(spell resistance which offers mitigation identical to the way armor affects melee.)) melee characters can choose heavy armor which offers less SR or choose a lighter armor version which increases SR. im pretty sure ive posted this before..


Having racial actually add 5% Mr for example is probably a good idea rather then a multiplier which might help balance reasons (So as you say it would add a static value instead of a multiplier which could help.) However, with SR on armor I think you add a huge balance issue and you'd have to completely revise the way characters work. You actually grant medium class users like slayers or barbarians SR just because they use medium armor. Paladins should have the choice of being good with both using higher wisdom (at least thats what i believe) but I think this would make it worse as obviously heavy armor would make them weaker to spells.
NiteHawk
Actually maybe something similar to classes dodge might work here.

I.E. gnomes and lings still have max of 21 agi and 23 agi, BUT when dodging they have +1 agi, similar to monks dodge bonus but for races. So similar to the small stat but kinda in formula I guess.

I.e. gnomes would have 21 agi when attacking but have the boost of 22 agi when dodging. A middle ground might be good cause 25 agi lings to me 'worries' me but a halver of what I talked about might be OK.


I like it.

That is what some of us suggested to make lings and gnomes get to the game.

Maybe +2 dodge agi pve and +1 dodge agi pvp?


That's a possibility but I'm not sure it is needed as they already start with higher AGI in PVE anyways. Might be more confusing if all the hidden values are random too and if we do use hidden stats it is good to try to reduce the confusion.
Terron
changing armor to reflect magic mitigation would cause more problems temporarily. it should. but in the end its easier to balance. and better for future oad gear because the next piece of armor can gain 1 or the other not just 1 ac. the reason i even suggested it is because the game sits relatively magicless at the moment. it isnt magic heavy at all. leaves plenty of float room for testing behind the scenes or for players to help you. the system of int vs wis, sr and ac , worked very well on my pen and paper rpg. the agility system inplace is similar to my paper rpg i just gave bonuses/penalties for size. i think the only factor thats different from my paper rpg and this game is rolled stats vs p p p x x x, and exponential damage multipliers.

currently noone would pick cloth wearing warriors because there is no reason to. same reason they run around with 10 wis freely.

ill pull up some of the classes my friends and i created, outfit some of the spells for ember and post them a bit later. because i feel the outlying problem is the scarcity of magic. i really feel sitting ingame with 10 melee classes and 10 magic classes would help the game far more than anything else.
Dan
Actually maybe something similar to classes dodge might work here.

I.E. gnomes and lings still have max of 21 agi and 23 agi, BUT when dodging they have +1 agi, similar to monks dodge bonus but for races. So similar to the small stat but kinda in formula I guess.

I.e. gnomes would have 21 agi when attacking but have the boost of 22 agi when dodging. A middle ground might be good cause 25 agi lings to me 'worries' me but a halver of what I talked about might be OK.


I like it.

That is what some of us suggested to make lings and gnomes get to the game.

Maybe +2 dodge agi pve and +1 dodge agi pvp?


That's a possibility but I'm not sure it is needed as they already start with higher AGI in PVE anyways. Might be more confusing if all the hidden values are random too and if we do use hidden stats it is good to try to reduce the confusion.


What about a text command that shows your "complete stats", like pet info does? Like natural and (after equip) stats. Plus pve/pvp atack and dodge agi.
NiteHawk
changing armor to reflect magic mitigation would cause more problems temporarily. it should. but in the end its easier to balance. and better for future oad gear because the next piece of armor can gain 1 or the other not just 1 ac. the reason i even suggested it is because the game sits relatively magicless at the moment. it isnt magic heavy at all. leaves plenty of float room for testing behind the scenes or for players to help you. the system of int vs wis, sr and ac , worked very well on my pen and paper rpg. the agility system inplace is similar to my paper rpg i just gave bonuses/penalties for size. i think the only factor thats different from my paper rpg and this game is rolled stats vs p p p x x x, and exponential damage multipliers.

currently noone would pick cloth wearing warriors because there is no reason to. same reason they run around with 10 wis freely.


I could see the mitigation actually being apart of armor but I'm wondering in a game like this that there actually should be heavy armor with mitigation but lower AC rather than cloth armor being the only high damage mitigation. Obviously cloth would have higher then heavy if this was the case, but I don't see any paladins using cloth armor and losing 50% absorption 'chance' for spell mitigation unless the mitigation was high which it probably wouldn't be super high anyways.. If it was high the issue obviously would be with players swapping gear which would most likely be a terrible thing if that was the case. Right now I believe with 20 wis you negate around 10% damage which is a fair amount since you can unaffect fully and absorption is often around 50% unless you get lucky and are using a shield for the 100%'s.


What about a text command that shows your "complete stats", like pet info does? Like natural and (after equip) stats. Plus pve/pvp atack and dodge agi.


I still think its starting to get overly complicated and honestly the game needs to be generally simple to understand for the most case. Having complete stats info could be a thing to see proper stats specially with other classes but I think +1 dodge agi is enough to start.
anthriel
The only 2nd thought I had re +1 dodge Agi on "little people" is that with gnomes you could technically +1 endurance and effectivly get a better than best elf sorcerer for the most part (ie 22 dodge Agi, 18 End and better int/wis... Only niche left for elf sorcerer to be better is if they choose to +1 End themselves ).

Therefore to address this, it possible to restrict the "little people dodge bonus" to only applying if Lings/gnomes keep 17end (ie don't bulk up)... Perhaps instead of a racial bonus for Lings/gnomes it could therefore apply to any race who decided to keep 17 end or under (i can't really see it being abused cos what user of other races in their right mind would want to choose 17 end / less HP willingly lol)... I know it does potentially complicate the hidden stats somewhat (which NH doesn't like) but it is a possible imbalance issue between gnome/elf mages that occurred to me so I wanted to point it out in case others had any ideas.
Styx
Proposal 15 *thumbsup*

<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />

Let's give it a try, see how it works. Then we can find out. All else change it by racial adjustments.
Lateralus
I really dont think we need to over complicate systems with mr and agi attached to armors. Much of the draw is approach-ability i understand depth but if the game is overly complicated its going to be unapproachable (thats not even considering how hard it would be to balance) we have a 20+ balancing post on over something that should be pretty simple and you wanna add 2-3 more layers on top of that mulitplying the complexity?


I like that you are contributing but I have not seen you in game for quite a while im not really sure you actually understand how the current balance is. You keep saying casters are under repped which i get but the more barbs, slayers, ninjas, knights etc there are means chanters/necros actually dominate more. I really dont think casters are in that bad of a place. yes penetration took a hit but casters still dominate in their situations.


I really dont think we need to over complicate this stuff things are not super outta wack and I dont think we need to change the whole game with complicated systems to find some kind of balance.

I think its ok to take small steps like changing a few races stats and then look at the next problem like how int matters on heal or adding spell damage to weapons etc...

If we try to approach every single aspect at once we are never going to get anything done tbh i know we wanna get this stat thing right but these are not huge changes they are just minor tweaks I am not sure why its taking this long no one is every going to agree on everything but I think we can find some kind of balance. The good thing is nitehawk is an active dev if shits outta balance after this its not like this was our one shot, we will just make another adjustment no big deal...


I really think we need to move this along we are very close and as many have stated they have halted leveling until something is finalized.
Terron
LAT,

an SR system isnt complicated lol. its already written ingame(minus armor desc changes). hence your armor code with a different precursor. the ability to change any aspect seperately is much easier to balance than a multiplication equation with 3 tiers. hence why elf has 0 mr due to 21 wis and goblins have 20 mr because of a crap 16/17. clerics have - mr so they need max wis for pvp. on melee damage you have ability, weapon, and str multiplication tiers pumping strength to the next level. i see this easy. i have built games and playtested for mmo's this isnt out of my scope of understanding. anyone can use a calculator and understand the law of averages.(nitehawk gives the formulas freely which is a +1 for him)

these are all little nuances of an imperfect system. if you dont care than you dont. i was offering up a good system i have used on a similar game. i can tell you personally only care for the creme of the crop builds and dont really care for 144 character choices. i ofcourse am thinking ahead and offering a free outlook. MR is fine because the game is 65% lizard and horc and Chanters own them. i do actually gather intel before i just run my fingers across keys(my mouf).

be that as it may the game runs smooth enough and it is exciting to play at times. i do however enjoy playing rare characters and weird stat characters, i like to explore limitations and max diversity. so when i say MR or agi dun wuk wight, or hip joints are whack-a-mole(gnome) it doesn't always entail cookie cutter vs cookie cutter vs cookie cutter. as a gamer and playtester i am always looking for the perfect game.
anthriel
I see both sides of argument. On one hand I appreciate that Lat just wants to get changes in quickly and do so at a more incremental/manageable rate. This is practical. But I do think that in trying to get this accomplished, his consistent posts effecively saying "calm down, all is well" can be perceived as "shut downs" of ideas and could possibly discourage the culture of ppl caring enough to make future contributions on MBs (which was an issue earlier in this thread)

I really like Terron's ideas and think his aims to change stuff more could unlock a lot of potential in the game. However we probably do need to move slower in order for community to 'catch up' and agree to any bigger changes along the way. Shrugs I see 22 pages of discussion as a good thing, not a bad one. Better to have a game where ppl care enough about the game to post, than one where ppl cbb posting cos they know what certain ppl are going to say back anyway.