Race Stat Changes
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Also @nitehawk: Would it be hard for you to get the % distribution of 25er races?
i.e, x% of 25ers are saurian, y% are elves and so forth.
This would enable us to understand if there is any given race that is materially underplayed, instead of us trying to guess based on what we "feel".
i.e, x% of 25ers are saurian, y% are elves and so forth.
This would enable us to understand if there is any given race that is materially underplayed, instead of us trying to guess based on what we "feel".
Just partied with some people from various clans and tried to get a discussion going on this to get their feedback, partially because of what Anthriel said above and the lack of people posting here on such an important topic.
few notes:
They seemed to think the issue is with the formulas not being balanced, but there were some inconsistencies with what they were saying
i.e. one moment they said agi was broken, that's why orcs and dwarves were good. but then they said removing 1 str from orcs and 1 end from dwarves would make them useless.
I was arguing that flattening the curve with racial stats and lessening the extremes would make it easier to balance the formulas.
They also asked who in theory should win the most out of a fight between a goblin and an orc, i argued that an orc should win slightly more often otherwise orcs have no purpose.
whereas goblins should be good at melee but also be able to fight magic users. Orcs on the other hand should not be able to fight magic users.
Discussion of cookie cutter classes came up, elemental elders were mentioned. orc slayers were mentioned
There was a mention of human slayers being useable in rok, i said that was only due to AC being broken in rok, and actually disputed human slayers were any good at all.
I said i think we're very close to balancing the melee classes if we were to +1 end dark elves and -1 str orcs and -1 end dwarves.
In theory you could have 6 races that are roughly balanced for melee, with some being slightly worse but having better MR to compensate. (sauris, drakes, goblins, dark elves, orcs, dwarves)
I did also say magic users would need considering for balance, and i haven't even considered bards/rangers/druids.
in theory with magic users, gnomes should do most damage/heals but be more fragile, other races might be less fragile (agi/hp) but do less damage/heals
elders are a tricky one to balance, but maybe -1 wis on elementals and adjust the overall stat points available.
In theory the "all round" races should be good at classes that require several stats, ie. guardians, druids
few notes:
They seemed to think the issue is with the formulas not being balanced, but there were some inconsistencies with what they were saying
i.e. one moment they said agi was broken, that's why orcs and dwarves were good. but then they said removing 1 str from orcs and 1 end from dwarves would make them useless.
I was arguing that flattening the curve with racial stats and lessening the extremes would make it easier to balance the formulas.
They also asked who in theory should win the most out of a fight between a goblin and an orc, i argued that an orc should win slightly more often otherwise orcs have no purpose.
whereas goblins should be good at melee but also be able to fight magic users. Orcs on the other hand should not be able to fight magic users.
Discussion of cookie cutter classes came up, elemental elders were mentioned. orc slayers were mentioned
There was a mention of human slayers being useable in rok, i said that was only due to AC being broken in rok, and actually disputed human slayers were any good at all.
I said i think we're very close to balancing the melee classes if we were to +1 end dark elves and -1 str orcs and -1 end dwarves.
In theory you could have 6 races that are roughly balanced for melee, with some being slightly worse but having better MR to compensate. (sauris, drakes, goblins, dark elves, orcs, dwarves)
I did also say magic users would need considering for balance, and i haven't even considered bards/rangers/druids.
in theory with magic users, gnomes should do most damage/heals but be more fragile, other races might be less fragile (agi/hp) but do less damage/heals
elders are a tricky one to balance, but maybe -1 wis on elementals and adjust the overall stat points available.
In theory the "all round" races should be good at classes that require several stats, ie. guardians, druids
My understanding on this is we are looking for balance, lessening one or more races hps and adding more to another isnt a fix, just my opinion.
MR needs to be balanced as per the casters INT, i dont play a caster myself but to kill a couple mini bosses and Ive noticed it blasts for a lot of dmg with 21 int, vs a saurian it would eat it up as it should. Horcs have a natural resist it seems to certain spells, ie: FF and sap but are still chanter fodder, which again makes sense, comes down to race.
Nobody's saying you have to play a horc or saurian slayer, they just seem to be the most popular and if you can play a slayer properly in this game you pretty much win 80% of your battles.
I guess it comes down to skill level and proper class/race choices?
Every class and race should have its str and weakness's, im thinking the only thing that needs tweeking is dodge, MR (racially), blast str and hp or dmg adjustments to balance everything.
Edit:
Maybe the classes should look something like this:
Melee
Cav - natural dodge low hitrate high dmg
Zerker - low dodge high hit high dmg
slayer - high dodge low hit rate high dmg
Ninja - high dodge high hit low dmg
Ranger - high dodge high hit low dmg
Druid - high dodge high hit low dmg
MR needs to be balanced as per the casters INT, i dont play a caster myself but to kill a couple mini bosses and Ive noticed it blasts for a lot of dmg with 21 int, vs a saurian it would eat it up as it should. Horcs have a natural resist it seems to certain spells, ie: FF and sap but are still chanter fodder, which again makes sense, comes down to race.
Nobody's saying you have to play a horc or saurian slayer, they just seem to be the most popular and if you can play a slayer properly in this game you pretty much win 80% of your battles.
I guess it comes down to skill level and proper class/race choices?
Every class and race should have its str and weakness's, im thinking the only thing that needs tweeking is dodge, MR (racially), blast str and hp or dmg adjustments to balance everything.
Edit:
Maybe the classes should look something like this:
Melee
Cav - natural dodge low hitrate high dmg
Zerker - low dodge high hit high dmg
slayer - high dodge low hit rate high dmg
Ninja - high dodge high hit low dmg
Ranger - high dodge high hit low dmg
Druid - high dodge high hit low dmg
Just a clarificational reply to Eld (and somewhat JF and Lat) to make clear that I am not saying Silh are all in agreement or trying to influence for their benefit etc (I was merely pointing out to NH that he has large blindspots in his information about his own game if he's only relying on MBs/discord/staff as his sources) ... My main discouragement to stop posting suggestions was NH's comment that revealed to me that he doesn't really seem to care if ppl leave his game cos he will just aim to replace them win new players from advertising... Unless I have misunderstood his comment, then I feel this to be an arrogant/complacent attitude for a game developer that is eventually likely to prove fatal for his game. Why should I bother wasting time to think and suggest things to help player retention if the game developer himself doesn't care about retaining players (except for maybe the most vocal ones within his circle of friends)?
I've said it before and I'll say it for the last time. Games grow and players keep playing cos the game makes them happy. I know you obviously can't keep everyone happy, but I can't understand why you would rather have players quit than to do something that would keep lots of ppl happy (eg have some way to change races especially when dealing with complex rebalancing and it is not difficult to do), especially if it would accomplish lots for the goodwill for the game with its players. And implementing a way to change race as a ongoing end-game feature actually gives ppl something to strive for in the end-game and a way to undo costly mistakes etc - which solves a lot of the "player goodwill" problems for future rebalancing issues.
I still don't know what NH's reasons for "never" wanting to consider it are ... but it was his blasé comments about simply replacing players (rather than striving to retain players) which clearly signalled to me that we differ ideologically .... And if this is the case then no amount of me posting more suggestions or joining staff or whatever is likely to make any difference. Therefore I feel that all I can say is to reiterate my "good luck to EO" and join the silent/unvocal masses in the less-invested/more-disconnected portion of the playerbase. Peace and good luck.
PS - I disagree with Lat's flawed logic that "classes get rebalanced but we don't offer class changes therefore we shouldn't offer race changes". The reason is because most ppl approach an RPG thinking "I want to create the best possible Sorc/Assy/etc, what race would help do that?"..... Unless they are hardcore RPers they probably aren't thinking "I want to create the best possible gnome/elf/etc, what class is best for that?". In short, the racial choice is a means to an end whereas the class (i.e the desired end itself) is not a choice that ppl (even newbs) are likely to make a mistake on.
I've said it before and I'll say it for the last time. Games grow and players keep playing cos the game makes them happy. I know you obviously can't keep everyone happy, but I can't understand why you would rather have players quit than to do something that would keep lots of ppl happy (eg have some way to change races especially when dealing with complex rebalancing and it is not difficult to do), especially if it would accomplish lots for the goodwill for the game with its players. And implementing a way to change race as a ongoing end-game feature actually gives ppl something to strive for in the end-game and a way to undo costly mistakes etc - which solves a lot of the "player goodwill" problems for future rebalancing issues.
I still don't know what NH's reasons for "never" wanting to consider it are ... but it was his blasé comments about simply replacing players (rather than striving to retain players) which clearly signalled to me that we differ ideologically .... And if this is the case then no amount of me posting more suggestions or joining staff or whatever is likely to make any difference. Therefore I feel that all I can say is to reiterate my "good luck to EO" and join the silent/unvocal masses in the less-invested/more-disconnected portion of the playerbase. Peace and good luck.
PS - I disagree with Lat's flawed logic that "classes get rebalanced but we don't offer class changes therefore we shouldn't offer race changes". The reason is because most ppl approach an RPG thinking "I want to create the best possible Sorc/Assy/etc, what race would help do that?"..... Unless they are hardcore RPers they probably aren't thinking "I want to create the best possible gnome/elf/etc, what class is best for that?". In short, the racial choice is a means to an end whereas the class (i.e the desired end itself) is not a choice that ppl (even newbs) are likely to make a mistake on.
I'm not sure why you would adopt such a stance re never allowing race changes, especially in the case of allowing some end-game way for new players to correct character creation mistakes made when they were new (perhaps you have good reasons you havent explained) ... In any case I wanted to give you feedback that the perceived attitude behind your above comment seems discouraging. I've been suggesting all along that EO's issue isnt as much "player attraction through advertising" as it is "player retention through game dynamics" (which you largely have more control over than advertising). But basically it seems to me like you are saying you dont give a damn about retaining players, you just care about replacing them with new ones (who may then quit anyway later)....which seems rather short sighted for a game developer and doesnt really inspire me to go grind out some more 25ers or interact with new players who are likely part of a revolving door.
Because being able to change races would dynamically make everyone cooker cutters and set everyone to a set few races. I don't think it would be fun or good at all if everyone was the same. Everyone would abuse it, specially vets, to change their characters into more useful ones. I also don't see these minor changes, even if we go with the first proposal being a reason to say everyone gets a free respec. The races are basically the same, except better at what they were geared for. Some people will find that X or Y might be better in X or Y situations, then they should level said char too. Giving a racial respec to everyone pretty much will probably shutdown any sort of leveling that still remains, too, etc. Someone makes a DE, realizes that lings more what they wanted because they wanted more dodge rate lets say, I get that, but that shouldn't warrant a racial respec. I can understand if the actual races were being changed into different categories (I.E. as an extreme, re-balancing saurians so they are weaker but have MR would be a completely different category) but I again don't see that here with any of the proposed changes. The most of who will benefit from this are vets, not new players too.
I do care about the players, and I have been working with players and accommodating them as much as I can. I often do get says on what needs to be done on everything, and this is no different. I am simply saying if some players are lost, which will happen in any game that attempts to balance, than it is what it is. Do I want this? Obviously not. You cannot make everyone happy when it comes to balance though as you have seen yourself. It's going to be down to me after we discuss on what needs to be changed and I know many have different ideas. However in same cases such as being able to change race, I don't think it would be a good idea in the long run. I 'want' members, and I want people to obviously stay playing.
Also, the forums and discord are not exactly representative of the entire community who play your game. The large majority of players active on forums and EO discord tavern seem to me to be from 1 guild. The large majority of active staff (at the time of this post) appear to be from 1 guild. Many of these players seem to be from an "in-crowd" community of close-knit Rok alumni. I suspect therefore the large majority of your interactions/surveys of "player opinion" come from a particular sub-community of players within the larger community (and you appear to give the suggestions of these players more weight/consideration). I have tried to be a voice that thinks outside this box to help EO with fresh/different ideas, but i tire of what seems to usually be a fruitless/unwanted task.... And your above "i dont really care if ppl quit" sentiments make me feel that although you have created a game that is a big improvement over Rok, it still has Rok's unhelpful feel of a game that is designed largely to cater for the gratification of the "in-crowd"/staff rather than for the gratification of the entire playerbase.
No, they aren't, so get them to post! I was simply making a point that a lot of discord members disagreed. I did not say that they represent everyone, only that there was a discussion about it. I however, wanted people to POST here so we can discuss it. Otherwise it's obviously hard to make opinions without people giving them. If you have friends who agree with you in game, then POST it. I've linked this in a bcast before too in game. We can't formulate stuff if people don't contribute, and no matter one each person who replies here is just that, one person in a bigger pool.
I'm not sure who you are referring to, Eld I assume? Actually he and I have been disagreeing on a lot of things with these race changes. I agree that there should be more than what he wants. Two of the three current proposals I would assume he disagrees with pretty strongly. If you were referring to a group of players being IG or on a 3rd party chat client, I don't relate to them at all or know who really is in any of the guilds/groups. I'm not really close to anyone and I keep it that way to prevent drama, and to attempt to be fair on others. Kind of like the warden job, but on an admin level. I think you got the wrong idea about 'people quitting' though, so apologies for that though. I did try to clarify it though. I do want people to play, obviously.
There is a need for more information specially on the char creator, but it's more of a how general points should be spent and some sample builds kind of thing that needs to be shown.
My understanding on this is we are looking for balance, lessening one or more races hps and adding more to another isnt a fix, just my opinion.
MR needs to be balanced as per the casters INT, i dont play a caster myself but to kill a couple mini bosses and Ive noticed it blasts for a lot of dmg with 21 int, vs a saurian it would eat it up as it should. Horcs have a natural resist it seems to certain spells, ie: FF and sap but are still chanter fodder, which again makes sense, comes down to race.
Nobody's saying you have to play a horc or saurian slayer, they just seem to be the most popular and if you can play a slayer properly in this game you pretty much win 80% of your battles.
I guess it comes down to skill level and proper class/race choices?
Every class and race should have its str and weakness's, im thinking the only thing that needs tweeking is dodge, MR (racially), blast str and hp or dmg adjustments to balance everything.
There is no natural resists to any spells, that is incorrect (obviously theres a slight racial bonus but that doesn't change based on spell). Lower wisdom does have shorter durations, but that is for any spell. If you have high wisdom and sap/etc goes through, it takes longer to wear off. So low wis, easier time to pierce but shorter duration.High wis, harder to pierce and longer duration. However, the pierce chance is the same as ALL other spells.
The whole what classes though should be another discussion. I do agree with you about strengths and weaknesses, but classes are a different monster to tackle.
From what I have been hearing the actual pierce rate isn't so bad now, but could do with little more tweaking. I'm not sure though why it's not exactly a fix. To me you're still looking at 960HP vs 1250HP which seems still like a good difference when it comes to the lower HP vs higher HP no?
Obviously de/lings/etc will never be as good as a saurian in physical combat which is understandable based on stats, but the MR of lings is obviously what gives them a better chance at surviving a mix or all spell casters. I don't really think the issue is the MR rates right now though, thats not what everyone has been really saying. It isn't an issue with overall survivability in PVE and PVP where getting double tapped is a thing with any of the lower HP races. It shouldn't be a 'super easy thing' to do. Granted, it should be a possibility and a benefit of using a fighter race, but pretty much the reason in 6vs6 you go for the higher END races is simply for not being killed instantly. I don't think it still makes them better at groups, but it helps a good deal so that they are actually usable races in PVP groups too.
Also @nitehawk: Would it be hard for you to get the % distribution of 25er races?
i.e, x% of 25ers are saurian, y% are elves and so forth.
This would enable us to understand if there is any given race that is materially underplayed, instead of us trying to guess based on what we "feel".
It is kind of a pain in the ass right now. I will have to see about it but I am literally doing it through text file searches etc. coping the files found, then doing it on those files and making a smaller search. It's not fun. I need a way to eventually get statistics easily.
I was arguing that flattening the curve with racial stats and lessening the extremes would make it easier to balance the formulas
I kind of agree with flattening the curve but I think we can go a little more for balance on lings and whatnot than what you say. I think the 2nd prop on the sheet at least would be a start, or a mix of the 2nd and 3rd. Still waiting on more feedback though.
If I had to go with a proposal I'd say the top half of 2 and bottom half of 3. I don't think orc and dwarf need to lose their power stats but could see them with less mr. They are already going to take an agi nerf once agi counts more. I think the 12 wis on orc is a good idea and removing the -10 spell pen and maybe even default less resistance on dwarf would be good again 23end and 20mr means they simply can't lose to a caster.
As for the top half I think it looks good but I'm not sure why elf would get an int point. They already have +1 end and +1agi on gnome which is a pretty big deal imo. With int no longer counting towards pen gnomes basically just have a tad more damage atm and a lot less defense. Yea they have higher wis but above 20 wis and a caster class doesn't seem to be a huge deal tbh your as good at 21 as you are 22. If you really wanna give elf another int I think you gotta give gnome a agi or something idk. Yes I understand a lot of casters are gnomes but that's about all they are good for imo. And after the pen change they lost their biggest selling point over elves. Elves work for a lot of classes while gnomes right now are a step below elves as casters and a few below elves as everything else (healers and any physical) giving them an extra agi on top of int might open them up to better brigands slayers druids etc.
Otherwise I think I agree with the rest.
As for the top half I think it looks good but I'm not sure why elf would get an int point. They already have +1 end and +1agi on gnome which is a pretty big deal imo. With int no longer counting towards pen gnomes basically just have a tad more damage atm and a lot less defense. Yea they have higher wis but above 20 wis and a caster class doesn't seem to be a huge deal tbh your as good at 21 as you are 22. If you really wanna give elf another int I think you gotta give gnome a agi or something idk. Yes I understand a lot of casters are gnomes but that's about all they are good for imo. And after the pen change they lost their biggest selling point over elves. Elves work for a lot of classes while gnomes right now are a step below elves as casters and a few below elves as everything else (healers and any physical) giving them an extra agi on top of int might open them up to better brigands slayers druids etc.
Otherwise I think I agree with the rest.
If I had to go with a proposal I'd say the top half of 2 and bottom half of 3. I don't think orc and dwarf need to lose their power stats but could see them with less mr. They are already going to take an agi nerf once agi counts more. I think the 12 wis on orc is a good idea and removing the -10 spell pen and maybe even default less resistance on dwarf would be good again 23end and 20mr means they simply can't lose to a caster.
As for the top half I think it looks good but I'm not sure why elf would get an int point. They already have +1 end and +1agi on gnome which is a pretty big deal imo. With int no longer counting towards pen gnomes basically just have a tad more damage atm and a lot less defense. Yea they have higher wis but above 20 wis and a caster class doesn't seem to be a huge deal tbh your as good at 21 as you are 22. If you really wanna give elf another int I think you gotta give gnome a agi or something idk. Yes I understand a lot of casters are gnomes but that's about all they are good for imo. And after the pen change they lost their biggest selling point over elves. Elves work for a lot of classes while gnomes right now are a step below elves as casters and a few below elves as everything else (healers and any physical) giving them an extra agi on top of int might open them up to better brigands slayers druids etc.
Otherwise I think I agree with the rest.
Spell pen is already removed on dwarves since 1.6.1.6. You need to make sure you don't shatter what separates a dwarf and HO too though. Maybe defaulting the spell penetration but regardless 20wis is pretty high in general and race bonuses bar goblins don't make a huge impact.
For the first proposal:
gnomes 16 21 17 23 22 20
vs
elves 18 22 18 21 21 22
is probably okay, but then look at lings with the changes vs elves.
des 20 22 19 20 20 16
vs
lings 18 23 18 20 20 22
vs
elves 18 22 18 21 21 22
Yeah it's one less int/wis for an extra agi. I dunno how useful itis. It might be OK but yeah. Then you got DEs which are fairly good too. I just feel like elves don't have anything special there, but to me they are very similar. The 22 int was more of a
---
For the 3rd proposal its simple:
gnomes 16 21 18 23 22 20
vs
elves 18 22 18 21 21 22
Aka they would be useless shadowed gnomes. If you give gnomes +1 end, you need to give something to elves to change them. thats why changing gnomes is a problem. If you add to a couple races, you need to rebalance the lot otherwise its not worth it for some races.
I made a 4th proposal based on your stuff here: <a class="postlink" href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15EUNEHza_TEiL4Qw-RofGVNX1mcBPQ0T9Ri8pB3EfXA/edit#gid=0">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... edit#gid=0</a>
Again none of those are set in stone, just making them cause they spark ideas/says. but I feel like DEs are a little better then Elves if you give them the +1 though lat, +1 end and +1 str, -1 wis/int. I'd say elves are shadowed in prop 4. Thats why I was trying to make them a in between gnomes thing.
Makes sense about the de overshadowing elf if elf doesn't get anything and de got end. in that case I'd say de would be fine with maybe just a pool stat or something instead of an +1end. De really are not that bad off I think giving them an extra pool stat or so might open them up to more balance play like pally without any overshadowing elf if they got an extra end.
Yea maybe a lower base resistance for dwarf would help the situation A bit.
Anyways I think I like proposal 4 the best I feel like it addresses the issues pretty well and also keeps changes to a minimum. Less for people to complain about and we know what we have right now is pretty close anyways why change a ton of stuff. I think doing less is more here.
Yea maybe a lower base resistance for dwarf would help the situation A bit.
Anyways I think I like proposal 4 the best I feel like it addresses the issues pretty well and also keeps changes to a minimum. Less for people to complain about and we know what we have right now is pretty close anyways why change a ton of stuff. I think doing less is more here.
Going to look at this from another angle, and compare the *current* strengths and weaknesses of the different races as i see it as an active player, if i was looking to make a new character today, as the races stand.
Dark Elf - Before very recently, this was one of the 2 realistic options for a melee fighter with MR (along with dwarves), since the very recent buff to goblin MR dark elves are now inferior in pretty much every way
Summary: I would not currently make any dark elf alt, except possibly a thief.
Drakeblood - strong melee option if you don't care about MR, similar to saurian, you make the choice between end/str.
The high Chr also gives you the option for a more combat orientated ranger (possibly also suitable for bard, i haven't researched how much chr affects bards, so i don't know if this is viable)
Summary: Drakeblood is a very strong option for melee characters and rangers (my stalker is a drake)
Saurian - strong melee option if you don't care about MR, similar to drakeblood, you make the choice between end/str
Summary: Very strong option for melee characters (my zerker is a saurian)
Dwarf - High HP, one of the few melee races with decent MR, but has a huge str gap to Orc which is very pronounced on classes with multipliers (slayers/zerkers) especially as these classes have negative MR, which negates one of the main selling points of a dwarf.
End is very high, and along with 17 int this currently allows for a high hp guard/priest.
I've also heard of dwarf elders, but i've heard these arent very good in practice other than for very high HP in bear mode (1500?)
Summary: I wish I hadn't made my slayer dwarf, i am relatively happy with my paladin though
Elemental - Widely seen as the standout race for elders, some people dispute this and claim elf/gnome are better but there isn't much evidence for this.
Elementals also provide options for clerics/chanters if you want a high MP pool for no mana events, however their low agi makes this a tough choice.
Summary: I'm very happy with my elemental elder, but i wouldn't make any other class an elemental.
Elf - I've heard many people previously claim that Elves made more rounded mages than gnomes, due to the extra hp. I've also heard they make good elders [sources needed]. They are also a good option for rangers/bards.
I don't have much of an option on elves as I haven't made one yet. I'd quite like to switch my death mage from gnome to elf to see if he's less fragile.
Summary: seem to be popular for several classes, and a bit less fragile than gnomes
Gnome - If you wanna zap lizards/orcs/drakes with high spell damage then this is the race to use. Satisfyingly high magic damage, but recently were nerfed when spell penetration was no longer linked to Int.
It's hard to see how this change will shake out.
Seem to be too fragile to use for any other class, though some people seem to like them as druids or clerics.
Summary: My gnome chanter was awesome, i need further comparison with other chanter races to see if this is still the case.
Goblin - the new "go to" choice for a melee class with MR. Low str is a bit of a downside, but good agi/end/MR helps a lot. Low str probably means they would still be bad on classes with damage multipliers.
With 17 Int they are also a strong choice for clerics/paladins due to the good agi/end.
Potentially also a good choice for brigands if/when trap disarms are introduced, due to their anti-poison traits
Summary: My brigand's backstabs are weak as duck's piss with 19 str, but they seem to be useful for many classes at the moment. They now shit all over dark elves.
Half Elf - Solid choice for classes such as priest/guardian and now chanters after the change to spell penetration.
Potentially also good choice for rangers/bards
Would be nice if they made good druids, but unsure how they would do at present.
Summary: My main is a half elf priest. I used to wish he was human for higher end, but hopefully the changes to agi make me stop wishing for a race change.
Human - Solid choice for classes such as priest/guardian and maybe chanter after the change to spell penetration. Very similar to half elf in many aspects, with the choice between str/end for humans and an extra agi point in half elves.
The lower chr means they're not as viable for rangers/bards.
Would be nice if they made good druids, but unsure how they would do at present.
Summary: Potentially 21 end with 20 agi and 20 int makes for a strong caster.
Halfling - Low str and low end make this race currently really bad for pretty much every class except maybe bards and rangers.
Their higher agi doesn't seem to save them in any instances.
Other people seem slightly less biased against halflings but i think they're trash at present
Summary: I wouldn't use a halfling for anything except maybe a bard at present. I might be unfairly biased but i don't think i am.
Half Orcs - High str and high end makes this race awesome for classes with attack multipliers. 25 str backstabs seem to land more often than you'd think and are devastating in PVP.
The low agi doesn't seem to harm them too much, but maybe this will change with the agi rebalancing?
Summary: I wish my slayer was an orc, but i made it a shitty dwarf. Woe is me.
Summary of summaries:
Looking at the above i think the 3 most obvious changes are:
- look at ways of improving lings (+end and an extra racial trait, such as extra mana regen, or extra chance to dodge, or a chance to land a crit hit)
- dark elves (extra end or str so they're similar to goblins but different)
- do some mass testing on elemental elders and see if they really are superior to other combinations, if they are look at ways this could be tweaked. Potentially less wis?
Other than these 3 changes, other changes that might be worth looking at:
-look at if gnomes are now underpowered after the recent magic penetration changes
-look at if 25 str on orcs is overpowered compared to other races
-look at if 23 end on dwarves is overpowered, but if this is changed make sure they either get 22 str or that orcs are nerfed in some way so the gap between the two races doesn't grow even bigger than it is now.
-look at ways to make elementals viable for other classes
-consider adding a new race that's like the "orc of magic casters"? higher hp, high int, very low agi.
This might be a horrific change because it could just outlast all the low MR melee and screw everything up.
Dark Elf - Before very recently, this was one of the 2 realistic options for a melee fighter with MR (along with dwarves), since the very recent buff to goblin MR dark elves are now inferior in pretty much every way
Summary: I would not currently make any dark elf alt, except possibly a thief.
Drakeblood - strong melee option if you don't care about MR, similar to saurian, you make the choice between end/str.
The high Chr also gives you the option for a more combat orientated ranger (possibly also suitable for bard, i haven't researched how much chr affects bards, so i don't know if this is viable)
Summary: Drakeblood is a very strong option for melee characters and rangers (my stalker is a drake)
Saurian - strong melee option if you don't care about MR, similar to drakeblood, you make the choice between end/str
Summary: Very strong option for melee characters (my zerker is a saurian)
Dwarf - High HP, one of the few melee races with decent MR, but has a huge str gap to Orc which is very pronounced on classes with multipliers (slayers/zerkers) especially as these classes have negative MR, which negates one of the main selling points of a dwarf.
End is very high, and along with 17 int this currently allows for a high hp guard/priest.
I've also heard of dwarf elders, but i've heard these arent very good in practice other than for very high HP in bear mode (1500?)
Summary: I wish I hadn't made my slayer dwarf, i am relatively happy with my paladin though
Elemental - Widely seen as the standout race for elders, some people dispute this and claim elf/gnome are better but there isn't much evidence for this.
Elementals also provide options for clerics/chanters if you want a high MP pool for no mana events, however their low agi makes this a tough choice.
Summary: I'm very happy with my elemental elder, but i wouldn't make any other class an elemental.
Elf - I've heard many people previously claim that Elves made more rounded mages than gnomes, due to the extra hp. I've also heard they make good elders [sources needed]. They are also a good option for rangers/bards.
I don't have much of an option on elves as I haven't made one yet. I'd quite like to switch my death mage from gnome to elf to see if he's less fragile.
Summary: seem to be popular for several classes, and a bit less fragile than gnomes
Gnome - If you wanna zap lizards/orcs/drakes with high spell damage then this is the race to use. Satisfyingly high magic damage, but recently were nerfed when spell penetration was no longer linked to Int.
It's hard to see how this change will shake out.
Seem to be too fragile to use for any other class, though some people seem to like them as druids or clerics.
Summary: My gnome chanter was awesome, i need further comparison with other chanter races to see if this is still the case.
Goblin - the new "go to" choice for a melee class with MR. Low str is a bit of a downside, but good agi/end/MR helps a lot. Low str probably means they would still be bad on classes with damage multipliers.
With 17 Int they are also a strong choice for clerics/paladins due to the good agi/end.
Potentially also a good choice for brigands if/when trap disarms are introduced, due to their anti-poison traits
Summary: My brigand's backstabs are weak as duck's piss with 19 str, but they seem to be useful for many classes at the moment. They now shit all over dark elves.
Half Elf - Solid choice for classes such as priest/guardian and now chanters after the change to spell penetration.
Potentially also good choice for rangers/bards
Would be nice if they made good druids, but unsure how they would do at present.
Summary: My main is a half elf priest. I used to wish he was human for higher end, but hopefully the changes to agi make me stop wishing for a race change.
Human - Solid choice for classes such as priest/guardian and maybe chanter after the change to spell penetration. Very similar to half elf in many aspects, with the choice between str/end for humans and an extra agi point in half elves.
The lower chr means they're not as viable for rangers/bards.
Would be nice if they made good druids, but unsure how they would do at present.
Summary: Potentially 21 end with 20 agi and 20 int makes for a strong caster.
Halfling - Low str and low end make this race currently really bad for pretty much every class except maybe bards and rangers.
Their higher agi doesn't seem to save them in any instances.
Other people seem slightly less biased against halflings but i think they're trash at present
Summary: I wouldn't use a halfling for anything except maybe a bard at present. I might be unfairly biased but i don't think i am.
Half Orcs - High str and high end makes this race awesome for classes with attack multipliers. 25 str backstabs seem to land more often than you'd think and are devastating in PVP.
The low agi doesn't seem to harm them too much, but maybe this will change with the agi rebalancing?
Summary: I wish my slayer was an orc, but i made it a shitty dwarf. Woe is me.
Summary of summaries:
Looking at the above i think the 3 most obvious changes are:
- look at ways of improving lings (+end and an extra racial trait, such as extra mana regen, or extra chance to dodge, or a chance to land a crit hit)
- dark elves (extra end or str so they're similar to goblins but different)
- do some mass testing on elemental elders and see if they really are superior to other combinations, if they are look at ways this could be tweaked. Potentially less wis?
Other than these 3 changes, other changes that might be worth looking at:
-look at if gnomes are now underpowered after the recent magic penetration changes
-look at if 25 str on orcs is overpowered compared to other races
-look at if 23 end on dwarves is overpowered, but if this is changed make sure they either get 22 str or that orcs are nerfed in some way so the gap between the two races doesn't grow even bigger than it is now.
-look at ways to make elementals viable for other classes
-consider adding a new race that's like the "orc of magic casters"? higher hp, high int, very low agi.
This might be a horrific change because it could just outlast all the low MR melee and screw everything up.
Stuff
22 str dwarves with 22 end might be an option. How would people feel about that? Would be ok IMO I think but also might over step other races, dunno, need to look at it. There kinda like then high end/str but with wis.
The debuff to goblins helps though, Goblins vs DE, you get more allocation points in so I think it works out too.
Brigs with a bow do around 3.5x damage.
Lings need something and I still think its more END. With the AGI changes and end, eh, make them viable in 1vs1 or 1vs2 situations which makes good for certain events too. still Saurians are gonna sweep the floor cause they have high AGI too really, and half orcs always can get lucky anyways which funks them due to their such high damage. Maybe they need a racial bonus on top just dunno yet what. Or more agi, or whatever.
Because being able to change races would dynamically make everyone cooker cutters and set everyone to a set few races. I don't think it would be fun or good at all if everyone was the same. Everyone would abuse it, specially vets, to change their characters into more useful ones.
I disagree that racial respec = everyone would have cookie cutters, as long as you have races with viable trade offs. Eg not everyone is a Horc slayer because there is a viable tradeoff in Saurians (some ppl rather big backstabs, others want to land more often). Its about presenting ppl with good choices, not punishing them for bad former ones.
Some people will find that X or Y might be better in X or Y situations, then they should level said char too. Giving a racial respec to everyone pretty much will probably shutdown any sort of leveling that still remains, too, etc.
Again, i think i ideologically disagree with you here and comments like these make me question how disconnected you might be from the ordinary experience of a common player playing your game. I believe that ppl wont be motivated to level if they think that the character they envision having at the end of a month of grinding is not going to be what they want. I've certainly lost interest in finishing several characters cos i now know that they are crap builds anyway so why bother making them 25ers. I cant be bothered starting new ones either because by the time i approach 25 there may be changes that make them useless too. Yes there are a small % of the community that can churn out 25er after 25er and can afford to level their 2nd or 3rd char of the same class, but the majority of players probably only have 2-7 25ers worth of leveling in them and then they want to get on with enjoying the end-game.... most ppl dislike leveling but will put up with it if they perceive there is a desired reward at the end (ie obtaining the character they envision having).... not presenting ppl with any other choice than to re-level new chars after any re-balancing is likely to destabilise faith in accomplishing that reward and be more de-motivational to leveling IMHO. I'm not saying racial respecs should be a free or easy thing (except as compensation for rebalancing)... merely a possible thing... i dont care if you make the item that does it a rare purple/orange one... it at least provides some end-game thing to strive for. Forcing ppl back into mid/early-game grind just to mask the fact that EO's end-game is lacking is not the right solution (and yes there are ways to make end game more interesting even with limited resources EO already has, but thats a different topic)
No, they aren't, so get them to post! I was simply making a point that a lot of discord members disagreed. I did not say that they represent everyone, only that there was a discussion about it. I however, wanted people to POST here so we can discuss it. Otherwise it's obviously hard to make opinions without people giving them. If you have friends who agree with you in game, then POST it. I've linked this in a bcast before too in game. We can't formulate stuff if people don't contribute, and no matter one each person who replies here is just that, one person in a bigger pool.
Getting the community to contribute to discussion is the domain of the game developer, not me as player (i'm already trying to help you by posting, for what its bloody worth). I think you need to ask yourself why people arent posting. Again, i could be wrong and only representing my own view but let me give you some possible suggestions in my opinion. In order to write posts, collect statistical proof, collect logs, chat on discord etc (i.e. all the stuff you want from players to help you make decisions), a player actually has to have a certain amount of care factor. They have to feel invested in the game. They need to feel that previous posts actually were listened to or appreciated or mattered etc. They wont post if they have already lost faith/care in the game and largely quit/gone inactive (i've tried to voice some of their reasons why they've quit, but i cant get these ppl to come back and post - sorry). They wont post anymore if they feel like previous posts have been ignored (by you not responding, or by not garnering enough interest from the skewed sub-community of regular posters to warrant your attention as an actual issue). They wont post anymore if they feel immediately shut-down by you after expressing their feelings about something (e.g. when you immediately throw game formulas at people to say they are wrong rather than saying "thankyou for posting your feelings" and validating their value as participants in discussion).
If you were referring to a group of players being IG or on a 3rd party chat client, I don't relate to them at all or know who really is in any of the guilds/groups. I'm not really close to anyone and I keep it that way to prevent drama, and to attempt to be fair on others. Kind of like the warden job, but on an admin level.
This confirms my suspicions that you dont actually play your own game, which would explain why some of your opinions about things seem so disconnected to me (or sound like opinions that have been fed to you by certain vocal ppl). While i really admire your desire to do this to remain neutral, i do actually think you actually need to find a way to play your own game abit (incognito and without actually tipping game balance) so you can get some first-hand understanding of issues (and not lightly make statements like "they should just level said character too")... Otherwise, you seem to express some very strong opinions about what "feels right/wrong" and what "will/wont happen" (eg racial respecs would destroy leveling) without any first-hand experience of your own in leveling your own 25er, interacting with ppl who do and get bored/frustrated in the end-game and quit etc (yes, i know you would have done this in Rok, but as you know well EO is a different game). If you only learn from those who stick around and are willing to post (ie your regular customers) you most likely wont grow this game long term even with advertising... you need to learn from those who have left or are starting to lose interest and leave (which can only come about if you get down and dirty interacting with ppl like that TV show "undercover boss" rather than expecting these people to care enough to post on forums etc - cos let me tell you i post on forums and for the life of me most days i wonder why i still bother). I know you are usually too busy developing the game to invest time playing/play-testing it (and the whole community is very grateful for that), but i wonder if your investment in playing a little would result in a small sacrifice in the quantity/speed of development for a much better quality of developments when they do come.
I am not your friend, so i can give you this honest feedback without fear of offending you. I dont know why i care enough to still post, and im pretty close to not caring anymore, but i do genuinely wish you and EO success that far surpasses Rok. I have given you what i can, and its up to you how you care to use it. I genuinely mean it when i say "peace and good luck".
stuff
I'm not sure if this is viable or wanted, but how about an option to delevel a character and convert half of their exp into an exp scroll? This exp scroll would be class locked to prevent abuse
i.e. say someone jokingly told me to make a dwarf bard, and i got it to level 22 before i realised it was a trash character (this actually happened to someone)
I could potentially convert half of that exp into a scroll that was locked for use on a bard.
I think the class locking and halving the values would overcome any possibility of abusing this mechanic, but i could be missing something
This doesn't help with all the gear they'd have SBed, but it would provide an option for the time spent levelling at least
stuff
I'm not sure if this is viable or wanted, but how about an option to delevel a character and convert half of their exp into an exp scroll? This exp scroll would be class locked to prevent abuse
i.e. say someone jokingly told me to make a dwarf bard, and i got it to level 22 before i realised it was a trash character (this actually happened to someone)
I could potentially convert half of that exp into a scroll that was locked for use on a bard.
I think the class locking and halving the values would overcome any possibility of abusing this mechanic, but i could be missing something
This doesn't help with all the gear they'd have SBed, but it would provide an option for the time spent levelling at least
Maybe this would be a solution idk. I guess personally I enjoy leveling not just end game so it wouldn't bother me to relevel a character if needed (although stat changes seem very minimal). Skill and tactic seem more valuable.
I guess what bugs me is saying hawk doesn't care about the game or appreciate the players because he has the foresight to know that race changes are a bad idea. I'm not saying I'm a god of game Dev or design but I do this for a living (outside of ember) I support a family on game design so I must be doing something right? While it might be a short term solution it's not great overall for the game and that's pretty clear to me. It's his choice what he does with his game but from a semi professional game Dev viewpoint race changes are not ideal it leads to cookie cutter builds and overall less play and overall less interaction(less people leveling and playing the game). Now I can see some type of pp purchase or iap type thing down the road but giving one out every balance change just isn't smart. Especially when he's so focused on balance that he's doing changes every few months. You guys maybe forget rok where you were lucky to get a balance change every few years.
What about a race build so it's a glass cannon melee type. Many suggestions for mage type so what cha all think?
Personally, I dont care what the new changes are, as long as we get to change races.
I'm sure it's possible to make a script for a trainer in seamoor where you have a month or whatever to go to to use up a 1-per char token you get where it will modify your race and force stat reallocation. So you would go to the guy and say /d xxx change to Saurian and it kicks you, you log back on as Saurian and reallocate points.
With all of these major changes it would be horrible if a class you lvl'd with a specific purpose suddenly became sub-optimal for those purposes. It would be a very shitty way of forcing players to lvl new characters to be honest and could cause great distress among the player base.
I thought we were supposed to be out of alpha/beta testing by now so such drastic changes shouldn't hurt the playerbase.
Also, casual players will be more affected than the hardcore players.
P.S.: I think proposal #3 is the least intrusive as it mostly buffs races and weakens others in comparison, rather than actually directly nerfing any races.
I'm sure it's possible to make a script for a trainer in seamoor where you have a month or whatever to go to to use up a 1-per char token you get where it will modify your race and force stat reallocation. So you would go to the guy and say /d xxx change to Saurian and it kicks you, you log back on as Saurian and reallocate points.
With all of these major changes it would be horrible if a class you lvl'd with a specific purpose suddenly became sub-optimal for those purposes. It would be a very shitty way of forcing players to lvl new characters to be honest and could cause great distress among the player base.
I thought we were supposed to be out of alpha/beta testing by now so such drastic changes shouldn't hurt the playerbase.
Also, casual players will be more affected than the hardcore players.
P.S.: I think proposal #3 is the least intrusive as it mostly buffs races and weakens others in comparison, rather than actually directly nerfing any races.
I disagree that racial respec = everyone would have cookie cutters, as long as you have races with viable trade offs. Eg not everyone is a Horc slayer because there is a viable tradeoff in Saurians (some ppl rather big backstabs, others want to land more often). Its about presenting ppl with good choices, not punishing them for bad former ones.
Normally bad choices are to do 'mostly' with stats and not races. I know there have been some people who used the completely wrong race for the class (lets say a elemental slayer, doesn't exist, but that's an extreme. If anything, if something like this was 'introduced', it would be more like your account gets lets say, two free racial change points and you can change two classes rather then being able to change all your races. I don't think many bar maybe the first couple characters a player might create have issues, and I still don't think you should be able to racial change twenty 25'ers.
Personally, I dont care what the new changes are, as long as we get to change races.
I'm sure it's possible to make a script for a trainer in seamoor where you have a month or whatever to go to to use up a 1-per char token you get where it will modify your race and force stat reallocation. So you would go to the guy and say /d xxx change to Saurian and it kicks you, you log back on as Saurian and reallocate points.
With all of these major changes it would be horrible if a class you lvl'd with a specific purpose suddenly became sub-optimal for those purposes. It would be a very shitty way of forcing players to lvl new characters to be honest and could cause great distress among the player base.
I thought we were supposed to be out of alpha/beta testing by now so such drastic changes shouldn't hurt the playerbase.
What major changes are we talking about here? Saurians/HO are still going to be the goto for melee race without MR but bigger general bonuses. The other races aren't being changes to a point of being seriously effected. A script or bonus token is a better idea though to change your race is another thing, kinda like the monster pics, but that would be more of a earned thing rather than everyone gets one. I do need to make a way to force reallocation though atm.
I'm not sure if this is viable or wanted, but how about an option to delevel a character and convert half of their exp into an exp scroll? This exp scroll would be class locked to prevent abuse
The EXP scroll thing might be an option though. Kind of like retaining at least some XP for it. I would assume you would need specific amounts or maybe a full amount. I.E: using this scroll will remove all your XP/put you to level 1 and give you half the XP back as a scroll. I dunno about class locking though because if you class lock scrolls what's the point of using scrolls? You might as well allow racial reallocations but for a XP fee on the character similar to how it is now, just a heftier fee. That would be a possibility too, and maybe a better choice to prevent abuse. Or a mix of what a I talked about with ant above and racial reallocations costing XP.
What about a race build so it's a glass cannon melee type. Many suggestions for mage type so what cha all think?
I would probably refrain from adding new races until we figure out what to do with the current ones. I do want to eventually add a couple in betweeners but I think right now that would be a bad idea. Feel free to post on your ideas though, but be better in another thread so its not lost in these pages.
-------
Ok lets get another proposal example going. Check #5 now. <a class="postlink" href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15EUNEHza_TEiL4Qw-RofGVNX1mcBPQ0T9Ri8pB3EfXA/edit#gid=0">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... edit#gid=0</a>
You need to look at all races and think if they are viable in any situation or if they are being overshadowed in prop ¤5. Remember with stat points I will give out one or two allocation points too depending on what they get generally.
For a goblin example you can make a:
19/22/20/14/17/10 goblin OR
19/22/21/10/16/10 goblin with a +1, the +1 could go anywhere. But thats 16 wis without INT so not viable for paladins I'd say because lowering wis hurts goblins hugely for INT.
DE's can do:
20/22/19/15/20/12 DE OR
20/22/20/10/18/10 DE with +1.
This makes them kind of equal though, except that DE has a choice to be a paladin/etc too with still OK MR. Something like a 20/22/19/17/18/10 is an option for DE. This means that DE's will have a LITTLE better MR or equal if we lower the goblin bonus to 15%. Then plays racial bonuses. Obviously goblins get a -10 damage reduction to spells and poison reduction. Both have infra.
They seem kind of close to being both useful though at that point with the END? Goblins focused more as fighters with spell reduction and poison reduction and DEs more as magic fighters or wanting more search out, hide chance, better spell usage, etc. They'd be ok druids too probably. That's just me looking at it though, feel free to voice on it.
I am sorry.
Looking at this file, it seems like all races are becoming the "same" thing.
I do not like them.
(disclaimer: only race i care for are saurians, which arent affected)
Looking at this file, it seems like all races are becoming the "same" thing.
I do not like them.
(disclaimer: only race i care for are saurians, which arent affected)
I am sorry.
Looking at this file, it seems like all races are becoming the "same" thing.
I do not like them.
(disclaimer: only race i care for are saurians, which arent affected)
The thing is though, races should vary a little, but I don't think we should have 'extreme case' races. I think all the races even with a few stat points differences are still beneficial. Races need to be usable, not completely different. And when i say not completely different, I am not saying 100% SIMILAR too.
Half orcs still have high damage, Saurians are still a great melee class, elves are a good all rounder for magic. gnomes are good at heaviest damage but weaker HP. Yeah it only varies a few points here and there, but I still think it makes a difference and matters.
Obviously I am not saying that #5 is anything final, we can still use any of the proposals here, just voicing my say though too <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
I am sorry.
Looking at this file, it seems like all races are becoming the "same" thing.
I do not like them.
(disclaimer: only race i care for are saurians, which arent affected)
I'd have to agree somewhat here I don't think we are that far off and I feel like 5 is kinda changing the whole system. I know it's harder to keep balance with a wider range of stats but at the same time I think it's more interesting to play and more of a reason to create diff combos of Alts which is good for the life of the game.
My vote is for option 4. It has the least amount of change keeps the races diverse but most importantly addresses the biggest issues.
The dwarf thing is interesting on option 5 tho and I could go either way. I like that dwarf has something unique with its end but understand that creates somewhat of a bigger gap so if that needs to go into option 4 to make it stick I can agree with it.
I am sorry.
Looking at this file, it seems like all races are becoming the "same" thing.
I do not like them.
(disclaimer: only race i care for are saurians, which arent affected)
I'd have to agree somewhat here I don't think we are that far off and I feel like 5 is kinda changing the whole system. I know it's harder to keep balance with a wider range of stats but at the same time I think it's more interesting to play and more of a reason to create diff combos of Alts which is good for the life of the game.
My vote is for option 4. It has the least amount of change keeps the races diverse but most importantly addresses the biggest issues.
The dwarf thing is interesting on option 5 tho and I could go either way. I like that dwarf has something unique with its end but understand that creates somewhat of a bigger gap so if that needs to go into option 4 to make it stick I can agree with it.
Wider range and still usable need to go hand in hand though. Option 4 was adjusted just now though to reflect the dwarf changes since I think it is a good idea, to be honest.
I feel that in option 5 it would make more races useful in PVP/PVE too but if too many people disagree with it, I'll go with what most people feel is best at least for a trial. Would be nice to make it a one time change though as each change will upset players, obviously. Too minimize that we need to make sure it is 'what' best for all races and all races are usable.