← Forum archive

Race Stat Changes

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Eld
How about +1 str for DEs (or even +2 str)

Or some sort of racial trait
something to do with extra hiding or extra sneaking

extra 0.5% chance to dodge?
extra ac?
1% chance to perform a critical strike?
NiteHawk
How about +1 str for DEs (or even +2 str)

Or some sort of racial trait
something to do with extra hiding or extra sneaking

extra 0.5% chance to dodge?
extra ac?
1% chance to perform a critical strike?

+1 str makes it a pretty OPish saurian with MR. Prob bad idear. Extra AC maybe. Depends on what we doing with them.
NiteHawk
Am a fan of this for DE: 20 22 19 18 19 16

I don't think WIS needs to go down much, if at all really. It's just the INT that is making them the superior choice for priests that is the issue. You could even 20 22 19 17 20 16 to ensure their healing isn't over the top but they still have solid MR (logically they should have solid MR as they are a fighter race with "only" 20 str).

edit: as far as CHR I don't see people using them for rangers unless CHR is at 20 or above, and that's a pretty sizable bump. My cav is 10 CHR, it's not exactly required for them.



Just pointing tis out: Problem with this is:

19 22 20 17 17 14

for -1 str you get 1 end. Making it not really different so much cause Wisdom is about the same with the MR bonus.

Honestly without bumping everything END wise Des probably should keep same stats but maybe some sort of bonus. That or it needs to be something like 20/22/19/18/20/16 but that still makes them pretty good overall, though with some magic tweaks would prob be better to go with a 20int+ race. thing is when you look at HEs its 19 21 19 20 20 21 vs 20/22/19/18/20/16 and I think for only two INT difference you get alot more meaning there is 0 reason to make a HE in most cases now, as guardians/etc are probably better with DEs. We might wanna focus instead on racial bonuses on this one. Generally this is why option #10 worked better in terms of keeping the HP more in check because you cant just modify DEs without it hurting others, meaning you need to bump up HEs. If you bump up HEs, you need to bump up elves and humans. its finkay. Option #10 has it issues too though.
Lateralus
Am a fan of this for DE: 20 22 19 18 19 16

I don't think WIS needs to go down much, if at all really. It's just the INT that is making them the superior choice for priests that is the issue. You could even 20 22 19 17 20 16 to ensure their healing isn't over the top but they still have solid MR (logically they should have solid MR as they are a fighter race with "only" 20 str).

edit: as far as CHR I don't see people using them for rangers unless CHR is at 20 or above, and that's a pretty sizable bump. My cav is 10 CHR, it's not exactly required for them.



Just pointing tis out: Problem with this is:

19 22 20 17 17 14

for -1 str you get 1 end. Making it not really different so much cause Wisdom is about the same with the MR bonus.

Honestly without bumping everything END wise Des probably should keep same stats but maybe some sort of bonus. That or it needs to be something like 20/22/19/18/20/16 but that still makes them pretty good overall, though with some magic tweaks would prob be better to go with a 20int+ race. thing is when you look at HEs its 19 21 19 20 20 21 vs 20/22/19/18/20/16 and I think for only two INT difference you get alot more meaning there is 0 reason to make a HE in most cases now, as guardians/etc are probably better with DEs. We might wanna focus instead on racial bonuses on this one. Generally this is why option #10 worked better in terms of keeping the HP more in check because you cant just modify DEs without it hurting others, meaning you need to bump up HEs. If you bump up HEs, you need to bump up elves and humans. its finkay. Option #10 has it issues too though.


Yea I think just keeping them the same is the most simple solution. You wont have people complaining because they have to change their sorc/necros/druids if there is an int nerf either.

Leave them at 18end and maybe give them a pool point or 2 or some kinda minor racial? DE really are not in a bad place I own a few and they do ok at melee and healers. I think if we can get this last race figured out we are very close to having this done and things set hopefully.
Folder
Am a fan of this for DE: 20 22 19 18 19 16

I don't think WIS needs to go down much, if at all really. It's just the INT that is making them the superior choice for priests that is the issue. You could even 20 22 19 17 20 16 to ensure their healing isn't over the top but they still have solid MR (logically they should have solid MR as they are a fighter race with "only" 20 str).

edit: as far as CHR I don't see people using them for rangers unless CHR is at 20 or above, and that's a pretty sizable bump. My cav is 10 CHR, it's not exactly required for them.



Just pointing tis out: Problem with this is:

19 22 20 17 17 14

for -1 str you get 1 end. Making it not really different so much cause Wisdom is about the same with the MR bonus.

Honestly without bumping everything END wise Des probably should keep same stats but maybe some sort of bonus. That or it needs to be something like 20/22/19/18/20/16 but that still makes them pretty good overall, though with some magic tweaks would prob be better to go with a 20int+ race. thing is when you look at HEs its 19 21 19 20 20 21 vs 20/22/19/18/20/16 and I think for only two INT difference you get alot more meaning there is 0 reason to make a HE in most cases now, as guardians/etc are probably better with DEs. We might wanna focus instead on racial bonuses on this one. Generally this is why option #10 worked better in terms of keeping the HP more in check because you cant just modify DEs without it hurting others, meaning you need to bump up HEs. If you bump up HEs, you need to bump up elves and humans. its finkay. Option #10 has it issues too though.



I could be the minority but I actually think 1 str and 1 end are very competitive stats. There is definitely a decision to be made between them, especially on classes with damage multipliers. I think it's fine to keep them at 18 end and consider a racial bonus (but what bonus lol?), I just didn't want to see them overshadow other 20 int races as casters.

and offtopic really but 10 CHR on a knight is really pretty fine if the base is 7.5%. Dumping 6-10+ points to get 7.5% DR is a no no imo. Fite me Chris.
Styx
Elf has int, dark elf does not, take the hit on int on dark elf so we can continue , giving dark elf a DE entry chance at becoming a melee class
NiteHawk
Am a fan of this for DE: 20 22 19 18 19 16

I don't think WIS needs to go down much, if at all really. It's just the INT that is making them the superior choice for priests that is the issue. You could even 20 22 19 17 20 16 to ensure their healing isn't over the top but they still have solid MR (logically they should have solid MR as they are a fighter race with "only" 20 str).

edit: as far as CHR I don't see people using them for rangers unless CHR is at 20 or above, and that's a pretty sizable bump. My cav is 10 CHR, it's not exactly required for them.



Just pointing tis out: Problem with this is:

19 22 20 17 17 14

for -1 str you get 1 end. Making it not really different so much cause Wisdom is about the same with the MR bonus.

Honestly without bumping everything END wise Des probably should keep same stats but maybe some sort of bonus. That or it needs to be something like 20/22/19/18/20/16 but that still makes them pretty good overall, though with some magic tweaks would prob be better to go with a 20int+ race. thing is when you look at HEs its 19 21 19 20 20 21 vs 20/22/19/18/20/16 and I think for only two INT difference you get alot more meaning there is 0 reason to make a HE in most cases now, as guardians/etc are probably better with DEs. We might wanna focus instead on racial bonuses on this one. Generally this is why option #10 worked better in terms of keeping the HP more in check because you cant just modify DEs without it hurting others, meaning you need to bump up HEs. If you bump up HEs, you need to bump up elves and humans. its finkay. Option #10 has it issues too though.



I could be the minority but I actually think 1 str and 1 end are very competitive stats. There is definitely a decision to be made between them, especially on classes with damage multipliers. I think it's fine to keep them at 18 end and consider a racial bonus (but what bonus lol?), I just didn't want to see them overshadow other 20 int races as casters.

and offtopic really but 10 CHR on a knight is really pretty fine if the base is 7.5%. Dumping 6-10+ points to get 7.5% DR is a no no imo. Fite me Chris.


It's kinda based on if you wanna tank or not. In PVE though it might work better in the near future giving more bonuses in PVE. Don't think in PVP it should go higher unless it starts alot lower. lets say only 2.5% and goes up to 15% or something making it more useful. 15% is quite alot for PVP reasons. In PVE I could see double.

For the DEs they could do with maybe armor or something to differate themselves a little. 4 armor for example to start.

Unfort I think giving DE's +1 end makes other races completely worthless and you need to balance the whole lot. It's an issue IMO and without boosting those races too I don't think DE's should get that.

<a class="postlink" href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15EUNEHza_TEiL4Qw-RofGVNX1mcBPQ0T9Ri8pB3EfXA/edit#gid=0">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... edit#gid=0</a>

Based on the bonuses now take a look and see what people think and feel about what they should get with current bonuses.
Styx
Will there be a 21 end race. I've seen it brought up about humans being possibly 21 end. This would give a wider spectrum of possible end choices
Lateralus
Yea I think they are fine with an extra pool and or a bonus. I wish we could give them something other than armor since 2 other races already get that but not sure what to give?

I know we don't wanna give them more power as a healer so less Fiz is prob out.

Maybe 1-2 hit rate or dodge rate although I know you'd just rather have agi act.

1% crit sounds messy when dealing with other crit stuff

Could do like a 2-4 physical damage reduction like dwarf have spell reduction of 10. That kinda makes healers better tho.

Could do like at night or underground 2% more damage.

Could just give them that extra 1 pool stat and bump their chr up to 18 allowing them to stack higher chr hp / mp bonus and make knights a bit better and a long shot ranger.

Maybe more hp recovery like suggested.

Maybe a search and hide bonus?



Just some ideas to work with.
Dan
About INT mattering more for healing, i thought there should be a minimum number to get decent healer, like we have with CHR vs Pet stats for rangers.

It could not exactly be those numbers, but should be enough to fighting races sacrifice some physical to be able to heal.

Like this (INT/amount of healing):

14 = 30%
15 = 55%
16 = 70%
17 = 85%
18 = 100%
19 = 104%
20 = 108%
21 = 112%
22 = 116%

Regarding Dark Elves, 19 END i think is fine, i don't see a reason to give them AC (like are they hard skinned?), maybe a small dodge bonus would be nice.

And humans definetly need some love, i would give them 21 END and another 1-2 alloc points. They should be that versatile. Maybe give HE 1 more alloc point too.
NiteHawk
Yea I think they are fine with an extra pool and or a bonus. I wish we could give them something other than armor since 2 other races already get that but not sure what to give?

I know we don't wanna give them more power as a healer so less Fiz is prob out.

Maybe 1-2 hit rate or dodge rate although I know you'd just rather have agi act.

1% crit sounds messy when dealing with other crit stuff

Could do like a 2-4 physical damage reduction like dwarf have spell reduction of 10. That kinda makes healers better tho.

Could do like at night or underground 2% more damage.

Could just give them that extra 1 pool stat and bump their chr up to 18 allowing them to stack higher chr hp / mp bonus and make knights a bit better and a long shot ranger.

Maybe more hp recovery like suggested.

Maybe a search and hide bonus?

Just some ideas to work with.


Search/hide bonus probably really does nothing and might be weird skillset as it only benefits some classes and not all. Not sure how I feel about that. I don't think they should get spell reduction because goblins get it, and it makes them very similar and we should try to space these races out a bit. Agreed with extra crit, also specific to classes too which is meh.

1 pool and 2 char is OK, it doesn't make them completely good just by doing that but it would help out a little. HP recovery is okay. HR and DR make no sense and if you give them that anyways you shadow making a ling so that is probably a bad idea too.

I think honestly they aren't terrible with the HP boost that they will still get. If you look at saurians vs them, they are quite similar. I don't think they need much to be honest. We might be looking at this incorrectly because we also have adjusted other races too.

I made changes to #11, check them out now. I think we are fairly close.

----

About INT mattering more for healing...


INT needs to have a linear scale, having a random scale that changes based on int point is often confusing to people and can be problematic. But again that should be posted elsewhere, we 'do' need to talk about magic scaling but it's going to be lost here and we're in to deep to change topics, need to focus on this one 8)

DE's with 19 END overshadow a couple races as it stands though. To be honest I think it's okay and I think we can probably test it out soon.


Will there be a 21 end race. I've seen it brought up about humans being possibly 21 end. This would give a wider spectrum of possible end choices


Not with the HP formula changes. Changing the HP formula plus giving HE/Humans END too is too much.
Folder
I think #11 is looking good and agree on DE's not really needing much else. Compared to Ling you get +2 str at the cost of 1 agi, a fair tradeoff.

I don't think DE needs anything else after looking at it all more closely, unless it's just a minor thing and mostly for flavor.

Is it safe to assume every race that has allocation points changed will get a respec?
Eld
Bit concerned these changes are going to make halflings a bit OP in comparison to half elf/human/etc. especially with the agi stat getting a bit of a boost.

The only classes you tend to use half elf/human/etc. for atm is cleric, paladin, bard and maybe ranger and sorc/necro.

Halfling will now be best for all of these.
10,23,19,20,20,11 OR 10,24,18,20,20,11 for cleric/sorc/necro just seems to be much better than other combinations available.

Halfling will also make Elves useless for bards/rangers due to having the same str/end/chr, but having higher agi.


I'll try to do a comparison in a short while of what would be the best options for different classes if #11 is implemented, but it does seem to be wonky to me
Folder
Lings are perhaps outshadowing elves for rangers/bards, but I mean I don't think we achieve 100% every-race-is-equal here. You could knock ling down 1 CHR to even that out, if desired.

For other classes:
18 23 18 20 20 22 Ling

vs

19 21 19 20 20 21 Half elf

We are giving up 2 AGI for 1 END. This is debatable imo, but I think it's close enough that this does not make lings instantly better than half elves for caster classes. I'd still pick half elf here but I will say that halfling makes a good enough choice now. I think that's the goal though!

Still going to pick elf or gnome for casters as well, I don't really feel the extra AGI outweighs losing INT.
Lateralus
Bit concerned these changes are going to make halflings a bit OP in comparison to half elf/human/etc. especially with the agi stat getting a bit of a boost.

The only classes you tend to use half elf/human/etc. for atm is cleric, paladin, bard and maybe ranger and sorc/necro.

Halfling will now be best for all of these.
10,23,19,20,20,11 OR 10,24,18,20,20,11 for cleric/sorc/necro just seems to be much better than other combinations available.

Halfling will also make Elves useless for bards/rangers due to having the same str/end/chr, but having higher agi.


I'll try to do a comparison in a short while of what would be the best options for different classes if #11 is implemented, but it does seem to be wonky to me


I wouldnt take halfling sorc or necro over elf of half elf I dont think most would. As for cleric I think id still favor elf for more int/mana pool with pretty much the same stats 1 agi isnt a huge deal. its only getting buffed .25% I highly doubt anyone will even notice the changes between 22 and 23 agi. Maybe between 19agi and 24agi but even then its 1.25%? again not a huge deal.


As for rangers and bards yea they might be better than elf and half elf but half elf and elf are better at sorc and necro so i dont think its a huge deal? I think drake is the best ranger anyways so halfling pretty much has best bard going for it. I dont think thats that bad.

Note: I have 0 halflings so no stake in them just looking for balance.
NiteHawk
Lings are perhaps outshadowing elves for rangers/bards, but I mean I don't think we achieve 100% every-race-is-equal here. You could knock ling down 1 CHR to even that out, if desired.

For other classes:
18 23 18 20 20 22 Ling

vs

19 21 19 20 20 21 Half elf

We are giving up 2 AGI for 1 END. This is debatable imo, but I think it's close enough that this does not make lings instantly better than half elves for caster classes. I'd still pick half elf here but I will say that halfling makes a good enough choice now. I think that's the goal though!

Still going to pick elf or gnome for casters as well, I don't really feel the extra AGI outweighs losing INT.


We need to see how magic works per INT point too, with healing etc, it probably can spike a little but I don't think it's too far off what ti should be now, but that will prob be done when we work weapons into magic damage.


Anyways, let's try to get this wrapped up. I think we are close here anyways.
Styx
I love lingd, gnomes and goblins. Why, back in the day I had to have small people to do oads, otherwise I would have only had 20 end plus. More life so I could do pvp stuff. But to reiterate. We had small people races only for certain oads. And if we do the small races then we better keep it going.
Dan
About proposal #11

I feel like taking away one alloc point for Saurians and Drakes is a bit too much a nerf.

They already have small MR, reducing their END is not enough?
FrostSlayer
I'm not sure if this is the right place to ask, but with all of the stat changes flying around I figured it would be ok. How does the natural AC of some races interact with absorb and deflect mechanics? Does it only affect absorb chances, or is it both, or does it only apply as a physical damage reduction percentage? I was always wondering this and thought I would ask. Thanks.
Lateralus
About proposal #11

I feel like taking away one alloc point for Saurians and Drakes is a bit too much a nerf.

They already have small MR, reducing their END is not enough?


Well when they lose and end they will have an extra point pretty much.

Right now lizard can build a 22 23 19 10 14 10
After the change they will b 22 23 18 10 14 10 (with losing an end and allocation point)

I guess I could see them keeping an allocation but really on lizard what are you going to do? Toss it in int?

Same with drake even if you go 12wis 14chr you don't gain and hp just mp.


That said I don't think it would hurt them keeping the allocation point since they lost an end I just don't think it makes a big deal.