← Forum archive

Shared Experience

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
Shared EXP should be okay to do I think. It's been talked about in the past and was just brought up again. I think EXP needs to be split depending on how many people are in the party, not a set EXP. But there is a few ways we can do this. I also think that only killshot needs to be split. Per hit is useless to split because it will reward people who are active more then just afk sitting... So:

Per killshot:
Idea 1:
Solo: 100% EXP
Two Members. 75% EXP
Three Members: 50% Exp
Four Members and up: 25% Exp

Idea 2:
Solo: 100% EXP
Two Members and up. 50% EXP

Idea 3:
Solo: 100% EXP
Two Members. 70% EXP
Three Members: 50% Exp
Four Members and up: 30% Exp


I think four members and up it will be okay to cap it from lowering any further. I don't think we need to go too low. But I'd prefer option 3 I think above all.

Also take note that when your mob gets the kilshot, it also adds to your EXP.
Lateralus
I think option 3 is good but there needs to be something in place to prevent it from being taken advantage of.


Idk what's to stop a level 5 from joining a level 25 and just sitting in the party getting power leveled on level 25 monsters?

Maybe like shared experience only works if everyone is within 4-5 levels of each other in the party? All members need to tag the monster?

Just spitting ideas because this seems very very easy to abuse
Kawasaki
The game I played before the monster had to be within so many levels of you in order to get any experience. Maybe something like that? If you are level 10 the monster has to be under level 20?
Lateralus
The game I played before the monster had to be within so many levels of you in order to get any experience. Maybe something like that? If you are level 10 the monster has to be under level 20?



Yea I like that idea id maybe even say 5? i mean its still going to be easy to abuse with shared exp but atleast it wont be super power leveling. I mean still whats to stop a level 5 from joining with a level 25 while the level 25 runs through a level 10 area just killing all the monsters super fast.

party exp is just something that can be easily abused without a ton of blocks.
NiteHawk
No worries, I have an idea for it that will base it on the killers level and players level. After a few levels (5-6) The exp wouldn't be worth the higher level killing it.

It's similar to how if you kill a mob higher level then you, you lose out on EXP.
alvarlux
Shared EXP should be okay to do I think. It's been talked about in the past and was just brought up again. I think EXP needs to be split depending on how many people are in the party, not a set EXP. But there is a few ways we can do this. I also think that only killshot needs to be split. Per hit is useless to split because it will reward people who are active more then just afk sitting... So:

Per killshot:
Idea 1:
Solo: 100% EXP
Two Members. 75% EXP
Three Members: 50% Exp
Four Members and up: 25% Exp

Idea 2:
Solo: 100% EXP
Two Members and up. 50% EXP

Idea 3:
Solo: 100% EXP
Two Members. 70% EXP
Three Members: 50% Exp
Four Members and up: 30% Exp


I think four members and up it will be okay to cap it from lowering any further. I don't think we need to go too low. But I'd prefer option 3 I think above all.

Also take note that when your mob gets the kilshot, it also adds to your EXP.


I'm all for EXP Share and making leveling a bit less grueling, but these numbers seem a bit too generous.

Remember that with a party you are killing monsters significantly faster then normal - 2x, 3x, etc. You already get that advantage as a multiplier. Not to mention, added abilities/support functions, protection aspects from random PK etc.

Based on Idea 3, from the perspective of each monster - you are making each worth 140%, 150%, >120%. If we are using the formula from RoK for monster exp values, KS was the most valuable part.

This is so far in favor of a leveling party, it's almost punishing solo play. I'm going to invite randoms in the arena to my party with this because it's more valuable then fighting by myself.

This should be a "nice to have" rather then "essential for leveling" - so you should be break even or even losing some, relying on the party multiplier to make up the difference and provide value. Maybe allow for a slight bonus for 3+ parties because they are going to be harder to put together with no alts, and also to account for less hit exp with larger groups.

Idea 4:
Solo: 100%
Two Members: 50%
Three Members: 35%
Four Members and up: 30%
NiteHawk
That's correct, I want to promote leveling together however. 70% might be too much, maybe 60% with two players. But I do want it to be higher then just halved, people leveling and interacting because it is a better trade off will make the game last longer and people will enjoy it rather then tavern sitting. You get bored leveling and at only 50% theres is no point to party.
alvarlux
That's correct, I want to promote leveling together however. 70% might be too much, maybe 60% with two players. But I do want it to be higher then just halved, people leveling and interacting because it is a better trade off will make the game last longer and people will enjoy it rather then tavern sitting. You get bored leveling and at only 50% theres is no point to party.


i would argue that people ended up tavern sitting more after they finished leveling, so making that go faster is not great. But you've already stated you plan on doing more "End Game" content so that's probably fine.

If we are encouraging parties, we should leave it heavier on the high groups, so I propose:

Idea 5:
Solo: 100%
Two Members: 60%
Three Members: 45%
Four Members and up: 35%

which translate to each monster being worth: 100%, 120%, 135%, >140%
thirdchris
The key here is increased social activity. Something that had become stagnant in the previous iteration. In fact, at least for me, it was annoying to share mobs with other players while leveling. Aside from say, the tulip. I think the player should be rewarded for leveling together. This may also help keep the PK factor of the game alive.

One thing to keep in mind here is that the difficulty of mobs can be significantly increased over what it used to be. With an actual programmer, new mechanics can be introduced to keep fights actually challenging, especially through the use of status effects, perhaps. I'd reward group activity and give bonus exp to parties, not reductions.
Satsujin
I agree with 3C, if we're trying to encourage party leveling, we should probably offer some kind of bonus to level appropriate party kills instead of splitting it. 10-20% more experience per party member or something,


Something else that needs to be considered is shared gold. If whoever gets the KS is the only one who gets the gold, then you further discourage partying, because then there's a chance you don't make any gold leveling, which means you can't buy levels, spells, whatever else you need to keep leveling. Sure, you could say have an agreement to split it down the middle before you leave town, but that relies on the honor system. And if there's anything we've learned from ROK in the past, it's that expecting people to follow the buddy system is laughable at best. Split the gold alongside the experience and boom, problem solved.

...Unless your leveling partner decides to stab you in the back/have a friend or guildie stab you in the back/is a thief secretly robbing you while you're spamming attacks and not noticing. The solution there is stab them back.
Rodeo
I figured the gold would just auto split. Another thi ng to think about is sellable drops selling those and splitting the gold from those aswell.
NiteHawk
Here is the simple formula I made up (sharing is in game but it's set atm, got this that I just modified now:)

(1.2 + (PartyCount * 0.5)) / PartyCount


It's a simple formula, the values would be as follows:

2 people in party = 65% experience per person (130% total experience)
3 people in party = 45% experience per person (135% total experience)
4 people in party = 35% experience per person (140% total experience)
5 people in party = 29% experience per person (145% total experience)


It might go higher or lower, but I think it's pretty fair so far. Only applies to current party members in square as well, obviously.

NPCs in your party also give experience, at 80%. This is also applied to the party formula too (So would be something like ((1.2 + (PartyCount * 0.5)) / PartyCount) * .8 . Only kill shots.


You can already test sharing in game, though. it just doesn't adjust after 5 people at the moment.
alvarlux
Here is the simple formula I made up (sharing is in game but it's set atm, got this that I just modified now:)

(1.2 + (PartyCount * 0.5)) / PartyCount


It's a simple formula, the values would be as follows:

2 people in party = 65% experience per person (130% total experience)
3 people in party = 45% experience per person (135% total experience)
4 people in party = 35% experience per person (140% total experience)
5 people in party = 29% experience per person (145% total experience)


It might go higher or lower, but I think it's pretty fair so far. Only applies to current party members in square as well, obviously.

NPCs in your party also give experience, at 80%. This is also applied to the party formula too (So would be something like ((1.2 + (PartyCount * 0.5)) / PartyCount) * .8 . Only kill shots.


You can already test sharing in game, though. it just doesn't adjust after 5 people at the moment.


Couple questions for testing:

Do NPC's count towards PartyCount? [i'm assuming no?]
Does shared exp scale with level? [i believe this was already mentioned and is yes]
Does scaling happen based on amount received on KS, or against base monster?

Example Math:
Party has 2 members - lvl 20 (Player A), lvl 22 (Player B)
Monster is lvl 21 - KS value is 100

Monster is killed by Player A - base monster shared:
Player A receives: (100 * 0.65) * 1.10 = 71.5 exp
Player B receives: (100 * 0.65) * 0.75 = 48.75 exp

Monster is killed by Player A - KS shared:
Player A receives: (100 * 0.65) * 1.10 = 71.5
Player B receives: ((100 * 0.65) * 1.10) * 0.75 = 53.625 exp
NiteHawk
Here is the simple formula I made up (sharing is in game but it's set atm, got this that I just modified now:)

(1.2 + (PartyCount * 0.5)) / PartyCount


It's a simple formula, the values would be as follows:

2 people in party = 65% experience per person (130% total experience)
3 people in party = 45% experience per person (135% total experience)
4 people in party = 35% experience per person (140% total experience)
5 people in party = 29% experience per person (145% total experience)


It might go higher or lower, but I think it's pretty fair so far. Only applies to current party members in square as well, obviously.

NPCs in your party also give experience, at 80%. This is also applied to the party formula too (So would be something like ((1.2 + (PartyCount * 0.5)) / PartyCount) * .8 . Only kill shots.


You can already test sharing in game, though. it just doesn't adjust after 5 people at the moment.


Couple questions for testing:

Do NPC's count towards PartyCount? [i'm assuming no?]
Does shared exp scale with level? [i believe this was already mentioned and is yes]
Does scaling happen based on amount received on KS, or against base monster?

Example Math:
Party has 2 members - lvl 20 (Player A), lvl 22 (Player B)
Monster is lvl 21 - KS value is 100

Monster is killed by Player A - base monster shared:
Player A receives: (100 * 0.65) * 1.10 = 71.5 exp
Player B receives: (100 * 0.65) * 0.75 = 48.75 exp

Monster is killed by Player A - KS shared:
Player A receives: (100 * 0.65) * 1.10 = 71.5
Player B receives: ((100 * 0.65) * 1.10) * 0.75 = 53.625 exp


NPCs do not count towards party count.

EXP is also cut depending on player level difference that is correct. A player can be one level higher or level before experience loss starts taken into effect, and after 4 levels or so it's not worth it. It also goes further if the monster is lower level too, so you'll typically want to try to level with people +2/-2 you (maybe +3/-3).

If a lower level player kills a mob, the exp passed to a higher level player is never over 100% (obviously not 100%, gotta factor in the party experience reduction etc).

Shared EXP is only the slay experience, not the per point experience.
Rodeo
you da man. on behalf of the people who always wished DM gave a shit, thanks for listening.


<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Kenichi
Make this shared experience toggle via a command for example.

/psharedexp
/pnoshared


/party

Status: Shared Experience
Member 1
Member 2
Member 3

/pnoshared
/party
Status: Killshot Experience.
Member 1
Member 2
Member 3