← Forum archive

[impressions] Battle system

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

tangar
Overall, I like Ember Online very much. This game has the most friendly UI (among MUDs) which I saw. It make playing this MUD very big pleasure.

Also I love the world, locations, setting, lore, classes and races... It's all very well done.

But I see some parts of gameplay which could be improved IMHO. And the most crucial is Battle system of some classes.

I like general battle concept very much - that there is certain time for a turn and you have some time between turns to understand whats going on. It's made very nice. But... battle itself is too repetive and at certain point become boring.

Of course, game has to have different classes. Some of them has to be more straightforward and easy to play, some has to be more complex. But currently there is too much 'one-click' fights, at least in PvE (I didn't try PvP yet... almost) - it looks like 'clicker-game' sometimes.

I suggest to add more skills to some classes. For example, I play sorcerer, lvl 15. I got 1 skill to attack,1 summon, 1 buff. Soon I'll have also 1 debuff (str). To tell the truth - it's not much. In general I have to 1-click all fights. Of course, it's not graphical MMORPG like WoW, where we could have 20+ skills, but at least it would be fun to have different attack skills. 1 AoE, 1 DoT, 1 spike damage, 1 control skill (interupt or stun) . I heard that AoE system isn't there yet, but then it could be different spike damage skills. Example:
1) 'Explosition' spell. After cast it do nothing, but at second (or third?) turn it make 1.5x damage of Blast
2) 'Strike' - it takes 2 stamina to cast it; it makes 2.5x damage of Blast.
3) 'Thunderstorm' - make 0.5 damage of Blast and mini-stun target (-1 stamina for 1 turn)
4) 'Slow time' - debuff, reducing (-1) 'stamina' for certain time
5) 'Elemental shield' - each time when enemy hits you, he takes certain amount of damage

Some of the most powerful spells could have cooldown (time to wait before next cast), so they wouldn't be harassed too often.

It's just an example, if it's good ideas, I'll be glad to participate in brainstorm and try to polish this concept.

Main idea - it would be fun to have more options in battle, to think and decide - which option to choose. It would make game _really_ perfect.

I understand that it's hard to balance a lot of skills... But it's very essential thing IMHO, to have more options in fights.

Now I'm rerolling to necro, cause at least necromancers has DoT skill, so it would be a bit more action around... But actually I like sorcerer magic more and I'm kinda forced to merge to another class to have more dynamic gameplay. And considering necro - I heard that it's mainly Rot+Leech rotation. Why not to make Beam also useful if you don't need heal atm, so it would make more damage then Leech? It would give some more choice...

Thanks for an attention,
Kind regards,
Tangar
Eld
Very good post, great feedback.
I like the sound of all these skills and they could all be worthwhile.

I also agree with the sentiment that we could do with more skills in battle, but you've rounded it out with some good suggestions.

As mentioned in Discord, i think the main game developer (Nitehawk) is on holiday until Tuesday, but he usually loves these well thought out feedback posts, especially from new players.

I hope you continue to play and contribute feedback!
Styx
The aoe and dot can become very over powered. And if you check out the forums all the racial stats we are in debate on balance issues

I like the idea of aoe and dot for all classes. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mrgreen.gif" alt=":mrgreen:" title="Mr. Green" />
NiteHawk
Once we get the current spells/attacks balanced we'll see about adding new spells slowly. I'm all for stuff like that anyways on spell casters.

The time slow is a pretty good once though, pretty much reverse haste. Might be a neat thing to have.
Sicx
Yep. Said most of this on Discord. We talked. Agreed on all parts


Sicx - Today at 3:54 PM
I wasn't
During the mosh
After watching tangars videos I've been trying to think how we can improve combat
Which was why I was saying we need more skills
tangar - Today at 3:56 PM
I'm writing message at forum about it atm :smiley:
Sicx - Today at 3:56 PM
lol.
:clap:
This simplistic combat works for us old schoolers...
But we're not going to get many new people coming in
We need skill set ups, etc.
Use this skill, then this skill, then this skill to achieve maximum DPS.
Not just 1 button wars.
We need Stun locks.
Bleed affects
We need more ailments
Paralysis
Confusion
Folder

We need Stun locks.
Paralysis


No <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_evil.gif" alt=":evil:" title="Evil or Very Mad" />

All other stuff good.
Terron
slow time would be funny if everyone just replenished half stamina or the mage sets aside 1 stamina for the duration and everyone else regens -1 aswell. reason i said half is -1 makes monks even better than they already are and cripples slayers unless they can regen normal off square.

and yeah i agree with necro needing a higher damage spell outside of leech. like negative energy ray or something. leech should do lowest damage and regen close to the same hps it does in damage. necro is one of my favorites, i just dont like that healing your zombie is a pain and usually less efficient to just re-summons.


no stun locks, dont want a game where u cant even leave town w/o a group of 4. because 3-6 people stun you endlessly

i wouldnt mind a root spell that breaks when u leave square draining 2 stamina. just prevents running away on 1 stam.

Druidguy calls upon the forest!

Roots and Vines grow up beneath you Rooting you in place.

bob is a blah blah blah he looks blah blah, He is Rooted.
Folder
Just not a fan of stun locks and abilities that make you lose control of your character. They have no place in a game that is designed to be relatively simple imo.

Roots and more spells in general are great though.
Sicx
The problem with that is people don't like relatively simple games anymore. So either we start getting with the program or the genre dies. The largest MUDs today have intricate battle systems, mini-games, etc.

We've over here like, huh, we don't need no mini game, let's do a Str vs Agi check. Awesome, done and done.

Hence our player retention.
Terron
grasping vines on nm had flaws tho, it could be healed and hit by anyone, was weak to machetes etc. i think it should just drain stamina to break it by moving. so u can move with 2 not 1 or something.


The problem with that is people don't like relatively simple games anymore. So either we start getting with the program or the genre dies. The largest MUDs today have intricate battle systems, mini-games, etc.

We've over here like, huh, we don't need no mini game, let's do a Str vs Agi check. Awesome, done and done.

Hence our player retention.


i beg to differ i see 1000s of people that just tap screens as fast as they can for points and millions of people play hatch an egg feed a pet games.

which muds have u played that dont have simplistic combat? ive tried almost every one in the top 100 and they all seem basic to me. more skills spells and areas but still basic.

this game wont compete with a graphic MMO w/o some kind of phone/tablet client. and to even achieve that the game cant be so difficult it cant fit on a single screen, like alot of muds that use java etc.

im not saying the combat cant be better, cuz it can. just ember is like at the newborn stage lol lets take it 1 diaper at a time
NiteHawk
The problem with that is people don't like relatively simple games anymore. So either we start getting with the program or the genre dies. The largest MUDs today have intricate battle systems, mini-games, etc.

We've over here like, huh, we don't need no mini game, let's do a Str vs Agi check. Awesome, done and done.

Hence our player retention.


I think you're confusing complexity with fun though. A lot of players who play the game aren't savvies and just want a game that's easy to follow. If they can't understand a game within the first hour most people give up and leave. It doesn't mean you have to teach them everything in that first hour obviously, and we don't in EO either, but if the game has to be easy to follow. Adding spells just adds another level of combat or a way to deal with things, but it doesn't need to be a whole lot more complex when it comes to the way things are dealt with. Yeah we could do with time slow spells, bleed effects, and some other ailments though. The way it's done though doesn't need to be complex to be enjoyable though. Yeah, mini games could be a thing for certain things though, but it needs to work text based too as most things do in the game right now. (Not saying it couldn't be some sort of display like you have there but there also needs to be an alternate way via text.)

I think the biggest issue with player retention is there is nothing to do just of yet. Games can be as complex as they want but once you have the best gear and level 25ers it doesn't matter how complex your game is, you'll lose players pretty fast.

On top of that the second issue is visibility, as Terron said people are literally playing games that involve clicking rapidly for little gain, or literally IDLING a game to achieve something. The reason is pretty simple, it's easy to deal with on your phone, tablet, on the web, etc. If you get a overly complex game that can't be played on a tablet then you'll lose players too. I almost bet if we had a facebook client, steam support where we were visible, and tablet client we could double our numbers pretty fast. The reason why I don't do this yet is because retention is tougher until we get more interesting things to do. The guild wars/etc system is a start though. Things like fishing, foraging, crafting, even the texas hold em poker, and other things could be a well addition too to prolong the end game content too.

I fully believe if we had the current combat system but with way more things to do with end game content alot more people would be happy right now. I'm not saying we aren't going to add spells, balance, etc, all I'm saying is that I don't think it's the reason why people leave the game on a normal case.


this game wont compete with a graphic MMO...


Very true, and I don't think we will ever, or are meant to be. However there's a big difference too. MMOs of that level probably need 5k+ players minimum in order to be successful. Maybe more. Depends on their world size I guess but often they are huge. I would be happy at least to start if we could pull 60 to 100 members on at all times at least to start. It's pretty achievable but yeah, we obviously need more support. Even once we release all this end game content it won't help bring in new players.. That would be where working on visibility starts, and that would be things like tablet clients, the new universal client, fb client, things like that as I said. Not many know we exist, but once we get more things going we'll attempt to solve that.
Terron
yeah i mean a game like this could get 1000s of players if it has the content. sadly the effort needed to be put in is about 100x as much as a gfx mmo. you need 10x the areas because u can run through them in 25 nsew's where as it takes several minutes to run through each area on an mmo. you need longevity crafts, for better potions, embers gear etc. ember gets better with each implement. TY for that.
Lateralus
I think a good approach would be to add a few lower level skills (even if they are out powered by level 25 skills).

For example rangers now start with pets however sorcs and necros have to wait a while for their pets and are very weak to start with. I would love to see them get a pet at level 1 just to have a buddy etc make the game more exciting maybe some kind of Imp or something just a weak damage dealer that would be overshadowed by the time you get your golem or zombie or whatever.

Wouldn't need to be div based you could prob just create 1 imp for both sorc and necro and it would add a ton to the game play experience without having to worry about it throwing off balance.


little things like that I think would be easy to add and could add some depth and fun for players to kind of break up the grind.
Terron
yeah id like the imp idea.

had an idea about the combat system. maybe certain classes (or races) get bonuses for the more of them in a party. an example would be like knights getting improved techniques when there is more than one. like maybe extra block %, bonus AC or something. maybe even a few skills based on this later on. might add a nice dynamic to combat