Few concerns
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
P.S. for MR the rates are between 24% to 65% not including racial or class bonuses which are now seldom bar a handful (so for example ninja could potentially get 73% cause they gain a static 8%.). It's closer to how AGI works, but still a little more extreme (29% to 51% ish) and I don't see that as an issue, it's probably alot more closer than what it should be. Maybe the per LEVEL should be lowered, which is at 2.5% higher or lower atm if level is different, per level. But that is same as AGI too. The hit rate is higher if its a player attacking a NPC, which is again, same as AGI works now too. (it is not higher the other way around though!)
If theres still issues the main thing might be looking more at the actual damage of spells or the INT on some mobs, rather then adjusting the formula which probably more near where it should be. 65% isn't a bad rate when going up against another spell caster, and fights won't go on forever because of it. But the issue might not be in PVP, maybe only PVE due to stats or damage.
If theres still issues the main thing might be looking more at the actual damage of spells or the INT on some mobs, rather then adjusting the formula which probably more near where it should be. 65% isn't a bad rate when going up against another spell caster, and fights won't go on forever because of it. But the issue might not be in PVP, maybe only PVE due to stats or damage.
Stop discussing stats and address the original poster's comments, please.
My take.
I think slayers are still very very good. I don't really know what you mean when you say you can't pot/dodge/land hits here - they have no attack penalties, and no other class could vanish and pot without being attacked. They DO take 4% more magic damage but I don't think that is game breaking. Another point on attacking - you can round people with only 2 attacks. No other class can do that. I mean your average slayer has something like 15% chance -every round- to kill someone all by themselves.
I have 3 slayers, Saurian, 22 str, Drake also with 22 str and a Horc with 24 str. I am yet to round anybody on any of them the wasn't already low on hps before I attacked.
Im going to say it isnt a gear isuue, I have 2 very good daggers on my one slayer and he still only averages around 420 dmg per bs and to land two in a row in succession its very rare. (this is without buffs of course)
I have rounded a lot of people on my zerker though but they were lower lvls so doesnt really count I guess...
ya bs are super weak now. id not even really have cared much cept for daggers being weakened. hittin 500s with 400pp dagger is a mission for my horc now
i believe most of the balancing was good for the game. still annoyed by it but then i remember it happened to everyone <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" /> but i dont think the daggers needed to lose anything just my opinion
i believe most of the balancing was good for the game. still annoyed by it but then i remember it happened to everyone <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" /> but i dont think the daggers needed to lose anything just my opinion
I mean basing it off saurians they lost around 30 damage due to the dagger change. The str change is around 2 damage per point less after 22 so if you have a 25 str slayer it's 6 damage lost, in BS it's 6x4 so another 24 ish. I get it's a hit but they still are doing the highest damage amongst everyone. You get around 1 or 2 damage back from the necklaces as well and having two embers will make your hits on div really high if you go that route.
The values with no div bonuses on a 25 str and a purple level 25 dagger with brill is:
Not DW:463-553
DW: 509-609
Already here the value is a fair amount compared to others. Yeah zerkers can achieve this too and potentially can get a little higher, but they are also way more random too. That involves at minimum 3 successful hits in PVP and with a HO its not a common feat.
Let's take the above, give it radiant, and give it a humming bonus too:
Not DW: 485-575
DW:534-633
Let's take the max, add +0.2 for the potential necklaces.
NOT DW:488-579
DW: 537-637
Let's add divinities, we'll only do 3% shards, which are more common now. So 3% with one dagger and 6% with two plus the 10% self bonus:
NOT DW:552-654
DW: 623-739
What about 5% shards, though this is probably the most rare you can get:
NOT DW: 562-666
DW: 645-765
I get having the highest possible isn't something easy to do, but I think on average you'll probably have somewhere in between 609 and 637 for a max stab DWing, and 680 to 730 on div. What do you guys think this was before the changes for HO's? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Daggers were literally Swords that could BS too, and it didn't make much sense either value wise, so if something is ever adjusted then it will be prob the modifier. I really don't see the change being that big of a hit. I understand about the nerf, but the potential was too high, and we gotta base it off that right now. It makes it VERY hard to add stronger daggers or quest daggers in the future when the high before was something over 800 damage.
Any sort of bonus with this class is powerful. I'm not sure why you claim they are super weak, they still are the leaders in damage.
P.S. a saurian with a humming radiant dagger, without divinity is 486-576 with only 22.2 str. so its that vs 537-637 25.2 str. Saurians didn't lose much though, probably the 30 damage around.
I also think peopel freak out when they see 500's instead of 600's, though got to remember its probably high 500s vs low 600's, etc.
Obviously this doesn't include armor, which can take somewhere up to 10% depending on the person you are fighting. Average is probably 5-7%. But EVERYONE gets effected by this. So that zerker also loses out on the damage, etc.
I was gonna test on Killua but then I realized you had two level 20 daggers equipped and are only level 23. I assume you have others but feeling you basing your damage off those two and yeah you're seriously lacking max damage.
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 554 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 506 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 598 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 554 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 598 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 598 points of damage!
That is your char with a 400pp items on killua at level 25. That is not DIV either.
With div and 3% shards:
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your dagger of destruction for 694 points of damage!
Take off about 6% and you'll get average damage in PVP. This doesn't include anything fancy either, no humming, no necklace, etc. Directly taken from your char Killua
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 554 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 506 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 598 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 554 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 598 points of damage!
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your dagger of destruction for 598 points of damage!
That is your char with a 400pp items on killua at level 25. That is not DIV either.
With div and 3% shards:
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your dagger of destruction for 694 points of damage!
Take off about 6% and you'll get average damage in PVP. This doesn't include anything fancy either, no humming, no necklace, etc. Directly taken from your char Killua
I was gonna test on Killua but then I realized you had two level 20 daggers equipped and are only level 23. I assume you have others but feeling you basing your damage off those two and yeah you're seriously lacking max damage.
killua isn't killa
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
I was gonna test on Killua but then I realized you had two level 20 daggers equipped and are only level 23. I assume you have others but feeling you basing your damage off those two and yeah you're seriously lacking max damage.
killua isn't killa
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Wooooooooops.
Well, thats a level 25 slayer with 24 str then, lol. Just saying that the damage wasn't bad at all. I am pretty sure he has 24 str on killa anyways so the examples should still apply.
I was gonna test on Killua but then I realized you had two level 20 daggers equipped and are only level 23. I assume you have others but feeling you basing your damage off those two and yeah you're seriously lacking max damage.
killua isn't killa
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
lmao. test still works tho <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
The values with no div bonuses on a 25 str and a purple level 25 dagger with brill is:
Not DW:463-553
DW: 509-609
Already here the value is a fair amount compared to others. Yeah zerkers can achieve this too and potentially can get a little higher, but they are also way more random too. That involves at minimum 3 successful hits in PVP and with a HO its not a common feat.
Let's take the above, give it radiant, and give it a humming bonus too:
Not DW: 485-575
DW:534-633
Let's take the max, add +0.2 for the potential necklaces.
NOT DW:488-579
DW: 537-637
Let's add divinities, we'll only do 3% shards, which are more common now. So 3% with one dagger and 6% with two plus the 10% self bonus:
NOT DW:552-654
DW: 623-739
What about 5% shards, though this is probably the most rare you can get:
NOT DW: 562-666
DW: 645-765
P.S. a saurian with a humming radiant dagger, without divinity is 486-576 with only 22.2 str. so its that vs 537-637 25.2 str. Saurians didn't lose much though, probably the 30 damage around.
Problem is not everyone can afford pp items or is attached to a large guild and can run around with someone to buff them, my point which has been missed is slayers are weak and by not being able to pot made them weaker.
Like I said earlier, i have 2 very good daggers on my one slayer and he rarely hits for over 500 and to land two bs's in succession its very rare, also factor in most classes have well over 1000 hps, double bsing someone and killing them isnt going to happen,unless they were already low on hps of course.
But PP daggers don\t really make the item. These daggers aren't even radiant. It's only OAD level. Blue daggers would probably be close to the numbers here too. Long as its a level 25 dagger. I am literally using a level 25 purple dagger. I'm not sure if you guys think PP items are super op or something, they really aren't. Devils Horn I believe is a purple 25er dagger. Hell the devils horn you have on the saurian slayer is pretty close to a radiant dagger. This is with your char I assume you talking about 22str saurry>
I'm not sure what the issue really is. Is it that you can't round people? That would make slayers pretty OP if they could just round people constantly, specially because no one else will really be able to do it as they can. The damage byfar is still good. hits for 480 are still fine IMO too, thats still 480x2 if you hit twice. That seems OK to me for 22 STR specially when sword users, for example a knight, get a regular base of around 143-186 with 22str.
Your hitrate is the same as everyone elses bar knights. With an average of 30-50% HR for any hit, not just backstabs, it's harder to land two in a row, yeah. If this was actually raised it would break team combat and everyone would be killing everyone with no effort. You really can only balance it for team fights vs solo. I attempted to do somewhere in the middle, but that means solo pking is going to be harder. Honestly though, because of the way the mechanics work its similar to ROK where you can simply run off fairly quick.
I think more the issue stems with that levelers can simply run. The actual damage and fights are good when they actually stick around (25er vs 25er or whatnot) and if you give them stupid amounts of damage when they are already getting one of the higher damage bases it will break PVP badly. In other games you typically can't move for a few seconds after you attack, and attacks are normally automated (set and forget). You only break out of attack when you realize and often it'll take a little bit of time etc. However if you balance for only people who run then you break proper PVP too. It is fairly harder to kill when they run in a round.
I'm not sure what the solution is, I doubt it is raising damage though. Maybe per level AGI needs to be more effective, maybe there needs to be a nomove mechanic (which i dont think would solve it anyways, only gives you a round really regardless, you cant set it over 8-10 seconds and tbh that would prob be annoying.) etc
NPC On div
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your devils horn for 581 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your devils horn for 605 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your devils horn for 581 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your swift strike for 605 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your swift strike for 581 points of damage!
You cannot hide for 0.13 more seconds!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your swift strike for 605 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your devils horn for 629 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your swift strike for 532 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your swift strike for 581 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your swift strike for 605 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a fire dummy with your devils horn for 605 points of damage!
NPC No div
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your devils horn for 472 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your swift strike for 566 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your swift strike for 521 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your devils horn for 589 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your devils horn for 589 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your swift strike for 566 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your devils horn for 472 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB a water dummy with your devils horn for 589 points of damage!
PvP div w/ 85 armor
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 577 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 488 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 510 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 532 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 488 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 577 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 462 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 554 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 532 points of damage!
PVP no div w/ 85 armor
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 457 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 519 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 541 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 478 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 519 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 478 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 499 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 457 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 499 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 519 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your swift strike for 478 points of damage!
You hide stealthily in the shadows...
You BACKSTAB NiteHawkTest2 with your devils horn for 541 points of damage!
I'm not sure what the issue really is. Is it that you can't round people? That would make slayers pretty OP if they could just round people constantly, specially because no one else will really be able to do it as they can. The damage byfar is still good. hits for 480 are still fine IMO too, thats still 480x2 if you hit twice. That seems OK to me for 22 STR specially when sword users, for example a knight, get a regular base of around 143-186 with 22str.
Your hitrate is the same as everyone elses bar knights. With an average of 30-50% HR for any hit, not just backstabs, it's harder to land two in a row, yeah. If this was actually raised it would break team combat and everyone would be killing everyone with no effort. You really can only balance it for team fights vs solo. I attempted to do somewhere in the middle, but that means solo pking is going to be harder. Honestly though, because of the way the mechanics work its similar to ROK where you can simply run off fairly quick.
I think more the issue stems with that levelers can simply run. The actual damage and fights are good when they actually stick around (25er vs 25er or whatnot) and if you give them stupid amounts of damage when they are already getting one of the higher damage bases it will break PVP badly. In other games you typically can't move for a few seconds after you attack, and attacks are normally automated (set and forget). You only break out of attack when you realize and often it'll take a little bit of time etc. However if you balance for only people who run then you break proper PVP too. It is fairly harder to kill when they run in a round.
I'm not sure what the solution is, I doubt it is raising damage though. Maybe per level AGI needs to be more effective, maybe there needs to be a nomove mechanic (which i dont think would solve it anyways, only gives you a round really regardless, you cant set it over 8-10 seconds and tbh that would prob be annoying.) etc