About anti-spy measures
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
The recruit rank is a good idea, would work great if we had a guild chat restricted to members+, and another for everybody.
dale gribble lol
I mean if you don't want them to talk to you guys either maybe they shouldn't be in the guild. That's literally all a recruit can do. lol <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Its sad i have to explain that.
Spies in your guild chat when you are planning stuff?
Nvm, i think we should just not use gc...
Spies in your guild chat when you are planning stuff?
Nvm, i think we should just not use gc...
Y'all worried too much about spies. My guild will never have spies in another guild, and frankly there's not many guilds atm so you can probably stop worrying and just invite people new to the game. There are legit new people that need homes.
i have spies in every guild. all future guilds will instantly have my alt in them, all former guilds have me as their last member. i have access to all staff characters and the server regularly Pms me all your locations for nudes. sorry it just is what it is.
"-Added a recruit rank. This rank is the initial join rank and is below member rank. People with recruit rank cannot see the location of players. It may have other 'spy' prevention measures in the future as well.
"
I am sorry maybe i should elaborate.
This game is trying to get more players.
Old players are taking advantage of that to make alts join other guilds, to check who is on and what they doing to just be on their way. They can easily found if a guild is on a oad, just by checking member locations.
Recruit rank prevents that, its an improvement.
Still, a recruit spy could stay for a while and see guild chat planning on doing stuff.
With 2 guild chats, you can use one to plan high level stuff, and another to regular chat/help the new members.
Just an idea.
"
I am sorry maybe i should elaborate.
This game is trying to get more players.
Old players are taking advantage of that to make alts join other guilds, to check who is on and what they doing to just be on their way. They can easily found if a guild is on a oad, just by checking member locations.
Recruit rank prevents that, its an improvement.
Still, a recruit spy could stay for a while and see guild chat planning on doing stuff.
With 2 guild chats, you can use one to plan high level stuff, and another to regular chat/help the new members.
Just an idea.
Its sad i have to explain that.
Spies in your guild chat when you are planning stuff?
Nvm, i think we should just not use gc...
I totally hear u bro. Ppl used to require seperate discord channels just for leaders to have private discussions... And yes I agree it would be nice to have it in game rather than out of game. But there's probably more pressing things for NH to do that would improve game quality-of-life more imho.
Adding recruit rank was a good overall move in the right direction for better in-game guild administration. But as for NH's suggestion that the recruits shouldn't be there if you don't trust them to talk/listen - it sounds nice theoretically, but in reality it totally goes against how he's wired the game (ie benefits for bigger numbers and being dependant on greater numbers for success at almost anything, plus wanting new ppl to join guilds as a means of getting game info). I mean it would be great if guilds had the luxury of only adding ppl they trusted/liked and could still succeed at things without having to deal with lots of inflated guild-administration issues... but that isn't the game dynamics or guild system he's designed/allowed/incentivised. Just my 2 cents. Peace all.
Honestly though who is even spying? It's no one from Silh. Jeff and Angie? Doesn't seem their style.
Are we sure this is a big issue? 100% not trying to be a dick here. I think end of the day we can, as a small community, just be cool about stuff like this.
Are we sure this is a big issue? 100% not trying to be a dick here. I think end of the day we can, as a small community, just be cool about stuff like this.
Ok Folder, so sorry for giving a suggestion to improve the game.
From now on i am making sure i talk to you first to check if its a subject that you approve.
From now on i am making sure i talk to you first to check if its a subject that you approve.
its not that "leader" chat is a horrible idea. its the fact that what ur asking for, imo, is already available via discord and/or direct paging.
would it be nice someday? sure.
would it be nice someday? sure.
Ok Folder, so sorry for giving a suggestion to improve the game.
From now on i am making sure i talk to you first to check if its a subject that you approve.
I don't think it improves gameplay by having new recruits not actually be able to interact with a guild. What game in the history of games does that? Seriously have you ever played a game where you join a guild and you can't actually interact with that guild? What's the point of joining a guild?
I know I'm the hugest prick ever for disagreeing, but I don't think this is helpful for the game at all. It does nothing but promote cliques and scare off newbies.
Ok Folder, so sorry for giving a suggestion to improve the game.
From now on i am making sure i talk to you first to check if its a subject that you approve.
I don't think it improves gameplay by having new recruits not actually be able to interact with a guild. What game in the history of games does that? Seriously have you ever played a game where you join a guild and you can't actually interact with that guild? What's the point of joining a guild?
I know I'm the hugest prick ever for disagreeing, but I don't think this is helpful for the game at all. It does nothing but promote cliques and scare off newbies.
Cliques are already rampant. They are just called "guilds" lol. Eg a newbie starting at the moment (while your recruitment is closed) would not be able to join/get to know your entire guild which makes up a rather significant portion of the stable game community. In order to avoid newbs getting scared away from the shortcomings of existing guild system then there probably eventually needs to be a way to seperate guild actives from player socialisation. I believe several other threads have suggested some ways for this such as limited worldchat or friend lists etc. Imho that's probably the direction this needs to go in terms of developing chat functionality - so newbs can make friends with all players in whatever guild, rather than find themselves bored/lonely etc esp if they live in non peak timezones. Peace all.
I think a leader chat is not a bad idea (or even some kind of chat that you can invite people into temporarily).
Sure you have alternatives:
paging: clunky if you are talking to more than one person,
party chat: need to form a party though,
discord: sort of the same problem as normal guild chat, unless you make a leader channel, but it is still a separate window (I sometimes do not look at discord when I am busy - levelling while watching something or playing some other game, but I will (usually) see guild chat).
I do not see the harm in adding another level of chat (be it leader chat or one where you can add people of your choosing into).
Recruits should still be able to see standard guild chat, or yeh... it'd be a lonely experience for them.
Sure you have alternatives:
paging: clunky if you are talking to more than one person,
party chat: need to form a party though,
discord: sort of the same problem as normal guild chat, unless you make a leader channel, but it is still a separate window (I sometimes do not look at discord when I am busy - levelling while watching something or playing some other game, but I will (usually) see guild chat).
I do not see the harm in adding another level of chat (be it leader chat or one where you can add people of your choosing into).
Recruits should still be able to see standard guild chat, or yeh... it'd be a lonely experience for them.
Ok, rehashing something i've proposed around here:
Force all characters to have a "surname" that is common to all characters of the account.
This "surname" can be different from the actual account name, for security reasons.
It can also be changed at will, but it will impact all characters of the account.
So for example, if I set my surname to "Glomgold", when one does /i to any of my chars, you'd read:
/i Tyrargo
Name: Tyrargo (Glomgold)
This will not only stop "spies" but also help us identify each other. It will also help prevent multiboxing.
Force all characters to have a "surname" that is common to all characters of the account.
This "surname" can be different from the actual account name, for security reasons.
It can also be changed at will, but it will impact all characters of the account.
So for example, if I set my surname to "Glomgold", when one does /i to any of my chars, you'd read:
/i Tyrargo
Name: Tyrargo (Glomgold)
This will not only stop "spies" but also help us identify each other. It will also help prevent multiboxing.
Ok, rehashing something i've proposed around here:
Force all characters to have a "surname" that is common to all characters of the account.
This "surname" can be different from the actual account name, for security reasons.
It can also be changed at will, but it will impact all characters of the account.
So for example, if I set my surname to "Glomgold", when one does /i to any of my chars, you'd read:
/i Tyrargo
Name: Tyrargo (Glomgold)
This will not only stop "spies" but also help us identify each other. It will also help prevent multiboxing.
I get this but it doesn't stop spies at all. People who make spy alts, if they do often use a separate account completely. I don't want to lock people to one account and it's impossible to do anyways as it is easy to get around a IP or computer lock per account, can't really be enforced properly.
ok, still do it for us to be able to know each other <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Anyway, does anyone actually have evidence of spies? I've seen our leaders boot people that "could" be spies, but even if they were, i cant recall any instance of us being "spied" upon.
Anyway, does anyone actually have evidence of spies? I've seen our leaders boot people that "could" be spies, but even if they were, i cant recall any instance of us being "spied" upon.
ok, still do it for us to be able to know each other <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Anyway, does anyone actually have evidence of spies? I've seen our leaders boot people that "could" be spies, but even if they were, i cant recall any instance of us being "spied" upon.
Yeah I can add something for that eventually, maybe when I get to seeing how friends list will work.
I think honestly there might of been one or two max but then it gets blown out of proportion.
Ok, rehashing something i've proposed around here:
Force all characters to have a "surname" that is common to all characters of the account.
This "surname" can be different from the actual account name, for security reasons.
It can also be changed at will, but it will impact all characters of the account.
So for example, if I set my surname to "Glomgold", when one does /i to any of my chars, you'd read:
/i Tyrargo
Name: Tyrargo (Glomgold)
This will not only stop "spies" but also help us identify each other. It will also help prevent multiboxing.
I like this idea and also think this would be a good idea for player socialisation (and guild administration too!). Something like making accounts show up as noble houses or something (eg Tyrargo of house Glomgold). Agree that it won't really stop the spies and I also don't think every char in an account should be forced to display the surname (eg there might be room for 'bastard' characters who choose not to bear surname so they can be anonymous but then ppl naturally will distrust them more).
ok, still do it for us to be able to know each other <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Anyway, does anyone actually have evidence of spies? I've seen our leaders boot people that "could" be spies, but even if they were, i cant recall any instance of us being "spied" upon.
I like.