← Forum archive

Slayers and how to fix.

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Rodeo
Right now we have ran into a road block with slayers being the only rounding class atm.
I know alot of us are old RoK slayer players and as much as we hate to see our beloved pking class get adjusted it really needs to happen.
We can pretty much round anything and dependent upon race eat pots like they are going out of style.

My suggestion to fix this problem is to lower the backstab multipler to what a brigands is but also add a blood letting skill that drains HP 5 HP per tick for 60 secs. This kinda puts Slayers inline with Zerkers the cloest DPS to them which use the same armor and arent able to hide from DPS. I have heard rumor of search being tampered with and I dont think the /search feature is the problem at all. Also to make Brigands Shine would be to add a poison skill to that class and this game might see more class diversity in events with new ways of playing a class instead of smash f1 then smash f2 or mouse clicky. lol
anthriel
Im going to have to respectfully disagree that slayer damage needs nerfing because atm they are one of the only classes that can 'end' a large group fight when priests are involved. If slayer damage gets nerfed then you definitely need to nerf priest healing otherwise group fights of equal numbers tend to end up as 30+ min stalemates where ppl just burn through pots and loser is the group that eventually runs out. Personally, I'd rather log off and do something else than bother contesting keys etc if group fights end up as 30+ min stalemates with the loser being determined by who runs out of pots first. Or alternatively it just encourages even more tactical emphasis on outnumbering ppl to finish a fight which is unhelpful for game balance too.

In single PKing, I'm guessing slayers rarely succeed in rounding anyone unless the person is already damaged. Once no-exp loss comes in for lvlers I don't think slayer damage in 1v1 is an issue either.

Slayers r much better balanced already when NH made them not be able to use pots while hiding. Nerfing their damage probably means necessary nerfing of other classes (eg priests) so I don't think any change is neede there. The only thing that may need to be dealt with is the slayers 100% ability to avoid FF when hiding behind a Guard (making Druids in group fight useless). The guard /protect should count for something but granting 100% immunity is excessive.

That's my 2 cents for what it's worth.
Rodeo
Right now tho we are in the position of 1 class making a deciding factor in a stalemate. In 1 round i could either do 500 or 1200 damage depending on what slayer/div I use. I dislike Elders FF mainly cause a Elder is pretty much balanced If FF was changed to just reduce armor by 10 that would be more balanced. I would like to see suggestions on bringing other classes UP in terms of giving them skills that can counter other classes. Example Pallys could get a Bash Skill that could stun a player for X amount of secs which would turn the tide so to speak in these 30 min stalemates. I have been there buddy I feel ya. Priest is stunned they cant heal which forces players to use pots. Slayer gets stunned they cant deal that elite damage. Right now we are going in the direction of RoK where Slayer is the end all dps. Its not that i dont like the other classes its just that I like to win and am forced to play what wins. We need to realize this isnt rok and can be changed to not resemble a clone of it.
JadeFalcon
I sort of agree with both of you, but i dont think nerfing slayers is the answer - upping other classes is.

First we need to define what classes are for what:
- PVE
- PVP
- Support

All PVP classes should be able to have a lower possibility to one round someone (or nearly so - one rounding someone is only possible with div, and mostly you need to be an Horc), or at least deliver an "alpha strike" type of damage. For example, Death mages could have a spell that enabled to have 2.5 damage for 2stam, or something.

Edit: Also, any class that gets damage to one round someone, should also get a spell to heavy counter it (like FF for slayers)
Edit2: Mixed feelings on guardians and FF - it actually gives guardians a use.
Ohko
The only thing that may need to be dealt with is the slayers 100% ability to avoid FF when hiding behind a Guard (making Druids in group fight useless). The guard /protect should count for something but granting 100% immunity is excessive.


I'm going to disagree with /protect here. Guardians are barely used as is, and /protect slayers/zerkers/gnomes are really the only function they have at the moment. Also casting sight on the blind.

There is also no counter to FF at the moment. Every other debuff (except wither) have a counter. slow <=> haste, rot <=> remedy, sap <=> power, blind <=> sight

My suggestion to prevent slayers from hiding forever is to set a limit to how long they could stay hidden. However, that would stress the server if 20 slayers are hiding at the same time so that's not currently possible.
Terron
the main problem is wizard classes are lackluster. glass pellet guns.

" For example, Death mages could have a spell that enabled to have 2.5 damage for 2stam, or something."
thats about what a chanter does lol.

atm a 10 str brig out-dps a 20 int dm in pve and depending on the pvp situation i have to be honest here id rather take the brig because the damage is higher on 9 races

casters have 0 power to end a half orc in group fights. because they resist about 3/10 and u fizzle 1/10. the 2-3 hits u succeed each round isnt enough you need 3 casters to round 1 horc slayer(half orc always can pot mid round due to pot timer), then oops cleric got a heal in need another wizard. 4 heals? yeah just forget about it. saurian doesnt have the fast pot timer to ensure they can pot in the middle of each round and they have less hps so priests have to be on point. saurians tend to die horcs dont.

searching slayers is relatively easy, theres just no high int characters used besides healers(busy healing).

i think slayers are fine tbh, its the fact that there is no counter to them. FF is just a pause button. it wears off and slayer goes back to work absorbing heals from 3 priests and hitting 600+ x2. doesnt matter if they had 10 agi, sooner or later they land 2x and its game over.

mage cant kill a horc thats the real problem, mage cant even hurt goblin mr or any race thats higher mr.
mr per race doesnt scale with melee prowess. horc saurian and drakes get hit by spells the other 9 pretty much immune with just 1 potion a round.

imo the best move is to remove potion timer from horcs and set them to max 10 wisdom. then scale mr on races by changing the wisdom stat to gradually elevate per race as the melee output diminishes. dark elf and goblin especially they arent even much weaker than a drake/saurian and get hella mr for free.
JadeFalcon
I think the problem is even before.
Do we want roles to exist, or do we want "all classes to be good at everything"?
If we want all classes to be good at everything, than enchanters are the last our worries - stalkers need like 2x damage.

Or do we want roles to exist? By roles i mean Support/PVE/PVP.

Support is the capability to support party members with heals/positive buffs
PVE is critical importance to fight high level mobs/OADS
PVP is critical importance to fight other parties.

If roles exist, the current distribution is:
- Support: Priests, Bards
- PVE: Brigands, Enchanters (dont laugh - enchanters are the only class required to finish certain oads/mobs, like casting SS on dragon, or /hover)
- PVP: Everyone else. And that is the huge problem, stemming from the "everyone must be great at everything" situation.

You might disagree with how alocated classes in the above - and that is the problem, we dont have an hollistic view of where each class sits - this needs to come with Nitehawk.
IF we had a proper allocation, then we could boost/nerf classes accordingly - to the point that in my opinion, if you want to run lets say the Seta Pillars, you can only hope to defeat the mob with Support/PVE chars, and risk wipeout if you take Support/PVP classes.

My point is, a Slayer "should" murder other people. That's in the name. Same with Death Mages. But they should be useless for other situations. On the other hand, overlooked classes such as Stalkers or Cavaliers should really be critical to take for OADs.
Terron
yeah i mean the roles are a major thing.

like chanter is it support? is it dps?

people call it support but minstrel supports better and heals for additional support. and if its support you cant really say its the "counter" to slayer.

slayer is a killer, its the only one that does what its supposed to really.
anthriel
Yeah I agree a lot with JF on this. I've always thought of chanter as a jack of all trades - can enchant, useful for oad, can stealth , can buff/debuff, can damage quite a lot to ppl with low mr etc. Very useful to have around really. (Druid kinda similar in having buffs/debuffs, heals, and ok damage). Chanters already got a large boost since last update (much more hps) and do decent damage so I dunno why Terron complain about them being crap. They were winning lots of KoTH etc too. You say gobs kill em but something has to be good against magic user. I mean the saurians n drakes r rightly getting fried (as we thought should happen) and the Horc slayer is well what it is (50/50 chance Mage or slayer wind depending on backstab luck)

Stalkers are pretty unloved. I hate lvling em and pet revive is less efficient than spawning golem/zombie for OAD. I find it amusing a freakin brigand can access ambush damage with bow and a stalker can't. (Brigs with bows seems stupid lore wise.... If younare far enough to use a bow how can u be close enough to pickpocket?... On other had stalker should be hiding in bushes ambushing ppls)

Cav shield bash having para effect would make them suddenly very interesting. Or another way to go would it be if the shield bash actually reflected 100% damage of a blocked melee shot (imagine the shocked slayer who cops his full backstab back lol - suddenly Knights would be non-stab targets for slayers).

But yeah the amt of exp needed to reach 25 is the other thing. I mean some classes probably should be worse if they only require a fraction of the exp that another class does. If we balance abilities then the question becomes whether cavs should really be 300m etc.

Shrugs - peace
Terron
well u can use my chanter if u like but most fights without pots ur playing a game where you hope absorbed hits will defeat unaffects. at 15 wisdom its pretty much 50/50. 17 wisdom (goblin equiv) u hit around 40% overall counting fizzles/resists similar to melee mage has 0 burst effect u either hit 7-9x really quick or u die. this tends to be mostly rng. you can hit 10/10 or miss all 10. 1v1 isnt really a problem or chanter as much as it is a dm.(see below)

the problem isnt that they do 0 damage. its the fact they have no burst potential and next to none on damage buffs. int song is unrealistic currently as mages tend to not hit that often on anything with mr. minstrel will buff physical attackers. u take a 24 int gnome mage and on avg if they manage 2/4 on an mr character thats 312 approximate damage on avg. potions heal 260. even with bard buffs the damage boost is around 18 extra damage max brings total to about 340. 80 net damage a round with 0 healers present and bard buffs.

lets stop and think...what if they are an elemental or elf chanter? oh right like 15min-30max less damage per hit. now ur getting to the point where pots cover the damage entirely. dm is the same way here they do awful damage. 20 int necro doesnt even see 145 damage with wither.

the lowdown is basically mages are only there to kill 10-12 wisdom characters with seemingly lower end hp tables. be it saurians/drakes or low wis minstrels and some zerks. but lets face facts here zerks are easier to kill with any other viable melee dps class.

my chanter has over 450 kills on it im pretty sure i know what is easy to kill lol. NOT half orcs. i can put money on it that 80+ of my 110+ deaths were exclusively half orc slayers and 60 of those trying to kill them 1v1. it doesnt happen they pot fast and kill me in less than 3 rounds most of the time. sad thing is most of the time they dont even ever get severely wounded. pretty much avoid them entirely unless its a surprise attack when they are wounded.

chanter is a decent support class, but it isnt an effective counter to low mr currently with priests healpower being almost 2x as much as blast/leech. also high dps chanters like gnomes are about as frail as u can get, i dont even sit still on mine. u cant. u will die.

edit: basically all that needs to happen is half orc slayers need to die to mages as fast as saurians do. not really anything drastic here. the highest melee power should die to magic the fastest right?
Boon
Right now we have ran into a road block with slayers being the only rounding class atm.
I know alot of us are old RoK slayer players and as much as we hate to see our beloved pking class get adjusted it really needs to happen.
We can pretty much round anything and dependent upon race eat pots like they are going out of style.

My suggestion to fix this problem is to lower the backstab multipler to what a brigands is but also add a blood letting skill that drains HP 5 HP per tick for 60 secs. This kinda puts Slayers inline with Zerkers the cloest DPS to them which use the same armor and arent able to hide from DPS. I have heard rumor of search being tampered with and I dont think the /search feature is the problem at all. Also to make Brigands Shine would be to add a poison skill to that class and this game might see more class diversity in events with new ways of playing a class instead of smash f1 then smash f2 or mouse clicky. lol



I think this is a great idea it would level out the spike damage and still allow slayers to put out serious numbers but it would help eliminate the rounding of other classes. You could also fix it where bleeding will not stop until fully healed or you can't hide if you are bleeding there are unlimited options that this could bring to the table.
anthriel
well u can use my chanter if u like but most fights without pots ur playing a game where you hope absorbed hits will defeat unaffects. at 15 wisdom its pretty much 50/50. 17 wisdom (goblin equiv) u hit around 40% overall counting fizzles/resists similar to melee mage has 0 burst effect u either hit 7-9x really quick or u die. this tends to be mostly rng. you can hit 10/10 or miss all 10. 1v1 isnt really a problem or chanter as much as it is a dm.(see below)

the problem isnt that they do 0 damage. its the fact they have no burst potential and next to none on damage buffs. int song is unrealistic currently as mages tend to not hit that often on anything with mr. minstrel will buff physical attackers. u take a 24 int gnome mage and on avg if they manage 2/4 on an mr character thats 312 approximate damage on avg. potions heal 260. even with bard buffs the damage boost is around 18 extra damage max brings total to about 340. 80 net damage a round with 0 healers present and bard buffs.

lets stop and think...what if they are an elemental or elf chanter? oh right like 15min-30max less damage per hit. now ur getting to the point where pots cover the damage entirely. dm is the same way here they do awful damage. 20 int necro doesnt even see 145 damage with wither.

the lowdown is basically mages are only there to kill 10-12 wisdom characters with seemingly lower end hp tables. be it saurians/drakes or low wis minstrels and some zerks. but lets face facts here zerks are easier to kill with any other viable melee dps class.

my chanter has over 450 kills on it im pretty sure i know what is easy to kill lol. NOT half orcs. i can put money on it that 80+ of my 110+ deaths were exclusively half orc slayers and 60 of those trying to kill them 1v1. it doesnt happen they pot fast and kill me in less than 3 rounds most of the time. sad thing is most of the time they dont even ever get severely wounded. pretty much avoid them entirely unless its a surprise attack when they are wounded.

chanter is a decent support class, but it isnt an effective counter to low mr currently with priests healpower being almost 2x as much as blast/leech. also high dps chanters like gnomes are about as frail as u can get, i dont even sit still on mine. u cant. u will die.

edit: basically all that needs to happen is half orc slayers need to die to mages as fast as saurians do. not really anything drastic here. the highest melee power should die to magic the fastest right?


I dunno man a lot of your complaint sounds like u want chanter to do everything. They are already the best support class in game. Give them better burst dps and they'd be way overpowered. You say chanters can deal 360 damage a round. A lot of melee can't even do that. Melee base hitrate is like 40% and even with great Agi differential u prolly looking 50% at best. That's not too diff from ur Mage hitting 2/4 (which already assumes your opponent has at least 16wis) and some melee class don't even hit for as much as blast does. So instead of comparing chanters to the best burst dps in game (slayer) and crying about it, I think they are already damn useful and pretty powerful when compared to some of the 1 dimensional crappy melee options there are out there. As for slayers, well they do kill efficiently but like JH pointed out they aren't bringing a lot of support for your OAD party so they have their speciality and limits. Should slayers have the bigger MR penalty compared to barbs? Sure I could see that. Could their armour be nerfed to keep with stealthy type lore? Possibly... But I dont really think Rodeos suggested solution to nerf their burst dps (even by delaying some of it) is really that effective for overall game balance. Peace.
JadeFalcon
The way I see it, classes should be like this:

Support:
Priests (no change)
Bards (no change)
Stalkers (give them abilities that enable them to buff allies, via the pets)
Druids (modify certain abilities - i see these guys as "witches" capable of creating poisons allies can use, for example)

PVE
Brigands (no change)
Enchanters (no change - WIS does need to be scaled better)
Guardians - No change. Perhaps rebalance to be weaker in PVP but stronger in PVE
Cavs - modify taunt to be more useful.

PVP
Slayers (no change)
Zerkers (more damage - they currently dont dodge, but should hurt alot more)
Ninjas (more damage, inverse situation from zerkers)
Death Mages (more damage)


Just my 2 cents.
Terron
actually i want chanter to be full support - lower damage, stone defense, maybe shields/cure. it would be nice to have a caster that doesn't die in seconds.

but the game as it is has chanter heavier dps than a death mage. so when they tell you magic is the counter to slayer it really doesnt make sense. power sap blind and search until a melee user kills the enemy slayer is not an effective counter lol

as tyrargo says DM is supposed to be the "slayer" of magic it just isnt.

maybe we just need a burst damage magic class that can round half orcs occasionally. dunno. but atm its currently easier to log on your own slayer to fight other slayers than it is to use a glass shelled caster.

i only think magic needs to scale better because most races are imo high mr, even the lower tier of these (goblin) resist 18/20 in koths vs mages.

guardians i would say are weaker pvp than pve already. they do however have a niche. stand there and heal themselves while slayer/zerk/druid sit behind you and kill or ff without worry. maybe protect shouldnt be 100%? i dunno, if it wasnt 100% it would make them even harder to kill imo.

stalkers need help but pretty much roped into the same calibre as dm/chanter. great 1v1 class without pots. lacks everywhere else.
i always thought pet skills should be heavily int dependent. so if u want best pets u need chr and high int and pets are your main source of damage. or you can go the opposite and be high dps but have fodder pets.

cavs should be able to use 2 handers in 1 hand or get a bonus on shield ac for deflects. taunt should steal enemy attacks randomly in group fights aswell.

zerkers can remain glass but i think they should be able to dual wield 2 handers for an extra stam but get -1 attack agi when doing so. either they need lethal rounding power or they need some form of physical damage negation. probably around 25. or both. it doesnt fit in group "target zerkers in pvp because they suck" it should be target zerks because "omg im scurred"
Reaper
Idea 1
Attack someone while hidden the same way you can attack an enchanter who is invisible(fixes attack and hide, also fixes moshes)

Idea 2
Hide timer so that a Slayer can only hide once per round. Timer starts after backstab or after being found.(Fixes almost everything tbh while not gimping them badly)

Idea 3
Guardians lose protection on a class if it hides(I think this is a good fix but doesn't really fix events or anything pking wise)

Idea 4
FF through protect(also good idea but still doesn't fix events or anything pking wise)

Idea 5
Backstab takes 3 stamina and get it at 25, lose dual wield but keep damage bonus so can equip shield since vulnerable after attack, get a crit chance bonus like barb and thief on attacks to make lvling easier and potential for slightly higher stab to compensate for one stab(This fixes a lot but seems over complicated when there are easier fixes)


A culmination of ideas from several people in Discord.
Styx
Slayers, take away duel wield and adjust so they use bows, this gives more use for bows in game, it's inline that way as brigs

Chanters loose sap

New hex class warlock/witch hex foes and magic class slayer

Ranger pets buff party

Druids, make animale form more useful, can /pounce xxx monster to attack ,,, special attack here lol

Edit. Don't delete slayers