Slayers - What to do with them? (REVOTE)
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I am comfortable with the armor as is - I think if we get suffixes for armor, then we can perhaps get class specific stuff? Dunno, sorry im thread jacking.
Class specific stuff like that though?
The point to lower armor would be so they take 5% more damage or so really. If you just lower their armor and then give them class armor it kind of defeats the purpose of a nerf though
I was thinking more along the lines of a ring armor for assassins with 0 ac, but that gives a haste bonus, for example. Hard tradeoffs that arent necessarily a nerf.
Making them have a penalty when being in a party doesn't work in most PVP fights. The problem would probably be at key areas anyways, it's a moot point as they can just disband when they arrive and rejoin when done. Not a real difficult task to do. You'd lose some watch on them in /party but it's fairly easy for slayers to run off to heal themselves.
I'm talking conceptually (ie suggesting the general concept that the route for slayer development is for them to be a solo killer but a groupfight liability). If the concept is helpful then there are many ways to make the concept work practically. Eg the most hardcore option is to stop them from being able to join a party at all. Other options could be things like coding it such that in a crowded room of more than X chars there is a random % chance that their bstab lands on a random target (including someone in their own party if they are in one, or anyone in the room if they are not - which would also fit with lore as its pretty hard to backstab ppl in a crowded situation) ... etc etc - im sure we can get creative n think outside the box if ppl agree that the concept of making them NOT be groupfight assets is a better route than straight out nerf. Its getting ppl to agree to a concept of change that is the hard part.
Shrugs.... I still think giving a %fail chance to /hide (for which there is a base amount dependent on Int and which then increases in party situations) is better than all the weird delay timers to backstabbing/hiding or restrictions to one bs a round etc that basically stop them from 1round killing in solo situations as well (cos they should retain this).
Anyhoo do what you will... imho this class-specific stuff isnt even the main prob anyway (cos any fixes to a class are a short term band-aid and powershift to another class). The prob of dealing with 10v10+ balance dynamics ultimately lies in reducing the incentive to form such large groups/factions. Class balancing can then be made more accurate once that is settled. Peace.
....
Actually, something like a /hide nerf if there are alot of people in a room would make sense to me.
So starting at 6 people total in a room, you get 10% fail chance on heal, increasing 10% per added person.
So, 6 people in a room - 0%
7 - 10% odds
..
12 - 60% fail odds
16 and above - 100% fail (cannot hide)
....
Actually, something like a /hide nerf if there are alot of people in a room would make sense to me.
So starting at 6 people total in a room, you get 10% fail chance on heal, increasing 10% per added person.
So, 6 people in a room - 0%
7 - 10% odds
..
12 - 60% fail odds
16 and above - 100% fail (cannot hide)
That is a possibility too, though I'd probably not make 100% fail, if that was an idea for em.
That is a possibility too, though I'd probably not make 100% fail, if that was an idea for em.
Now go make me my 0AC Haste Ring Armor, please.
im dead against nerfing skills on games. its already boring enough that the game is pushed to f1 bashing and rng. this might be why slayer is a heavy favorite - they get to use 2 or 4 buttons. (exciting!)
keep hide ff protect backstab taunt roar etc all need to be very useful. you have hard counters to slayers already, just search with a mage. but the issue is here that theres no pause/break between hide and stab to even search. which is why i like #4 if your targeting a player. i dont think it needs the 1s penalty if you hit monsters.
i mean wed likely have the same issue if 10v10s had 7 chanters on 1 side aswell, its just that 7 chanters wouldnt beat 7 slayers and 7 chanters cant kill the foundation of support most groups have.
if option 4 only has a 1s wait period for backstabs on players and not monsters then i think option 4 is the best route to strategically combat slayers in party fights. now it might no help mass wars with 20 people but it still helps more than the other ones. and it keeps them the same pve on hard mini bosses and vila traps etc as they can move and rehide still.
keep hide ff protect backstab taunt roar etc all need to be very useful. you have hard counters to slayers already, just search with a mage. but the issue is here that theres no pause/break between hide and stab to even search. which is why i like #4 if your targeting a player. i dont think it needs the 1s penalty if you hit monsters.
i mean wed likely have the same issue if 10v10s had 7 chanters on 1 side aswell, its just that 7 chanters wouldnt beat 7 slayers and 7 chanters cant kill the foundation of support most groups have.
if option 4 only has a 1s wait period for backstabs on players and not monsters then i think option 4 is the best route to strategically combat slayers in party fights. now it might no help mass wars with 20 people but it still helps more than the other ones. and it keeps them the same pve on hard mini bosses and vila traps etc as they can move and rehide still.
I still think the old system should be removed though, that's just me. It would really help with fixing alot of these shitty issues and I wouldn't have to really feel like I had to nerf damage so much if we could test that. I'm not sure if you guys are just clinging on the ROK style, but it is honestly crap and brings problems when you can just reset your timers by moving.
I look at it two ways at the moment with #4:
Remove the old system, making rehide 0.5s instead of 1s, and then making the other 0.5s in between hide and attack.
/hide
0.5s timer
a NAME
0.5s timer
/hide
0.5s timer
a NAME
would be a round. Pretty straight forward. Less hide timer means probably no one would use the old system anyways.
----
OR
Remove the old system, remove the rehide delay and move it to a 1s wait between attacking. Add a /search out find delay of 1s. So
/hide
1.0s timer
a NAME
/hide
1.0s timer
a NAME
Would be a round. And if found out, you can't hide for a second.
---
The idea about making /hide harder the more players are around is not a bad idea, but if we were to do that it wouldn't be a 100% ever. It would be more like 25% max I'd say. Completely gimping a class like that even is its the big bad assassins over numbers in a game is a bit eh. It's a possibility though too
I look at it two ways at the moment with #4:
Remove the old system, making rehide 0.5s instead of 1s, and then making the other 0.5s in between hide and attack.
/hide
0.5s timer
a NAME
0.5s timer
/hide
0.5s timer
a NAME
would be a round. Pretty straight forward. Less hide timer means probably no one would use the old system anyways.
----
OR
Remove the old system, remove the rehide delay and move it to a 1s wait between attacking. Add a /search out find delay of 1s. So
/hide
1.0s timer
a NAME
/hide
1.0s timer
a NAME
Would be a round. And if found out, you can't hide for a second.
---
The idea about making /hide harder the more players are around is not a bad idea, but if we were to do that it wouldn't be a 100% ever. It would be more like 25% max I'd say. Completely gimping a class like that even is its the big bad assassins over numbers in a game is a bit eh. It's a possibility though too
Either example though would work.
Remember it takes about 0.4-0.5s to do a N/S. thats why the current search timer is 1s.
What you'd generally do (now) is put that into the rehide delay, (0.5s instead of 1s) and then move the rest into actually hiding, it will at least give a quick reaction time for the priest instead of being insta death. This way you can still snipe in small combat when they don't realize you are there for the quick snipe, because their reaction time will be slow, but you kind of solve the larger groups and they can prepare more.
The second option just gives a little more time in any case to catching them through a search instead. 1s goes by pretty quick though. It does allow them to rehide faster but they'd risk getting caught. But generally both options allow the larger combat groups to stop slayers if they are paying attention but still let slayers get the surprise on unsuspecting people.
Remember it takes about 0.4-0.5s to do a N/S. thats why the current search timer is 1s.
What you'd generally do (now) is put that into the rehide delay, (0.5s instead of 1s) and then move the rest into actually hiding, it will at least give a quick reaction time for the priest instead of being insta death. This way you can still snipe in small combat when they don't realize you are there for the quick snipe, because their reaction time will be slow, but you kind of solve the larger groups and they can prepare more.
The second option just gives a little more time in any case to catching them through a search instead. 1s goes by pretty quick though. It does allow them to rehide faster but they'd risk getting caught. But generally both options allow the larger combat groups to stop slayers if they are paying attention but still let slayers get the surprise on unsuspecting people.
just hurts them solo training imo. because i literally only like to fight monsters i can move and rehide instantly on. otherwise pot use is so high i cba. (this is a problem in general not just from the slayer p.o.v.)
either way 2 or 4 break the instant .04 second dbl stabs so in a way those help more than armor nerfing and damage nerfing. but they still need damage lowered a bit. i rounded a half orc with a gnome ffs(buffs and div ofc but still i only had shivs with no embers)
as far as armor i always thought it should be
cloth: ninja chanter deathmage
light: priest brigand slayer
medium: stalker druid minstrel
heavy: cavalier guardian zerker
either way 2 or 4 break the instant .04 second dbl stabs so in a way those help more than armor nerfing and damage nerfing. but they still need damage lowered a bit. i rounded a half orc with a gnome ffs(buffs and div ofc but still i only had shivs with no embers)
as far as armor i always thought it should be
cloth: ninja chanter deathmage
light: priest brigand slayer
medium: stalker druid minstrel
heavy: cavalier guardian zerker
just hurts them solo training imo. because i literally only like to fight monsters i can move and rehide instantly on. otherwise pot use is so high i cba. (this is a problem in general not just from the slayer p.o.v.)
either way 2 or 4 break the instant .04 second dbl stabs so in a way those help more than armor nerfing and damage nerfing. but they still need damage lowered a bit. i rounded a half orc with a gnome ffs(buffs and div ofc but still i only had shivs with no embers)
as far as armor i always thought it should be
cloth: ninja chanter deathmage
light: priest brigand slayer
medium: stalker druid minstrel
heavy: cavalier guardian zerker
It doesn't need to be added in PVE, only if you attack a player's monster or a player. Depends though how people feel about it.
I kind of agree for armor changes, not exactly that, but I understand what you're doing there and it is a good idea in the long run.
I still think the old system should be removed though, that's just me. It would really help with fixing alot of these shitty issues and I wouldn't have to really feel like I had to nerf damage so much if we could test that. I'm not sure if you guys are just clinging on the ROK style, but it is honestly crap and brings problems when you can just reset your timers by moving.
I look at it two ways at the moment with #4:
Remove the old system, making rehide 0.5s instead of 1s, and then making the other 0.5s in between hide and attack.
/hide
0.5s timer
a NAME
0.5s timer
/hide
0.5s timer
a NAME
would be a round. Pretty straight forward. Less hide timer means probably no one would use the old system anyways.
----
OR
Remove the old system, remove the rehide delay and move it to a 1s wait between attacking. Add a /search out find delay of 1s. So
/hide
1.0s timer
a NAME
/hide
1.0s timer
a NAME
Would be a round. And if found out, you can't hide for a second.
---
The idea about making /hide harder the more players are around is not a bad idea, but if we were to do that it wouldn't be a 100% ever. It would be more like 25% max I'd say. Completely gimping a class like that even is its the big bad assassins over numbers in a game is a bit eh. It's a possibility though too
How would you remove the old system entirely though? I get u can remove the up/down allowances on certain KTP squares to stop a slayer leaving and coming back in on say a Vila trap square ... But if it's in the open field like with dragon or something then won't old school slayers still move N/S to reset their backstab?
I mean in your first eg if you have a choice of staying in a room unhidden and letting ppl pound u for 0.5sec or leaving to avoid damage for 0.5sec and introducing potential confusion about how soon you may be reentering the room - I think most would still choose the latter anyway... And In the 2nd eg it seems you can rehide immediately after attacking which probably means slayers will spend even more time hidden and forcing opponents time to waste attacks /searching (cos they can then immediately rehide after attacking or even if they are found)...
These type of restrictions make for weird game flow methinks ... Take it too far n slayers can't land 2bstabs before ppl pot/heal etc anymore and their class-identity is gone. Too little and you don't achieve any difference. The increasing %fail of /hide (due to circumstances like being crowded rooms, due to INT, due to parties etc) sounds to me like a better/smoother way of introducing RNG of failure into what is now almost 100% certainty. It does largely reflect lore also (eg even though Terron doesn't like nerfing skills, we can't expect any slayer to always be able to find a hiding place at will within a split seconds notice etc... Even spells have fizzles). Shrugs
I think there are two points:
1. One is what NH plans to do, which is to prevent a sort of "technical abuse". I am fine with that, although Anthriel does make the point this needs to be finely tuned. But i guess that is something we can all work on
2. The other point is Slayers being unbalanced. I think we agree that the issue is more group fights than 1v1. For that I think we could have
2.1. Hide % penalty in crowded rooms (NH does not like it, I and Ant do, not sure about anyone else. Again, something
to be tinkered with.
2.2. My own view that actually instead of changing anything on slayers, work on other classes to make them more fun
to play. I think one of the things that makes slayers so popular isnt their raw power, its that, as piddy mentioned,
they are the most fun class to play. You get cool skills for tactical gameplay, or just to run around (i love spying
on people). No other class has that, and that in my opinion, is the true issue.
1. One is what NH plans to do, which is to prevent a sort of "technical abuse". I am fine with that, although Anthriel does make the point this needs to be finely tuned. But i guess that is something we can all work on
2. The other point is Slayers being unbalanced. I think we agree that the issue is more group fights than 1v1. For that I think we could have
2.1. Hide % penalty in crowded rooms (NH does not like it, I and Ant do, not sure about anyone else. Again, something
to be tinkered with.
2.2. My own view that actually instead of changing anything on slayers, work on other classes to make them more fun
to play. I think one of the things that makes slayers so popular isnt their raw power, its that, as piddy mentioned,
they are the most fun class to play. You get cool skills for tactical gameplay, or just to run around (i love spying
on people). No other class has that, and that in my opinion, is the true issue.
I opt for change the armor to balance out the armor choices, we could give cleric back heavy armor since cleric was always getting the berg. O.o now that it's slayers notice how big the discussion has become. Personally a cleric or monk could use a cloak and just a dust the ac gains.
Leave slayer dammage alone. It's row meta. Otherwise to many will cry and prob leave. But being the meta then adjust all other classes to upgrade their attack dammage
Leave slayer dammage alone. It's row meta. Otherwise to many will cry and prob leave. But being the meta then adjust all other classes to upgrade their attack dammage
the problem is you cant just boost all classes damage. think about it, if a priest has to start burning 2 heals per ninja or cav, the slayer basically gets to try and round every single time instead of priest only having to really worry about the slayers stabs. basically all that happens is slayers killshot people even easier. once a clerics timing is off its likely the slayers only have to hit once instead of twice. its basically like turning dark elf slayer into a horc.
How would you remove the old system entirely though? I get u can remove the up/down allowances on certain KTP squares to stop a slayer leaving and coming back in on say a Vila trap square ... But if it's in the open field like with dragon or something then won't old school slayers still move N/S to reset their backstab?
I mean in your first eg if you have a choice of staying in a room unhidden and letting ppl pound u for 0.5sec or leaving to avoid damage for 0.5sec and introducing potential confusion about how soon you may be reentering the room - I think most would still choose the latter anyway... And In the 2nd eg it seems you can rehide immediately after attacking which probably means slayers will spend even more time hidden and forcing opponents time to waste attacks /searching (cos they can then immediately rehide after attacking or even if they are found)...
These type of restrictions make for weird game flow methinks ... Take it too far n slayers can't land 2bstabs before ppl pot/heal etc anymore and their class-identity is gone. Too little and you don't achieve any difference. The increasing %fail of /hide (due to circumstances like being crowded rooms, due to INT, due to parties etc) sounds to me like a better/smoother way of introducing RNG of failure into what is now almost 100% certainty. It does largely reflect lore also (eg even though Terron doesn't like nerfing skills, we can't expect any slayer to always be able to find a hiding place at will within a split seconds notice etc... Even spells have fizzles). Shrugs
I'm not sure what you really mean? You remove the old system by not making your hide timer remove. It's up to you if you wanna still go back and forth but it won't help you none when the /hide timer is reduced. You're thinking like I couldn't make it not prevent a backstab for X amount of time though. AKA reset based on time, not movement.
AKA /hide timer becomes 0.5s, which is the same as going north and south. This means going north and south would be the same. However there would be some merit in going north and south still in some regards.
The other option to resolve this would instead put it into /hide DELAY attack. This means that you remove any merits of going back and forth.
Yeah, you waste attacks searching, that's is the point! In small combat, 1vs1, 2vs2, you probably won't waste so much attacks. In bigger fights, you might have one guy who has high int handle it and try to prevent slayers. I see it no different then making the /hide mechanic not work with 16 people as Jade said, the only difference is you force players to use mechanics like /search which would be done in larger groups to stop slayers. The more players around, the higher chance a slayer has to be found as more people coming out of attacks at random times will warrant them /searching, etc. And again, in 2vs2/1vs1 lets say, you wouldn't search out a player for the most case due to not wanting to waste attacks then, and probably not searching at the correct times as they wouldn't be hidden.
Doing it this way, I could even see preventing searching out your own mates. AKA a /search only finds non party members.
Jades hide method is still fine and we can go that route NP and not do the change to /hide timers or even leave it the same and do the system here or Jades system. It doesn't change the fact that I think the old movement system for hide is dumb and benefits people with faster pcs and connections. It's a relic from ROK.
yeah i like the delay when hitting players. makes no sense you hide and are instantaneously within stabbing distance of your target.
The other option to resolve this would instead put it into /hide DELAY attack..... I see it no different then making the /hide mechanic not work with 16 people as Jade said, the only difference is you force players to use mechanics like /search which would be done in larger groups to stop slayers.
I see a world of difference between these 2 options actually. Below is why.
Option1: "hide delay attack"
"Hide DELAY attack" means that ppl will always (100% of the time) have a chance to pot/heal/search/run/FF in between 2 backstabs... its already hard to land 2 backstabs in a row and it rarely happens in 1v1... so what you are doing by implementing this is screwing solo slayers from being able to pk anyone who isnt already half dead.
Option 2: reducing scale of /hide success% based on certain factors
Whereas a %fail for hide in a more crowded room (or in increasing stacking of %fail to hide if other circumstances are met eg being in party or hiding behind guard etc) means that there is still a chance to double backstab (based on your luck with RNG) and that chance is higher in solo situations and much much lower in groupfights.
Eg system could go like this:
%success of /hide = 100% - [20% - (player INT x 1%)] - 1% for each person in room - 10% if protected by paladin
Therefore a 10int horc slayer hiding in room with 16ppl (eg 8v8 battle) and sitting behind paladin would have a %success on /hide of: 100%-(20%-10%)-16%-10% = 64% ... that means he still has a 64% chance to kill via double bstab in groupfight rather than almost zero if it was "hide delay attack" (cos he'd get FFed, priest would heal victim, he'd get searched or victim would pot etc)... and most ppl will be mashing F1/F2 so they wont be waiting to see if /hide succeeds or not anyway (otherwise they would be self-imposing a delay) so it is effective and natural. This is in effect a nerf (cos currently the Horc has 100% success% on /hide in groupfight)... but at least it is not a nerf absolutely all the time due to RNG (but a delay is a nerf 100% of the time)
The same 10int Horc slayer in a solo situation hunting a solo player would have a /hide success% of 100%-10%-2%-0% = 88% (still a nerf but much more respectable for solo situations)
But a 20int DE slayer in a solo situation hunting a solo player would have a /hide success% of 100%-0%-2%-0% = 98% (much more respectable again, but requires choosing a race with less STR in any case)
etc etc
____________________________
Basically choosing something like Option 2 over Option 1 above means the following:
1. less intelligent slayers (who are generally maxing strength) will suffer abit of disadvantage hiding compared to more intelligent slayers (somewhat solves your horc = OP problem... and it fits with lore that stupider slayers would have more problems hiding)
2. slayers retain their ability to 1round slay in single combat (via possibility of quick double bstab, which would be largely removed in a "hide delay attack" situation)
3. slayers become largely less useful in crowded groupfight situations (largely stopping the scaling 10v10+ problem where multiple slayers are focus-firing backstabs on a single target, which is enough to kill anything)
4. RNG plays a bigger part, instead of a straight nerf 100% of the time by introducing a delay. A very lucky slayer could still make a difference in a group situation (ie it doesnt necessarily exclude them entirely, which may piss off ppl more).
These reasons are why i suggest option 2 as far more interesting, palatable and lore-fitting than the clunky imposition of "hide delay attack". Peace
Edit - The above is just an example of values, not the exact ones i would suggest etc. In fact i realised that my math is wrong cos to successfully land a double backstab it would need to be like 64% x 64% (or whatever) which is way too low of a chance so the values need to be tweaked anyway. Basically was just drawing out the differences in concept and showing why i prefer something like option2.
there should be an option of leaving the damage the same and lowering backstab agility by atleast 5
Option1: "hide delay attack"
"Hide DELAY attack" means that ppl will always (100% of the time) have a chance to pot/heal/search/run/FF in between 2 backstabs... its already hard to land 2 backstabs in a row and it rarely happens in 1v1... so what you are doing by implementing this is screwing solo slayers from being able to pk anyone who isnt already half dead.
All the option does if it's the 'first' option of the two I talked about would be adding a 0.5s delay. The other 0.5s for rehiding is the same delay as moving back and forth, for a 'FAST' player. 0.5s isn't alot, and to me, giving people the chance to counter with such a low amount of seconds is fine. To me this doesn't screw solo at all, unless you consider the extra 0.5s seconds between the attacks what would kill a solo player. It probably wouldn't, and potting once most of the time won't save you from dual backstabs, though in most 'surprise attack' cases, you aren't prepared and you won't react anyways. Most peoples complaints are to do with their damage, while I think that's a slight problem, I think the bigger issue is to do with high strikes that you can't react too.
%success of /hide = 100% - [20% - (player INT x 1%)] - 1% for each person in room - 10% if protected by paladin
Therefore a 10int horc slayer hiding in room with 16ppl (eg 8v8 battle) and sitting behind paladin would have a %success on /hide of: 100%-(20%-10%)-16%-10% = 64% ... that means he still has a 64% chance to kill via double bstab in groupfight rather than almost zero if it was "hide delay attack" (cos he'd get FFed, priest would heal victim, he'd get searched or victim would pot etc)... and most ppl will be mashing F1/F2 so they wont be waiting to see if /hide succeeds or not anyway (otherwise they would be self-imposing a delay) so it is effective and natural. This is in effect a nerf (cos currently the Horc has 100% success% on /hide in groupfight)... but at least it is not a nerf absolutely all the time due to RNG (but a delay is a nerf 100% of the time)
The same 10int Horc slayer in a solo situation hunting a solo player would have a /hide success% of 100%-10%-2%-0% = 88% (still a nerf but much more respectable for solo situations)
But a 20int DE slayer in a solo situation hunting a solo player would have a /hide success% of 100%-0%-2%-0% = 98% (much more respectable again, but requires choosing a race with less STR in any case)
If we do it this way it's not a bad solution either. It doesn't solve the main issues with slayers though, which is to do with being able to queue two backstabs and kill someone. I feel that it would have to be in conjunction with something else to either make them more like glass cannons like armor reduction/etc.
1. less intelligent slayers (who are generally maxing strength) will suffer abit of disadvantage hiding compared to more intelligent slayers (somewhat solves your horc = OP problem... and it fits with lore that stupider slayers would have more problems hiding)
I think option 1 is also viable for this reason. Low int is low hide. Easier to find. But both options work here in your case too.
2. slayers retain their ability to 1round slay in single combat (via possibility of quick double bstab, which would be largely removed in a "hide delay attack" situation)
Again, the whole issue with slayers to me isn't their damage so much as their ability to snipe players with no reaction due to high strikes though, at least giving some sort of reaction time, even though it's still low.
The idea for option 2 and putting it with INT will work better then static though, for sure.
there should be an option of leaving the damage the same and lowering backstab agility by atleast 5
I don't think I want to include that option <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" /> I feel like that kind of craps on slayers in everything for no reason.