← Forum archive

Amulets - What amulet type is best? (Revote)

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
We were discussing amulets the other day and we kind of talked about the amulets and potential balance issues etc. I wanted to throw this up for a quick vote and see what people like the most, if any. Obviously we added .1 and .2 amulets, they don't do much, they really aren't meant to, it was mostly to 'start' and test how they fair. There is some minor problems with the charge system but that will be addressed though soon.

1. First the original idea. Adding +1 and +0.5 amulets. There is not much to this, you just add them in game like the current amulets and done. There will probably be means for getting them all via gold eventually, though will be steep.
2. Amulets that are like 1. but also give a weakness. I.E. a STR amulet that gives 1 str, but -1 end.
3. Adding 'active' amulets. For example, we bring in amulets that give a passive 0.2 to any of your stat. When you ACTIVATE the amulet, you will get another 0.8 of that stat for X minutes/seconds. It can only be used Y times a day as well. This can be discussed more for the times per day and X minutes/seconds if people like it. This means amulets would be more of an active thing to give you bonuses in certain PVP fights that can give you an extra short boost, without being so op.
4. Adding class specific amulets. This would mean that amulets could be tweaked. For example, you can have two amulets per class. Let's say for Knights, you can have a 'Defensive Amulet' that gives 0.5 END/0.5 CHAR. And then another Knight amulet that is a 'Power Amulet' that gives 1 STR only (or something entirely different!)
5. Don't add anything. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" />

Once we figure out what is best we can go more in depth. I'm trying to cut the clatter of 1000 different ideas and make it so we pick ONE idea and then go from there. Our discusses have been a little erratic lately so I think this is might be better to get everyone to focus on X idea instead.
JadeFalcon
Seeing NH poll, and because i dont think we ever had actually a discussion about stat amulets (Sorry NH!)...
Current proposals are:

1. First the original idea. Adding +1 and +0.5 amulets. There is not much to this, you just add them in game like the current amulets and done. There will probably be means for getting them all via gold eventually, though will be steep.
2. Amulets that are like 1. but also give a weakness. I.E. a STR amulet that gives 1 str, but -1 end.
3. Adding 'active' amulets. For example, we bring in amulets that give a passive 0.2 to any of your stat. When you ACTIVATE the amulet, you will get another 0.8 of that stat for X minutes/seconds. It can only be used Y times a day as well. This can be discussed more for the times per day and X minutes/seconds if people like it. This means amulets would be more of an active thing to give you bonuses in certain PVP fights that can give you an extra short boost, without being so op.
4. Adding class specific amulets. This would mean that amulets could be tweaked. For example, you can have two amulets per class. Let's say for Knights, you can have a 'Defensive Amulet' that gives 0.5 END/0.5 CHAR. And then another Knight amulet that is a 'Power Amulet' that gives 1 STR only (or something entirely different!) If you feel that amulets are too 'op' you can also make amulets give a bonus and a weakness, (aka +0.5 agi/+0.5 str/-1 end) though again this can be discussed once we sort out what people like the most.
5. Don't add anything. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" />


I still think option 1 is the best, its simple and gives something to aim for - assuming a very steep price either in gold or PP.

Option 2 seems like something i'd consider - but thing is, it would have to cost alot less than option 1.

Option 3 seems useless to me. It is just one more macro to activate - unless you make the duration very short, but then it will have to cost alot less.

Option 4 seems grand, because you could toy a lot with this. I dont think it should necessarily add a weakness, but perhaps give each class a choice of different skills (ex. for Cavaliers, 1 amulet that gives +30ac, another that gives +1agi, another that doubles Bash chances and damage). Again price is something to be factored in.
NiteHawk
The discussion didn't happen here but most of the options are from the discussion.

I was trying to avoid making a post until we know what one we like the most, then talk about that specific option. I find we go way off-topic alot of the times and alot of people end up not bother posting, it ends up being only a couple people who post because a lot of people feel they get over ridden/stomped by off-topic banter; it's a reason why people stopped posting on the boards unfortunately. Ah well. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />

Well since it's actually here now, Option 4 is probably my bet. It would prevent certain classes being so over powered, like slayers, because you really don't want slayers having even more STR.
JadeFalcon
I actually changed my vote from 1) to 4) after i wrote this post.
I think it would much more interesting, and add a lot more diversity to the game if we could have 3 cavaliers (for example) all sporting different abilities from their amulets.
I also agree its a lot easier to manage amulets in order to give abilities that are interesting, without being OP.
NiteHawk
I actually changed my vote from 1) to 4) after i wrote this post.
I think it would much more interesting, and add a lot more diversity to the game if we could have 3 cavaliers (for example) all sporting different abilities from their amulets.
I also agree its a lot easier to manage amulets in order to give abilities that are interesting, without being OP.


P.S. I did unlock the method to change your votes now too so that's a thing, and yeah I agree too.
Kruell
Thanks for making the post. With just the poll people may read it without thinking it through all the way. I like being able to speculate somewhat because it makes people think about the answers. Plus, the very act of writing out a response sometimes can make people realize some point they hadn't thought of earlier.

1) Quick, simple, and easy... but we can do better.
2) Better than 1 when you consider balance but then the overall WOW effect of an amulet is dropped.
3) Please no. This reminds me of the pvp trinkets in Warcraft.
4) Complex. The major issue with be in equality of effectiveness between classes. I would hate for someone to come up with an amulet that gave slayers an extra .5 to their backstab multiplier. Possiblities with this are greater but it will require the most work.
5) only if it will throw off game play or overwhelm part of the player base

I've seen all the options on other games. In all cases they "worked" at least to the point that people adapted their game play to account for the item in a positive way.

oohh.... gave me an idea while thinking about other games
NiteHawk
I merged the post and it deleted the poll, thx PHPBB.

Anyways I will readd the poll in a little bit, I got some other options later.
Lateralus
Looks like it’s option 8 now you guys get to decide what’s balanced and best for each class. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />

Also make the names too let’s player source this. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" />
daedroth
doesnt allow multivoting.

i think 1 2 and 4 should be added.


I second this, options are good. Variety is the spice of life or soemthing.
Terron
i like that option, but with the examples given it just doesnt fit as a class only, seeing as every class would just about use the same amulets. it would just get horrible with sorting gear if they were boss drops later on. i would see class only amulets giving specific bonuses to the class and stat manipulation aswell.

for instance you kill an oad and he drops an amulet. the amulet is a purple called amulet thats it. once activated(person wins random or whatever can activate) it rolls a specific set of abilities randomly for the class its activated on. so say i use a brig to "identify" this amulet.
the amulet gets 1 thief enhancing bonus and 1 stat enhancement on it.

i.e deft amulet of power. the deft enhancement allows stealing easier by 3% and gold stolen increased by 8% the power enchantment adds +1 str.
JadeFalcon
Just to clarify:

We are talking about PP bought amulets, right?
I assume 600pp amulets? Just asking because Pids mentioned OAD drops

This is important because obviously price will dictate how powerful stuff is.
NiteHawk
We may add other ones but IMO we are doing one at a time. Having differences is cool but one at a time is fine.

I'm not sure the price of them now, 600PP was for the 1 stat items but it may be different now, or the same. Depends how much they give/etc.
Terron
i mean a non penalty +1 stat amulet should be high pp cost.

the offsetting penalty amulets could easily be oad drops. or even normal monster drops (similar to embers) and just have varying degrees of power. i.e lvl 15+ monsters can drop a white amulet and it gives +.1 str and -.1 agi. the stat mods can be random which would give a reason to farm. and these amulets could have generic names as in all white amulets are just called opaline amulet or something. then it just works varying degrees up until a purple amulet which is oad. maybe have these cap out at .5 and a -.5 penalty. 1 would seem excessive seeing you could farm until u get a +1 str -1 int amulet and would basically be worth 600pp.

another option is to just save the "class only" amulets as the oad specific drops and keep then more powerful amulets in this category.
Lateralus
I mean let’s have some insight here and look ahead to what the classes will want huh?

Most melee will want +1 str
A few melee might want +1 agi
Most casters will want +1 int

Druids will want +1 wis but that’s not happening too op which is why we are even suggesting class amulets. I guess what I’m getting at is we are going to have 20+ ammys and they are basically going to do close to the same thing but have diff names and won’t be interchangeable between characters unless it’s the same class. To me I don’t see the appeal to class specific but I’m happy to make 8 or so str ammy with a diff name and 4 int ammy with a diff name and so on.

Seems like a lot more complication for the players & builds for what benefit? To keep druids from having a wis ammy and maybe slayers from getting a str ammy?
Kruell
Seems like a lot more complication for the players & builds for what benefit? To keep druids from having a wis ammy and maybe slayers from getting a str ammy?

That is a very good argument. Class ammy is a great idea but with what level bonus? Is it worth the work and effort Staff will have to throw into the creation and balance of the items? Is the end result of class ammys going to make enough of an impact to make it compare to a straight +1 to a stat?

Would a Cav amulet that gives 10% damage bonus to shield bash damage be a good idea? How about a Slayer amulet that gives them an effective +2 Int on searches to be not found? Zerkers with an amulet that gives a 10% bonus to rage buildup? Chanter ammy that gives an extra 5% to pierce magic resistance? Will these bonuses be considered equal or will a this just start a rush of people claiming their favorite class was shafted?
Lateralus
Seems like a lot more complication for the players & builds for what benefit? To keep druids from having a wis ammy and maybe slayers from getting a str ammy?

That is a very good argument. Class ammy is a great idea but with what level bonus? Is it worth the work and effort Staff will have to throw into the creation and balance of the items? Is the end result of class ammys going to make enough of an impact to make it compare to a straight +1 to a stat?

Would a Cav amulet that gives 10% damage bonus to shield bash damage be a good idea? How about a Slayer amulet that gives them an effective +2 Int on searches to be not found? Zerkers with an amulet that gives a 10% bonus to rage buildup? Chanter ammy that gives an extra 5% to pierce magic resistance? Will these bonuses be considered equal or will a this just start a rush of people claiming their favorite class was shafted?


If it were going to skills it would be one thing but these class ammys we are talking about are just stats as far as I know.


Let’s see
Zerk 1 str, 1 agi
Monk 1 str, 1agi
Knight 1 str, maybe .5 end .5 Chr? Or 1 agi (why should they be limited to just 2 when they use more than two stats so another problem)
Ranger 1 str 1 agi or 1 chr (again why limited?)
Sorc 1 int, 1 wis? Or 1 end (limited)
Necro 1int, 1wis 1 end


As you can see lots of repeats and the classes that do use more than 2 main stats are going to get screwed by ya choosing what we think is best if we only do 2 ammy per class. And if we do more than two we are going to end up with 30 some amulets that really just complicates a problem that does not need to be there.
Kruell
If it were going to skills it would be one thing but these class ammys we are talking about are just stats as far as I know.

Why would we have class specific amulets that just changes stats? You are 100% right that making them stat specific to class means that the primary stat is what people will need boosted with a few people going for their secondary. Unless there is a desire to change amulets to affect skills and abilities then class specific amulets are a waste of time.
Lateralus
If it were going to skills it would be one thing but these class ammys we are talking about are just stats as far as I know.

Why would we have class specific amulets that just changes stats? You are 100% right that making them stat specific to class means that the primary stat is what people will need boosted with a few people going for their secondary. Unless there is a desire to change amulets to affect skills and abilities then class specific amulets are a waste of time.



The idea was to stop druids from using wis ammys. Which can be solved by making a mr/mp ammy that has the same values as what a wis ammy would with giving druids a boost and stopping slayers from having 26 str which adds about 40 damage to bs stops (if we are merging slayer damage anyways is a null point).

That’s the only reason they were suggested. As you pointed out before it opens up a whole other balance issue when we are deciding what classes get what stats or even worse what bonuses rather than a simple stat.