← Forum archive

Armor discussion

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

JadeFalcon
I think we all need to debate a bit armor

I think currently there is an issue of mismatching types of armor with classes (ex. 60% of classes wear medium armor).
What classes should wear what armor?
I am fairly comfortable with what we have to be honest, but others will have a different view.

Also, can/should armor that gives passive bonuses a thing?
- I personally would love if there were armor pieces that gave for example, a bonus to spell resistance, or a permanent haste bonus, at the expense of a very low AC for their class
- I would like to have armor bonuses depending on the set you are using (ex if you are using all mithril armor plus mithril weapons, you get a bonus).
Kruell
Ideally you want an even distribution of classes to types of armor but that isn't required. Spreading out who can use light/heavy helms to coincide with armor groupings for more divergence is also an idea. This would be my choice even though it isn't even.

Heavy: Cav, Guard
Medium: Elder, Minstrel, Stalker, Zerker
Light: Brigand, Ninja, Priest, Slayer
Cloth: Chanter, DM

The main issue with trying to have an even spread is who gets the boost to Heavy armor without overpowering them? If I had to spread them out evenly though right now I think I'd go the following way.

Heavy: Cav, Guard, Zerker (ling zerker op with 25 agi dodge too?)
Medium: Elder, Minstrel, Stalker
Light: Brigand, Ninja, Slayer
Cloth: Chanter, DM, Priest (possibly boost their aegis though)

I like the idea of armors that have different bonuses or abilities. Have an armor that is -2 on comparable but give a bonus to MR. A lower AC shield that gives a bonus to shield bash damage. There are plenty of possibilities but it all requires some major coding changes. I'm not sure as to how much work would be needed and too much could detract from other things needing done.

While I do like set bonuses, I'm not to thrilled with having them in Ember. Having spent a decade playing warcraft, I can say that sets are a great motivator to get people out and running. This isn't warcraft though and we won't have increases in levels every 2 years requiring new sets. If this was done I'd suggest the bonuses be mild. For instance, equipping a set worn by a Cavalier ends up giving you -5 AC (or more) but you gain bonus damage reduction or extra shield bash. Working out equivalent set armor for every class would be difficult and the bonuses would need to be hard capped. This is probably worth discussion since it could add flavor but I'm hesitant to support it due to the extra complications it could bring in.
NiteHawk
Ideally you want an even distribution of classes to types of armor but that isn't required. Spreading out who can use light/heavy helms to coincide with armor groupings for more divergence is also an idea. This would be my choice even though it isn't even.

Heavy: Cav, Guard
Medium: Elder, Minstrel, Stalker, Zerker
Light: Brigand, Ninja, Priest, Slayer
Cloth: Chanter, DM

The main issue with trying to have an even spread is who gets the boost to Heavy armor without overpowering them? If I had to spread them out evenly though right now I think I'd go the following way.

Heavy: Cav, Guard, Zerker (ling zerker op with 25 agi dodge too?)
Medium: Elder, Minstrel, Stalker
Light: Brigand, Ninja, Slayer
Cloth: Chanter, DM, Priest (possibly boost their aegis though)

I like the idea of armors that have different bonuses or abilities. Have an armor that is -2 on comparable but give a bonus to MR. A lower AC shield that gives a bonus to shield bash damage. There are plenty of possibilities but it all requires some major coding changes. I'm not sure as to how much work would be needed and too much could detract from other things needing done.

While I do like set bonuses, I'm not to thrilled with having them in Ember. Having spent a decade playing warcraft, I can say that sets are a great motivator to get people out and running. This isn't warcraft though and we won't have increases in levels every 2 years requiring new sets. If this was done I'd suggest the bonuses be mild. For instance, equipping a set worn by a Cavalier ends up giving you -5 AC (or more) but you gain bonus damage reduction or extra shield bash. Working out equivalent set armor for every class would be difficult and the bonuses would need to be hard capped. This is probably worth discussion since it could add flavor but I'm hesitant to support it due to the extra complications it could bring in.


Despite what people say, zerkers only get a -1.5agi decrease to DODGE only, and not attack. They aren't garbage dodgers, they just are a bit weaker. If you pick HO though you'll for sure have low dodge, (17.5 right?) and that makes it hard for them. That being said I think they'd be in a good spot with heavy armor though. I don't think they are so powered in PVP because of how they work and they cannot just 'get rage' everytime. it has to be built up and if you miss, it resets. Often does in PVP.

I don't think priests need to be changed, they were already changed and IMO if they are to op you just adjust aegis.

Heavy: Cav, Guard, Zerker (possibly zerker here)
Medium: Elder, Minstrel, Stalker
Light: Brigand, Ninja, Priest
Cloth: Chanter, DM, Slayer

Would be where I think it should be and probably is the most minimal changes but makes it still work. Brigs, Slayers would need adjusting, zerkers you just tell em to farm. Slayers is a debate though and depends on how they are changed.

Armor sets and the like are neat ideas though. I’d like to eventually have that. For bonuses though I don’t know if the prefix suffix thing will be too much on top with specific armor bonuses too. I intended on armor having a prefix or suffix sometimes . Think like Diablo. Atm it was going to be all suffix and prefix can be added to all ac but if you change certain classes, for example slayers to cloth, and make the armor types not all medium armor classes you could have specific prefix or suffix bonuses based on the armor type. Cloth could have spell bonuses, a light haste, etc. heavy could have additional armor, thorn armor, things like that. Not sure about that but I think the prefix suffix thing is enough to make a lot of interesting armors without adding tons of armors
JadeFalcon


Heavy: Cav, Guard, Zerker (possibly zerker here)
Medium: Elder, Minstrel, Stalker
Light: Brigand, Ninja, Priest
Cloth: Chanter, DM, Slayer


Doesnt make much sense that Brigands and slayers are in a different class..
Either way, put slayers/brigs in light, priests in cloth - i mean literally "a man of the cloth" is a synonym for priest <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
NiteHawk


Heavy: Cav, Guard, Zerker (possibly zerker here)
Medium: Elder, Minstrel, Stalker
Light: Brigand, Ninja, Priest
Cloth: Chanter, DM, Slayer


Doesnt make much sense that Brigands and slayers are in a different class..
Either way, put slayers/brigs in light, priests in cloth - i mean literally "a man of the cloth" is a synonym for priest <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />



It could be light armor for em too yeah. I probably wouldn't put priests armor up though, they could do with a little less AC anyways.

In terms though (of what I was thinking) was mainly to do with Brigs and Slayer balance, not so much the 'validity of it'. Aka Brigs have lower damage and can steal have a little higher armor, and slayers are better at damage. but have lower armor. Either or though lowering their armor to at least light is probably a OK choice here as they can use /hide for cover most of the time.
Styx
Zerker is a high dps output, equipping heavy armor could cause problems

Ps guardian dammage is weak at best
NiteHawk
Zerker is a high dps output, equipping heavy armor could cause problems

Ps guardian dammage is weak at best


I dun think you know how dem work.

The idea, on what I like about zerkers, is that they are HEAVY HITTERS, but random as hell for rage. I don't want them to have more HP, they have enough and upping HP is too much at this point. They literally die in PVP unless they get lucky (normally) and are obviously more non-resistant to magic. AKA HIGH RISK, HIGH PAYOUT IF YOUR LUCKY. It's damn rare to get three rages on at once, yet alone more than one.

I would relish the fact of making the class have heavy armor, lower agi, higher damage. This to me is a rather UNIQUE class then, and they do need a little more love, but not much. I think they're generally 'OK', its just right now that there's another option that's better due to less penalties for high damage :>

So instead of dodging, you make them absorb more damage. However, I'd say people would prefer dodging then absorbing, its not like they'll start absorbing 80% of everything just because they have slightly heavier gear. Another 10-15% of absorb at best. Might even make a zerker with a shield viable too.
JadeFalcon
If you arent giving them more HP, give them more damage - no reason why they cant round people more consistently.

Perhaps its just me, but it just seems "weird" that they should have heavier armor... i mean they are supposed to be crazy murderers without much finesse.. running around in rags, but hey, killing alot.

Edit:
I am a consistent person, i suggested that here before:

<a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=2261&start=10">viewtopic.php?f=11&t=2261&start=10</a>
Terron
cloth : ninja deathmage chanter
light: brigand priest slayer
medium: druid minstrel stalker
heavy: cavalier guardian zerker

i can tell you why i stopped using my zerker. it died in 2 rounds all the time to non slayers. it needed a guard to last more than 30 seconds. struggled finding guard users, so i just play the guard now. and on top of that slayer is just better.
Kruell
Before changing zerkers to heavy armor it would be easy to give a few zerkers AC rings to see how they do in events. Just give them 2 pp for an event no matter how they do, that way if it is overpowered they won't be stacking huge pp but it also gives them an incentive to do as many as possible just to get a good testing on how they stand. Using players this way to test the zerker would be an easy way to see if the class becomes op when boosted to the next level armor. With guilds fighting each other so much at oads and keys we will hear what people have to say about the change in the world at large. Things like this are very easy to test before implementation.

PS: Anyone want to start running their slayers or ninjas on weaker armor just for kicks to see how they do... it would be an interesting experiment.

"Tyrargo is protected by his Void Cloak." <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" />
Terron
you act like armor saves you lol

monks dont have high armor, they dont die in seconds. dodging is just more important than armor.

this is like saying the guy hit me for "10 attacks in a row for 200 each" and somehow if i was in heavy armor instead, and got hit for 10 attacks in a row for 197s youd have survived.

time to get real people.

RNG luck trumps both armor and agility

end of story.
NiteHawk
Armor on certain classes actually often lets them survive a lot longer, but depends on the type and whatnot. While it's not a guarantee as it's RNG as well, Paladins for example have around 45% absorb and 15% deflect. That means at least more than half of the fight they're absorbing/deflecting on average 35%-40% probably. Most of the attacks for survivability have nothing to do with passive armor though, only active.

It wouldn't help them though, cause a class that doesn't deal damage means it's just prolonged more than anything, though they need some modifications, the main purpose is being a wall rather than DPS. I kinda guarantee if you threw heavy armor on lets say cleric and toss em a shield, they'd take way more damage. When I was testing no armor to armor on saurians, it made their survivability a lot larger.

Monks right now have +2 ag on dodgei/+1 attack which gives them a pretty advantage. Obviously the MR comes in a factor with spell defense too. I kinda see they are the jack of all trades and need a little tweaking anyways too. I dunno where you are coming in that they don't have armor, they do. Not as high as others, but wha, 0-10 points of ac from most medium armors. Armor a that point makes little difference if your fighting someone of around the same armor value, since both your survivability are extended the same. They get their AC bonus is the reason why obviously.

A problem though with most classes and not seeing the 'difference' is because alot of them seem to end up at 80+ armor, so even though the necromancer, sorc, etc has cloth armor, you pretty much give them a heavy boost by SS and then armor types don't matter for the most case. I'm no saying certain classes don't need it. but we can probably should split armor more.

In terms of Barbarians having heavy instead of medium, it's another 10-15% of absorb chance. It wouldn't hugely affect their outcome, just make them slightly harder to kill.

Barbarians only have 1.25 AGI less dodge, not 0%, and it's not a % modifier either, it's literally removing -1.25 AGI. If they are dying, AGI is the slight issue but it's not the main. I think most people base this off word of mouth that they don't dodge worth crap, but I'm just laying down the facts here. Sure if you had a HO another -1.25 would hurt more than lets say, a LING, but it probably not the soul problem then on them.

Perhaps its just me, but it just seems "weird" that they should have heavier armor... i mean they are supposed to be crazy murderers without much finesse.. running around in rags, but hey, killing alot.


I mean, yee say this but then are against things like slayers in cloth armor. If we're gonna be 'lorey' then people who move in the shadows don't use armor, they want the most fitness/non clunky/no sound. So if we're going to start bringing in lore reasons now to me it's weird that slayers have medium armor. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" /> But I try to avoid thinking that way too, we're playing a fantasy game after all. I've seen barbarian types with heavy armor, i've seen them with no armor. I've also seen battle priests who wear heavy gear like knights, etc. There's a bunch of options anyways and I don't think we should be tied to 'what looks right' otherwise half our classes have problems.

I dunno what is the deal of having more classes that round people, no offense. I think it makes the game really boring, you can't balance anything in team combat like that either.

Anyways, if we want armor values to matter more, we probably need to stop trying to make everyones armor the same in the end with AC increases per class, AC spell buffs, etc.
Terron
well assassin isnt a class its a job. and japanese assassins often wore the same brigadine as the people they killed. you dont think an orc assassin wouldnt be a huge beast in heavy armor that splits their targets head in half with a battle axe. the problem is daggers are lightsabres on this game because of huge multipliers. the multiplier could be 2.0 and the class would still be burst damage. and still have a far easier time in group getting kills the way the game mechanics work.

i can fully say armor isnt much impact because i have joined events and won naked..
NiteHawk
View linked image

I kind of picture them like this. More scrawny but still generally built.

Also nice wins then but I didn’t say it couldn’t happen either. But in game tests heavy armor ups your general to die from 8 attacks to 13-15 attacks with a class of moderate HP but those tests were done before hp changes. Should still be relevant though. Thats an average and not always obv. Regardless the base absorb alone of 42-45% with heavy armor alone will at least do that much and absorb 20% to 50% each time.

Also

View linked image
NiteHawk
What makes the game boring is having one class that can round people with no counter to it.



COUNTER TYME.
Styx
Ok barbs can wear heavy. Just seemed wierd cause I pictured them as wild human creatures running around uncivilized

We do need to break up the armor classes just so all classes are kinda even distribution and not 6 classes relying on a single armor