Prefix/Suffix. How to do it (MK II)
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
i mean the reason hack n slash/mmo rpgs work is that you kill things alot. diablo 2 you could do boss runs in 30 seconds at times, or a couple minutes on poorer equipped stuff.
even if we had 10 oads next week and got this system inplace its literally only 10 rolls per day, if they even drop, and not everyone can enjoy it. thats the big one. i can log on an mmo and pick plants, farm gems, kill monsters for mats, kill bosses for rarer stuff, and use all that to progress an alt through crafting or something.
Hold my beer, im about to mud for 7 minutes its seta time... <---this isnt keeping people interested
+1 agree. This is the basis for my issues with the oad system (which I’ve raised previously) too. Basically terron has outlined the main problems of current oad system killing interest:
1. Too little access to enjoy drops for the majority of player base (only few oad drops a day, need mega-guild numbers to farm keys and be online at right times etc)
2. Too boring to want to access (need to grind out running same oad to kill exactly the same monsters at exactly the same time each day rather than having some variety in what you kill or when you kill it to get the items)
This is why in past I’ve suggested that general play would be vastly improved if good items dropped more randomly (in both timing and from variety of monster) rather than current oad system.
Thanks for being open to listen to ideas though NH. I get that change is going to be difficult given ppls embedded self-interest with what they currently dominate and familiarity with rok’s legacy (which makes ppl change resistant or unimaginative for something better). Peace
The oads are broken up time wise so people who want to play can, depending on what time they wish to play.
If all oads were the same time then it would be leaning towards one time zone.
If all oads were the same time then it would be leaning towards one time zone.
I hate the term oads cal them bosses and have them set to varable timers like dragons. This would work better imo. Really if the prefix/suffix material is only gonna be obtainable through current bossing then you might aswell scrap the idea all together cause its still gonna promote the same US vs THEM mentality which has guven us such great toxicity we have now.
Variable timers equal people working together at times when people have low numbers on both sides. Not everything on this game has to be a power stuggle.
Variable timers equal people working together at times when people have low numbers on both sides. Not everything on this game has to be a power stuggle.
The current OAD system is here to stay for now, it's far to deep right now for a fast change and it's not something that I think a 'random drop' like diablo handles will solve. I picture it more like WOW's drop system rather then a more randomish one. I 100% disagree with the 'complete random' system. It makes doing certain areas pointless. I do agree with adding more different drops however based on specific things. I.E. the flame salamander could drop fire weapons. etc.
I never said that bosses would be the only way to drop prefix/suffix gear though, I meant it more about any mob that can drop gear could drop a prefix/suffix gear or those small mods.
This was also the idea but as I said I wasn't 100% certain it should be 'pickable' and instead should be random rerolls, kind of how Path of Exile does it. They allow you to reroll your gear, im not 100% sure how it works but I think it gets a higher and higher cost each time. The 'idea' was that to reroll/add prefix or suffix to your gear, you would need X dust, X being the rarity.
I.E. Disenchant a blue item for blue dust, use blue dust to reroll/add prefix/suffix. I think being able to 'pick' though might be too 'easy' though. The whole HP/MP/MR addition was just EXTRAS that any item that drops could have, this didn't have nothing really to do with the prefix or suffix. It just made dropped items last a little longer.
The prefix/suffix was more something that can be added by the player, either via the item dropping and having it, or via what I talked about, some sort of crafting combine/etc or whatever.
Variable timers are nice and we'll add some more world walkers but this isn't the sole thing the game will have.
I never said that bosses would be the only way to drop prefix/suffix gear though, I meant it more about any mob that can drop gear could drop a prefix/suffix gear or those small mods.
But if the prefix/suffix bonuses were somehow craftable or able to be slowly worked towards then it would give much more incentive to play more and work towards them for ppl who are casual players, in bad oad Timezones, or don’t want to join a super-guild factional warmachine. Peace.
This was also the idea but as I said I wasn't 100% certain it should be 'pickable' and instead should be random rerolls, kind of how Path of Exile does it. They allow you to reroll your gear, im not 100% sure how it works but I think it gets a higher and higher cost each time. The 'idea' was that to reroll/add prefix or suffix to your gear, you would need X dust, X being the rarity.
I.E. Disenchant a blue item for blue dust, use blue dust to reroll/add prefix/suffix. I think being able to 'pick' though might be too 'easy' though. The whole HP/MP/MR addition was just EXTRAS that any item that drops could have, this didn't have nothing really to do with the prefix or suffix. It just made dropped items last a little longer.
The prefix/suffix was more something that can be added by the player, either via the item dropping and having it, or via what I talked about, some sort of crafting combine/etc or whatever.
Variable timers are nice and we'll add some more world walkers but this isn't the sole thing the game will have.
Right now the game is so candy assed with timers peope literally log on to do bosses at set times and log right back off during the dead zones of time people have literally nothing to do. I have always been in favor of building a char instead of the stagnate level 50+ chars system we have in place. We ain't suggesting this shit for our own interests we are suggesting things to keep people motivated and interested. It's not like any of the suggestions are overly complicated and wr understand alot of them will take time to complete but saying you are to far into a different system is just a cop out and you know it.
Right now the game is so candy assed with timers peope literally log on to do bosses at set times and log right back off during the dead zones of time people have literally nothing to do. I have always been in favor of building a char instead of the stagnate level 50+ chars system we have in place. We ain't suggesting this shit for our own interests we are suggesting things to keep people motivated and interested. It's not like any of the suggestions are overly complicated and wr understand alot of them will take time to complete but saying you are to far into a different system is just a cop out and you know it.
So you want a bunch of random timers in the game with different mob spawns like dragons. Then I think that's a bad idea to only have that. It feels like a boring system without the other stuff. I'm saying we'd add more 'variable timers;, not completely remove the current OAD system and only have variable systems mobs.
I want to add more things to do obviously during the day/etc. I think it's a good idea for foraging, crafting, disenchanting, etc, that sort of thing as Piddy was talking about in some cases (I.E. Stuff to do) and it's in the works, but to completely make everything a variable timer is a bad idea.
Alot of 'bosses' were on variable timers, (aka different times they spawned) and most of the game hated it. Just to state it's a reason why it become OADs instead. I'd prefer more of a mix (some variable, some oad) etc though.
some of both would be good
set timers will be fine when theres more to pick from at each slot. imagine having to choose from 5 oads at 4 pm. yeah that will be the fun stuff
set timers will be fine when theres more to pick from at each slot. imagine having to choose from 5 oads at 4 pm. yeah that will be the fun stuff
One of the areas in game I designed was meant to have multiple variable timer bosses. I left before the system got put in place for the monsters to be able to do what I needed them to do. After the update hits, I hope to be able to either do a lot of things I once wanted or else convince someone else to implement them. Maybe we can even get the Phantom Foreman to walk the mines like he was meant to. Most advances to the code structure allows major upgrades and options for builders to utilize. For instance, I left just as monster scripting was being rolled out. I've seen the options build from simple monsters with easy drop chances to a pretty complex system that exponentially increased what can be done in game. Like I've said in other places, a lot of the issues people see as problems in this game can be fixed by creative builders.
That's one of the systems that I like. I am totally against the idea of picking your prefix. Having the reroll with incremental cost adjustments is probably a good idea. Players can keep trying to get the modifier they want on the gear they have or keep killing the boss hoping for the right drop. As long as the items require to reroll can be gotten by anyone (not just those running the boss) then it should work just fine.
This was also the idea but as I said I wasn't 100% certain it should be 'pickable' and instead should be random rerolls, kind of how Path of Exile does it. They allow you to reroll your gear, im not 100% sure how it works but I think it gets a higher and higher cost each time. The 'idea' was that to reroll/add prefix or suffix to your gear, you would need X dust, X being the rarity.
That's one of the systems that I like. I am totally against the idea of picking your prefix. Having the reroll with incremental cost adjustments is probably a good idea. Players can keep trying to get the modifier they want on the gear they have or keep killing the boss hoping for the right drop. As long as the items require to reroll can be gotten by anyone (not just those running the boss) then it should work just fine.
i think u should be able to pick prefixes and suffixes but to get them is random when its crafted.
basically prefix and suffix are longterm crafts via enchant. once u "craft" one its modifier is rolled at random. then u can attach it to the weapon/armor
sockets would be shorter term crafts via enchant with small boosts (similar to rings).
and X amount of mods would be rolled when items drop. larger range modifiers so its hard to find perfect items
basically prefix and suffix are longterm crafts via enchant. once u "craft" one its modifier is rolled at random. then u can attach it to the weapon/armor
sockets would be shorter term crafts via enchant with small boosts (similar to rings).
and X amount of mods would be rolled when items drop. larger range modifiers so its hard to find perfect items
It's not just the boss timer spawn, it's the key spawn times also, most oads collate (or however it would be best worded ) so key times and boss spawn times are the same to be ran.
Guess we could do key expiration times of 30 minutes. But I git a bad feeling people would complain cause then they won't have enough time cause they want to do events also.
Keys were done to give time in completing a boss within a certain time period. And if people were finishing them then they could actually oad for most of the day through out, instead of just one or two oads.
Yep, could be possibly we do 30 min expiration on keys, but that would just make more saying they wanted to do events, times all clashing. But this way people have plenty of time to finish it.
All people have to do is get 1 key to stop others and or fight it out. It's the people's choice to decide what to do.
Guess we could do key expiration times of 30 minutes. But I git a bad feeling people would complain cause then they won't have enough time cause they want to do events also.
Keys were done to give time in completing a boss within a certain time period. And if people were finishing them then they could actually oad for most of the day through out, instead of just one or two oads.
Yep, could be possibly we do 30 min expiration on keys, but that would just make more saying they wanted to do events, times all clashing. But this way people have plenty of time to finish it.
All people have to do is get 1 key to stop others and or fight it out. It's the people's choice to decide what to do.
the oad system just sucks. atm
it creates gaps of noone playing. u log on for 10 minutes and log off "yay we won".
problem is, its not actively keeping people logged in at non oad times, because its predictable. log on see numbers omg 3v12 nvm good bye.
1) this will correct itself with several oads every hour - but thats a long long ways out.
2) this would be fixed if every oad was random throughout the day like a dragon - easy temporary fix, but like hawk said it can be just as crappy if the server randomly gives you nothing to do when u log on
3) this will be affected greatly by crafting and "farming" if thats ever a thing. farming in general is probably not all its cracked up to be, mini bosses spawns are infrequent as hell.
face it games new, and u got a shell. their pumping out oads to hit every range of item green/blue/purple and that isnt completed yet. all you can do is wait for more oads or randomize some. could keep the oads the same times and let rng pick which one spawns 1st through 7th, so its atleast different each day
it creates gaps of noone playing. u log on for 10 minutes and log off "yay we won".
problem is, its not actively keeping people logged in at non oad times, because its predictable. log on see numbers omg 3v12 nvm good bye.
1) this will correct itself with several oads every hour - but thats a long long ways out.
2) this would be fixed if every oad was random throughout the day like a dragon - easy temporary fix, but like hawk said it can be just as crappy if the server randomly gives you nothing to do when u log on
3) this will be affected greatly by crafting and "farming" if thats ever a thing. farming in general is probably not all its cracked up to be, mini bosses spawns are infrequent as hell.
face it games new, and u got a shell. their pumping out oads to hit every range of item green/blue/purple and that isnt completed yet. all you can do is wait for more oads or randomize some. could keep the oads the same times and let rng pick which one spawns 1st through 7th, so its atleast different each day
Or we could just be a copy of Diablo. Log a zerker, make a mad dash for the same exact boss, kill him , warp to next boss repeat, kill same exact boos till your sick of it and no true randomeaning then after a while quit answer complain cause there is nothing to do cause your killing the same exact boss over and over.
Personally I think imo we need to stop the constant bickering of rng , and work toward other goals
Personally I think imo we need to stop the constant bickering of rng , and work toward other goals
the oad system just sucks. atm
it creates gaps of noone playing. u log on for 10 minutes and log off "yay we won".
problem is, its not actively keeping people logged in at non oad times, because its predictable. log on see numbers omg 3v12 nvm good bye.
1) this will correct itself with several oads every hour - but thats a long long ways out.
2) this would be fixed if every oad was random throughout the day like a dragon - easy temporary fix, but like hawk said it can be just as crappy if the server randomly gives you nothing to do when u log on
3) this will be affected greatly by crafting and "farming" if thats ever a thing. farming in general is probably not all its cracked up to be, mini bosses spawns are infrequent as hell.
face it games new, and u got a shell. their pumping out oads to hit every range of item green/blue/purple and that isnt completed yet. all you can do is wait for more oads or randomize some. could keep the oads the same times and let rng pick which one spawns 1st through 7th, so its atleast different each day
+1. This shows sense & vision in illustrating how shorter term fixes (eg more random timers, or randomizng which OADs spawn at which times etc) can function to help stem the tide of players leaving while waiting for longer term fixes to be developed. Something does need to be done, and we dont really need to wait till there are that many OADs created to do it (otherwise there are likely not going to be enough active players left to warrant a world which has enough areas to generate multiple OADs every hour)
Or we could just be a copy of Diablo. Log a zerker, make a mad dash for the same exact boss, kill him , warp to next boss repeat, kill same exact boos till your sick of it and no true randomeaning then after a while quit answer complain cause there is nothing to do cause your killing the same exact boss over and over.
Personally I think imo we need to stop the constant bickering of rng , and work toward other goals
IMHO what you describe of Diablo is basically what EO currently is (but EO has even less depth). EO players are logging on to kill the exact same boss and repeating that day in and day out until they get bored as heck and quit (and unlike diablo you dont even get random gear drops... just 1 item to split between 6 or whatever for 1hr of work each day per OAD). And usually they only stay online for the duration of that boss/key and then log off. Terron is right that EO is new and there should be grace while it evolves. But i find your post(s) to be unimaginative and smacks a lot of the "remain calm, all is well" mentality that basically keeps an improvable status quo unchallenged.
You say we need to "stop bickering and work towards other goals" - well please do share somewhere what these lofty "other goals" are. People like Terron, Rodeo, myself etc appear to be suggesting that the most important game-design goals for player retention in EO atm are things like fixing the loot (OAD/boss) system and also the guild/faction/numbers dynamic (which leads to toxicity and causes issues with loot system also)... In my mind (at least) these are the key goals that need to be addressed before any other additions (such as new areas, guild houses, character renaming, class rebalancing, new classes etc etc) are really going to matter a great deal in retaining players longer term. But if you think there are more lofty goals we should be discussing in order to secure longer-term player retention/interest then please do raise these issues on a new thread. I'm all ears. But its probably best not to try and condescend people who are actually attempting to discuss what they think are the important issues in a thread that is related to those topics. Peace.
PS - btw if you your lofty "other goals" are something like "we need to advertise more" or something to that 'cart-before-horse' effect then feel free not to post and save me facepalming myself.
Diablo was well past beta stage and finished, with a nice budget for advertising?
Major game manufacturers have the whole game done, anyone remember guild wars , back when it was beta testing? I was beta testing and It was pretty well much a finished game with a slew of programmers etc.
Your 3 vs 12 odds would be different if we had more people whom joined the community. Yes people come and go, it's hard for people to stay when there are mmos with intense graphics etc. But then there would be other competition?
Unless you don't want other competition and want just a small group of x amount just to play?
Major game manufacturers have the whole game done, anyone remember guild wars , back when it was beta testing? I was beta testing and It was pretty well much a finished game with a slew of programmers etc.
Your 3 vs 12 odds would be different if we had more people whom joined the community. Yes people come and go, it's hard for people to stay when there are mmos with intense graphics etc. But then there would be other competition?
Unless you don't want other competition and want just a small group of x amount just to play?
And "boss" monsters spawn at given times depending on when the people are online, we could have all boss monsters spawn right at reset , but then people wouldn't be happy cause then it's not divided amongst everyone.
Ultimately our lives have changed, people have obligations to home, family etc, and our personal life must always take precident over a game.
So some do log to play for a while and relax, then they can log off, catch up on real life, which is more important, then log back in and play a little.
Even if they log just to kill something. That's an individuals personal choice on how they want to play.
Ps, when your playing at night and your child wakes up, I hope your child is more important then to keep playing a game.
This is so completely off topic.... shesh
Ultimately our lives have changed, people have obligations to home, family etc, and our personal life must always take precident over a game.
So some do log to play for a while and relax, then they can log off, catch up on real life, which is more important, then log back in and play a little.
Even if they log just to kill something. That's an individuals personal choice on how they want to play.
Ps, when your playing at night and your child wakes up, I hope your child is more important then to keep playing a game.
This is so completely off topic.... shesh
diablo didnt even have advertising. and diablo 2 didnt need much advertising after diablo won game of the year. killing monsters and farming loot, random mods, its interesting. diablo 2 added long term crafts and socketry to the genre for a reason right?
ember has nothing to do during non oad times. how do you expect to keep players even if you had a huge advertisement budget? we gotta have stuff to do all day, thats a no brainer lol.
random mods on drop wont keep people interested in the long term currently, because most people dont oad or dont get to. and combod with all non 25er gear is junk and low drop rates on good equipment, i just dont see it making people awestruck. farming drops from dozens of monsters and slowly building up craftable mods, imo, brushes more of this games content. favors non oad hours, and atleast attempts to make the game interesting all day.
the reason these threads go off topic is people think they are connected issues. you want cool random loot on oads, awesome. that brings the oad system into question, which brings the guild system into question. in this case its all relative.
what we have is huge recruitment races, no guild diversity, and a bunch of people who oad for several minutes a few times a day. and the only other reason they log on is to harass and grief the players who play outside of just oads. horrible and toxic. nothing else to do.
ember has nothing to do during non oad times. how do you expect to keep players even if you had a huge advertisement budget? we gotta have stuff to do all day, thats a no brainer lol.
random mods on drop wont keep people interested in the long term currently, because most people dont oad or dont get to. and combod with all non 25er gear is junk and low drop rates on good equipment, i just dont see it making people awestruck. farming drops from dozens of monsters and slowly building up craftable mods, imo, brushes more of this games content. favors non oad hours, and atleast attempts to make the game interesting all day.
the reason these threads go off topic is people think they are connected issues. you want cool random loot on oads, awesome. that brings the oad system into question, which brings the guild system into question. in this case its all relative.
what we have is huge recruitment races, no guild diversity, and a bunch of people who oad for several minutes a few times a day. and the only other reason they log on is to harass and grief the players who play outside of just oads. horrible and toxic. nothing else to do.
I feel like alot of us want the game to progress but it's apparent that the progression is missing steps/wrong order. I have heard time and time again from various people and staff included that this is his game he can do what he wants with it. I am gonna totally disagree with that statement altogether. With no players we have no game and without input from us players we also have no learning. I have never been the type of person to just accept things are gonna be this way forever and that's that. Everything needs work. Before this update actually hits it would be wise to go back to the start and zone everything off and balance it all out before we move forward any further cause with new additions = new problems and If we don't have the man power to properly test anything then it should be put on the back burner until it can be looked at.
Preach on piddy!
Preach on piddy!
The problem is we need more comments too by others. I'm not saying I disagree with all of it, but I don't agree with some of it either such as advertising at this time. Also comparing this game to Diablo in any sense, including advertising, is really silly too. Different times too.
No, guilds, etc have absolutely nothing to do with this topic. Make another topic for this or post on one relevant to bring it out of the grave. This is part of the reason why I hear time and time again that people stop posting and it sucks. You might disagree with it, but I've heard it from many people now. It's not that I want the lot to stop posting either, but I know people would really love less fighting amongst each other and more constructive posts on the specific topic at hand. If there's a problem with OADs, make a post with that and ways to fix it there, not in 50 other posts. OADs have a small connection with these, but no, adding prefix/suffix does not change the way OADs drop atm, so i'd have to say it's probably better for another topic, specially since it's such a HUGE one. Guilds too, it's obvious an issue there, which I know, but this area isn't the place for that either. Makes it easier to deal with too and to discuss topics. I mean why is there even a post about advertising and irl situations. Then seems like everyones doing light attacks on each other. Ugh guys.
I mean a overhaul of the OAD system would be a even heavier need to 'test' though. I'd rather have the update soon since many are waiting and then go from there, it's not a easy/light task. And again, I'd prefer a mix of them, rather then just one way. You three might not like the OADs, but there are also people who do. That's why being able to supply more then one option is better instead of nixing everything. I'm totally all for adding new ways bosses work in the game, but yeah, prefer another topic on this.
Also, the crafting system coming will involve stuff such as farming mobs etc though, that part you don't really have to be concerned about, I get grinding is apart of the game and it gives players stuff to do (though some players whine about grinding, it honestly is apart of why people will actually stay, etc). So expect that after the update too with the other stuff.
the reason these threads go off topic is people think they are connected issues. you want cool random loot on oads, awesome. that brings the oad system into question, which brings the guild system into question. in this case its all relative.
No, guilds, etc have absolutely nothing to do with this topic. Make another topic for this or post on one relevant to bring it out of the grave. This is part of the reason why I hear time and time again that people stop posting and it sucks. You might disagree with it, but I've heard it from many people now. It's not that I want the lot to stop posting either, but I know people would really love less fighting amongst each other and more constructive posts on the specific topic at hand. If there's a problem with OADs, make a post with that and ways to fix it there, not in 50 other posts. OADs have a small connection with these, but no, adding prefix/suffix does not change the way OADs drop atm, so i'd have to say it's probably better for another topic, specially since it's such a HUGE one. Guilds too, it's obvious an issue there, which I know, but this area isn't the place for that either. Makes it easier to deal with too and to discuss topics. I mean why is there even a post about advertising and irl situations. Then seems like everyones doing light attacks on each other. Ugh guys.
Everything needs work. Before this update actually hits it would be wise to go back to the start and zone everything off and balance it all out before we move forward any further cause with new additions = new problems and If we don't have the man power to properly test anything then it should be put on the back burner until it can be looked at.
I mean a overhaul of the OAD system would be a even heavier need to 'test' though. I'd rather have the update soon since many are waiting and then go from there, it's not a easy/light task. And again, I'd prefer a mix of them, rather then just one way. You three might not like the OADs, but there are also people who do. That's why being able to supply more then one option is better instead of nixing everything. I'm totally all for adding new ways bosses work in the game, but yeah, prefer another topic on this.
Also, the crafting system coming will involve stuff such as farming mobs etc though, that part you don't really have to be concerned about, I get grinding is apart of the game and it gives players stuff to do (though some players whine about grinding, it honestly is apart of why people will actually stay, etc). So expect that after the update too with the other stuff.
I agree they should be on a separate thread. But it doesn't negate that all 3 issues are directly connected to the boredom factors
I agree they should be on a separate thread. But it doesn't negate that all 3 issues are directly connected to the boredom factors
Hey we agree about the threads, but this ain't the boredom factors thread. Let's get back to prefix/suffix here. 8) I think you should bring up OADs and ideas to improve it, I'll even chime in on it as there could be ideas to it (For example, instances so that anyone can run it whenever, crafting can be brought up for crafting certain things, making 'farming' a common thing, etc.), things like that. Obviously we have one about guilds already but if we got more ideas or more discussion it should go there. I'm not 100% set on what we should do just yet on that front.
I'm still trying to see what prefix/suffix should actually be a thing, if they should be multiple bonuses for one prefix or suffix, or simply one bonus, etc. Makes a big difference code wise if we're just sticking to one bonus per prefix or suffix, etc.