← Forum archive

Guilds Redux

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Miach
Like I've said in the past, incentivize what you're trying to accomplish.

Here's an idea of the top of my head:

CREATE guildCount as Integer = 1
CREATE loopCounter as Integer = 0
CREATE tempGuild as String

loopCounter = Party.Size()
tempGuild = Party.Player(loopCounter-1).Guild()
loopCounter = loopCounter -1
WHILE (loopCounter > 0)
IF (tempGuild != Party.Player(loopCounter-1).Guild()) THEN
guildCount = guildCount + 1
END IF
loopCount = loopCount -1
END WHILE
IF (guildCount > 1)
dropRate = dropRate + (dropRate * 0.05 * guildCount)

Some pseudocode so you get the idea. Incentivize mixed grouping.

Edit: some people will take this at face value, please realize this was off the top of my head and there are other ways to incentivize group mixing without replacing the need for a brigand or anything. This was just idea #1 of what could be many ideas. I wrote it just to get your thinkers thinking.
anthriel
I'm obviously supportive of something being done to promote guild diversity and reduce factionalism within the playerbase

I dont have alot of time atm to think of new ideas so ill chuck in my comments on the existing ones:

Option 1 - I think if we go this route then a different (better) mechanism has to be put in place. Eg each account has a "house" attached to it and houses can have allegiances to other houses etc or something to that effect. I might be "House Ronin" or something... and maybe i decide that im a casual and need to become the bannerman of a more active player etc (eg say Gyko's House Brotherhood). Or maybe i become the ally of another house like Mort's House Fart or whatever. Then add in some aim like the ultimate goal for each house is to sit on throne of Alderra (which perhaps pays that account some good rewards to do aspire to this - eg PP/champmarks/gold/taxes etc per day)... so if Gyko wants to do that and gather lots of bannermen/allies then he can but he'll have to work hard to keep them all happy cos he's the only one getting the rewards from sitting on the throne... He may also have to fight off House Footclan & all AJ's bannermen/allies or House Soma & all Eli's bannermen/allies etc..... and if he doesnt keep me & his other bannermen happy we may switch allegiance to House Soma or House Footclan etc... basically something like this could end up like a game of thrones esque type dynamic (though not sure if politcally backstabbin each other could create more drama too lol - but it would be interesting)... basically it allows ppl to network more as individuals though.

Option 2 - i do think this is preferable to superguilds but the chat channel functionality may need some further upgrading to accommodate this. Otherwise a limit of even 15-20accounts could be a compromise as it would see more guild diversity than now. There may also need to be ways to help newbies (eg autojoin newbie guild where other guilds can send 1-2 of their most friendly representatives to be part of the newbie guild too - ie a functionality which allows say 2 ppl per guild to multi-guild in the newbie guild if they are the guild's designated "newbie rep"). I am a fan of some form of global embers or guild-specialisation like Wayne mentioned. It could make for more interesting dynamics.

Option 3 - this would obviously only be possible if you remove 1 guild per account. It does help reduce factionalism but i feel there is no easy mechanism to change divs on chars so unless that was introduced there would be a weird mismatch to begin with. Eg i for one have no voltus 25ers and im probably not going to bother leveling one.

Option 4 - ive never played WOW or any other factional game so i dont know how it would go. I'm not entirely sure how it solves problems having 2 large set guilds though. Its just like what we have now but you take the management out of player hands?

Other Options eg incentive systems - I'm still a fan of incentive systems rather than hard caps. I think its better to allow ppl to choose something based on what they value than be forced. You just have to make the incentives sweet enough. Some variant of my initial suggested system is still the best thing i can think of atm. Here is the link: <a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1512">viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1512</a> .... can obviously be modified to pay them in herocoins/champ-marks/more-lucrative control crystal rewards/whatever... but something like this at least promotes activity and leaves ppl with the choice of staying with all their friends and earning less or branching out to potentially earn more. Some may not take it, some will.

Shrugs that's all i have for now. Will post if i can think of any other suggestions or if any other posts here inspire ideas to that regard. Peace all.
S0mveraa
Oh yeah..allow me to add I personally think this will solve itself when we get more people playing the game, advertising and what not. The size of the player base now only allows for so much, and if we change it to meet the demands we face now. It might not be so good if we suddenly doubled in size or more ...i think. I'm just the nub tho <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Ohko
I agree guild needs to be revamped. However, the whole staff/guild thing is imo a non-issue. It have been said before and remains true, being on build is actually more disadvantageous to a guild rather than it being a benefit for the guild. You also can't split staff evenly between guild. Since I've been on staff besides NH/Lat/Ack, all I've seen are a number of rotating new staff members who for one reason or another couldn't remain being staff and inactive staff coming back for a little bit sometimes disappearing again. Can't really say, "your guild already have 2 staff members. I really want/need you on staff but you're SOL," or "You have to join another guild before I can hire you". That would just discourage people from applying to be staff and NH already needs more not less.

Out of the four options, I like a combination of option 2 and 4. (explained below)

Option 1, I think will scatter people too much. People will just organize outside of the game (ex. Discord) as someone said previously. We would probably need to have something to replace guilds tho.

Option 2 allows us to keep something to what we have already, but scaling down a bit. A max of 5 is definitely too little. 10, maybe 12 max I think is a good number I think. I've said it before, I think a size limit is a good thing. It would allow the guild to keep a group of core members and a handful of more casual players so they can have a full party to run Oads. If you have people that stops playing, kick them out and replace them with active people. When they come back, either you have space for them, join another guild or form a new one and make an alliance. This option doesn't stop alliances, but I think long term wise it will probably sort itself out. Or maybe not.

Option 3, is just weird if you split by divinity. Like Som said, one div will always beat up a specific div. Race wouldn't work either since some races don't do well for certain classes (minus Inverno's weird alts).

Option 4 is interesting. Having a 2-3 factions could work given that all sides are balanced. It would work better if there's a larger playerbase but could be done with 20-30 players. Factions get reshuffled each period/season. At the begining of each season each player picks a side, but you can not pick one that have more than the others. Selection is upon first signon at season reset so you can't really wait for the other sides to fill up so you can join your friend's side. You could, but you might be waiting awhile. During the season, you try to achieve certain goals for your fraction like how many zones you can keep control, most bosses killed, etc. At the end of the season, the players on the winning side gets some rewards (xp/gold scroll, special crafting materials, cm/pp, etc). You could still include small guilds (maybe a little bigger than strictly option 2) so people can feel they're still with their friends, but working with your guilds won't have as much of a benefit compare to factions.

With either option 2 or 4, we could include special guild/faction weekly/monthly quests.
[list]
[*]Participate in # of faction zone captures, faction wars, faction activity, etc...[/*:m]
[*]Run # daily quests with guild members[/*:m]
[*]Level # 25ers[/*:m]
[*]etc...[/*:m][/list:u]

I have some more ideas, but I'm getting too tired to type them out.
anthriel
Just responding to Soma & Miach’s well worn idea that advertising and getting more players will naturally solve the problem ...

My well worn rebuttal to this logic is this: EO has a bigger retention problem than it does attracting new players (which ROK goodwill largely takes care of)... just look at the number of forum accounts vs number of active players ... ppl r coming, playing awhile n leaving... and a large part of the problem is the current guild system which leads to factionalism, toxicity etc. So based on having seen this cycle play out many times I refute the suggestion that just advertising and getting new players with the current system is going to fix anything (cos ppl don’t stay). I can only see it repeating the current cycle/trends and burning more ROK goodwill. This is a why we need to fix the system/problem before advertising imho.
S0mveraa
Just responding to Soma & Miach’s well worn idea that advertising and getting more players will naturally solve the problem ...

My well worn rebuttal to this logic is this: EO has a bigger retention problem than it does attracting new players (which ROK goodwill largely takes care of)... just look at the number of forum accounts vs number of active players ... ppl r coming, playing awhile n leaving... and a large part of the problem is the current guild system which leads to factionalism, toxicity etc. So based on having seen this cycle play out many times I refute the suggestion that just advertising and getting new players with the current system is going to fix anything (cos ppl don’t stay). I can only see it repeating the current cycle/trends and burning more ROK goodwill. This is a why we need to fix the system/problem before advertising imho.



Yeah man I haven't been around all that long, as I said that's just my...mostly uniformed opinion, more optimism then anything else I suppose. I Support any changes that help the game grow, no matter what.
Rafael
I think that an area with middle purples (stuff that comes radiante and humed that are +1 on blues) that ENFORCE guilds to work togheter, like a guild locker to Keys, and make guildes work togheter.... its a way to reduce toxic..

make people work togheter
Hanibal
Just my 2 cents, I'm all for smaller guilds myself but the only issue with it is if its small and you need at least 5-6 people to run most if not all the keys/bosses to compete with said big guilds you cant.

To fix this why not allow a 2 character log in system?

Now some people will say won't those bigger guilds just be bigger, well of course but if it could be coded some how to limit the amount of people/guild allowed per room be it boss or key or area that may be a easy solution. Or limit the amount of people/accounts allowed per guild.

Or get rid of bosses altogether, design a craft looting system where all mobs drop items that could be crafted to make different gear, ie: cloth for light/cloth armor, iron for med/heavy and weapons, this would eliminate the need to be in a big guild other then for people to hang with.

Maybe design a dungeon crawl area that would take hours to complete, with a lot of team work with descent rewards so those people who feel they need that kind of stuff aren't left out.

I don't know, I have always been for alts, leveling alone sucks and grinding out one char at a time isnt fun either. Also not being in a boss friendly time zone doesnt allow myself and most people to be on to do them.

Again just my 2 cents and a few ideas.

Edit: Wanted to add an argument behind my train of thought, if big guilds are about getting loot and dominating world crawlers eliminate or change the way the boss system is designed, sometimes the easiest fix is overlooked. I mean most mobs drops stuff now just make it so they can be used for something other then handing them in for quests.
Miach
What is it that we're trying to accomplish?

Why is this a problem?

On your end, what can you do to fix it with or without game changes?

If everyone can answer those questions that would help. I think commonly we, as humans, look externally for a solution because it is easier than accepting that the problem can be fixed internally or that the fault is not in the game or its mechanisms.

I appreciate all of the thought and input so far, but look at the coding job a lot of the ideas require. What you're asking or proposing in many cases isn't impossible, but would 1) alter the game almost entirely or 2) become a domino effect of balance/counterbalance or 3) take a long time to develop, test, and implement.

What is the most effective and simplest solution that is not radical in nature?

Let's keep the discussion going.
Mort
What is it that we're trying to accomplish? Make the game friendlier to smaller guilds/solo play.

Why is this a problem? Not everyone wants to be in or deal with empire.(Use to be sihl) The game should not be decided by who has the most players or else we will continue to see an imbalance. I'd like to see people come back.

On your end, what can you do to fix it with or without game changes? Without changes I can quit like most of the people I have played with in the past.
Aftershock
Hey, i'm on my phone so may look a little messy. (figured i'd have a little natter about this since i got a minute)

Limiting Guilds to 10 accounts per is just going to create more drama than it's worth. You will just end up with different people in the Guilds daily. Said person doesn't log on or comply they will get removed and replaced. Then you're gonna end up with more small guilds with 2-3 people in them. Just doesn't seem a legit possibilty that will work.

Removing Guilds for me would work. You may use Discord but honestly, i don't see it happening. You can integrate a proper LFG system that can help with OADS or just let the game flow. Right now Guilds don't mix on OADS. Even when said Guild have 5 online, they won't ask another Guild if they got a member who wants to go. They will just leave it and not bother until they have people (Kinda sucks this way when other Guilds who can't get OADS could use loot). You remove alot of Guild drama and alot of PvP drama (including events). The new chat stuff you added in update will probably get alot more use (no idea what use it has now).

Divinity Guilds is another good idea but i think for this you would need to make /ignore work for Guild chat too. You will always have those trolls. Always. Would make it a nice way to add Div OADS and areas. Would also solve some of above. PvP would be interesting.

Lat mentioned an auto join type way for OADS which sounds great. That should be added!

IMO Guilds need removing. Would kinda suck to do it with the work you put into Guild Halls but honestly, people would work together rather than against if this would be to happen. Those going against this idea right now would obviously be the people who are siting pretty with a big Guild. I like that AJ said he supports whatever NH does. Fair play to him, he's a good dude.

I could be wrong but from the start, Guilds have been an issue. People are and have quit because of it. The Toxicity has mainly come from Guilds spatter too.
Miach
It's not all Empire's fault. Stop blaming others.

What can YOU do to positively impact the position of guild dominance? Why is every solution a massive coding overhaul?

I think that there's a ton of finger pointing going on about quitting because of this or that, but no one is man enough to say that they quit because they just got disinterested in the daily grind. Could people form up and fight? Sure. Is there plenty of people who are not Empire who could form up and fight? Sure. The problem isn't guild domination. The effect is guild domination, and the cause is...? People getting bored? Not having enough fun? Realizing they don't have the time commitment to play actively and the casual gamer gets the shaft?

The blame is honestly far too often put on an external factor. When people in this world want something, they stand together and fight for it and historically the political activists and activists for other reasons get stuff done and make a difference. What's happening is that instead of actually doing something about it, everyone wants NH to do something about it.

It's become a coding issue because of the laziness/casualness of others. When I asked for everyone to look at internal factors, what I'm looking for you to say is that you could do something about it. While a coding change might be a good idea, is there some other way to tackle the issue?

By the way, Empire doesn't really have that many actives. They have their good days at 10 or so, and their bad days at 2-5 or so, and they average about 4 actives at a time (using recent statistics). They commonly have the "raise the dead" on discord to fill a 5 man party and get a OaD completed. These are not overwhelming numbers. Sure, Empire has had better numbers, and so has any other major guild in the game.

It is a problem that needs to be addressed by actually competing. You're not trying.
Dan
Hello,

I don't think that guilds are the problem. The problem is guild dependance.

Join the big one or struggle.

In my opinion, the best way out of it is:

-craft system with items equally good as oads

-Oads being guild instanced

Any of the above options would help, even implemented separatedly.

That would end in guild member reduction anyway, but not a forced one.

People would have the option to choose from:

- More guild bonuses and oad drop competition with other members (bigger guild)

or

- Fewer guild bonuses and more oading drops (less competition for drops - smaller guild).


A casual could join the bigger guild and craft his items, or join a smaller guild and hit oads in a guild that plays in the same time of the day.

Idk know how hard a instanced based oad would be to implement tho.

EDIT:

I was thinking, you don't necessarilly need to instance oads, but you can make the craft system guild based, and limit the number of crafts per week, for example.

But fixed amount to all guilds, not scalable to guild size.

That would have the same, or even better effect of instancing oads (which would still be be neat), regarding people spreading in other guilds.
Mort
Wasn't blaming Empire they are just the current face of the issue that has been around since I started.
You asked what I could do. Not what we could do as a players(maybe you think two forced guilds would be better), with the options you've given without coding it's one of three things.
Join the big guild and be part of the problem, Shut up and watch it still be 20 empire vs 8 of everyone else(doesn't matter if you remove the number of online members on gtop),or find something else to do with my time. My opinion won't change with the shift to me to prove the problem is a problem. If Nitehawk is willing to code a solution then great if not then it is what it is.
Kruell
I have a habit of writing down random thoughts and musings. When I came back to this game months ago I wrote down my experiences and observations. I have a whole section of my writings devoted to guilds. One of the most glaring things I noticed about Ember was that while people complained about guilds, the game is designed to funnel people into guilds. I don't just mean guild membership for OaD completion, I mean to fully enjoy the game past level 16(ish) you need to be in a guild. Playing the game solo after a certain point becomes difficult to the point of mind numbing banality. The way that builder philosophy has structured this game, you must be in a guild once you get to a certain level or you can't complete quests, get equipment upgrades, or even level effectively. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, but at the same time it forces players into the social stigma and infighting that comes along with joining a guild. There needs to be more to this game than just joining the right guild at the right time.

Guild dominance is a problem that appears greater than it really is because people confuse their own apathy with another guild dominating them. I have seen Empire not do OaDs at all (even collect keys) and the guilds that get the keys refuse to run the OaDs. I've seen Empire invite other guilds along (not anymore due to Discord drama) on OaD runs and the other guilds get the item. I assume Silh faced some of the same complaints and issues when they were the largest guild. Before the one guild per account I was in a few guilds. Most of what I heard was ultimately an issue of motivation and not an issue of another guild oppressing others. Even the Kill/Death counter, which was a good idea, has become a reason for people to run away and cry foul if they think they are going to be outnumbered and die. Perception has overtaken reality in many facets of the game. The issue keeps coming back to guilds, as if guilds are the core problem. The reality I believe is that the game has become structured around guild warfare and all other methods of play have been ignored.

Cutting down on the number of accounts that can be in a guild is a viable option. Cutting the number too low will be destructive. Removing guilds from the game goes counter to every game treatise written over the last 15 years on MUD design. Social interaction stimulated by guilds is necessary for a healthy player base. Forcing people into guilds where the membership is determined by administration is probably going to be a major problem. Do we really want to force people into a guild with people they can't stand and constantly fight with?

I suggest that builders open up the world a bit more. Create content that is meant for a solo player or even a small team where being in a guild isn't necessary. Implement the World Embers which benefit smaller guilds more than larger. Expand quests so players can level up without having to join a guild so they can get an effective party together. Use the tools already in game and borrow ideas from other successful games to implement things that break the mold of "X Guild pwns all". Players and staff should come up with other event ideas so people can gain PP without being swarmed by one guild or an alliance of enemy guilds. Some of these things are in the works and others can actually benefit the game if they are tried.

Look at creating monthly "leader-boards" for the game. Create a point system and let players and guilds compete against each other for the top spot. Things like "most NPCs killed by X Player" or "Most NPCs killed by X Guild" in a month; most gold acquired in a month; most Experience gained by a guild during a month. These things don't reward anything except bragging rights but it also gives a better view of what is actually happening in game.

I'll leave it at this and see how others feel... otherwise I'll break the board with a novel.
Whitestar
Kruell For Prez.

Guild dominance is a problem that appears greater than it really is because people confuse their own apathy with another guild dominating them.

Show up (means empire too)

sorry i cant be helpful i get pretty much that something needs to be done. im a problem finder not solver
Terron
really just need to incentivise smaller guilds. the oad design (mainly keys) of the older oads just make it so u need huge numbers to do the oad. been this way since archfiend was only oad. gotta get 5 keys within 2 days before expiration kills your hope. gotta get 2 keys within 1 day in a 4v10 atmosphere. this is why there are huge guilds.

as far as i see it, keys favor big guilds. death sickness favors big guilds. healing and potion decay favors big guilds.

oads themselves do not favor large guilds and thats about the only thing that doesnt. a guild of 5 would get outfitted alot easier than a guild of 15 they just wont win keys. crafting would fix alot of it imo.

i think if a guild can happily keep dozens of members, then staff shouldn't tear that down, just looks bad, and wont get the desired results youre lookin for.
Whitestar
shiv, cavs, second floor all are smaller guild accessible keys. remember when silhouette sent 6 to shiv empire on occasion still managed to get. cavs and second floor are mana's dependent and generally done as little members as possible (since seemingly no one wants to do)
anthriel
Things I largely agree with that others have pointed out:
[list]
1. Guilds are good for games. I do like guild diversity and having some sort of way to group like minded people to work for common goals. I prefer to often play as an individual nowadays but i did like the guild diversity of ROK and I’d join a guild again if they had similar ideals (its abit hard to find a superguild that mirrors my ideals tho cos too many players in them)

2. Game build is favoured towards joining guilds (as kruell mentioned) and unfortunately build design like keys requiring large parties to farm or OADs appearing several hours after the key appears necessitate big guilds (as mentioned by Terron).

3. Loot system issues (eg OADs) have always been closely related to guild issues. There should be other ways of progressing towards top gear than merely joining the powerhouse guilds and placing oneself on an oad farming roster - eg crating (like Hanibal mentioned) or ranking tables (like kruell mentioned)
[/list:u]

Things I disagree with that others have raised:
[list]
1. “Current guild system is not a problem”. Yes it is. The reason is that the current system has no answer for “bigger numbers is always better”. There’s literally zero drawback to keeping as many actives or inactives on your roster as you possibly can. There’s very little incentive not to join a big faction also. This leads to the current climate of superguid factionalism whereby half the player base is conditioned to hate the entire other half and toxic drama spreads like wildfire. If you are friends with group A it’s hard to also make friends with ppl associate with group B. Game becomes a chore of logging into deal with psychological warfare & drama between factions rather than something relaxing and fun.

2. “Issue is a player issue, not a coding one”. There’s some truth to the fact that players (like all humans in society) are broken/flawed. That’s why we have laws and whatnot. Governments step in to keep things as fair and functional as possible. All this “what can you do to be a better person” is all nice and good but most societies don’t rely on this alone. They have police and legal systems etc to ensure society functions well. That’s what the coders of the game provide. If the current laws are creating bad outcomes for the community, they need to step in and make ones that produce better outcomes.

3. “Let’s just make some world events to force ppl from the current 2 superguilds to work together and that will solve the problems” - to me at the heart of this game is pvp and competitiveness. I don’t think many rok alumni aren interested in solely cooperative pve interaction. And one or 2 forced events of this aren’t going to undo all the toxicity that factionalism causes outside of this. The game is best where there is competition but not a black and white faction A vs B competition imho. More colour and unpredictability in competition would make it far more interesting.
[/list:u]

Basically I think it’s good to keep some semblance of the guild system but there needs to be a serious counter-adjustment to the current “bigger numbers is always better” truism (eg some lucrative enough incentives to make ppl think very selectively before adding to their roster). Some build adjustments to allow alternative ways to progress etc besides guild play (eg crafting, rankings, changes to OAD keys etc as others have suggested) is also a helpful avenue of investment. But whatever build adjustments are done it can’t just be within the current “bigger numbers is always better” frame otherwise it’s useless to fixing the problem (eg if you can still craft many times faster in a big guild or get still get keys for smaller OADs faster in big guild etc). Whoever it was who suggested something like limiting the amounts of crafting that guilds could do (make it slower for bigger guilds to outfit everyone) was on to the right idea. There either has to be drawbacks to being too big like that, or adequately lucrative incentives for going small (eg global embers could come in here but honestly the benefits need to be much more exponential than NH’s previous imaginings cos theres no point getting an extra +1str for being in a small guild
when that’s not going to help you stand your ground at all when outnumbered 4to1 against a larger guild).

Will keep thinking on possible equitable solutions. Peace.