← Forum archive

Events banning weapons

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Folder
1v1 events are still banning class weapons. Can we PLEASE stop doing things like this? Let me explain how amazingly powerful and glorious this banned weapon is:

Skullsplitter axe:
...This item has an average power of 29. This axe has a 10% damage bonus on greenskin and humanoid NPCs. It also increases your rage damage by 2.5% (NOT STACKABLE WITH OTHER ITEMS)...

This is the same AD as a humming PP weapon but this weapon is banned from 1v1 because of 2.5% bonus rage damage. Let's say in a 1v1 you hit 3 flurries (beyond unlikely) and they all hit for 250 damage. 750 x .025 = 19 damage.

It gets better though!

Ring of fury:
...The Ring of Fury grants 20 health on equip. It also increases your rage damage by 2.5% (NOT STACKABLE WITH OTHER ITEMS)...

This item is not banned. Not only does it give the same bonus but it also adds 20HP (again not likely to matter, but besides the point).

-----
Can we please stop preventing people with class weapons, yes like me, from doing events? Not sure why we are punishing people for having gear that is BARELY any different from other easily available gear just because it has a fancy name and is theorized to break 1v1.
Ohko
I disagree with banning class event items. They give such a small advantage that rng plays a bigger role than the slight bonus they give. Especially in 1v1, rng is the biggest factor of who wins and who's sitting in their temple.
Folder
Out of curiosity why do you feel that way Kruell? I'd argue every day of the week that RNG plays enormously more of a factor in every aspect of combat than any minor bonus from gear.

We punish people for getting marginally better gear, it's crazy. Maybe no one gives a shit but I've stopped doing events almost entirely. That's surely not what we want. Get gear > stop playing because not allowed to use gear? That can't be the goal here.

If you had 100% div weapons or something like crimson blade v1, sure, that's different. But I mean let's be honest 1v1s are all luck, it's a roll of the dice. Go ahead and put something in storebought white gear against something with full 400pp humming orange gear and guess what? The guy in white is still going to win plenty of times because the dice were in his favor.

The idea that banning any items from 1v1 or other events will magically balance out these events is backwards thinking and not being honest about how this game works.

Why stop at banning class items? Ban Easter Sword. Ban Devourer items. Ban 400pp items. Ban humming items. None of it matters, RNG wins at the end of the day. All of these items give a marginal advantage over someone who doesn't have them. If that's the goal then let's just make events use white or green items only. For fairness. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" /> <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" />
Terron
infinity arrows is worse than jagged arrows.... <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif" alt=":lol:" title="Laughing" />

personally i think why ban anything. only thing that needs a ban in 1v1 is neutral divinity.

i can roll in with a priest using skullsplitter axe ring of fury drake bone armor and whatever event items there are. still aint winning with 2 heals. i would say rng predicts the outcome of every fight but thats wrong. rng just influences which 1 of the 3 or 4 superclasses always win at that specific time. theres 12 classes and 8 surely suck regardless of event items.

how bout we get some testing and make the rules so 12 classes can win, then worry about orange and red equipment.
Rodeo
This is what I have been saying since I got the first crimson weapon ingame equip it on a character and that character can I longer be used in events. I think the mao. Mentality is that if you don’t have it then it’s unfair. What’s more unfair is keeping a player from doing something cause another group decides it’s not in their favor.
Kruell
Just from observation, but when people are allowed their class items in the game they tend to win the event. Look at the stalker with full class gear, easily won a fight club event. Same would go with other class weapons/items. It would become an issue of those who didn't have it wouldn't even bother participating. You want to encourage people without the best gear in game to compete, not show them that it's useless to fight against those in the best gear. You think 2.5% isn't much, but you are asking for 5% and saying it won't change anything. These bonuses do add up. Even if we are only talking about perception then the perception that you can't win without this stuff will prevent people from joining events. We already have perception problems with this game due to the focus of class items within a set group, we don't need more issues. If you feel that you can't compete in events, then keep a weapon for events so you can switch out in order to compete.

Be glad I'm not event cause anything that was higher than PP items would be banned from all of my events (that includes items that give bonuses not available from regular items). If everyone can't have them with effort, then nobody should be able to use them within the system that rewards better gear. The reward for owning these items should not equate to bonus PP simply because you have the items. Other games are stricter than Ember on this issue. Most ban items not gained through normal questing/oading for events. Warcraft even got rid of the bonus for having tier pvp gear by equalizing all gear across battlegrounds due to the inbalance of having top restricted items vs available items.


i can roll in with a priest using skullsplitter axe ring of fury drake bone armor and whatever event items there are. still aint winning with 2 heals. i would say rng predicts the outcome of every fight but thats wrong. rng just influences which 1 of the 3 or 4 superclasses always win at that specific time. theres 12 classes and 8 surely suck regardless of event items.


If you roll a priest with all the class gear for other classes then congratulations.. you have hacked or broken the game.

Invalid argument
Rafael
Lets equalize more, Just allow store brough itens.

Edtied to add:
I think that ppl should be abble to use what they have, maybe que should do a mosh allowing just reg blue itens, but makes a big list of itens and not allowing ppl to use os boring.
Terron
regardless the class wouldnt win even if i got a 2 hander and a shield on it and u know it. 1v1 event games all ninjas casters and cavs with a sprinkling of a druid going last or stalker never facing a mage. u know this, its only been that way since... yup forever. the gear is more or less irrelevant because div plays more of a role. well it did before neutral anyway. and rng trumps any gear aswell otherwise monks in blues wouldnt beat monks in orange/purple shit.

you can be snide about it or just plain ignorant. doesnt matter 8 classes suck because they cant win. no event weapon allows a stalker to not get destroyed by magic. stalker is a great class when no casters are in the event or you face none..
Rafael
regardless the class wouldnt win even if i got a 2 hander and a shield on it and u know it. 1v1 event games all ninjas casters and cavs with a sprinkling of a druid going last or stalker never facing a mage. u know this, its only been that way since... yup forever. the gear is more or less irrelevant because div plays more of a role. well it did before neutral anyway. and rng trumps any gear aswell otherwise monks in blues wouldnt beat monks in orange/purple shit.

you can be snide about it or just plain ignorant. doesnt matter 8 classes suck because they cant win. no event weapon allows a stalker to not get destroyed by magic. stalker is a great class when no casters are in the event or you face none..


I had a few fights against Actaeon (stalker )using my chanter, I think i Lost more than I won and my chanter have a decent gear. Stalker can win.
Kruell
you can be snide about it or just plain ignorant. doesnt matter 8 classes suck because they cant win. no event weapon allows a stalker to not get destroyed by magic. stalker is a great class when no casters are in the event or you face none..


Sorry, it just seems to me that the answer people are giving to a problem of a broken class system is to break the event system as well. Balance is a delicate thing and it does take time to get it right since changes aren't just a simple thing as turning a dial. If the issue is that your class can't win in an event without class specific items then that has nothing to do with the items but is a class ballance thing that once fixed, will break the events even further. I tend to think of solutions that won't create more problems. Instant grattification is not a good way to go for the health or longevity of a game.

As to the priest thing, if the rules don't allow priests to win then change the rules and don't crash the whole system out of pique.
The following is based on current event rules:
Enchanters and Death Mages = Changes coming, already on build testing. Can't do well now but should with update.
Elder Druid = Changes planned... not worked out yet. Good in groups cause they destroy /hide classes
Cavalier and Ninja = Already winning events and currently tops in pvp events
Stalker and Zerker = They don't win often, but they do win. Could use more testing since they are seldom used in events.
Slayer and Brig = They used to dominate, now people don't like the change but they still do well unless against a caster
Minstrel and Guardian = good in groups but can't win 1v1 against top pvp classes
Priest = fails at pvp unless in a group. Is king in a group

It isn't as lopsided and unworkable when you break it down. Not every class will be capable of standing up 1v1 against every other class.
Terron
group combat doesnt get u any prestige, regardless of what the game agenda or dynamic is you are throwing tons of pp at the same 3 classes over and over.

when u calculate a 1v1 and influence

1) class
2)rng
3) race
4) div
5)embers
6) event item - almost a non factor.

good classes win with greens, other classes cant win with oranges.

the event items dont erase a classes flaws so therefor dont really matter.

there is no balance to break imo. but what do i know ive only abused this lack of balance for 3000 pp now? yeah nvm leave it how it is.

edit: "these items have little to no effect on the outcome of battles. However, they are banned to eliminate the discouragement of newer players that may feel otherwise, causing them to not join" - might be the answer you're looking for.
anthriel
Event system is broken in its entirety anyway. You don’t even need good gear to win PP in events. You just need to live in certain good timezones and rock up for “losers moshes” and “everyone who participates gets PP” events - which happen quite regularly.

If you don’t live in one of these good timezones then good luck in getting PP at all. The event balance is already broken and barely anyone complains because the majority do live in good timezones and benefit from it. Here we have a case where a minority within that majority are complaining for further advantage. Seems like a lot of rich ppl whining to me.

In any case, whether or not ppl can use their questie oranges in events is a much smaller issue for retaining players than Folder makes out. Things like fixing the event distribution over timezones or the guild redux reforms are far more pressing. To me, this is such an insignificant issue that i would gladly concede to letting orange questies be used in events if ppl supported guild redux or event reforms being implemented.

Change it or dont change it, but please don’t give this priority over more pressing matters. That’s my 2cents. Peace all.
daedroth
You should be able to use anything or nothing.
Everyone should be able to use the gear they have or all should be made to use class specific gear (some script to enforce this?). Arena gear, all the same for all.
It is silly that you get nice gear but you cannot use it in an event. So you then need to keep a spare weapon/armour/shield (etc) that sits around until needed taking up space.
I have said all this before.
Maybe allow an extra equipment slot (for all gear) that can only be used in the event arena?
It seems like you get penalised when you get a nice shiney as is.
Ohko
Event system is broken in its entirety anyway. You don’t even need good gear to win PP in events. You just need to live in certain good timezones and rock up for “losers moshes” and “everyone who participates gets PP” events - which happen quite regularly.

If you don’t live in one of these good timezones then good luck in getting PP at all. The event balance is already broken and barely anyone complains because the majority do live in good timezones and benefit from it. Here we have a case where a minority within that majority are complaining for further advantage. Seems like a lot of rich ppl whining to me.


This has already been addressed mostly. Crystal Smash (Wed) have been run earlier around 4-6PM server time and Fight Club (Thurs) have been moved to the same time slot. There's already random moshes that are ran during the day. I live in the "good" time zone and I make it to one to three events a week including the random moshes that are held late in the evening. However, this is a whole different discussion.
Terron
i dont think it was actually addressed well. it seems like a couple events were picked to be for european gamers. but instead of giving them an 8pm event like the standard "american event time" they just got strategically placed to catch most EST players at work/dinner etc. and the participation is low quite often. which events were selected for Australians? what about school aged children on lunchbreak? they need atleast 2 events.

most gamers in any game are from pacific time zone and sadly i dont think we have any. and to attest i played the game while living in california and pretty much quit while i lived there. was nothing to do at all but train.

im sure it can be better if we had more people and could actually do events by zone.

id prefer 1v1 prestige events to go away. run moshes drafts and team events all the time so 12 classes can be cool again. then add a prestige system for each character to progress PP through quests feats and PVE stuff. then all our "SUPERLOOT" can be used.
anthriel
Event system is broken in its entirety anyway. You don’t even need good gear to win PP in events. You just need to live in certain good timezones and rock up for “losers moshes” and “everyone who participates gets PP” events - which happen quite regularly.

If you don’t live in one of these good timezones then good luck in getting PP at all. The event balance is already broken and barely anyone complains because the majority do live in good timezones and benefit from it. Here we have a case where a minority within that majority are complaining for further advantage. Seems like a lot of rich ppl whining to me.


This has already been addressed mostly. Crystal Smash (Wed) have been run earlier around 4-6PM server time and Fight Club (Thurs) have been moved to the same time slot. There's already random moshes that are ran during the day. I live in the "good" time zone and I make it to one to three events a week including the random moshes that are held late in the evening. However, this is a whole different discussion.


You are right- it is a different discussion. But you are wrong that it is “mostly addressed”. I live in Oceania region and it’s a rare day I see any event on at a time I can participate. And it’s not just a matter of needing more event staff. There are creative ways to allow for more fair PP distribution (eg A no pk room worldwalker that spawns between 3-5am server time that drops silver herocoins into inventory of ppl hitting it, random Easter eggs spawning at 3-5am server time etc). In any case I raised it merely as an example of something that is ACTUALLY broken with the event/PP system which fixing could help a lot more players than a small already-privileged minority. Anyways i’ve pitched in my dose of perspective for the day so pls carry on discussing the main topic if you think it’s worth it (I don’t). Peace.
Miach
It's rare to see an event at all, really.

I like in the "optimal" timezone and with my schedule I just don't see much other than KoTH.
daedroth
It's rare to see an event at all, really.

I like in the "optimal" timezone and with my schedule I just don't see much other than KoTH.


and i never get to see KoTH. I see the odd random team mosh.