2 hander option for chanters.
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
i think allowing a 2 hander option for sorc/chanter would open up some variation and be like a whole new class with almost no work from devs.
personally there is no way to get max str int wis agi end anyway so a "battle mage" would be choosing where to place its weakness anyway.
any thoughts?
personally there is no way to get max str int wis agi end anyway so a "battle mage" would be choosing where to place its weakness anyway.
any thoughts?
Spell damage based on equipped item is coming. They can't wear a shield so you can simply say already that a staff is 2 handed for them. If you are talking about letting them equip a 2hander like spectral scythe in order to melee that would be interesting but it would cut their magic damage down by half probably. I kinda like the idea if that's what you mean. If you mean they get bonus spell damage (since their spell damage will depend upon their weapon) then I'd say no because they already don't wear shields so there is no trade off.
yes i mean using a scythe or whatever and being a melee character with lesser support. fade for the suprise attack, power/ss for damage/armor boost and max str. more or less the character would lose wisdom or int. so its spell casting dps would take a hit.
This sounds interesting but I’m guessing that even a 24str mage wielding a 2Hander would do less damage than a blast. This is cos each class seems to have a different (hidden) damage modifier such that 24str on a cav doesn’t equate to same damage as 24str on an elder or a priest etc. I’m guessing mages have the lowest damage modifier, which would more than offset a 2Hander’s damage increase to their current staves.
I’d love to see a battlemage class inmplemented some day though - but I’m guessing that it may actually need to be coded as a new class.
I’d love to see a battlemage class inmplemented some day though - but I’m guessing that it may actually need to be coded as a new class.
mage doesnt actually have the lowest modifier im pretty sure slayer and brig do. 21.5 ad staff on a 10 str mage is 66.5 AD. 24.5 AD dagger on 10 str brig/slayer is 66.
no im for certain they wont be out smashing 250s like a cav can potentially do. however, a race with nice str and decent Int on top might hit quite hard.
sometimes its not about adding new bests. i for 1 would just settle for new classes in general, but this is "like" a new class with almost no effort from nitehawk. that being said im sure most players would try it once or twice. some may even like it.
besides blast is pretty low damage without div and enhancements/buffs. you do like 143-182 with 24 int. im pretty sure a 2 hander and 23 ish str(base +power) on chanter with 2 hander will hit as much as that.
no im for certain they wont be out smashing 250s like a cav can potentially do. however, a race with nice str and decent Int on top might hit quite hard.
sometimes its not about adding new bests. i for 1 would just settle for new classes in general, but this is "like" a new class with almost no effort from nitehawk. that being said im sure most players would try it once or twice. some may even like it.
besides blast is pretty low damage without div and enhancements/buffs. you do like 143-182 with 24 int. im pretty sure a 2 hander and 23 ish str(base +power) on chanter with 2 hander will hit as much as that.
To give perspective... tested this on build and a 16 str (19.5 powered) gnome chanter with a skullsplitter axe on neutral div does the following:
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 155 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 150 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 145 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 136 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 131 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 126 points of damage!
Maybe for 25+ or "prestige" abilities wielding a 2 hander will be an option. I do like the idea and it would add flavor and a difference to the game but I'm not too sure about implimenting this until it's tested further. I can imagine a whole hoard of enchanters running around with their melee weapons and that just isn't good imo. Maybe have these give 0 spellpower so your blast was maxing at 80 damage on div... make people have to choose between a spell weapon and a melee weapon. Heck, I'd love to see a melee chanter mosh!
I'm not sure if this will work or ever be implimented... but it gave me a smile thinking about it.
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 155 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 150 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 145 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 136 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 131 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 126 points of damage!
Maybe for 25+ or "prestige" abilities wielding a 2 hander will be an option. I do like the idea and it would add flavor and a difference to the game but I'm not too sure about implimenting this until it's tested further. I can imagine a whole hoard of enchanters running around with their melee weapons and that just isn't good imo. Maybe have these give 0 spellpower so your blast was maxing at 80 damage on div... make people have to choose between a spell weapon and a melee weapon. Heck, I'd love to see a melee chanter mosh!
I'm not sure if this will work or ever be implimented... but it gave me a smile thinking about it.
why would u pick 16 str melee wizard? lol try a dwarf or dark elf. maybe a goblin saurian or even drake.
dark elf would be like 23.3 str 20 22 18 20 15 10. or 20 22 18 17 18 10 etc
but yeah my idea is that their spell damage is basically gone. or something like blast cant be cast w/o a staff is possible.
dark elf would be like 23.3 str 20 22 18 20 15 10. or 20 22 18 17 18 10 etc
but yeah my idea is that their spell damage is basically gone. or something like blast cant be cast w/o a staff is possible.
To give perspective... tested this on build and a 16 str (19.5 powered) gnome chanter with a skullsplitter axe on neutral div does the following:
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 155 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 150 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 145 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 136 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 131 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 126 points of damage!
Maybe for 25+ or "prestige" abilities wielding a 2 hander will be an option. I do like the idea and it would add flavor and a difference to the game but I'm not too sure about implimenting this until it's tested further. I can imagine a whole hoard of enchanters running around with their melee weapons and that just isn't good imo. Maybe have these give 0 spellpower so your blast was maxing at 80 damage on div... make people have to choose between a spell weapon and a melee weapon. Heck, I'd love to see a melee chanter mosh!
I'm not sure if this will work or ever be implimented... but it gave me a smile thinking about it.
This dmg seens preety good for this character build. I would lvl one for sure.
To give perspective... tested this on build and a 16 str (19.5 powered) gnome chanter with a skullsplitter axe on neutral div does the following:
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 155 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 150 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 145 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 136 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 131 points of damage!
You attack a lightning dummy with your skullsplitter axe for 126 points of damage!
Maybe for 25+ or "prestige" abilities wielding a 2 hander will be an option. I do like the idea and it would add flavor and a difference to the game but I'm not too sure about implimenting this until it's tested further. I can imagine a whole hoard of enchanters running around with their melee weapons and that just isn't good imo. Maybe have these give 0 spellpower so your blast was maxing at 80 damage on div... make people have to choose between a spell weapon and a melee weapon. Heck, I'd love to see a melee chanter mosh!
I'm not sure if this will work or ever be implimented... but it gave me a smile thinking about it.
This dmg seens preety good for this character build. I would lvl one for sure.
Remember, that is with a Skullsplitter. It would be nice to see it with a Spectral Scythe (hint hint maybe) or celestial halberd (and as Piddy sorta mentioned, something with more strength? Gnome, Elf, Drow please? FOR !!!SCIENCE!!!).
why would u pick 16 str melee wizard? lol try a dwarf or dark elf. maybe a goblin saurian or even drake.
Cause I was doing it quick and dirty and I don't have an orc chanter
yeah either way it would be fun.
Kind of a pain to make these so here's probably the most logical build for this idea
View linked image
View linked image
Cheers Rigs!
lookin good, i want one.
I mean I don't know what kind of testing this is though <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" /> We're testing using sword two handers, something they'll never achieve anyways. Even if a staff weapon was introduced, it wouldn't be sword levels, and then would have to be class locked too just in case. But seems like a hack that way.
I'd rather just boost their class damage overall to about that damage as posted above (or slightly less as I don't see that he STR buffed himself) rather then faffing about with making class only weapons that are this specific. Even if it was a two hander staff (???) it's only 1/1 to 2/2 more which wouldn't give them the damage you see above. That is if we even do it.
Really what you want is a better class damage modifier.
Two handers promote nothing as if two handers are the best weapons for them, that's all they'd go for. They only have 'one weapon' and no shield, so introducing a two hander with no reason not to use a two hander (because they don't use shields) makes no real sense. There's an actual reason to use two handers vs a shield as it's more damage vs more defense.
Simply making their str modifier better would be the real solution here. Necromancers can use daggers, something which doesn't get used anyways currently and would probably assist them somewhat.
I'd rather just boost their class damage overall to about that damage as posted above (or slightly less as I don't see that he STR buffed himself) rather then faffing about with making class only weapons that are this specific. Even if it was a two hander staff (???) it's only 1/1 to 2/2 more which wouldn't give them the damage you see above. That is if we even do it.
Really what you want is a better class damage modifier.
Two handers promote nothing as if two handers are the best weapons for them, that's all they'd go for. They only have 'one weapon' and no shield, so introducing a two hander with no reason not to use a two hander (because they don't use shields) makes no real sense. There's an actual reason to use two handers vs a shield as it's more damage vs more defense.
Simply making their str modifier better would be the real solution here. Necromancers can use daggers, something which doesn't get used anyways currently and would probably assist them somewhat.
I.E. A 23 str/20 int would boost to 26str on a sorc, hitting for 137-174 damage with the boost.
I.E. A 23 str/20 int with a dagger necro, hitting for 144-172 damage with the boost.
Something like that I guess, or around.. Based on with div, no ember, brill purple atm.
I.E. A 23 str/20 int with a dagger necro, hitting for 144-172 damage with the boost.
Something like that I guess, or around.. Based on with div, no ember, brill purple atm.
i think youre reading too much into it. i want them to use a 2 hander like a battle mage and lose channeling power by having no focus(wand/staff). the idea is choice. opening up class variations and in all honesty opening up the class in general to over a half dozen races. i dont really just want super staffs or 2 handed staffs that already just sounds like alot of nothing. i mean if thats the case you an just make the power spell 2x as powerful on self. the idea isnt to have a class do superior physical and magic damage. as something would have to balance the spell output with some sort of sacrifice factor. possibly no blast w/o a staff equipped.
i chose 2 handers because they seem more or less a 1 class item, and not even optimal for zerks either. to be frank i prefer 2 1 handers and double embers any day. i think the game hasnt quite caught up to that yet as swords are a little scarce but wont be forever.
i think everyone would agree boosting chanter damage with 2 handed staff/power boost isnt really fair to other classes who generally have to pick 1 type of damage. and chanter could easily sacrifice the +1 and a couple wisdom and have a character doing high physical and magical damage. that isnt what I intended with the suggestion. that being said lets weigh in the pros and cons.
PROS:
-12 races can actually be a chanter
-decent melee character with levitate
-2 handers get a prime use. (recently i was in silhouette and handed every cavalier in guild a 2 hander and we still had over 40 2 handers on storage)
- magic oriented class that can actually hurt other casters.
- hybrid damage user (theres a few of these they dont really work pvp but pve its nice sometimes)
CONS:
-lose blast while equipping 2 handers (only real way to counterbalance this otherwise the premise is just a bard with blast)
-armor blocks/absorbs
-shieldless melee user(not prime in pvp)
-will generally have less AGI than other melee users.
BIT of BOTH:
-generally have to lose MR to achieve best battlemage stats. (bad for player, good for gameplay)
i chose 2 handers because they seem more or less a 1 class item, and not even optimal for zerks either. to be frank i prefer 2 1 handers and double embers any day. i think the game hasnt quite caught up to that yet as swords are a little scarce but wont be forever.
i think everyone would agree boosting chanter damage with 2 handed staff/power boost isnt really fair to other classes who generally have to pick 1 type of damage. and chanter could easily sacrifice the +1 and a couple wisdom and have a character doing high physical and magical damage. that isnt what I intended with the suggestion. that being said lets weigh in the pros and cons.
PROS:
-12 races can actually be a chanter
-decent melee character with levitate
-2 handers get a prime use. (recently i was in silhouette and handed every cavalier in guild a 2 hander and we still had over 40 2 handers on storage)
- magic oriented class that can actually hurt other casters.
- hybrid damage user (theres a few of these they dont really work pvp but pve its nice sometimes)
CONS:
-lose blast while equipping 2 handers (only real way to counterbalance this otherwise the premise is just a bard with blast)
-armor blocks/absorbs
-shieldless melee user(not prime in pvp)
-will generally have less AGI than other melee users.
BIT of BOTH:
-generally have to lose MR to achieve best battlemage stats. (bad for player, good for gameplay)