← Forum archive

Instead of 25+

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Hanibal
Im just full of ideas lately and have played many many games with different systems to keep people active and not know what to do after max level.

One game in particular had a rebirth system after max level and it gave you options for different class combos, now they only had 4 primary classes but i don't see why it wouldn't work with this game even though it has many more.

I'll explain how it worked.

So you hit max level, tried a few different classes now what?

Rebirth, resets your character back to level one with a new ability depending on the path you choose to take, natural rebirth for example priest > priest might give you a new spell or a chance to reflect damage.

All your gear you choose to leave equiped has a chance to get a bonus, of course you have to unequip or it autos unequip cus its lvl 25 but this could add a new market for differing gear or make those greens actually worth something.

What if you decide to go priest > ninja, here's where new skills could be added and a wider range class types, your new ninja with rebirth could now have a minor heal spell or a cool new hp steal effect, again because of the wide range of classes this game has the combos are endless, well almost.

The game i mentioned above has had a very strong player base and has lasted for years with many games like it and this is not something ive ever seen in a MuD type game, im sure people have tried it or maybe not and this one could be the first.
Hanibal
Possible rebirth skill break down:

Pure rebirths would get a specific skill and combo rebirths would get one possibly two skills from the class they were previously and maybe a hp boost when lvling up the 2nd time so if they were getting 40 hps avg per lvl maybe 43-45 the 2nd time around , it could look something like this.

Priest > Priest - at 2nd lvl 25 heal spell that heals to whole party

Paly > Paly - at 2nd lvl 25 reflect, kind of like bash but could deal upto 100% dmg

Elder > Elder - at 2nd lvl 25 haste would add one additional stam, so 5 attacks instead of 4

Zerker > Zerker - at 2nd lvl 25 rage, 200% (can be adjusted) attack dmg for one round plus .5 agi one round

slayer > slayer - no exh with auto sneak, hide and stab timers non existent

Mini > Mini - new song maybe agi song or something

Now a few examples of a mixed rebirth

Priest > Pally - stronger heal spell maybe like aid, so basically a battle priest to balance maybe it takes more mana then it did for the priest to use

Cav > Slayer - able to wear heavier armor, so can upgrade from cloth to medium or maybe the slayer gets to bash the cav previously had?

Priest > ninja - minor heal spell, basically any priest > whatever class gets a minor heal spell

pally > mini - mini could learn /protect maybe?, paly > whatever class would learn protect that actually drops after X amount of stam so they have to redo it?

Slayer > Cav - at 25 could learn death strike, kinda like a backstab maybe not as strong, slayer > whatever class would learn this skill, imagine a slayer > priest with a kick ass attack it could use when not healing everyone, of course AD plays a big part in the dmg so you wouldnt see a priest death strike for 400+.

All non pure would probably need a stat allocate and this could be given for free after rebirth.

If your armor class doesnt fit into what your reborning into so be it either goign from cloth to heavy or vice versa the system would give you a coin so you can change that gear much like when slayers armor was changed but with a possibilty of getting a hum or some cool stat bonus?

Anyway just a few ideas and i figured it would be easier to code some new cool skills then add new lvls, gear and areas for lvl 25+ to lvl in.
NiteHawk
That's pretty much what we intended on doing. Just adding more levels will create a bigger problem with PK and other things. I've also talked about making two 'class branches' (aka skills) for each class to branch too. I.E. a Sorc could maybe focus on buffs or damage branch. A priest might focus on single target vs group heals. I don't think I want dual classing though, I think it's going to be way to hard to balance 100+ different 'class combos' to be fair.

But yeah it's generally how I would want it in general. :> So you're not far off anyways.
Hanibal
That's pretty much what we intended on doing. Just adding more levels will create a bigger problem with PK and other things. I've also talked about making two 'class branches' (aka skills) for each class to branch too. I.E. a Sorc could maybe focus on buffs or damage branch. A priest might focus on single target vs group heals. I don't think I want dual classing though, I think it's going to be way to hard to balance 100+ different 'class combos' to be fair.

But yeah it's generally how I would want it in general. :> So you're not far off anyways.


Wouldnt be a duel class really, just a rebirth to a new class keeping one of the previous classes skills, true balance is done by the player base not so much by the builders, all classes should have a bane thats where having the right party composition helps you win battles.

My idea is basically a branch of skills as you mentioned just relvling back to 25 to get them, I so wanted to relvl my useless horc slayer into a cav with a /death strike skill lol

I like what you guys are doing, keep up the great work. Feel like this game is going in the right direction it just needs those few tweeks.
Terron
"true balance is done by the player base not so much by the builders"

lol very true, atleast it should be. problem is it has been easier to whine for nerfs instead of leveling the bane.
daedroth
Brainstorming!:
I think with Perks or Rebirth, with either one you should have choices to make and you should not be able to eventually get all the choices.

If rebirth you can only go through each class once (or a maximum of X amount of classes), choosing an option from three choices?
Could even be a pre-existing class skill/spell/weapon/armour choice (One that you have at 8th). Balancing in some cases could be icky, but just leave out unbalanced choices?

If perks, you go from 1 - 25th again with a choice of perk every X amount of levels (maybe make it 1, 8, 15, 20, 25). Choice from three at each point (choice based on class base: Rogue, Fighter, Mage, Healer or actual class, or combinations, maybe even racial)?
You can only do this once.


Ideas:
DDO Rebirth System: <a class="postlink" href="https://ddowiki.com/page/Past_Life_Feats">https://ddowiki.com/page/Past_Life_Feats</a> (I think this is where this idea came from, could be wrong though).

Fallout Tactics Perks: <a class="postlink" href="http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_Tactics_perks">http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_Tactics_perks</a> (I chose this one because there are way more than Fallout 1/2).

Only adding the below coz, meh.

Fallout 3: <a class="postlink" href="http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_3_perks">http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_3_perks</a>

Fallout 4: <a class="postlink" href="http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_4_perks">http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_4_perks</a>

Etc etc.

Fallout Tactics: <a class="postlink" href="http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_Tactics_traits">http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_Tactics_traits</a> (Traits to be chosen on character creation or rebirth, if wanted).
Terron
well, if we just do rebirth, it becomes stagnant again in a month. yay u got a mage. that relevels and is a...yep mage. itll be like conquer where u get like 4 rebirths now? lol they just keep adding more for players to "grow"

level 25 should be fine.
perks are fine just pick em every level, really just adds flavor.
fallout trait types on creation would be cool. huge bonuses with huge drawbacks.

the reason i say endless "leveling" is because you can create a system of progression that doesnt end and doesnt really matter just slightly helps in a non damage/hit rate way.

obviously we dont want level 400s with 9000% hit rate on level 25s. the leveling should stop at 25 period. then 25ers can have a separate "grind level" that promotes them bonus every 100-250 or so million exp. itll rack up by using the characters via oad/farming/holiday events etc. but again the bonuses should be small. a few hps, a couple mana, 0.1 to a skill roll. you could even cap the amount a character can select the same "perk". but in all, its just better.
NiteHawk
well, if we just do rebirth, it becomes stagnant again in a month. yay u got a mage. that relevels and is a...yep mage. itll be like conquer where u get like 4 rebirths now? lol they just keep adding more for players to "grow"

level 25 should be fine.
perks are fine just pick em every level, really just adds flavor.
fallout trait types on creation would be cool. huge bonuses with huge drawbacks.

the reason i say endless "leveling" is because you can create a system of progression that doesnt end and doesnt really matter just slightly helps in a non damage/hit rate way.

obviously we dont want level 400s with 9000% hit rate on level 25s. the leveling should stop at 25 period. then 25ers can have a separate "grind level" that promotes them bonus every 100-250 or so million exp. itll rack up by using the characters via oad/farming/holiday events etc. but again the bonuses should be small. a few hps, a couple mana, 0.1 to a skill roll. you could even cap the amount a character can select the same "perk". but in all, its just better.


Well I am not a fan of endless leveling too. I assume we'd just do some sort of level 25-50 that works like a 'rebirth', something like that.
Perks are another perhaps too instead of rebirth type leveling. I would have a cap after a certain amount though for sure.
Terron
yah i dont want levels in a sense, as in anything that gives combat benefits or affects the current pvp system. i dont think a level 25 bonus level 2 should increase in hit rate or damage or anything over a level 25 bonus level 0.

i also dont think you should be able to grind a level 25 in 3 days then rebirth it in 3 days because it ends up as nothing, might aswell just double the exp requirements and give them a pick a path ability half way through. its the same. i think this is the easy button.
however, its not a bad start to progression post 25. it will just be short lived really. and still doesnt fix the problem of benefitting using characters for a long time. you just level twice instead of once. (hope tonya is ready)

a perk system would be epic for character development. preferably one with like 3 points every level to diversify your characters and make them different.

all of these will be fun, i just think a single rebirth is more like a temporary fix. but im not against it in any way. a longer/better progression system can always be added later on.

Edit: i posted something similar awhile back about a class restructure thing at level 25. <a class="postlink-local" href="https://ember-online.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=2086">viewtopic.php?f=20&t=2086</a>
anthriel
I don’t mind more progression (e.g. some sort of 25+ rebirth etc) but I feel that the way we go with 50ish characters there is bound to be more leveling/equipment fatigue (I suspect there is already some but it would be worse if suddenly everyone’s 25ers were the equivalent of a lvl 20 again and you have 50 of em)

So I offer an alternative suggestion. It doesn’t fix all the progression problems and I’m still happy to have some sort of additional progression in tandem (but maybe not as much as lvl 25-50). What it does do is allow people who want to play more of a “main” to do so and see tangible benefits of doing so, but also with some additional risk/replayability.

Basically I suggest this: now that we are all restricted to 1 account each, allow each account to create 1 special character (let’s call these angelic/demonic characters for lack of a better creative lore term atm). These characters only require 10% the exp to level to lvl25, have 50% more HP and hit for 150% damage to a normal 25er (these values could be adjusted eg maybe 50% on more HP on priest is OP but basically they should dominate). Their drawback is that they suffer permadeath (basically upon death, you are back to lvl 1, all exp is wiped and all items equipped and in inventory are dropped - ie soulbinding doesn’t work).

Here is why I think this system would benefit the game:

[list]
1. People could enjoy playing these characters as mains and dominating with them. Eg say someone like JF/Tyrargo could have a angelic/demonic saurian slayer and round people like he wants to. Dominating is something ppl enjoyed in ROK (usually via obtaining OP weapons) and lament not being able to do as much in EO (so we cater for this market)
2. There is a risk/reward with dominating. Right now if Tyrargo is hunting you he could do so with impunity and zero repercussion (and he has done so in the past). But if he was using one of these chars then he may kill you easier, but as a victim you might now find it worth setting a trap for him (eg asking a guildie to put a secretly faded chanter in your party). If you kill him then he has to level 35mil again before he can come back after you. (The combination of points 1&2 should revive the Pking element from ROK that was lost in recent no-exp-loss etc changes, but do it in a better/more fair way than early EO)
3. It helps even out the "bigger numbers = always better" PVP dynamic cos now you have a choice to bring one of these ‘uber’ characters to try and offset the numbers imbalance. 3 could actually beat 5 If one of the 3 was a demonic/angelic char. None of the 5 may want to risk their own demonic/angelic chars.
4. It promotes more leveling in a nice way. Basically levelling 35mil is not very hard for anyone and most people won’t find this too tedious. Yes it would hurt to lose your angelic/demonic char but you could get it back in not too long. With more repeated leveling of these chars, more game areas are used and there is an incentive to PK again. Eg JF is re-levelling his demonic-Saurian slayer Tyrargo - maybe let’s go hunt him! (i.e. the main chars being re-levelled and targeted for PKing are likely these uber angelic/demonic chars)
5. It increases the market for (currently useless) grey and green items. Who wants a dreadfang? Only newbs or perhaps as fodder when crafting comes in. But with this system you will want dreadfangs cos it’s unlikely u r gonna equip your demonic saurian slayer with a devils horn (cos its likely he will eventually die and you will drop it). So the market & usefulness for green items especially will increase.
6. Could add some spice to events if these chars were added (eg you could gamble to win the whole thing by bringing your angelic/demonic char but if someone else does too then one of u will be crying). Alternatively you could ban these chars from some events (or have angelic/demonic char only events) if it makes for better balance.
7. Allows ppl to try different race/class combos quicker than the tedious grind of lvling a normal 25er. I’m never going to level an elemental guardian for example (I know others have, but with my lack of time and for very niche use, it’s just not worth it). But with these angelic/demonic chars only needing 30-35mil exp I just might do so. And when it dies evenetually, I might try levelling an intelligence-build gnome elder (something else I think is not worth it now but could be viable as an angelic/demonic char)
8. Allows people to do OADs undermanned (ie improves numbers needed for PVE dynamic). Perhaps using these demonic/angelic chars you might be able to risk doing mana caverns OAD with only 3 ppl. This would reduce the strain of always needing big numbers and big guilds etc to do things.
9. Allows new players to get into the game and enjoy interacting with others in endgame action much faster. Right now, the perception of new players is often that they are stuck grinding away alone slowly while their guildies are off doing some keys, bosses and other 'fun' stuff they cant participate in (level-locked zones/areas makes this even worse cos u may not even be able to level with others if say you are at lvl 20 and your guildies are 23+ leveling in dreadlands). With these type chars at least the newbie could quickly get a character that could help do 'cool' stuff and interact with others on endgame content. This should help new player interest/retention.
10. It opens a new paradigm for casual players, which could help playerbase growth. Basically some casuals may decide to only play their one angelic/demonic char and enjoy doing that. (Hardcore players can still invest in building their versatile army of 50+ regular 25ers). With this option, a casual can enjoy endgame content in a short amount of time-investment and not overly care about farming the best purple equip etc cos their angelic/demonic char should be quite competitive to normal chars, and if/when they die they can happily enjoy the replayability. This could help if trying to cater for mass market (esp if EO is serious about trying to enter the realm of games for tablets/apps etc where ppl want more instant gratification).
[/list:u]

Basically what I’m suggesting doesn’t solve all the problems of ongoing progression but it does add a lot of “replayability” and it caters to a lot of “markets” of players and what they liked about ROK (eg pking, dominating etc) while adding some helpful counterbalances to current EO (reduces emphasis on numbers for pvp/pvp, adds risks to pking/dominating, allows people to focus on a “main” if they choose, revives economy for green items etc etc).

Hope this helps. Peace.
Terron
myself i wouldnt bother with a supercrit on this game. the only ones that will be used are slayers (150% damage...) and chanters yummo 250-350s. they will only be used to grief other characters. and all that power insta gibbed when you leave town and get dropped instantly by 2 npcs slapping you for 700s as you walk by. whats to say you even equip them anyway? 150% i can probably round anyone with 2 raiders edge while naked.

yeah wouldnt bother contributing to griefing everyone thats left. theres always pac-man if i want to play high score games. you could essentially just give every class rounding power and achieve exactly what u want. it just burns everyone out.

we really need to focus on enjoyment of everyone and all future prospects. not implementing things that benefit a select few and anger others.
anthriel
It’s hard to “focus on the enjoyment of everyone” because people enjoy different things. Some want to pk/pvp and dominate. Some want to be left alone to pve. Some want to RP etc. You are the one who rightly said we can’t afford to alienate any groups of players.

My suggestion is merely trying to help cater for more different “markets” of enjoyment. So what if ppl use the chars to PK. Right now the victim loses next to nothing and under my system the risk is all on the PKer cos he could lose his char if things go badly for him. If +50%hp/+150%damage is too much then make it 30% or whatever shrugs. It’s basically the concept (for the reasons I outlined) that I am saying will be helpful overall. It adds replayability. It blends with the current system relatively well (ie instead of nerfing everyone’s permanent characters it lets u play 2 diff tracks - ie. permanent and impermanent characters - which have their own pros/cons/functions etc). It helps with a lot of the ‘numbers’ balance issues (if done well). And each account only gets 1 so it’s not like it’s going to flood the game with grief (there’s a limit to it anyway cos u can just eventually kill the persons supercrit and send them back to re-leveling). Shrugs.
Terron
need to get them content so they can dominate. if its pks they want those are pretty easy when characters have flaws. however most of the characters used dont have flaws now. mages rape slayers in seconds so noone uses slayers. mages are scarce because theres no lizards roaming around anymore, mostly just used on dragons. characters are supposed to have flaws so they can be defeated. be it brute force/hide skill/magic whatever. just seems like skills get nerfed so brute force can win everything, and in group brute force is exploitable so we all go better then well rounded races like dark elf goblin and helf.

everyone is high mr melee because you are generally immune to casters and at nearly no disadvantage to hardcore dps races because if a horc or saurian actually shows up, people just swap to caster and slaughter it. if the horc doesnt notice beforehand and instantly swap to dark elf instead...problem 1 is way way too many characters but that isnt changing. i tried getting no swapping character changes on areas and not even a whisper. the system is like caster >melee = melee with mr > caster, the = part should go away and be changed to >.

ive played hardcore modes on games, and all too many times i just dont play that way after some stupid server crash, power outage, horrible mechanic destroys my character while im helpless. never again imo.

your idea is an option but i dont think itll draw support because of the ability to grief others.
anthriel
(mainly @Terrron)

I actually think having my angelic/demonic supercrit idea will also improve the rock/paper/scissors (ie weaknesses/flaws) system. See right now say you have a Horc slayer. There is no mage in the world who can round you. It doesnt matter what equip/race/etc you have - the mage's 4 attacks and even a watcher exploding is still probably not going round a full HP Horc. And so the Horc slayer can attempt to round the mage and run if you fail. Its hardly "being destroyed" by your kryptonite/weakness... in fact the mage is the one on the defensive cos they can get rounded! This is an example where the current rock/paper/scissors (ie weaknesses system) fails.

But if the supercrits were in the game then the Horcs have to rethink. Now there is some magicuser out there that could totally round them. Anyone with a supercrit Chanter/DM could probably round them easily. And the same fear would go into all the people who play other high DPS, low MR race/class builds. This helps make the rock/paper/scissor system actually work!

And the swapping problem is managed by the fact ppl can only have 1 supercrit per account. My supercrit could be a Saurian Zerker. I could be running around smashing all your normal melee crits. Then you switch to your supercrit which happens to be a Chanter. Im screwed at this point. Cos i dont have say an equivalent Elder or whatever magekiller class supercrit to switch to. This again helps with the rock/paper/scissors by putting a limit to it. And it encourages specialisation of whatever your main/supercrit is.

So yeah i hear what you are saying, but I think having 1 supercrit per account will actually help fix what you are lamenting of (for the reasons ive mentioned).
Terron
yeah man i said its an option for sure. i just am way to casual to grind 35m exp a day even if i started with max stam. also i fight 1v10 alot so theres no reason i would want to partake. the things i enjoy most on the game would get me killed regardless of supercrit status. ktps paralyze grabbed by npc as u walk by, rounded by a queuing bug. theres just too much against it for me.

it would end up feeling like you had to have a supercrit to compete vs several supercrits at a dragon fight or something. then sooner or later u die, and go back to level 1. meanwhile several of the supercrits that you kill or died in general are back the very next day, while my ass is grinding exp for a month to get it back. its an option but im not really interested.