← Forum archive

Logging off exploitation.

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

daedroth
Right, not sure how this one will be perceived.
Ever hated when someone logged out to avoid being pkd/to drop steal etc?
I play another game where even after you log out you remain in game for 3 minutes... i found this out the hard way (no one was around me at the time... but logged on dead losing lots of shit, and wondered wtf happened?).
"Off" is written in brackets, by their name.
I am not suggesting anything as long as 3 minutes, i think that is too much, but maybe some delay in logging off?
I know it will be inconvenient (I have 2 kids, random shit happens with them, but such is life).
I am also not bothered if this is implemented, it is just something I witnessed in another game.
Lateralus
I wouldnt mind seeing this but im not sure how complicated it would be programming wise and if problems from it would pop bug wise. Think 3 mins is a bit long maybe like 1min?
Zilveari
With this would come an issue with people DCing accidentally and getting killed. Possibly while holding an expensive item that is not SBed or a ton of gold.
daedroth
Oh yeh, Im aware of accidental disconnects, but a lot of the time it tends to affect all people. In olden days bad internet could be blamed, but most internet connections are fast now. Right now im having a problem with our phone wire, phone calls kills my internet, hanging up also does this. Also a lot of the time when accidental discons happen your ghosted anyway.
Hmm... do I sound bad by saying, "sometimes shit happens"?
Kawasaki
With a 3 minute delay it would prevent the user from logging back on in the case of accidental disconnect, might be a bad idea because of that.
Rodeo
15 to 30 secs that's enough time to get a round off into them before they log off so when they do log back on they don't get off Scott free. It could be adjusted so no more than a round can be got in.
daedroth
Well, as i said several times, the 3 minute logout is what the other game uses and I think that is too long; but some kind of delay would be nice. Right now this would affect me quite badly, problem with wire and two young kids to look after means random doscons (I am actually ghosting right now coz internet flurbed on me, pretty sure im dead too). I think server stability would be a factor in this, as in if the server is screwy (ala old rok) it may be a pain in the ass (but as I also said, then its not just you getting affected).

Wow, still ghosted, thats far more than 3 minutes <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
daedroth
Decided to ressurect this posting because it seems that some people are very brave when their out pking on 25ths, but when the situation is reversed they logg off like p*****s (although in this case it was a pkk, and kudos to those who stayed).

I am so tempted to name and shame...

It is a Horrid tactic, and needs to be hit on the head with a Mallet.

Anyway, could there be a cool down introduced that stops you gfrom logging off when youve been in combat (like the eating food one but twice as long)?
The simplest would be to just combine it with the combat cooler, but eh...
Vindal
Decided to ressurect this posting because it seems that some people are very brave when their out pking on 25ths, but when the situation is reversed they logg off like p*****s (although in this case it was a pkk, and kudos to those who stayed).

I am so tempted to name and shame...

It is a Horrid tactic, and needs to be hit on the head with a Mallet.

Anyway, could there be a cool down introduced that stops you gfrom logging off when youve been in combat (like the eating food one but twice as long)?
The simplest would be to just combine it with the combat cooler, but eh...


I hear you. I got no problem that saying yes when your crew of SIX 25ers shows up to our leveling group of level 20s that I log off of my leveler and onto my 25er to try and defend our group. I will absolutely claim this behavior without a problem. If you want me to go one square north next time onto a safe zone before switching over I have no problem doing that instead. I don't call out anytime you Silo babies log out during a PK.

I will also say fuck you to your face instead of that nonsense you just posted.
Vindal
On a constructive note I see no problem with a logout timer of 30ish seconds when a disconnect happens. It kind of makes sense. But also 30 seconds for a level 8 soloing a mob is more than likely a death. I can argue in favor or against it either way.

Also still fuck you.
daedroth
On a constructive note I see no problem with a logout timer of 30ish seconds when a disconnect happens. It kind of makes sense. But also 30 seconds for a level 8 soloing a mob is more than likely a death. I can argue in favor of it either way.

Also still fuck you.


Touch a nerve did I?

I cannot speak for my clannies (I have never witnessed any of them logg off to avoid being pk'd, but I am not on all the time), but I have never logged of when there has been a pk attempt on me, even when I was new (to Rok) and even when I had stuff to lose. I would fight or flee.
Personally I think you are just saying that to save face or to vindicate yourself, but nm.
How you react is entirely up to you, I just find logging off lame. Fight or flee (to a safe spot - not one square away, unless it is a safe spot) THEN log on your 25th.
I thought better of you man.

Dying at level 8 to a mob or pker is not really much of a set back. What about jumping out of the room first (with regards to mob)?
If your speaking on behalf of newbies, it will be a learning experience for them. They will remember not to allow themselves to get into such a predicament the next time (ie: low on health oopsie better take evasive maneuvers, have pots, use pots).
Sorry but that argument is lame also.
Vindal
I don't care to stand and fight, and I don't care to lose xp when necessary. I stand my ground plenty and I die plenty. This time I logged onto my alt to try and come protect my clannies and didn't think of it any more than that. Feel like you're owed a kill? Shoot me a page and I will come let you take one of my leveling alts out if it will make you feel better, I will just spend eight minutes leveling it back.

I was just speaking in general. As I said I personally think it makes sense to have a delay timer whether the logout is purposely or accidental. Whether the lesson is don't run or buy better internet I think both make for a better gaming experience.
Lavelia
I see this going horrifically wrong for those that end up disconnecting from the game. I personally have this issue from time to time and, in all honesty, when I'm leveling on my alts and I get hit with a disconnect then, for whatever reason, end up ghosting because of it I worry. Because I seldom go up against mobs that are weaker than my character, which means that every second I'm ghosted in game (which is basically what you're recommending to have happen) there's a high chance my character is going to die because I can't heal. Yes, internet is faster but it's not always reliable. Power outages happen, disconnects happen due to weather, the ISP decides it needs to do an update to their network, or you live in a part of the world with crappy internet services (a friend of mine lives out in the country and they have satellite internet and it causes disconnects a lot) this idea would harm the game more than help it.

As for logging out while pking....you know what was done on Nightmist when that happened? A party would sit on the square until the player logged back in and then the battle would resume. It was effective. Annoying, but effective.

Logging off in an instant is something that players should be able to do because as someone already said in this thread, stuff happens. I don't think normal players should be penalized for something that happens during PVP in all honesty and this suggestion to add a timer to log out is just that, imposing a penalty on regular players. Anyways, that's my opinion on this matter.
daedroth
But the choice to log off is surely seen as a command from the user (you go to the options and choose to log out right or click on the windows close option?) so isn't there a way for the game to differentiate between that and your internet connection going wonky?

My proposal would not have any effect ghosting however or random disconnects you mention, that would happen regardless.
However there should be an idle disconnect with a variable setting chosen by the play (ala old rok). That might save some asses if you set it short enough. Or if there is a way for the game to see that there is on longer any communication from your end, then you get auto disconnected after a count of 30 (that would possibly help with ghosting), kinda like Vindal said.

Also this would affect me a lot, since I go afk/log off to deal with my kids or answer the commands of my wife and such like, but such is life. I will either try n take an extra couple of seconds to get to safe spot and log or take my chances and log off where i am.

As for the loses. There is not much, all of which are easily gained back, money/exp/items.

Also a countdown rather than a combat specific one, as in you cant be locked online by something attacking you.
Thi
I lol'd at this post, struck a nerve right on.

I do agree with the log off timer, and quite possibly another timer to enter safe zones after being in a pvp fight.
Mujahideen
I would like to see it where not only can you not log off for a minute, but you also can't run more than 1 square from the original spot where you got attacked by another player for 30 seconds.
Folder
I would like to see it where not only can you not log off for a minute, but you also can't run more than 1 square from the original spot where you got attacked by another player for 30 seconds.


lol that's way too harsh.
daedroth
I would like to see it where not only can you not log off for a minute, but you also can't run more than 1 square from the original spot where you got attacked by another player for 30 seconds.


lol that's way too harsh.

Not for pkers; pkers wet dream <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Imagine how many people would rage quit... OMG! I would be forced to stand and fight! <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_eek.gif" alt=":shock:" title="Shocked" />