Making caster weapons matter
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
This was mentioned last night when we were chatting, but it'd be nice for caster weapons to impact their spell casting in some way. It just makes more sense, and it'd make gearing them more interesting.
Initial suggestions so far:
- Alter the spell dmg formula so weapon level is involved. You'd aim for the same damage values you have now, but it'd make weapons actually matter.
- Weapons increase spell duration. This would be cool for stoneskin/haste, but it could be challenging to balance.
- Frizzle/unaffect rates. This could over complicate these formulas since they are influenced by stats and races (if like RoK) already.
- World benefits. Weapons let casters access certain areas throughout the world like hidden shops/guilds/warp paths. Less about power and more about convenience.
Initial suggestions so far:
- Alter the spell dmg formula so weapon level is involved. You'd aim for the same damage values you have now, but it'd make weapons actually matter.
- Weapons increase spell duration. This would be cool for stoneskin/haste, but it could be challenging to balance.
- Frizzle/unaffect rates. This could over complicate these formulas since they are influenced by stats and races (if like RoK) already.
- World benefits. Weapons let casters access certain areas throughout the world like hidden shops/guilds/warp paths. Less about power and more about convenience.
kinda on the fence on this since it complicates things a bit but a simple way would be adding int or wis to the weapon. Maybe this could be added down the road if they need a bit more power once we see how everything balances out.
As Lateralus says dding +Int/Wis would probably do the trick and be easily done. I think these items would cost a good bit of money though.
I am always in favor of adding stat mods through wrapons
OOOO What about variations to the enchantment spell? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Standard +to power or + to stat etc. Meh, just an idea.
Standard +to power or + to stat etc. Meh, just an idea.
What was always irritating about rok is that if you didn't pay cash for Stat mod items you simply never got to use them unless you had some friends with some major cheddar. I think if stat mods are ingame they should be obtainable by anyone just not the elite few.
But thats discriminating against the elite few!
Ok I was thinking about this while on patrol.
If something like the enchantment for stats thing was to be used:
Right Click on item - Enchant - drop down menu for enchant type you want.
Now the icky bit I do not know the values about what I am about to speak of, but bare with me:
From memory dull enchant = +4 ac, so lets assume its +4 attack power as well, and lets for simplicity say +4 attack power is equal to +1 str, then it would be simple conversion, you choose +4ac or attack or +1 stat bonus (although who would want + to attack power if you could get the str equivelant?... but I digress).
Str/Int/Agl: Are the easy ones, itll just be the equivelant of a + to the stat
End: is roughly +3 hp/lvl per +1, so thats easy also (does it give poison resistance also? always thought it should personally).
Wis: not sure how much mana/MR this adds but same principal as End
Chr: is a bit more icky, but you could use something like +1hp/lvl & +1 mp/lvl and + to charm chance (and whatever else chr gets used for...) per +
Obviosuly there would nbeed to be something added to the level up script to take into account the equipment stat enchantments.
I also think this should only apply to body armour and weapons... although that would be unbalanced in favour of dual wielders... ack... unless only one stat enchantment is applied from a weapon, and the other is ignored (so players responsibility to choose attack power)?
Eh... im going now
Could even add suffixes... for example a Long Sword with a Strength enchant: Long Sword of Strength
If something like the enchantment for stats thing was to be used:
Right Click on item - Enchant - drop down menu for enchant type you want.
Now the icky bit I do not know the values about what I am about to speak of, but bare with me:
From memory dull enchant = +4 ac, so lets assume its +4 attack power as well, and lets for simplicity say +4 attack power is equal to +1 str, then it would be simple conversion, you choose +4ac or attack or +1 stat bonus (although who would want + to attack power if you could get the str equivelant?... but I digress).
Str/Int/Agl: Are the easy ones, itll just be the equivelant of a + to the stat
End: is roughly +3 hp/lvl per +1, so thats easy also (does it give poison resistance also? always thought it should personally).
Wis: not sure how much mana/MR this adds but same principal as End
Chr: is a bit more icky, but you could use something like +1hp/lvl & +1 mp/lvl and + to charm chance (and whatever else chr gets used for...) per +
Obviosuly there would nbeed to be something added to the level up script to take into account the equipment stat enchantments.
I also think this should only apply to body armour and weapons... although that would be unbalanced in favour of dual wielders... ack... unless only one stat enchantment is applied from a weapon, and the other is ignored (so players responsibility to choose attack power)?
Eh... im going now
Could even add suffixes... for example a Long Sword with a Strength enchant: Long Sword of Strength
The simplest way to tackle adding stats to items is to avoid a enchantment system and make oads that drop with a stat already affixed to them and have them set as class specific weapons and armor so you avoid dual welders being able to to abuse them by setting the item as max equip of 1 only so they can't use two of the same weapon example two swords that give +1 you can only equip one at a time.
I am also in favor of making rings and amulets that give Armor and stats aswell as long as they are obtainable ingame. But if we go the route of stats being added through items I would rather see 2-4 ac rings and amulets with a variety of stat mods being added to the game instead of weapons and armor altered to add stats.
Ring of strength 4 ac +1 str and so on and so forth with other stats maybe have a max equip of 1 stat mod ring and you can only equip armor rings after you equip a stat ring.
Can even get fancy and add gloves and boots. But let's see what chris sas on it. I think it could be alot of fun.
I am also in favor of making rings and amulets that give Armor and stats aswell as long as they are obtainable ingame. But if we go the route of stats being added through items I would rather see 2-4 ac rings and amulets with a variety of stat mods being added to the game instead of weapons and armor altered to add stats.
Ring of strength 4 ac +1 str and so on and so forth with other stats maybe have a max equip of 1 stat mod ring and you can only equip armor rings after you equip a stat ring.
Can even get fancy and add gloves and boots. But let's see what chris sas on it. I think it could be alot of fun.
Stat adding items working out just depends on how the formulas scale. In RoK, they were generally broken for agi ones because ago scaled super fast.
I'm not sure how I feel about rings/amulets/etc that give flat stats. I just want caster weapons to matter more than them trying to melee with 10 strength or weird chanter builds with max strength lol
I'm not sure how I feel about rings/amulets/etc that give flat stats. I just want caster weapons to matter more than them trying to melee with 10 strength or weird chanter builds with max strength lol
I remember in RoK when we did the world TGC for best of class. One of my Death Mages won because he was able to beat the crap out of other casters with his staff and therefore had better mana economy. He even managed to win a few open TGCs using the same tactics. I also had an enchanter who won several TGCs using the same tactic. Caster weapons did matter if the player was willing to think outside the box. Half Elves were the kings in that build btw.
I agree that caster weapons should have some reason other than decoration or freaks like me who love to pwn elitists jerks. All this talk of adding stats to the items sounds cool and all but it's a coding and balance nightmare. The thought of adding different "enchants" to the weapon is rediculously complicated as well for the same reasons. I know we all wish that we could go full bore and get this thing up to 100% of it's potential in a very short amount of time but there is only one coder who also happens to have a life. Things can be added later and that's good but let's not be trying to make things too complicated at the start.
With all that said I do have a suggestion that would be fairly easy to put in. Add the bonus from enchants and blesses into the damage formula for spells as well as melee. It's a small thing, but it helps. Then I'd look at the formula for spell resolution and see if I couldn't use the weapon levels into the formula for fissle and unaffect. These small steps will change the trend of having chanters running around with no weapons at all or those who just carried rocks or some other novelty item for obit laughs.
I agree that caster weapons should have some reason other than decoration or freaks like me who love to pwn elitists jerks. All this talk of adding stats to the items sounds cool and all but it's a coding and balance nightmare. The thought of adding different "enchants" to the weapon is rediculously complicated as well for the same reasons. I know we all wish that we could go full bore and get this thing up to 100% of it's potential in a very short amount of time but there is only one coder who also happens to have a life. Things can be added later and that's good but let's not be trying to make things too complicated at the start.
With all that said I do have a suggestion that would be fairly easy to put in. Add the bonus from enchants and blesses into the damage formula for spells as well as melee. It's a small thing, but it helps. Then I'd look at the formula for spell resolution and see if I couldn't use the weapon levels into the formula for fissle and unaffect. These small steps will change the trend of having chanters running around with no weapons at all or those who just carried rocks or some other novelty item for obit laughs.
Don't have time to read it all but right now any divinity bonuses on a weapon will reflect on spells too. You can contest this but if a regular weapon has a 5% bonus then generally a spell could have it too. This includes the embers that can be added to items in the future.
I don't think stat bonuses should be on every items, and I think you guys are over complicating things. I'd say something like OADs could be class specific and give some bonuses (for example more damage = more int). one int point typically give 5-10 damage extra, extended duration, etc. I don't want stat bonuses to be a typical thing on all classes though. It's a touchy subject.
If anything staves would have an extra stat modifier, something simple, like spell damage, that increases the spells by X damage or X percent. I'm not so sure it's needed though just yet. I think the embers that will change how weapons, armors, spells boosts, etc will work is enough to start and effect generally everything without effecting the game so greatly (Assuming 1-5% embers. Check the embers post for more details.)
I don't think stat bonuses should be on every items, and I think you guys are over complicating things. I'd say something like OADs could be class specific and give some bonuses (for example more damage = more int). one int point typically give 5-10 damage extra, extended duration, etc. I don't want stat bonuses to be a typical thing on all classes though. It's a touchy subject.
If anything staves would have an extra stat modifier, something simple, like spell damage, that increases the spells by X damage or X percent. I'm not so sure it's needed though just yet. I think the embers that will change how weapons, armors, spells boosts, etc will work is enough to start and effect generally everything without effecting the game so greatly (Assuming 1-5% embers. Check the embers post for more details.)
What about a D2-esque approach to mage weapons?
They could have charges of determined spells, or lower-end variations or weapon-unique spells. And these need gold to be recharged.
For example, Crystal Staff can come with 20 curel-like charges. So this will give limited healing to sorcys, and can be refilled at a considerable rate so they can be used as a gold sink.
Suggestions of spells:
- Small, stackable buffs (AC, Agi, Str)
- Heals
- High accuracy, low damage spells
- Summons
They could have charges of determined spells, or lower-end variations or weapon-unique spells. And these need gold to be recharged.
For example, Crystal Staff can come with 20 curel-like charges. So this will give limited healing to sorcys, and can be refilled at a considerable rate so they can be used as a gold sink.
Suggestions of spells:
- Small, stackable buffs (AC, Agi, Str)
- Heals
- High accuracy, low damage spells
- Summons
Or maybe just make mage weapons add a % to spell damage?
Or even damage % to determined spells. Or maybe have them increase the efficiency of other spells like stoneskin or the str buff.
It would be nice for staves to be useful for once.
Or even damage % to determined spells. Or maybe have them increase the efficiency of other spells like stoneskin or the str buff.
It would be nice for staves to be useful for once.
I forgot to write last patch I changed it.
At the moment it gives piercing power, aka less chance to resist. It'll give duration as well. It doesn't need to grant any change to the bonus, it's too hard to balance if we get that technical with it and I'd rather keep the damage simple.
Remember ember bonus or a div weapon does effect damage though. 8)
At the moment it gives piercing power, aka less chance to resist. It'll give duration as well. It doesn't need to grant any change to the bonus, it's too hard to balance if we get that technical with it and I'd rather keep the damage simple.
Remember ember bonus or a div weapon does effect damage though. 8)
MR was adjusted. Overall it's higher.
Staves now increase piercing the targets MR and dealing damage. They also increase duration of positive spells, like stoneskin or power. I lowered the durations on positive spells to compensate for it a little as well.
This at least makes generic staves useful now. (Though embers will help damage a bit too...)
Staves now increase piercing the targets MR and dealing damage. They also increase duration of positive spells, like stoneskin or power. I lowered the durations on positive spells to compensate for it a little as well.
This at least makes generic staves useful now. (Though embers will help damage a bit too...)