← Forum archive

1 Character

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Lateralus
So I know most of you are not going to be fans of this suggestion but I think it might be the single most important aspect of the game succeeding and here is why.

We are going to want to attract new players and limiting people to playing 1 character is going to be critical in that. New players shouldnt have to worry about mulitple windows when starting and vets shouldnt have an advantage over them because they do play more than one. By limiting to 1 character it makes the game soo much more approachable and really adds to the RP aspect of the game as well.


We have a fresh start and a chance to build the game around this 1 character limit rather than how the game before was slowly built around alts. Towards the end of rok it was nearly impossible to level solo just because of how the game was built for alts but if we start it right I dont see this being a problem at all.


While I know rok is unique there really arnt successful games that allow more than 1 character (you can multibox in a few but the general playerbase doesn't).

So yes let the flaming begin but I really think this should be considered. Look past your wants for rok and consider the future of it.

I use to actively recruit for rok and when i introduced people to the game it went a little something like this: OK pick your class and then make a paladin too because without playing atleast 2 characters you really dont have a chance. It really shouldnt be like that.
damaji
You've got my vote for this as well. Everything is easier to balance and it makes utility classes much beloved. The whole point of the game, to me, is to be an in-game version of Me, not this me, that me, the other me.
Rodeo
As long as I can have multiple chars In my account I am down for the 1 alt limit. Just make sure joey can log his hats from my account. IP based? Lol
Satsujin
I'm all for a single alt logged in at a time limit. There may need to be something worked out for the case where two or more people are playing from the same IP, but we can cross that bridge when we get to it.


On the other hand, trying to recruit new people by telling them how they need to play the game is (to be very blunt) a stupid thing to do for any game. When I first started on ROK, I had much more fun with the game when I was just leveling my thief, even if I wasn't particularly "good" at the game. Then people told me I needed a paladin if I was going to do anything at all, and they refused to let up on it, so I forced myself to stop leveling a thief I was having fun playing in order to level a paladin that I didn't want. Then I needed a sorcerer, because no one wants someone on OADs who isn't running a guard/chanter combo unless they absolutely have to have another class. Even with BOTH of those things, I still wasn't "doing it right" by their standards - my guardian was half-elf instead of halfling, my sorcerer was an elf instead of gnome, and I stopped having any kind of fun because I kept hearing I was playing the game wrong. I didn't start having fun on ROK again until I literally told everyone to go eat a dick and went back to playing my way.

Which has very little to do with the topic, but I felt that needed to be said.
Lateralus
You've got my vote for this as well. Everything is easier to balance and it makes utility classes much beloved. The whole point of the game, to me, is to be an in-game version of Me, not this me, that me, the other me.



Thats exactly how I see it as well. I really love the RP aspect of the game and I feel like it loses a lot of that when you are running alts.
Lateralus
As long as I can have multiple chars In my account I am down for the 1 alt limit. Just make sure joey can log his hats from my account. IP based? Lol


Of course on multiple account characters and I assume Chris will implement a vault type feature so transferring items between characters can be done very easily.
Dorgon
As long as I can have multiple chars In my account I am down for the 1 alt limit. Just make sure joey can log his hats from my account. IP based? Lol


Of course on multiple account characters and I assume Chris will implement a vault type feature so transferring items between characters can be done very easily.


I'm all for one alt at a time, and I love the idea of a vault to transfer items between them. Just in case I haven't said it lately, you guys are awesome!!!@
NiteHawk
Yeah the vaults already in place but needs to be linked I think to all characters. Maybe not though, it might work as intended. I don't remember <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />

In terms of 1 character. I think that's 'ok' if people feel that should be the max. I was actually thinking 2 characters limit for the purpose of leveling. 3 is too much. However if we go with one only, that's okay too. I just worry about things like leveling getting a bit to painful for classes that can't heal and must use potions which are often costly.

The benefit obviously with 1 character is balance. You can balance OADS for example alot easier. But again, two would be fine too as long as its never changed from that. I think either or ROK was never balanced for the amount of characters it allowed, it was a bit of a mess with that.



Either or I'm going to convert this post to a poll, just have a quick vote.
Lateralus
Yeah the vaults already in place but needs to be linked I think to all characters. Maybe not though, it might work as intended. I don't remember <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />

In terms of 1 character. I think that's 'ok' if people feel that should be the max. I was actually thinking 2 characters limit for the purpose of leveling. 3 is too much. However if we go with one only, that's okay too. I just worry about things like leveling getting a bit to painful for classes that can't heal and must use potions which are often costly.

The benefit obviously with 1 character is balance. You can balance OADS for example alot easier. But again, two would be fine too as long as its never changed from that. I think either or ROK was never balanced for the amount of characters it allowed, it was a bit of a mess with that.



Either or I'm going to convert this post to a poll, just have a quick vote.



For me 2alts might as well be 10atls just the more than 1 window really takes away from the RP experience and is discouraging to new players. If this game succeeds and I think it will we are going to be the minority of the player base. We need these new players and with anything above 1 character it's just a huge turnoff I'm most cases. :/

As for the trouble leveling solo that is a builder design thing. If the game content areas npcs items are built knowing it's a solo character thing its shouldn't be much of a problem.

All that said building should be a lot easier to instead of trying to build some areas for Alts and some for solo. Everything just kind of turns into Alts like how old Rok was.
Dorgon
Yeah the vaults already in place but needs to be linked I think to all characters. Maybe not though, it might work as intended. I don't remember <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />

In terms of 1 character. I think that's 'ok' if people feel that should be the max. I was actually thinking 2 characters limit for the purpose of leveling. 3 is too much. However if we go with one only, that's okay too. I just worry about things like leveling getting a bit to painful for classes that can't heal and must use potions which are often costly.

The benefit obviously with 1 character is balance. You can balance OADS for example alot easier. But again, two would be fine too as long as its never changed from that. I think either or ROK was never balanced for the amount of characters it allowed, it was a bit of a mess with that.



Either or I'm going to convert this post to a poll, just have a quick vote.


Didn't think about 2. 2 it should be!!
Messenger
I'm pretty firmly in the 1 Alt camp. In time the Spikes will come, but truthfully for now, at it's creation, this game is a lot of Timmy and Johnny and running multiple characters around doesn't foster a community
Mujahideen
I think 2 is fine, I was raping everyone with 3 because most people dont even run 3 or know how to do it well.
NiteHawk
If there is a tie or its too close to determine I'll start off with one. It's easier to go up on characters then down.
Lateralus
I think 2 is fine, I was raping everyone with 3 because most people dont even run 3 or know how to do it well.



Thats exactly what I am hoping to avoid by limiting it to 1 character. New players dont stand a chance controlling alts! Most new players are busy learning the basics of the game (where to go, how to fight, how to level, etc) toss a whole other character in there and its just an overload and turnoff.

Most of you guys know the game inside and out so controlling alts isnt a big deal and I admit its a bit more fun/tactical but for this game to be a success we need more than just the 20-30 people from old rok. We need this game to be as approachable as possible and limiting to 1 character in my mind is the #1 thing we can do to ensure that.

Put yourself in a new players shoes and think about approachability, think about when you first started the game. I know I didnt use alts and im sure most of you didnt either until you needed to (either others were using them or areas were too hard etc...)

I really can see a huge influx of people to this game I would not be surprised if we passed old roks top numbers there is a huge market for this game and indie games like this are more visible than ever but we gotta take the right steps here.


I am sorry I am so passionate but I really think this is a make or break decision for the game.
Rodeo
I think what this will boil down to is either a split player base wanting 1a and one wanting 2a. Good times.
Vircyn
How can you say that it will make or break the success of this game when ROK ran perfectly fine allowing people to run more than one character? That statement is rather hyperbolic.

And are we really making core game decisions based on RP aspects? I know this is a MUD and in a lot of MUDs RP is an important aspect of the game. But I never got that in my years playing ROK. 10%, maybe, of the player base actively RPd. To the point where if you wanted to RP you'd likely have to join a specific guild. Also, people who want to RP end up finding others that want to RP. And those people can choose to only run one character. Having the option to run more if you aren't into RPing should be available.

Speaking of new players. Who's going to want to come in and level a cleric alone? The leveling that was done in ROK is going to have to be seriously revamped to make it even somewhat balanced in leveling between classes. You're always going to have classes that level faster than others but having a one character limit will expound that I think.

Lastly, if this pole is going to be used to make this decision the selections should be a) 1 alt and b) 2+ alts as those who voted for 3 in this pole should be grouped in with those that voted 2.
Mujahideen
I don't see how we can jump from having three characters to one, that's a pretty big change in game dynamics.
Rodeo
How can you say that it will make or break the success of this game when ROK ran perfectly fine allowing people to run more than one character? That statement is rather hyperbolic.

And are we really making core game decisions based on RP aspects? I know this is a MUD and in a lot of MUDs RP is an important aspect of the game. But I never got that in my years playing ROK. 10%, maybe, of the player base actively RPd. To the point where if you wanted to RP you'd likely have to join a specific guild. Also, people who want to RP end up finding others that want to RP. And those people can choose to only run one character. Having the option to run more if you aren't into RPing should be available.

Speaking of new players. Who's going to want to come in and level a cleric alone? The leveling that was done in ROK is going to have to be seriously revamped to make it even somewhat balanced in leveling between classes. You're always going to have classes that level faster than others but having a one character limit will expound that I think.

Lastly, if this pole is going to be used to make this decision the selections should be a) 1 alt and b) 2+ alts as those who voted for 3 in this pole should be grouped in with those that voted 2.


Alot of people miss that randy is looking at this from wanting to make it mobile aspect which 1a is great and leveling a cleric alone was easy considering how deathbane worked.

Plus everyone isn't wanting this to be exactly like old rok with 30 max players online we are wanting to introduce this to a younger generation of players.

If we can't get the mile aspect of it to work then by all means let's bump the alt limit to 2 or 3 but for thus game to really take off we need to keep it as simple as possible.
Lateralus
I don't see how we can jump from having three characters to one, that's a pretty big change in game dynamics.



I know it's a bit hard to imagine but that's because the games content (areas, monsters, etc) was built around the idea of everyone having alts. Since we are starting fresh building the game from scratch it shouldn't be a problem this time around at all.