← Forum archive

Divinity indicator

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

kaijick
One thing I always hated about the old game was that I was constantly having to go look at the wiki to see things like how much exp I needed, costs, etc.

I have seen some of these things addressedin other threads.

I haven't seen, but think it would be a great quality of life upgrade, is if we could see what divinity our enemies were. They play a big part of the game, I think it should be transparent upfront.

If not for everything, then for mobs at least so we know what we should be hitting for leveling?
Aieron
I'd rather monster divinity just make sense OR/AND you have a resource to find such information in game (academia). Putting it in the description is the easiest solution, but it detracts from the adventure of exploration/learning that RPGs have. Should you have to run around hitting every monster to figure out its divinity? Hell no. Should you have to research and learn about an area to unlock secrets like monster weaknesses? Yes, definitely.
Thoth
I think by giving into people wanting to know mob divinity you are removing the challenge of the game. Make'em work for it and keep making them do so. In fact I say go the other way with this idea.

If your keen on divinities being logical then to me logic dictates that periodically people change their beliefs/divs. You might say these are just kill'em up shoot'em up mobs but in a fantasy world where fantasy creatures can actively tell you to gtfo or die it wouldn't be a far stretch to think that they could change their allegiances.

Once a year mobs should have a divinity scramble capability (eventually as this isn't even halfway important at the mo) so that players that once thought Treants were the place to level for yourdiv type crit have to find a new place. It keeps the challenge up and going for leveling so that it doesn't remain the same constant grind of treants for blahdiv crits. It also keeps PKers on their toes to search for people in different spots every so often rather than always just knowing the hotspots of where to go.

<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mrgreen.gif" alt=":mrgreen:" title="Mr. Green" />
daedroth
or... make most of them a certain div, but every so often their not...
75% usual div
25% random div
kaijick
I think of it in terms of a game dev.

I understand where this game comes from, and the past was great, don't get me wrong.

But today is a decade in the future. Do we want new players, or just the 30 or so hardcores we have had following this game for years? Then we need to get rid of the shadow stats and have everything be transparent. This game is already doomed to fail if we are seriously wanting shadow stats that players need to "discover themselves", especially in the subject of something so major as divinity.

Players today do not expect to have to memorize an entire compendium of information, nor spend a bunch of their time GUESSING at things. The worst thing about RoK back in the day was constantly having to refer to a third party wiki that felt like it had information that should have been inside the game to begin with.

Let the divinities change by the week or whatever, or the 75% idea stated above (I like that one actually, it could be on each individual spawn as opposed to a day or week etc), but at least have them be transparent and easily identifiable.
Thoth
Guessing on how to do a thing right IS playing a game. Games are things like puzzles, riddles, problems, conflicts, stories.....all that we are trying to figure out the reason/response/answer/ending for. Take that away from the game and you have work. Work is a set standard of things that you NEED to know how to do in order to earn a paycheck. The joy of a game is having folded that piece of paper a thousand times (it's an exaggeration so don't focus on the thousand...yes some people do and it's annoying af) before you get the "OOooooohhhh that's how you make an origami bird."

This is not work. This is a game.
daedroth
one of my ideas was to have a thing like diablo (the original), where the more you killed a creature the more info you got on it
i have mixed feeling on how much info shouild be known, knowing too much infro makes you lazy but makes things easier, knowing too little is frsutrating but more rewarding... meh like i said mixed
Aieron
The argument that not showing divinities is an old way of doing things is so very wrong. I'm getting tired of that cop-out being used for lazy game design. Even modern games like Witcher 3 make you learn about the world / monsters before you know their weaknesses.

Should you have to go hit every monster in game with multiple characters to figure out every divinity? No, you're right, that is an ancient way of doing things.

You should however have to be engaged in the game world to learn about it. This is where good world building comes in. Want to know a monster you should be killing at lvl12? The game's NPCs/town/academia/quests should have this information for you.
Thoth
I don't mind the idea of forcing people to research areas to learn about their weaknesses but to make it so that they can just do it once and done IS lazy game design. One and done means the game grows stale. Perpetual change (and for that like I said once a year or 6 months so that the change is more before your eyes rather than instantaneous daily which would be dumb) so that areas go through slight changes to offer a constant challenge to a player is what may keep a player playing. The problem with RoK and games like it is that they never account for realtime. I can level the same area ad infinitum (or until an admin just garbages it in favor of a new game direction) but why not account for the fact that real life areas go through changes.....so why shouldn't it in a game?

You already create time movement through quests but the rest usually stays stagnant. People quit games like these and return because at the time of quitting they have maxed out alot of the things they can have....when they choose to return years later it is usually because they have forgotten most of everything about the game but remember the nostalgia of it and return. At the point of return some changes may have been made but then they reaquire the knowledge and before you know it again it's quit city....what would you prefer? Constant playership or sporadic popins?
kaijick
I see your concerns, Thoth, but you are using reality as a basis for what can/should be done in a game (a MUD for that matter) and that is ALWAYS dangerous territory for a fantasy game (or RPG in general usually) that has spells, goblins, etc. It's just not a good door to open.

Think about this from the perspective of someone who has no clue what RoK was, and stumbled across this game due to a friend, website, etc. THAT is the crowd we need to be concerned about attracting and retaining.

We need to worry about what will get people to START the game before we can discuss with them what will KEEP them in the game a year down the road. I don't think making leveling, which is by the far the worst part of most games these days, to be a hassle for "lore" purposes is the way to go.

People want to be able to level the most efficient way possible. That means the fastest (albiet not safest usually) way of leveling. The wonder of most MUDs is gone after the first hour of grinding exp. You start making things grindy and annoying with something as upfront and influential as div, it's going to go nowhere fast.

There's nothing fun about an RPG (NOT a puzzle game) making me run everywhere or talk to a dozen people ("go here", "retrieve this" "kill that" "talk to this person") so I can learn which mobs I should be leveling on.

That takes right straight back to a third party wiki becoming required for the vast majority of people to play, learn, and enjoy this game
Aieron
I see your concerns, Thoth, but you are using reality as a basis for what can/should be done in a game (a MUD for that matter) and that is ALWAYS dangerous territory for a fantasy game (or RPG in general usually) that has spells, goblins, etc. It's just not a good door to open.

Think about this from the perspective of someone who has no clue what RoK was, and stumbled across this game due to a friend, website, etc. THAT is the crowd we need to be concerned about attracting and retaining.

We need to worry about what will get people to START the game before we can discuss with them what will KEEP them in the game a year down the road. I don't think making leveling, which is by the far the worst part of most games these days, to be a hassle for "lore" purposes is the way to go.

People want to be able to level the most efficient way possible. That means the fastest (albiet not safest usually) way of leveling. The wonder of most MUDs is gone after the first hour of grinding exp. You start making things grindy and annoying with something as upfront and influential as div, it's going to go nowhere fast.

There's nothing fun about an RPG (NOT a puzzle game) making me run everywhere or talk to a dozen people ("go here", "retrieve this" "kill that" "talk to this person") so I can learn which mobs I should be leveling on.

That takes right straight back to a third party wiki becoming required for the vast majority of people to play, learn, and enjoy this game


I hate everyone trying to use new players as an excuse to simplify mechanics. That's not how you attract/keep new players. You build an immersive world that the player grows attached to. You build reward systems that encourage exploration and adventure. You don't do things for the sake of "lore" as you're implying, you do them so players grow attached to the lore. There's a lot to be said for readability/accessibility of games, but in this case, it's a world building issue more so than a core mechanic issue.

You're thinking about this as if Ember is RoK. It isn't.

Yes, a new player logging on right now would have a shitty experience. That's because there's no quest system, very little world development, and story in place to guide them. This isn't what Ember will be like when we're actually looking for new players.
Thoth
I see your concerns, Thoth, but you are using reality as a basis for what can/should be done in a game (a MUD for that matter) and that is ALWAYS dangerous territory for a fantasy game (or RPG in general usually) that has spells, goblins, etc. It's just not a good door to open.

Think about this from the perspective of someone who has no clue what RoK was, and stumbled across this game due to a friend, website, etc. THAT is the crowd we need to be concerned about attracting and retaining.

We need to worry about what will get people to START the game before we can discuss with them what will KEEP them in the game a year down the road. I don't think making leveling, which is by the far the worst part of most games these days, to be a hassle for "lore" purposes is the way to go.

People want to be able to level the most efficient way possible. That means the fastest (albiet not safest usually) way of leveling. The wonder of most MUDs is gone after the first hour of grinding exp. You start making things grindy and annoying with something as upfront and influential as div, it's going to go nowhere fast.

There's nothing fun about an RPG (NOT a puzzle game) making me run everywhere or talk to a dozen people ("go here", "retrieve this" "kill that" "talk to this person") so I can learn which mobs I should be leveling on.

That takes right straight back to a third party wiki becoming required for the vast majority of people to play, learn, and enjoy this game




OADs are puzzles, some of which that are riddled with riddles. Quests are time related and show storied progression. You were gone for 13 years and in that time a ton of things happened that showed time progression in RoK and RoK had spells and goblins as you say. Where is there an issue to use reality amidst a fantasy/RPG game when you still obey the essential rules of a reality anyway I mean...ask our Loremaster. He knows as well as any of us that if there is not meant to be gravity in a game that there needs to be a reason for that. In this case this game already has a time progression and storyline based around a century post RoK as it is, more of a nudge to the other game than anything but still a basis.

Also...how you might be accustomed to playing a game (efficiently) isn't a blanket for how everyone actually plays. As for keeping players....if your game isn't already in tune with how they will keep players long term then they have already lost them all. As for the types of players you think games like this should have, well...from what I know so far there is already a plan to take this game onto multiple platforms including FB which opens up a variety of possibilities as to what kind of player we will get in the long run.

It's better to plan for the players you can't predict as opposed to the ones you can (all your long term used to play RoKers). Noobiness needs to be accommodated for as well which to laymen's for you means easy to start easy and fun to play and content that draws them in and KEEPS them in.

Most of this however is neither here nor there because in the end it's not anyone here's decision as much as it is a majority response with Chris's veto power.
Aieron
Simplify mechanics? Like what? showing me what divinity a mob has by inspecting them?


Yes.

Instead you could be told a story/do quests that show you why the nearby cultists worship XX God.

Instead you could be tasked with a quest to unlock a bestiary written by an ancient huntsmen.

Instead you could be socializing with other players to find out the ideal spots.

Instead you could spend 10 minutes researching in an academia to prepare for your adventure. While doing this, you could stumble upon cool things like hints to rare mob drops / rare mob spawns / OAD hints.
kaijick
Again, super basic yet ultra important game mechanic, hidden behind a grind. Are these seriously what you guys consider good ideas for game development?

Div isn't some secret advantage, it's not some secret location; it's as basic as the class and race you choose at the same time.

Want to learn where an OAD is? Refer to ideas above.
Want to learn a secret forest or location? Refer to ideas above.
Want to learn basic mechanics so you know how to play the game? Go play something else because that's a grind too
Thoth
Edit: Ferget it. Im dun.

<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mrgreen.gif" alt=":mrgreen:" title="Mr. Green" />
Aieron
Again, super basic yet ultra important game mechanic, hidden behind a grind. Are these seriously what you guys consider good ideas for game development?

Div isn't some secret advantage, it's not some secret location; it's as basic as the class and race you choose at the same time.

Want to learn where an OAD is? Refer to ideas above.
Want to learn a secret forest or location? Refer to ideas above.
Want to learn basic mechanics so you know how to play the game? Go play something else because that's a grind too


Who said anything about making it a secret advantage? I'm just saying it creates a richer experience to have that information presented organically. Not like going to the Academia and searching an article on Bullfrogs is very difficult. Not like doing a quest that gives you a reward and gives you monster information is something troublesome to do.

Honest question: What -DO- you want to do when you play the game? If it's all about getting to max lvl, dualing in the gameroom, and entering events then we're envisioning a very different direction for the game.
Satsujin
Including the divinity of a monster in the look over is a horrible idea, both from a game play standpoint and an immersion one. FWIW I'm also against displaying divinity in character bios as well, though I would be less adverse to that if it at least used the gods' names FFS.

There is no game, or at least not one I want to be part of, without story elements and at least some immersion factor. Every RPG I've played in the last 20 years that's featured a bestiary has required you kill the monster in question to learn about it first. In most modern RPGs (Dragon Age: Inquisition, for example), the more of the monster you kill, the more you learn about them, and in exchange you get a bonus against that kind of monster in the future.

Some games feature a shortcut around this - The Witcher has a skill set that let's you learn about monsters without having killed them, Final Fantasy has Scan/related spells that tell you what monsters are strong/weak against with some being immune, Dungeons & Dragons has skills that give you a chance to roll to see if your character knows anything about the area/enemies.

Now, there are a number of ways to handle this that might make most people happy.

The first way is to utilize the Academia and encourage players to research the area they're going to be leveling in. This uses a game feature that, on ROK, had no purpose, because it wasn't maintained by anyone who gave a shit, and encourages immersion and player contributions to ensure the Academia is story relevant and always up to date. Personally, this is the option I, as the primary lore guy, support the most.

The second option is a skill similar to Final Fantasy's Scan. Make it tell you some basic information about the monster, but make it cost an action, and give it a chance to fail. This allows people too lazy to read (and I won't even try to sugar coat this, if you don't want to read, what the fuck are you doing on a MUD?) the chance to learn pertinent information about the mobs they're leveling on, while also ensuring people can't spam the hell out of it, giving them some motivation to use the Academia instead, where there's no chance of failure. I don't like this option, but I find it infinitely more acceptable than carebearing players by putting a big KILL THIS GUY sign on every mob.
kaijick
I expect BASIC MECHANICS, such as something I choose IN MY CHARACTER CREATION, to be transparent, and not hidden behind a grind or secret knowledge of locations. You are telling me you think it is FUN to not know what something IN MY CHARACTER CREATION does until I GRIND enough to find out?

Well good luck with that. This says a lot about where this game is going to go
NiteHawk
I expect BASIC MECHANICS, such as something I choose IN MY CHARACTER CREATION, to be transparent, and not hidden behind a grind or secret knowledge of locations. You are telling me you think it is FUN to not know what something IN MY CHARACTER CREATION does until I GRIND enough to find out?

Well good luck with that. This says a lot about where this game is going to go


I'll finally chime in on this.

What you might think and what others might think is different. I don't think theres a 100% way to please everyone. I understand where you are coming from but sometimes people enjoy a little bit of figuring out what is the best mob and exploring the realms. I think everyone in the end is entitled to their opinions and I'll normally do what I think is best.

With this, I was intending on making a ranger skill that could identify creatures. It could give basic information about the NPC, such as divinity, etc. Keith came up with a cool idea to work in scrolls (as we use scrolls for alot of things now) and make Identify Scrolls. What this means is rangers could create the scrolls, and they can be given out or used to identify.

They'd use the blank scrolls as it is now, so it's a fair price anyways. Perhaps the identify could have a chance to fail/etc etc. But generally that was the idea. I don't want the information to be easily gained, but I think this way it doesn't make it hard at all either, but still lets the player explore and figure out the world using a actual game mechanic.