Interface
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I'm all for customization (I.E. moving the minimap to the top of the stats for example, and closing the bar). but I think it doesn't need to get overly complicated. I don't really like those systems where you can move all windows all over the place, it bothers me for some reason, hence why I like this setup which has some freedom but not 'messy'. It's similar to a new age ROK client pretty much.
I was literally telling someone earlier that some customization is good but too much is bad. The goal should be a "controlled chaos" of sorts. Lots of options but never, ever total freedom.
Agreed. The way ghost dealt with it I think gives plenty of customization without making the client a complete mess looking. It has that old client feel, but it has newer modern features that people would enjoy.
I really like it. A++ 8)
I really like it. A++ 8)
Looks great! I usually like the player list on the other side but it looks so good I could sacrifice.
As for fully moveable Windows besides being a pain to program how would that hurt? Like confusing for the player?
I guess I love how aleveria worked and how when I use gimp I can move crap where ever when working. Dont get me wrong it would all still be in a main window but moveable within?
As for fully moveable Windows besides being a pain to program how would that hurt? Like confusing for the player?
I guess I love how aleveria worked and how when I use gimp I can move crap where ever when working. Dont get me wrong it would all still be in a main window but moveable within?
Idk how i feel about players/items on the left....awkward xD
Idk how i feel about players/items on the left....awkward xD
If players and items were moved to the right and the stats/inventory were on the left, I'm sold.
Idk how i feel about players/items on the left....awkward xD
If players and items were moved to the right and the stats/inventory were on the left, I'm sold.
Me too but why not just have movable windows within the client if it's not too hard to program. Then people can put crap wherever they want. I guess I'm confused why this could be a problem?
The reason I've decided to design this way is so that "Important" information is fixed in it's location in the interface. This allows my "eye" to know where certain information is going to be at any given moment. This improves my ability to process and scan for the most important information quickly... Because I know where it's going to be. (Not to mention the majority of our users will be accustomed to processing content left to right (language)).
If we design an interface with a collapsable panel and the layout (thus information) is designed to move because of that, we don't want the starting point for the other information on screen to move if it's important.
If the collapsable content was on the left, then where my eye goes to process the text, in a text based game, can vary by 150-200 pixels. This will slow game play and ultimately provide a disadvantage to skilled players as they develop hundreds of hours familiarizing themselves with the layout. It would actually be in their best interest at this point to never collapse the menu - which isn't what we want.
Sure, all of you today, as players of RoK, are uncomfortable with the progression of information – but that will change quickly. RoK wasn't designed with collapsable content. This game is and we want to take all of that functionality into account. Especially based on a previous conversation about the panel auto-expanding when pertinent information is present.
The reason we don't wanted to create a fully customizable interface with draggable and moveable panels, is because we want to be able to fully understand the User Experience with our content. If we know specific information is always going to be on the left, when we can design interactions based on the fact that content is on the left. Both Nitehawk and Remnant spoke to this earlier. Customization only makes sense when the range of interactions is vastly different amongst each user. However, In Rok and Ember, almost every activity in the game follow the same user flow (leveling, OADing, dueling, exploring - the same). It's better to not customize but instead improve those exact user flows than to allow users to customize and muddy the User Experience unknowingly.
But hey, if it's what you want - go for it.
If we design an interface with a collapsable panel and the layout (thus information) is designed to move because of that, we don't want the starting point for the other information on screen to move if it's important.
If the collapsable content was on the left, then where my eye goes to process the text, in a text based game, can vary by 150-200 pixels. This will slow game play and ultimately provide a disadvantage to skilled players as they develop hundreds of hours familiarizing themselves with the layout. It would actually be in their best interest at this point to never collapse the menu - which isn't what we want.
Sure, all of you today, as players of RoK, are uncomfortable with the progression of information – but that will change quickly. RoK wasn't designed with collapsable content. This game is and we want to take all of that functionality into account. Especially based on a previous conversation about the panel auto-expanding when pertinent information is present.
The reason we don't wanted to create a fully customizable interface with draggable and moveable panels, is because we want to be able to fully understand the User Experience with our content. If we know specific information is always going to be on the left, when we can design interactions based on the fact that content is on the left. Both Nitehawk and Remnant spoke to this earlier. Customization only makes sense when the range of interactions is vastly different amongst each user. However, In Rok and Ember, almost every activity in the game follow the same user flow (leveling, OADing, dueling, exploring - the same). It's better to not customize but instead improve those exact user flows than to allow users to customize and muddy the User Experience unknowingly.
But hey, if it's what you want - go for it.
The reason I've decided to design this way is so that "Important" information is fixed in it's location in the interface. This allows my "eye" to know where certain information is going to be at any given moment. This improves my ability to process and scan for the most important information quickly... Because I know where it's going to be. (Not to mention the majority of our users will be accustomed to processing content left to right (language)).
If we design an interface with a collapsable panel and the layout (thus information) is designed to move because of that, we don't want the starting point for the other information on screen to move if it's important.
If the collapsable content was on the left, then where my eye goes to process the text, in a text based game, can vary by 150-200 pixels. This will slow game play and ultimately provide a disadvantage to skilled players as they develop hundreds of hours familiarizing themselves with the layout. It would actually be in their best interest at this point to never collapse the menu - which isn't what we want.
Sure, all of you today, as players of RoK, are uncomfortable with the progression of information – but that will change quickly. RoK wasn't designed with collapsable content. This game is and we want to take all of that functionality into account. Especially based on a previous conversation about the panel auto-expanding when pertinent information is present.
The reason we don't wanted to create a fully customizable interface with draggable and moveable panels, is because we want to be able to fully understand the User Experience with our content. If we know specific information is always going to be on the left, when we can design interactions based on the fact that content is on the left. Both Nitehawk and Remnant spoke to this earlier. Customization only makes sense when the range of interactions is vastly different amongst each user. However, In Rok and Ember, almost every activity in the game follow the same user flow (leveling, OADing, dueling, exploring - the same). It's better to not customize but instead improve those exact user flows than to allow users to customize and muddy the User Experience unknowingly.
But hey, if it's what you want - go for it.
Honestly, I think some people just need to get into it. For the actual right and left panels being swapped, that is easily done through a configuration option, but I think default can be the way you designed it, as I agree with you 100% on how collapsible content should be. Besides that though I 'won't' do fully draggable/movable panels or anything like that. I don't like it that way period. Someone else with permissions can eventually make a different client that's like that but the default client I prefer something more set. So I agree with the partial things you can do with panels as discussed.
I try to take what people say at heart for alot of things, but sometimes I'm going to go with what I think will be better in the end. I think in all honestly Ghost has a good idea on how a client should flow, so I do hope you continue with what you're doing for the client interface. 8)
@nitehawk good deal honestly I could care less about moving panels was just curious why everyone was against it. It seems a lot of people want the client set up differently so it seemed like a everyone wins.
But I totally agree you need to take a stance on things. We all have our own visions of what we would like the game to be and if everyone had their way it would be a cluster haha.
But I totally agree you need to take a stance on things. We all have our own visions of what we would like the game to be and if everyone had their way it would be a cluster haha.
@nitehawk good deal honestly I could care less about moving panels was just curious why everyone was against it. It seems a lot of people want the client set up differently so it seemed like a everyone wins.
But I totally agree you need to take a stance on things. We all have our own visions of what we would like the game to be and if everyone had their way it would be a cluster haha.
I think I like some order above all when it comes to the interface layout. ROK's for example was easy to use. I don't mind some movement but I think some limitations would be good. I think a nice presented interface can go far vs just set windows you can move around. I also think people will grab the interface better (and play better) when they are accustomed to a set interface, bar what they think is best. I know that sounds terriblish, but designs and the way an interface functions can effect user experience.
This doesn't mean that I don't want other clients, I.E. A phone based client if you think it could work.. It might actually benefit it there to have more movement because your screen is often alot more limited. But for the default computer client I think it works good.
I rather not have windows in a window.... please
I rather not have windows in a window.... please
[attachment=0]5536768.jpg[/attachment]
Anyways as I said, it seems like the general thing is that we should use this interface, and I fully agree on it.
On top of that, I like the E for the icon too. It looks nice. Would go well with the new client too. The logo itself looks nice and I'd be happy to use that too.
It's no rush on it though Ghost to finish it up. I still need to obviously get everything going first, then once I settle down I'm going to be reworking/redoing the client. I think maybe the best method would be once it's actually complete perhaps a PSD photoshop file or something in which I can extract most of the needed images and such if you think that would be good too.
On top of that, I like the E for the icon too. It looks nice. Would go well with the new client too. The logo itself looks nice and I'd be happy to use that too.
It's no rush on it though Ghost to finish it up. I still need to obviously get everything going first, then once I settle down I'm going to be reworking/redoing the client. I think maybe the best method would be once it's actually complete perhaps a PSD photoshop file or something in which I can extract most of the needed images and such if you think that would be good too.
I've been working on some of the secondary interactions and functionality and can post those soon.
Just let me know when you're getting closer to point in which you'll want the PSD. However I've tried to design the interface in a way that doesn't require heavy use of imagery - so if you'd like me to mock up an HTML/CSS version of the interface I can provide that as well - Not sure how you're coding it.
Just let me know when you're getting closer to point in which you'll want the PSD. However I've tried to design the interface in a way that doesn't require heavy use of imagery - so if you'd like me to mock up an HTML/CSS version of the interface I can provide that as well - Not sure how you're coding it.
No that's fine. All I need is the design and I can determine what needs to be an image and what doesn't. I'll splice off needed bits NP. Don't worry about anything more though.
I need to figure out a good plan for the interface as I want it to work on all os. I know of some ways, but need to see whats best
I need to figure out a good plan for the interface as I want it to work on all os. I know of some ways, but need to see whats best
I know I'm coming late to the game but here are some thoughts. I love the proposed new look. I've played games though that allowed you to have a "core" game screen and then certain sections were modules that could be moved wherever you wanted and organized to your taste. Without digging for images, just open up winamp in full mode and see how easy they have it to move the modules around. It's not something I particularly liked in the game bacuase I would end up accidently moving something when not intending but some poeople like that. The main reason I bring this up is it also allows the person to play the game "on top" of their computer while moving the modules to the sides to keep an eye on what's going on beneath. Plus, if you add in a single button to "return to default" and some locking pins even people who don't pay attention can fix their screw ups.
I love that updated client layout. I think it'd be cool to see monsters being an overlay on top of the room imagine if it's going to be that large. It makes the monsters feel like they're in the world more, and it's better than looking at a long list with monsters/players/items imo. If the room image won't be that big then ignore this suggestion. I think it'd only work with the increased size.
All I request is a sword icon to attack with, so I don't have to type: "a troll" then spam up+enter.
I like da clicky sometimes.
I like da clicky sometimes.
All I request is a sword icon to attack with, so I don't have to type: "a troll" then spam up+enter.
I like da clicky sometimes.
Word
All I request is a sword icon to attack with, so I don't have to type: "a troll" then spam up+enter.
I like da clicky sometimes.
Word
Speaking of 'word' is there any word on the new client interface. I know you've been working hard on the game mechanics, I don't want to come off as demanding or ungrateful. I just haven't heard much in terms of timeframe for the release of the new client and I'm excited to see the game get the interface overhaul.