← Forum archive

Monks

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Atticuz
I would really like to see this in action but when asking people i either get a no or no response at all.

So lets theorize for a bit

Using 33 percent hit chance rather then 38 percent easier for me to calculate but still puts forward what i'm trying to say.
If each of the three chances is completely independent of the others, then you just multiply all the odds together.
1/3 x 1/3 × 1/3 = 1/27 = 3.7%
First hit Second Hit Roundhouse

Damage absorption or reflection doesn't play a role here as they count as a successful attack

So my chances of getting a successful roundhouse off and have the first two hits hit

round 1
1 33% independent
2 33% independent
3 roundhouse rely's off first two hits plus its own independent hit = 3.7%
4 33% independent
5 33% independent

round 2
1 roundhouse rely's off first two hits plus its own independent hit = 3.7%
2 33% independent
3 33% independent
4 roundhouse rely's off first two hits plus its own independent hit = 3.7%
5 33% independent

round 3
1 33% independent
2 roundhouse rely's off first two hits plus its own independent hit = 3.7%
3 33% independent
4 33% independent
5 roundhouse rely's off first two hits plus its own independent hit = 3.7%

round 4 is same as round 1

So using 3.7% = the same as 37 hits out of 1000 that seems really low chance of getting a roundhouse off

If a monk's damage is based off hitting not so hard but hitting consistently to get roundhouse off(which is the source of damage for them and the reason why you would make a monk) then you can see why it feels like making a monk is sorta not preferable unless they are different from other class's to allow for the big damage source (roundhouse) to land more often, taking away their inbuilt hit rate makes them way less preferable then other melee damage class's.
Now i know people will say well Barbs need three hits in a row also but you could make a Goblin Zerker with 19 str and 23 agi which would have the same chances as a monk to get their flurry off, I would need the Math's on STR to compare damage output but from fights with HomeGrown I am pretty positive he hits harder with his regular attacks plus the flurry damage. But again will need maths on Str to say for sure. ( I say this because a decked shadow sword has 26 AD and a decked void staff has 22 AD but depending on Str 4 AD may even out with less Str i would like to see the numbers)
Was just thinking could even make a Saurian Zerker with 22str and 23 agi and therefore definitly getting more damage out with a two hand or dual wielding and would still have the same hit chance as a monk
Ardrahz
If you dont have numbers, my net should be fixed very soon and i dont mind crunching some data with you man.
Mujahideen
It's simple math.

.38 X .38 X .38 = .054872. Or in other words a 5.4872% chance at landing ANY 3 in a row.

Unless my logic is off, a ninja with +1 agi over his opponent should roundhouse once every 3.664 rounds.

Seems about right.

100 divided by 5.4872 = 18.224. So once every 18.224 attacks should be a roundhouse. Ninjas have 5 attacks per round right?

18.224 divided by 5 = 3.664 rounds.
Folder
Anecdotally monks don't feel like they are in a bad place. I do well in duels and pvp on mine, a goblin. NH has the data you guys are looking for, there's no need to run tests or whatever. There's a spreadsheet with dodge/hit rates, it's not a mystery that needs solving <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />.

The real question is when do monks get to use fist weapons?!

edit: I do think div in pvp possibly plays too big of a role. But that's a different topic...
Atticuz
If you guys are happy to have a 5.4% chance to hit 3 attacks in a row (the amount of rounds doesn't matter) for a Ninja (who rely's off it to have any source of damage that cant just be healed up by a pot) then thats that.

Enjoy!
Folder
I think it sounds worse on paper than it is in practice. Monks certainly hit for less per attack but they have that 5th attack to help and I think it balances out ok. They aren't huge burst damage but they are pretty consistent in my experience.

I do understand that lower damage numbers feels worse sometimes. Not sure what to do about that though because they need to hit for less per attack because of 5 actions.

About the only thing I could think of is giving RH attacks a + to hit, if we feel they just aren't really happening much.
NiteHawk
Div and damage does, but not dodge rate or hit rate. As per data, paper stats are OK but when it gets to stuff bigger then 1vs1 it's nice to have proper data. But yeah, when it comes to 1vs1 that's the case.

And yeah, when you are fighting someone of similar AGI or higher, it's going to be harder to land roundhouses. Seems valid to me.

taking the same value it would be 12.5% chance on high vs low AGI to RH. Which means 1.6 rounds to land a roundhouse each time. Seems legit? Two high AGI characters are going to struggle at roundhousing each other, though 3.6 rounds isn't terrible.
Atticuz
Ill add one more thing that i am struggling to understand

From the math you are correct every 3.6 rounds in theory should be a roundhouse, but every hit is independent of eachother and there is no magical after 3.6 rounds guarantee roundhouse
It is always going to be 5.4% EVERY round

After this post i see no reason to make a Ninja unless you are very lucky, ( say a Barbarian who hits harder but has the same chance to hit makes way more sense to make over a monk)
Folder
Zerkers do more damage but they also take more damage, both magic and melee. Something to keep in mind.
Lateralus
Zerkers do more damage but they also take more damage, both magic and melee. Something to keep in mind.



In realitiy I would say zerkers are better in pve (more damage output and more damage coming in). Monks are much better in pvp (often have high number damage output and take less physical and magical damage).
daedroth
I made a Barbarian and at level 10 it almost out damages my Saurian Ninja. Just saying.

Wow, your barb will be a God when he is zerker <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Much GREATNESS!
NiteHawk
I made a Barbarian and at level 10 it almost out damages my Saurian Ninja. Just saying.


You must have a terrible ninja then.


The damage output is 161-192 with div (Not including RH), though that is with purple OAD, it's probably one or two less min/max I think that is released right now, so its probably more like 7-12 damage less overall. (So something like 150-180 would be a good base on DIV). RH is double attack so x2 when it happens. They have 5 attacks. There is a potential of two roundhouses per round if you are lucky.


---

Your level 10 barb, dealing with level 8 items because you can't use level 15 items. With a purple level 8, which I highly doubt you have, but we will use that for the sake of argument, 11-15 min/max. I'll even deck it out for you. 67-79 damage, on div. This is also using two swords. Obviously you have the rage which is 40% more damage, but that still is like 117 max. VS a roundhouse at level 25 that can probably hit for just under 400.

---

General damage output, I'll even only use one RH. 192, 192, 384, 192, 192 = 1152 damage, but probably take away 50-70 damage since OAD purple items aren't in. Lets say around 1080 per round.


Your level 10 barb: 79,79,117 = 275 damage per round
Next round could be: 117, 117, 79 = 313 damage per round, but if I said this, then I would have to include the chance of two roundhouses in the next round of a monk which would boost the damage of a monk to around 1260.

Both 22 str. I DUNNO MAN I DONT FEEL IT. I mean sure at level 25 you will see a gap as zerkers will do more damage overall, but also die faster. Specially to spell casters. Literal bricks. I disagree with people stating that monks will have higher damage in PVP. They won't, zerkers will, but they'll probably have overall less damage in the end because they'll die alot quicker in which the monk will probably still be on the battlefield. Zerkers make ideal hitting targets to make clerics sweat.

So monks, have overall less damage but much higher survivability, and zerkers will have more damage, but less survivability. Seems reasonable to me.



Not trying to be a dick here, but false information sucks in general. Riles up people too.


P.S. on 'MY SAUR MONK DONT DO THAT ON DIV YET.

You attack a earth dummy with your oad staff for 192 points of damage!


Can't be far off.
NiteHawk
Monk won't hit 5/5 unless really really really lucky.

Obv i was joking though. Fancied a troll.


Yeah yeah, but you do know this is how people start rumors cause people are terrible. 8) So I'd rather hit people with a data book just in case.

You are correct, monks won't hit 5/5 all the time no, but zerkers won't get all 3 of their rages either, at least in PVP anyways for both.
Lateralus
guys please consider that the best monk weapon in game is a -1min green item (void staff) while the best zerker items are purple weapons (spectral 2 hander blue thats = to purple damage because its 2 hand) and void blade which is purple. so atm zerks have something like +2-3min and max over monks.

so im saying stick with us builders to get better staffs out then things will even out. i still think monks are the better of the 2 in pvp by far and zerks better in oad situations but monks are still good.
Thi
Monk won't hit 5/5 unless really really really lucky.

Obv i was joking though. Fancied a troll.


Yeah yeah, but you do know this is how people start rumors cause people are terrible. 8) So I'd rather hit people with a data book just in case.

You are correct, monks won't hit 5/5 all the time no, but zerkers won't get all 3 of their rages either, at least in PVP anyways for both.

<3 you for the databooks, keep it up man.