← Forum archive

Leveling-group healers get the shaft

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Metzger
So if I am invited to a leveling group as a healer, cleric or otherwise, I'm typically asked, or expected to heal. As a result, these things happen:

[list=1]I get less EXP because healing a player does not give nearly as much EXP as it does casting a spell on a monster. Healing a player seems to be about 1/3 or 1/4 the exp that attacking a monster would give.
[/list:o]

[list=2]
As a result of primarily healing the group, I get very few killshots. Lately, most leveling groups have been doing the, whoever gets the killshot, gets the loot, rule.
[/list:o]

[list=3]
As a result of getting few killshots, it makes it quite difficult to finish quests, and/or make any goldwhile leveling in a group.
[/list:o]

Sure there are ways to work it out with the group so that we can round robin the loot, but let's be honest, that almost never happens. People like the, KS gets the loot, rule.

I could also go level by myself, but what fun is that? Not to mention, Nitehawk said somewhere that he wants to "encourage group leveling" I think, right?

I think to fix part of the issue, healing a player should give the same EXP that attacking a monster would give. Also, I'd love to see loot options available for selecting while in a party: KS gets the loot, Round Robin, etc.. etc..

What do you guys think?
NiteHawk
So if I am invited to a leveling group as a healer, cleric or otherwise, I'm typically asked, or expected to heal. As a result, these things happen:

[list=1]I get less EXP because healing a player does not give nearly as much EXP as it does casting a spell on a monster. Healing a player seems to be about 1/3 or 1/4 the exp that attacking a monster would give.
[/list:o]

[list=2]
As a result of primarily healing the group, I get very few killshots. Lately, most leveling groups have been doing the, whoever gets the killshot, gets the loot, rule.
[/list:o]

[list=3]
As a result of getting few killshots, it makes it quite difficult to finish quests, and/or make any goldwhile leveling in a group.
[/list:o]

Sure there are ways to work it out with the group so that we can round robin the loot, but let's be honest, that almost never happens. People like the, KS gets the loot, rule.

I could also go level by myself, but what fun is that? Not to mention, Nitehawk said somewhere that he wants to "encourage group leveling" I think, right?

I think to fix part of the issue, healing a player should give the same EXP that attacking a monster would give. Also, I'd love to see loot options available for selecting while in a party: KS gets the loot, Round Robin, etc.. etc..

What do you guys think?


It's based on your level vs mob level or player level is why. It's the same formula for both monsters/players. I'd assume the monsters are higher level though. You might wanna get proper stats though for similar leveled mobs vs players.. I'm pretty sure it shouldn't be 1/4th the exp.

In terms of looting, I think we can add party gold exp but adding a round robin system is a bit eh, because then the item would be locked to the KS, and no one else could pick it up etc etc. Meaning people can't loot or steal and stuff, and I kind of like that mechanic. If your party mates aren't giving you good loot, maybe you should find new friends who aren't dinks. Most people split gold afterwards generally when it comes to items. I don't really want items to be stuck on the ground for only X people to pick up.
Folder
With smite I felt that I had plenty of opportunities as a pally to get xp, but I do hear you. The only true solution is to make all xp shared and not just KS.

Re: loot. I think that this is solved by groups themselves. People are pretty cool in groups in my experience. When healing on my pally typically people gave me all mana drops and some even tipped me after.

So that is to say it was a good leveling experience for me even when fulltime healing. I'd say we should talk about all xp being shared as well as group killshot credit for quests. Those 2 things would balance things imo.
NiteHawk
With smite I felt that I had plenty of opportunities as a pally to get xp, but I do hear you. The only true solution is to make all xp shared and not just KS.

Re: loot. I think that this is solved by groups themselves. People are pretty cool in groups in my experience. When healing on my pally typically people gave me all mana drops and some even tipped me after.

So that is to say it was a good leveling experience for me even when fulltime healing. I'd say we should talk about all xp being shared as well as group killshot credit for quests. Those 2 things would balance things imo.


I don't think I'll be adding exp per point to all. It's a pain to calculate everytime and I think it will be hard on the server to have to deal per shot. Won't be nice.

Credits for quest though would be something I could look at though for kill shots.
Folder
Ok fair enough. Group quest credit would be real nice. As an example earlier today running a 4man group doing corrupt guard quests...quest is to kill 20, so that means 80 in a group and an awful lot of stopping dps so specific people get the KS. Kinda bleh.
Folder
Chris have you ever considered getting rid of per-hit xp and increasing KS xp to balance that out? You could equalize party xp this way and it would even be less calculations for the server.

Doing that and adding group credit for KS on quest seems like a pretty interesting idea. Big change perhaps but would encourage grouping more and even xp out.

Also maybe worth considering nerfing KS xp a little in bigger groups so that 6mans dont level 6x faster than solo.
NiteHawk
Chris have you ever considered getting rid of per-hit xp and increasing KS xp to balance that out? You could equalize party xp this way and it would even be less calculations for the server.

Doing that and adding group credit for KS on quest seems like a pretty interesting idea. Big change perhaps but would encourage grouping more and even xp out.

Also maybe worth considering nerfing KS xp a little in bigger groups so that 6mans dont level 6x faster than solo.


I'm not sure how I feel about that specially if others come and steal KS. Since it has been happening I wonder if this would make people rage who are soloing, specially if there is more then one person in the arena. I don't generally like the idear though of removing it as it at leasts prevents this from happening when not partying up.

The exp isnt 6x though, not sure where people are getting that. It doesn't mean everyone gets 100%. The exp is actually split, but you do gain a bonus. I am lowering the bonus a bit though.

I.E> two people in party is 130% exp split (so 65% exp each).
Six would be 150% exp split etc etc

Obviously they are killing faster though too. So technically if 6 people killing it means they gain 50% faster. Instead of starting at 30% and ramping to 50%. I am lowering it to 10% and ramping it to 30%. I'm having gold/party kills for quest added as well.
Lateralus
Chris have you ever considered getting rid of per-hit xp and increasing KS xp to balance that out? You could equalize party xp this way and it would even be less calculations for the server.

Doing that and adding group credit for KS on quest seems like a pretty interesting idea. Big change perhaps but would encourage grouping more and even xp out.

Also maybe worth considering nerfing KS xp a little in bigger groups so that 6mans dont level 6x faster than solo.


I think in a game like this is might make ks farming a little too easy and could be taken advantage of. IE group of players goes around getting things to crit and player to be leveled is out of the party and just grabs killshots and speed levels.
daedroth
The ks gets the drop issue, isn't there that "/randomparty" thing? That could be used to fix the ks gets the item problem thing (and the person who got will get skipped the next time to keep it fair). Although if your with the right group the loot is usually not an issue (gather loot, sell loot, one person gets all the gold, gold then get split between the group. With items it can be honour based (as in who needs gets) or the /randomparty think I already mentioned... off course as I said that depends on who you are with, maybe make out rules before you go out? Then there are no misunderstanding or whining... haha, good luck).
Rodeo
I like the way revelation: lands of kaldana did exp with KS say yoy killed a bear bears GI've 45k exp if you do 75% of the damage to the bear and sone one runs in and kills it the player who did the majority gets the exp. This game had a really good group/solo play aspect and if it was still around I would suggest you guys check it out.
NiteHawk
Is KS stealing really a big issue though?

The reason why I ask is that generally adding this I feel will be a heavier load on the server, pretty much a list for EACH mob that needs to store both the name and the damage dealt. (You'd then have to loop through all the names to get total damage, then get percentages for each.). You'd probably have to make sure the player is on the square too. That or you'd have to have a timer that removed player after X seconds. Or record the time and only award people that attacked it within the last 2 minutes.

It wouldn't be so much a strain with only 20 people, but if theres 100 people running around hitting things one day then it's going to hit the server huge because each attack and spell needs to be recorded DPS wise.

I'm not sure what you mean by total healed/heal ratio either. How would that work in with this though? Healing vs KS seem completely different to me? Unless you mean you'd have to record all the heals done during the battle, but no way I'd add something like that. That is getting over complicated for EXP distribution. The % based one is at least do-able rather easily. I just don't like adding more strain to the server if it can be avoided. Specially lists of data.
Kismet
Let's just say the percentage based one then. Otherwise it wouldn't be fair for those who contribute more to the party's total damage and leeching should rightfully be discouraged.

Edited for apologies. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_redface.gif" alt=":oops:" title="Embarrassed" />
Rodeo
I myself would like to move away from experience per point of damage that's how we do it now right?

Giving each monster a set experience and dividing it by the number of party members seems to be fair for healers and dps alike. You could also give a party bonus of 2 to 8% depending on how many party members are in the group so that working solo isn't always the best way to go.

As to deter leeching a party leader command of /premove (player) would be a benificial addit ion as if they are idle you can just drop them in town or leave them at a spawn to die.

As far as strain on the server can this be lessened by donations for a better server that can handle whatever load that is being put on it?
NiteHawk
I myself would like to move away from experience per point of damage that's how we do it now right?

Giving each monster a set experience and dividing it by the number of party members seems to be fair for healers and dps alike. You could also give a party bonus of 2 to 8% depending on how many party members are in the group so that working solo isn't always the best way to go.

As to deter leeching a party leader command of /premove (player) would be a benificial addit ion as if they are idle you can just drop them in town or leave them at a spawn to die.

As far as strain on the server can this be lessened by donations for a better server that can handle whatever load that is being put on it?


/kick exists already. Check /help party for commands.

Yeah but you strain even a heavy server by doing this. I would generally like to know peoples take on this though. Party already gets a KS bonus as it is depending on the party size. I kind of like the PPD though cause it makes players feel like they're gaining exp 'fast'. It is the whole quest that requires 5 items that drop 5% of the time, or 20 items that drop 20% of the time type deal. Yeah, you need 20, but the time to complete would be the same, it just feels like 'more' is happening.

It's both KS and PPD. PPD is pretty low and KS is mainly the lot of it I think.


But if people feel like it needs to be adjusted I can eventually see. I disagree with it right now as I don't see it as an issue, but other people can chime in here and tell me what's good.
Reaper
I personally think it is fine the way it is. I don't really see a big issue. I'm in the process of slowly leveling a cleric, so I guess when I start GY'ing I will be able to give better feedback. I do think if you are concerned as a healer, go into the party letting them know to bring their own pots. Tell them in an absolute emergency you will heal but you will be DPSing and not paying attention to health to get exp.
NiteHawk
I personally think it is fine the way it is. I don't really see a big issue. I'm in the process of slowly leveling a cleric, so I guess when I start GY'ing I will be able to give better feedback. I do think if you are concerned as a healer, go into the party letting them know to bring their own pots. Tell them in an absolute emergency you will heal but you will be DPSing and not paying attention to health to get exp.


Well, the exp less on clerics is due to that. 300mil to 400mil is 25% reduction which attempts to account for struggling a bit too, or healing others. I can look at the EXP per heal too shortly.
Lateralus
While party leveling can beat bit slower they still have an improved ray that deals some good damage while in parties.

Solo level clerics are hands down the fastest class to level with their always hitting heal undead.


As for shifting all exp to killshot that would just be abused people would widdle down npcs the tale ks on the character to be leveled outside the party. People in parties would abuse it as well seeing you really could be Afk just getting all that ks exp. atleast now you have to do a little hitting to get good exp in parties but it's still abused you can be Afk in party and make more than solo leveling.
Metzger
Hit priest earlier, so here's my priest leveling guide:

Ray sucks ass. Only use it for levels 1 - 8.

Quest through Cemetery and Grove until level 18.

Cure whatever you div on in GY until 21.

Aid whatever you have div on in DY until 25.

Smite sucks ass. No point in using this unless you want to conserve mana and level slower. Don't do that though because you need to get to level 25 ASAP. Also, it has a lower hitrate than aid, so F that.

Soulbound is nice, but whatever, spending 5k to SB is probably faster.

Also, skip parties at all costs. It'll just slow you down.

Side notes:
I think priests should get a group heal. And something that does more damage that ray.
NiteHawk
Ray is a low level spell correct. They will not get anything better. They are not meant to dish out the DPS and be super hard to kill too.

Anyways, there are changes based on this discussion and the healing discussions (that was in the assassin area goofy enough.)

Aid does -50 less heal (-25 on monsters since its /2). It is around 275 with 22int on max.
Heal does around 112-131 with 16-20 int at max.
Cure does around 76-98 with 16-20 int at max. For bards its around 98-120 with 12-20int (Bards gain a larger bonus so even 12int is 'ok' but not great, and yeah, cure is int based on them.). For druids, add about +5 int that thats your max (so 12-16 int would be 76-98 heals for example.)

SMITE is now a set 5 MP for both classes. Smite damage is also increased a little bit on clerics. I felt it was OK for paladins. It should be more worth it now.