← Forum archive

Casters and Weapons

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Honzo
Do the penetration bonuses increase as the item level increases so that way casters can still gain effectiveness from gear and not just from their base int? It would be a little unfair if other classes that deal physical dmg dealt more damage because their items scaled higher with dmg. Additionally, do the bonuses work on other items like daggers(for necros) or would an item have to be kind of preprogrammed to be like that if it isn't a staff?
NiteHawk
Do the penetration bonuses increase as the item level increases so that way casters can still gain effectiveness from gear and not just from their base int? It would be a little unfair if other classes that deal physical dmg dealt more damage because their items scaled higher with dmg. Additionally, do the bonuses work on other items like daggers(for necros) or would an item have to be kind of preprogrammed to be like that if it isn't a staff?


Yes, penetration scale with staff and gets better depending on enchants, the item values, etc. Bonuses do not work with daggers and never will, It's preprogrammed into the staff. Any class can use it to increase penetration rate. It also increases duration a bit too.

It's not a set value too, it uses min/max values of the weapon to get a calculation of penetration.

Embers should also increase damage, long as the ember is the same divinity as you.
Cerebrus
Embers should also increase damage, long as the ember is the same divinity as you.


Wait, so my fire div monk with an ice ember on one staff and earth on the other, doesnt receive anything from those embers being on my weapons since they arent fire div like my monk?

Not sure why, but I figured adding a div to your weapon gives you a slight bonus against npcs and players of that div

Example: My bone staff has an ice ember (1%) aura, figured it gave me 1% more dmg against ice div npc's and players lol
NiteHawk
Embers should also increase damage, long as the ember is the same divinity as you.


Wait, so my fire div monk with an ice ember on one staff and earth on the other, doesnt receive anything from those embers being on my weapons since they arent fire div like my monk?

Not sure why, but I figured adding a div to your weapon gives you a slight bonus against npcs and players of that div

Example: My bone staff has an ice ember (1%) aura, figured it gave me 1% more dmg against ice div npc's and players lol


Oh actually, you know what, that might be true.

Edit; Yeah nevermind, it's as you said it is, hyuck hyuck.
Cerebrus


Wait, so my fire div monk with an ice ember on one staff and earth on the other, doesnt receive anything from those embers being on my weapons since they arent fire div like my monk?

Not sure why, but I figured adding a div to your weapon gives you a slight bonus against npcs and players of that div

Example: My bone staff has an ice ember (1%) aura, figured it gave me 1% more dmg against ice div npc's and players lol


Oh actually, you know what, that might be true.

Edit; Yeah nevermind, it's as you said it is, hyuck hyuck.


lol I just hunted down your post about embers and reread it to make sure <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />
Honzo
Thank you for the expedient reply. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> This is awesome! Next thing we need is a charter membership to help contribute monetarily! <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
NiteHawk
Do staves make a difference for clerics when healing or only for Smite / Ray?

Not for healing, but for smite/ray.
Vindal
This brings up an interesting point.

We are in a group with a Monk, Cleric, Necro, Sorc, and Pally. Bone staff drops.

Monk needs it cause hes a monk and attacks with staff.
Sorc and Necro need it cause it increases spell penetration.
Cleric and Pally ALSO need it because leveling each of those classes with smite is the current hotness.

Maybe a little too much value placed on staff weapons?
NiteHawk
This brings up an interesting point.

We are in a group with a Monk, Cleric, Necro, Sorc, and Pally. Bone staff drops.

Monk needs it cause hes a monk and attacks with staff.
Sorc and Necro need it cause it increases spell penetration.
Cleric and Pally ALSO need it because leveling each of those classes with smite is the current hotness.

Maybe a little too much value placed on staff weapons?


I think it makes it useful if anything. For cleric/pally its just another weapon you could have, but can honestly do wtihout. It shines with high int on a necro and sorc though. I don't think it has any less value then swords for half the classes.
Vindal
I agree with you that it doesn't take away from swords, but it removes all usefulness from blunt weapons. Not a reason for a cleric to wield a badass hammer any longer.

Not complaining by any means. Just thought it was funny five different classes all wanted a staff <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
NiteHawk
Give blunt weapons spell pen, w00.

And fix it so paladins can use them!


Making all weapons have spell pen kind of defeats the purpose though.

Paladins will typically use it to level but otherwise they'll use swords, be silly not too. Clerics as well will not probably use a staff unless needed. It's kind of like choice on those anyways.
Thi
This brings up an interesting point.

We are in a group with a Monk, Cleric, Necro, Sorc, and Pally. Bone staff drops.

Monk needs it cause hes a monk and attacks with staff.
Sorc and Necro need it cause it increases spell penetration.
Cleric and Pally ALSO need it because leveling each of those classes with smite is the current hotness.

Maybe a little too much value placed on staff weapons?


I think it makes it useful if anything. For cleric/pally its just another weapon you could have, but can honestly do wtihout. It shines with high int on a necro and sorc though. I don't think it has any less value then swords for half the classes.

This is kinda unfair, Priests need weapons to matter for healing purposes as well, cause no priests wil be fighting using their weapons and let's all agree that Ray sucks hard.

Guardians could be interesting if some of them had spellcasting bonuses, since they already have the benefit of hitting things with them so it should be more of a rarity.
NiteHawk
This brings up an interesting point.

We are in a group with a Monk, Cleric, Necro, Sorc, and Pally. Bone staff drops.

Monk needs it cause hes a monk and attacks with staff.
Sorc and Necro need it cause it increases spell penetration.
Cleric and Pally ALSO need it because leveling each of those classes with smite is the current hotness.

Maybe a little too much value placed on staff weapons?


I think it makes it useful if anything. For cleric/pally its just another weapon you could have, but can honestly do wtihout. It shines with high int on a necro and sorc though. I don't think it has any less value then swords for half the classes.

This is kinda unfair, Priests need weapons to matter for healing purposes as well, cause no priests wil be fighting using their weapons and let's all agree that Ray sucks hard.

Guardians could be interesting if some of them had spellcasting bonuses, since they already have the benefit of hitting things with them so it should be more of a rarity.


Ray is supposed to suck. They are priests, they don't work by damage. Staffs don't benefit healing spells anyways.
Thi


I think it makes it useful if anything. For cleric/pally its just another weapon you could have, but can honestly do wtihout. It shines with high int on a necro and sorc though. I don't think it has any less value then swords for half the classes.

This is kinda unfair, Priests need weapons to matter for healing purposes as well, cause no priests wil be fighting using their weapons and let's all agree that Ray sucks hard.

Guardians could be interesting if some of them had spellcasting bonuses, since they already have the benefit of hitting things with them so it should be more of a rarity.


Ray is supposed to suck. They are priests, they don't work by damage. Staffs don't benefit healing spells anyways.

Wouldn't it be possible or worth considering to make them benefit healing? (Staves)
NiteHawk

This is kinda unfair, Priests need weapons to matter for healing purposes as well, cause no priests wil be fighting using their weapons and let's all agree that Ray sucks hard.

Guardians could be interesting if some of them had spellcasting bonuses, since they already have the benefit of hitting things with them so it should be more of a rarity.


Ray is supposed to suck. They are priests, they don't work by damage. Staffs don't benefit healing spells anyways.

Wouldn't it be possible or worth considering to make them benefit healing? (Staves)


Yeah, but I'd nerf current healing though then. I.E. If 22int heals for 290, and I make staves useful to them, then I'd change it so that they heal for lets say 250, and then 40 more for a OAD staff, with other staffs progressing up to 290 max.

Aka heal would be the same, just staff would play a secondary part to max heal.