← Forum archive

Agility

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

dyer
Hey NH/Devs,

Just had a question around agility and how you have used this attribute I decided to utilise the 5 stat points to push this up to 23 for drakeblood on a monk and it seems we are getting no benefit of doing this? I still struggle to hit and get hit alot.

So curious did i waste 5 stat points? Personally i think if 5 stat points are used to push that attribute to 23 there should be some sort of extra bonus or obvious increase over those who didnt?

Cheers
Mujahideen
Ur about 1/22nd more agile than normal, you most likely wouldn't notice anything unless you ran the numbers and averaged it out.
dyer
Yea thats crap and a waste of 5 stat points..... I think it should be buffed if you utilise 5 stat points to get a +1 increase.
NiteHawk
Did you have one or two fights and then post this? <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" /> That is not testing mate. However theres a couple things I want to point out, which I did in your PM that you sent me. This is based on the overall of yesterday:

Base agi is 40% dodge if both parties had same agi. In the extreme cases 23 vs 18 agi its 50% hit (you) rate vs 30% hit rate (his). Though yours might be more like 26% hit rate (1/4th) due to monk dodge bonus. This means you'd be fighting at 50% vs 26% hit rate. So 1/4 vs 1/3. I'm not so sure that this is a terrible thing. Are you really sure it's the AGI that is the issue here? To me that seems like a good amount of AGI for using 23 agi vs 18 agi. Maybe someone can chime in on this though with stats.

However you fought Gemini! A 22 agi slayer! Not a Half-Orc. You're looking at 42% hit rate vs 34% hit rate now. When you say AGI is broken, are you thinking that by taking one AGI point, you suddenly should become god like vs a 22 agi character? I think your thinking here is completely wrong. It is OK to use +1 agi but it's going to probably feel more effective against lower AGI characters.

I'm not saying the per point AGI is set, nor perfect, but 22 vs 23 agi is going to have some similar AGI because of how close it would be. It would be the same as fighting 19 agi vs 20 agi, or 10 agi vs 11 agi. If you look at the fight you sent me, you hit him 8 times. He hit you 3 times. You could say since he has to hide, that his hit rate would technically be double, so 8 times vs 6 times. To me that seems fair for one point of AGI, no?

There are some other factors I see that could be an overall problem but then I can't really take your fight seriously because Gemini has divinity over you as well. I do think that monk damage might be to low however as a whole, but that could be due to the passive armor damage reduction, a fault with the monk values, or something else. Passive armor might be a bit too op with the active armor kicking in all the time. I see in the fight that he got either very lucky with shield blocks or I need to take more look into that. I'd say since shields are only doing 15% chance probably right now with the highest shield that he got very lucky on the damage absorption, but often when fighting against divinity you are fighting a losing battle.

So you were generally fighting a character whom has only -1 AGI on you, and had divinity on you. You surely can't base a proper test of agi on those two. AGI is the DIFFERENCE between two characters.


I will be giving out one free stat re-allocation once we are done balancing though, so you can shape your character as a whole. I disagree with AGI giving plus 2, makes no sense for that one stat to do so and it does have benefits in different scenarios, but you won't find much benefit in the fight you gave me.
dyer
So understand the div and not worried about the damage front,

Im very much more concerned on the 1 sided fight and the amount of BS being landed vs the hits i could actually land even with higher AGI, then as you advised when getting a hit most of them were absorbed. so while it may not be agi (im not a coder) the fight should show something isnt quite right.

The other aspect i feel is a bit raw is the 5 stat points used to gain the +1 which is clearly not prooving to be beneficial or worth the extra point sacrifice, well IMO i would have been better going INT/WIS for search/spell protection with an extra 5 points, or all roll saurian for STR.
dyer
For those curious in the fight where i got completely owned by Gemini!

=> Gemini arrived from the east.
From Cerebrus: Gemini?
From Dyer: r
From Gemini: ready
From Cerebrus: 3
From Cerebrus: 2
From Cerebrus: 1
From Cerebrus: GO!
gem is not here!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger for 384 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
You attack Gemini with your void staff, but his shield deflects half of the blow for 62 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff for 105 points of damage!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger for 523 points of damage!
Gemini is looking at you.
From Dyer: fuck me
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
gem is not here!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
You launch into a ROUNDHOUSE KICK against Gemini and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
You attack Gemini with your void staff, but his armor absorbs half of the blow for 69 points of damage!
Gemini is looking at you.
Cerebrus is looking at you.
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
Cerebrus is looking over Gemini.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
You attack Gemini with your void staff, but his shield deflects half of the blow for 45 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
Cerebrus is looking at you.
Cerebrus is looking over Gemini.
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff for 94 points of damage!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
gem is not here!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You look over Gemini.
Cerebrus is looking at you.
Cerebrus is looking over Gemini.
You are too exhausted.
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
You attack Gemini with your void staff, but his shield deflects half of the blow for 42 points of damage!
gem is not here!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
You attack Gemini with your void staff, but his shield deflects half of the blow for 35 points of damage!
You launch into a ROUNDHOUSE KICK against Gemini and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
From Dyer: 42
Cerebrus is looking over Gemini.
Cerebrus is looking at you.
You attack Gemini with your void staff, but his shield deflects half of the blow for 42 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the east.
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger for 474 points of damage!
Gemini has killed you!
>>> Dyer was killed by Gemini <<<
NiteHawk
So understand the div and not worried about the damage front,

Im very much more concerned on the 1 sided fight and the amount of BS being landed vs the hits i could actually land even with higher AGI, then as you advised when getting a hit most of them were absorbed. so while it may not be agi (im not a coder) the fight should show something isnt quite right.

The other aspect i feel is a bit raw is the 5 stat points used to gain the +1 which is clearly not prooving to be beneficial or worth the extra point sacrifice, well IMO i would have been better going INT/WIS for search/spell protection with an extra 5 points, or all roll saurian for STR.


That feels invalid to me. Putting a point into wisdom or int doesn't mean you are going to suddenly get super amounts of wisdom or search ability too. +1 wisdom doesn't give you 10% more resistance, +1 int doesn't give you 20% search rate. They are all minor effects. Even STR is only 6-10 more damage on a good case per point with div. Though for slayers I suppose this is amped up a bit due to x4, (with 22 str and an oad dagger on div they get the lower end though, which is typically 6 more damage, so x4 that.)

Again I will be giving a free re-allocation once I am done balancing things, but +1 is more for a small boost and it won't extremely change the character. It's more like a love tap.

I'm just trying to see this from a logical point. If you had div against him, you would of done 643 damage against him vs the 494 damage you did there. He also wouldn't of killed you either most likely with three. If the armor absorbs weren't a case, and you were fighting against div, you would of done 791 damage. If you had div, it would of been 1028, which would of killed him. That's why I generally say armor needs looking at. I am not saying that you would of done that and you still would of died if it was against div, but based on fights armor does effect alot right now.

I'm trying to look at this from a logical approach. I disagree with basing it off AGI because your agi was similar to his.
dyer
1 point? it cost 5 stat points to get the +1 agi as drakebllod is 22 max then the 5 point sacrifice to get 23?

so that would give me 5 points to put into int/wis???

Cheers
NiteHawk
1 point? it cost 5 stat points to get the +1 agi as drakebllod is 22 max then the 5 point sacrifice to get 23?

so that would give me 5 points to put into int/wis???

Cheers


Oh sorry, you meant as dispersing the stats. Yeah that is correct. Again, it is the players choice to make a more hard hitting character or slightly dodging more type deal. I thought you meant +1'ing wisdom or int for some reason.

You won't find any wisdom resistance with a drakeblood though. 10wis or 12wis you're going to be mince meat cause the multiplier on drakebloods is super low, and monks alone won't help a large amount. It might be around 8% more resistance with 2 more wisdom though, but thats basing it off 20 or 25% resistance to begin with.

5 points into wisdom on another race if you could do it would help though. But yes, that is the intension normally when picking a race that actually has wisdom to sink it into. A situation would be do you want to hit and dodge a little more against physical classes by +1ing agi or hitting a little harder.;.. Or do you want to use the +5 points for an extra point and put +5 into wisdom to make a more resilient character against spells. On one note, you will be better at specific class fighting, but in another note, you will be weaker on others.

You won't be perfect at everything, you specially won't be perfect at everything if you +1. It is a sacrifice for a gain in another area.
Folder
This is exactly why it's your choice whether to +1 or not. There has to be a decision there. If +1 were ALWAYS the right thing to do then what's the point of it at all? It becomes moot if it's the only viable option. I think it's in a pretty good place right now, you do make a sacrifice to +1 but then you do get that small bonus.

I post on everything Killa, has nothing to do with what guild it is.
NiteHawk
This is exactly why it's your choice whether to +1 or not. There has to be a decision there. If +1 were ALWAYS the right thing to do then what's the point of it at all? It becomes moot if it's the only viable option. I think it's in a pretty good place right now, you do make a sacrifice to +1 but then you do get that small bonus.

I post on everything Killa, has nothing to do with what guild it is.


This.

I have said it in several threads, but I will give everyone one stat reallocation once we balance things. Could be a little while, but it's a promise.
FrostSlayer
I'm not sure what the issue is here... I got lucky with the shield blocks, and landed a few backstabs, but also missed a few backstabs. I have div which let me 3 shot instead of 4 shot. You recently lost 7.5% hit rate as a monk (which I approve of) and we all received 5% base hit rate increase. Is the problem here that your 23 agi vs my 22 agi doesnt allow you to land all your hits and dodge all of mine?

If we replayed that scenario 1000 times, i am 99% sure i would not win them all. There would be some times that I would miss every backstab and you would land all your RH attacks. Small sample size and using that an example of what is and isn't fair or right is never the way to do it. Even during that fight, i missed a ton of backstabs... would have been over sooner if i landed another one near the start.

I hear 19-20 agi chars complaining that agi matters too much, i have 23 agi chars complaining it doesnt matter enough. Does that mean its right where it should be?

Even if you had your 5 points back from agi, what would you do with them? cap your int and wis at 12 and put 1 in cha? I don't think youll see the benefit from that which you think you would.

Nitehawk laid out some pretty good numbers to work with. In many, many other scenarios it would play out differently, and this time it just played out in my favor. Sorry <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" />
NiteHawk
I'm not sure what the issue is here... I got lucky with the shield blocks, and landed a few backstabs, but also missed a few backstabs. I have div which let me 3 shot instead of 4 shot. You recently lost 7.5% hit rate as a monk (which I approve of) and we all received 5% base hit rate increase. Is the problem here that your 23 agi vs my 22 agi doesnt allow you to land all your hits and dodge all of mine?

If we replayed that scenario 1000 times, i am 99% sure i would not win them all. There would be some times that I would miss every backstab and you would land all your RH attacks. Small sample size and using that an example of what is and isn't fair or right is never the way to do it. Even during that fight, i missed a ton of backstabs... would have been over sooner if i landed another one near the start.

I hear 19-20 agi chars complaining that agi matters too much, i have 23 agi chars complaining it doesnt matter enough. Does that mean its right where it should be?

Even if you had your 5 points back from agi, what would you do with them? cap your int and wis at 12 and put 1 in cha? I don't think youll see the benefit from that which you think you would.

Nitehawk laid out some pretty good numbers to work with. In many, many other scenarios it would play out differently, and this time it just played out in my favor. Sorry <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" />


Yeah, this is the biggest issue too. I have people on both ends screaming its too much and it's to little. The only real issue I want to test is armor. Armor does do alot right now, I am wondering if it's too much. Going to make a post about something soon though.
dyer
Cool i guess it goes down to a lucky fight then, but the numbers are still bugging me if i break it down.

For a Ninja with +1 agi, natural dodge bonus and natural hit bonus its apparently about a 1% difference on that fight if we ignore the 75% shield deflect rate Gemeni happened to get.

22 attacks , 6 landed = 27.7% hit rate
28 attacks, 2 hits 6 deflects = 28.6% hit rate

im hoping ive messed up the math here, or missed something otherwise it really contradicts what you guys are saying or Gemeni had a leprechaun hiding in his pocket.

Re the stat convo, i wouldn't role a drake blood again, there is no point, better going saurian, same AC bonus, + Magic resil with something like 23,22,19,10,10,14 to max strenth out with a loss of a little HP.
dyer
New fight, still shows backstab hits more than monks do normally.

Gem 14 attacks , 6 landed = 42.8% hit rate
Dyer 15 attacks, 5 hits = 33.3% hit rate

=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the west.
=> A bone archer arrived from the west.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
A skeletal beast attacks you with his teeth and misses!
You are too exhausted.
You are healed for 225 hit points.
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff for 115 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You are too exhausted.
You are too exhausted.
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
Gemini drinks a blood potion.
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
A skeletal beast attacks Gemini with his teeth and misses!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 65 points of damage!
=> Gemini went west.
=> A skeletal beast went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the west.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
Mort Wraith attacks you with his spectral scythe and misses!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the west.
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 383 points of damage!
Mort Wraith attacks you with his spectral scythe and misses!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff for 105 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff for 112 points of damage!
Gemini drinks a blood potion.
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the west.
=> A skeletal beast arrived from the west.
You are healed for 225 hit points.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
A skeletal beast attacks Gemini with his teeth and misses!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the west.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger and misses!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow and misses!
A bone archer attacks you with his bone bow for 99 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff for 112 points of damage!
You attack Gemini with your void staff and miss!
You attack Gemini with your void staff, but his armor absorbs half of the blow for 60 points of damage!
A bone archer attacks Gemini with his bone bow, but his armor absorbs some of the blow!
Mort Wraith attacks you with his spectral scythe for 250 points of damage!
Gemini drinks a blood potion.
Mort Wraith attacks Gemini with his spectral scythe and misses!
A skeletal beast attacks Gemini with his teeth and misses!
A skeletal beast attacks you with his teeth and misses!
=> Gemini went west.
=> A bone archer went west.
=> Mort Wraith went west.
=> A skeletal beast went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the west.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 386 points of damage!
=> Gemini went west.
=> Gemini arrived from the west.
=> Mort Wraith arrived from the west.
Gemini BACKSTABS you with his bone dagger, but your armor absorbs some of the blow for 348 points of damage!
Gemini has killed you!
>>> Dyer was killed by Gemini <<<
FrostSlayer
1) monks no longer have a passive hit rate bonus, it only applies to dodge.

2) your sample size, again, is far too small to draw any conclusions.

3) your armor absorbed 2 attacks, while mine absorbed 0, and 0 shield deflects. based on this info, using what you think is a fair amount of data, i can conclude that your armor is too high, and my armor/shield need to activate more. Correct?
dyer
1) monks no longer have a passive hit rate bonus, it only applies to dodge.

2) your sample size, again, is far too small to draw any conclusions.

3) your armor absorbed 2 attacks, while mine absorbed 0, and 0 shield deflects. based on this info, using what you think is a fair amount of data, i can conclude that your armor is too high, and my armor/shield need to activate more. Correct?



1 - Hit rate, fine nerfed, should still dodge more with +1 agi and the ninja dodge so stats show otherwise on the 2 fights we have had.
2 - You are right it is, im raising a potential balancing issue so how are you helping?
3 - I never said i had a fair amount of data? stop trolling and start helping?

Cheers