← Forum archive

Logging off exploitation.

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

daedroth
Someone obviously doesn't have enough boob in their life.


Well ok perhaps I have exaggerated slightly with what I said in my previous comment, my apologies. I shall endeavour to be more literal in future in case I am misintepreted.

PS. Your right I do <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" />
NiteHawk
I do agree that there should be a logoff timer or some sort. Implementing it is kind of a nightmare hassle right now but I will attempt too eventually.

You shouldn't be able to log off to get to safety, it's cheap.
daedroth
I hope this gets done soon. I don't mind getting beat at keys etc, but getting beat because someone logs with the keys is just... ewww. Why not just run Mr. Gump?
Terron
waiting any amount of time to swap characters is retarded. you cant honestly value a "chance at a pk" more than the hassle of tapping impatiently as you try and switch alts, or using a sneaky character to run supplies to wait more, or how shitty it will be when 6 people want to swap alts to form a boss/training party? mixed in with all the bs timers and the "ill log on after this is done" could be a waste of 10-20 minutes.

i cant honestly see the timer higher than 10 seconds without it being more annoying than its worth.

"hey im getting attacked at this orange boss, can you help me teammate? "nah, no point itll be dead 2x over before my alt logs in."

i think the problem is you can log off indefinitely and next day boom you're in a temple safe zone(this can be highly abused by thief cause there is no reason to be online after you rob the grid anyway)

better changes would include;
-items that drop are locked to the KSer's party for 30 seconds(only thief could break this rule)
(yes that promotes trying to kill steal opposed to tap /get macro, meaning you are out in the open for counterattack)
-characters cannot log off unless in a safe-zone(guarded town/temple)
(sucks for newer players to explore but it can be easily addressed via wiki, to get help with exploration from a clan/veteran/helper)
Folder

better changes would include;
-items that drop are locked to the KSer's party for 30 seconds(only thief could break this rule)
(yes that promotes trying to kill steal opposed to tap /get macro, meaning you are out in the open for counterattack)
-characters cannot log off unless in a safe-zone(guarded town/temple)
(sucks for newer players to explore but it can be easily addressed via wiki, to get help with exploration from a clan/veteran/helper)


Not a fun of locking loot to a group. Safe zone could maybe be a thing, but tbh this sounds like it would be way more annoying than a 10-15 second logout timer. If you're in the middle of Dreads and need to go what then? It might take you 5 mins to fight your way back out.

Logging blows, it's game breaking imo.
Styx
Nighthawk has a lot of things to do, finish new scripting so staff can build new oad areas etc, let alone the difficulty to design new client after. And programming it for log off timer based on multiple instances. And connection speeds etc.

I think nighthawk has enough on the table to work on and we should wait till this game get caught up and just enjoy the hard work that's been done.
Terron
logging isn't as game breaking as alts are. you are saying logging for one purpose is fine but not another, all for a slight chance at a pk in some situations. I get where you're coming from but it isn't that big of a deal imo.

personally i log in and out about 100x a day using my high level monk to critically wound good exp monsters for my shitty lowbies. because the game isn't as enjoyable smashin 24-35s and hundreds of misses and gulping pots every 2 rounds so you can kill a bear. granted it does get to the point(lvl 18 or so) all you do is wait for an exp party to exploit fast ks exp. at times this is even less exciting than slaying potions to achieve a bear kill. its better just hyper training to 16+ in an hour or so. so your crits are atleast semi fun solo, when noone is partying. personally id like questlines to account for gear, gold, and all the exp for 1-25 but that's a long ways off id imagine.

i have played a few games where alts are allowed but only on a per day instance. your first login was the crit you were allowed that day. several of them had level caps between 25 and 30. new characters were graced until 10-15 on those games. not a fan with such a limited playerbase, but a possibility if it ever booms.

log off timers longer than 10 seconds wont be favorable by most new players if you ever get any. i do however believe there should be a short timer. because it is relatively easy to train copius amounts of alts, a person could just set a large number of characters on important squares and log them all simultaneously slinging what would seem as unlimited amounts of stamina.

i think the combat timer would be an adequate log off timer, if it was changed to consider players and monsters differently. that way if a player is lost or left behind they can log until finding help, and players directly under attack cannot log unless not under attack for awhile.
NiteHawk
logging isn't as game breaking as alts are. you are saying logging for one purpose is fine but not another, all for a slight chance at a pk in some situations. I get where you're coming from but it isn't that big of a deal imo.

personally i log in and out about 100x a day using my high level monk to critically wound good exp monsters for my shitty lowbies. because the game isn't as enjoyable smashin 24-35s and hundreds of misses and gulping pots every 2 rounds so you can kill a bear. granted it does get to the point(lvl 18 or so) all you do is wait for an exp party to exploit fast ks exp. at times this is even less exciting than slaying potions to achieve a bear kill. its better just hyper training to 16+ in an hour or so. so your crits are atleast semi fun solo, when noone is partying. personally id like questlines to account for gear, gold, and all the exp for 1-25 but that's a long ways off id imagine.

i have played a few games where alts are allowed but only on a per day instance. your first login was the crit you were allowed that day. several of them had level caps between 25 and 30. new characters were graced until 10-15 on those games. not a fan with such a limited playerbase, but a possibility if it ever booms.

log off timers longer than 10 seconds wont be favorable by most new players if you ever get any. i do however believe there should be a short timer. because it is relatively easy to train copius amounts of alts, a person could just set a large number of characters on important squares and log them all simultaneously slinging what would seem as unlimited amounts of stamina.

i think the combat timer would be an adequate log off timer, if it was changed to consider players and monsters differently. that way if a player is lost or left behind they can log until finding help, and players directly under attack cannot log unless not under attack for awhile.


Combat timer would be a good one but the issue comes that if you log off anywhere with an NPC you will die, for sure. There does need to be something to prevent it, a 15-25 second timer would be okay, two or three rounds extra virtually.
daedroth
One of my thoughts when I originally started this thread was using the combat timer, but then I realised it would get reset every time the person logging got attacked (which would not be fair either).
A flat timer would work best.

Also, as Vindal mentioned, it would be good if there was some kind of idle disconnect as well. If the game receives no signals from the source of a character (the Pc, internet connection) then the character is automatically disconnected (would help with ghosting issues). Not sure how feasible this is though.
Folder
logging isn't as game breaking as alts are. you are saying logging for one purpose is fine but not another, all for a slight chance at a pk in some situations. I get where you're coming from but it isn't that big of a deal imo.


That's your opinion. It absolutely is GAME RUINING to me when people use logging to secure items or run from a pk attempt. I almost quit entirely because of it.

personally i log in and out about 100x a day using my high level monk to critically wound good exp monsters for my shitty lowbies.


Ok, well. That's basically a hack around the 1 alt thing. I see now why you don't want a logoff timer lol.

because it is relatively easy to train copius amounts of alts, a person could just set a large number of characters on important squares and log them all simultaneously slinging what would seem as unlimited amounts of stamina.


What? When you log in your stamina timer is reset. So if you use it all and then log out, it'll restart from 0 seconds when you log back in.

10-15 second combat timer, or whatever NH feels is easiest/most appropriate. It doesn't need to be so complicated. Please just fix the logging bullshit because people will always abuse whatever they can.
Cerebrus
That last bit is untrue. If you log out with no stam, you will be exhausted when you log back in. At least from what I've experienced, thats been the case.
Terron
you can run multiple characters to the same square that aren't exhausted and machinegun stamina. ive already tested it lol. i can do about 4 characters in 10 seconds. so if i autosneak or hide a thief/assassin on mort wraith for instance, i could wait for an enemy to stam out and sling 15-20 stamina on him with 3-4 monks lol.(this is why it should be a minimum of 5 seconds)


i think making a copy of the current combat timer, and setting the copy to reflect player attacks is the most feasible option. if youre under attack you can run/run and hide, whatever. aslong as logging under duress from other players is prohibited.(this would count both attacking and being attacked)


@folder it is still almost impossible to kill the player with a short log off timer. it isn't changing much at all. you realize at a 40% pvp hit rate and needing to land about 7-8 attacks, .4x.4x.4x.4x.4x.4x.4 isnt even a 1% chance you will kill the logging player anyway. you can argue that you have a party and all could attack but that's irrelevant because if you had a party worth of attacks you could have killed him while he was hitting the monster in the first place...

this is why i said the dropped item should be party locked for 30 seconds. in conjunction with a player combat timer, it would be very hard to steal an enemies item(s) w/o getting attacked and having a difficult time escaping with the item, but its still possible.

me killing risen on lvl 8s isnt very problematic because i wouldnt do it if anyone was online to party up when i have time to play. noone is doing shit during late hours of PST, this game is time horrid for west coasters.(nothing is in, ive never seen a key battle,oad, or even have anything to rob on my thief lol. its already cleared) besides the fact that im pretty much done getting every class to 17+ already. highly doubt ill make duplicates with nothing to do but train, unless the ability to train crits in trade for endgame equips arises.
Folder
i think making a copy of the current combat timer, and setting the copy to reflect player attacks is the most feasible option. if youre under attack you can run/run and hide, whatever. aslong as logging under duress from other players is prohibited.(this would count both attacking and being attacked)


Yes, of course. This is always how I envisioned it working. Solves the issue.
NiteHawk
i think making a copy of the current combat timer, and setting the copy to reflect player attacks is the most feasible option. if youre under attack you can run/run and hide, whatever. as long as logging under duress from other players is prohibited.(this would count both attacking and being attacked)


Yes, of course. This is always how I envisioned it working. Solves the issue.


The problem with this right now is that character is bound to the slot, and when the character leaves, the character data is destroyed. It's overall a nightmare but I'm trying to see if there are any easy ways of dealing with it. I thought that a simple hold the character data would work but it won't, because when you disconnect completely, the slot is completely cleared. Saying to store it elsewhere is one thing vs actually doing it. On top of that functions use the sessions list to get data, such as searching for a player to attack, etc etc. It's more than just a small change. I'm not sure where to even start with it yet. If I had thought about this ahead of time and made a list where the player was linked to the slot using a variable for calling, then you'd just have a player list you loop rather then a session list. Would of saved me alot of problems, but it ain't like this, so yeah, goody.

However, I think it needs to include PVE too to be honest, otherwise people will logoff after getting keys right on the square. As long as you can relog said character it should be fine.
Terron
i get what youre saying, that kinda sux.

i dont think theres a problem with logging with the keys aslong as you arent under attack from other players, i dont see anyone logging if they arent in a risky pvp situation. why would you lol.
Commander KO
panda might be the greater idealists in the matter of once you strike you don't run or log, yet considering ghosting as an exploit should be discarded for the coding allows it, it always allows for cowardice of falling fair on your square gambling experience and obituary.

but let us do that too irl and haha we will never be defeated, but i still see it as weak AF as weak as old rokian bug tripping to crash the server for whatever reason....

who here or near can show me how to do it irl...
Commander KO
(*V*) Only fools fight in burning houses (*V*)

and we burn and still fight...

so apologies if i address our relation to the coding more than the classic armchair coding variations we offer...

but to that i say make all on a square warp to a battle stage and those left can stop attack to trigger a timer to warp back.

can that be coded muh ngz?