Unaffect scaling
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
the luck of the draw from koth is the only factor keeping it interesting in my opinion. winning the event isnt "winning" in my eyes tho. you can win by going last. if a chanter cuts through 12 saurian monks and you kill the mage on your 90 MR bard its more like luck than a win. the mage wins in my book but yes they can "win". but since i've started that has been rare. its almost entirely monks and chanters/necros with the one exception killa/soldier. poor guy has to be sick of dieing on horcs by now. "sweet" a ling monk i got a chance..aww i missed 27/28 .....this temple looks familiar.
its quite simple if a chanter beats a wisdomless heavy dps 99% of the time than a high dps should beat low con mr characters 99% and the mr characters beat mages 99% or it isnt balanced. atm its like 55 87 99 but id rather the setup get tweaked so its closer to 70%-70%-70% on that tree. it would have to start with wis/mr since mages are at the high end atm.
its quite simple if a chanter beats a wisdomless heavy dps 99% of the time than a high dps should beat low con mr characters 99% and the mr characters beat mages 99% or it isnt balanced. atm its like 55 87 99 but id rather the setup get tweaked so its closer to 70%-70%-70% on that tree. it would have to start with wis/mr since mages are at the high end atm.
People keep saying this "if you go last, you win" crap for awhile and it just isnt true.
I see going last as a disadvantage.
1. You lose out on winning the streak prize. Someone who goes near the beginning has a better chance at winning streak prize, as well as winning the whole thing. We've had quite a few people start near the beginning and go all the way to win it all.
On the other hand, I RARELY see the person who goes last winning.
It actually kind of balances itself out. If you're towards the beginning you have a shot at winning streak (maybe even king)
If you're at the end you cant win streak, and have a slight chance at winning king.
There are advantages at both ends of it.
I see going last as a disadvantage.
1. You lose out on winning the streak prize. Someone who goes near the beginning has a better chance at winning streak prize, as well as winning the whole thing. We've had quite a few people start near the beginning and go all the way to win it all.
On the other hand, I RARELY see the person who goes last winning.
It actually kind of balances itself out. If you're towards the beginning you have a shot at winning streak (maybe even king)
If you're at the end you cant win streak, and have a slight chance at winning king.
There are advantages at both ends of it.
the luck of the draw from koth is the only factor keeping it interesting in my opinion. winning the event isnt "winning" in my eyes tho. you can win by going last. if a chanter cuts through 12 saurian monks and you kill the mage on your 90 MR bard its more like luck than a win. the mage wins in my book but yes they can "win". but since i've started that has been rare. its almost entirely monks and chanters/necros with the one exception killa/soldier. poor guy has to be sick of dieing on horcs by now. "sweet" a ling monk i got a chance..aww i missed 27/28 .....this temple looks familiar.
its quite simple if a chanter beats a wisdomless heavy dps 99% of the time than a high dps should beat low con mr characters 99% and the mr characters beat mages 99% or it isnt balanced. atm its like 55 87 99 but id rather the setup get tweaked so its closer to 70%-70%-70% on that tree. it would have to start with wis/mr since mages are at the high end atm.
I am not sure I understand what any of this is supposed to mean, nor am I trying to be a smartass. Additionally I guess that I must be a ghost that haunts EO and only certain players can see when I've entered events. Most of my PP has come from long streaks in KOTH. If it wasn't for that I'd be screwed! Everytime I've gotten to the final match before King I have lost. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Something useful to know is that NO ONE used to play Death Mages until people realized that "Hey, these guys aren't half bad!" and now they are finally popping up. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> Gotta try new stuff!
P.S. - I play an Elder Druid. If you participate in KOTH much you'll notice there is a huge variety of players. Lots of different classes but it also depends on the week. There is a such thing as predicting what others will play so you can play something against it that has an edge. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_wink.gif" alt=";)" title="Wink" /> You need to remember that there is strategy to the game and to PVP. People argue things are always slanted one way or another but at the end of the day, we the people that run events, actually get to SEE what is happening and who is winning and how things turn out. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" /> I recommend you coming out for some events and seein' what happens!
There are advantages at both ends of it.
Yes.
because you aren't choosing what you fight going last is a 50/50 chance, it is a greater chance to receive pp than going for streak. you only have to beat 1 person opposed to 3-4 on average. now i do agree it isnt always a great match at the end. for instance my drake monk entered koth last time and even if i won my round there were 3 mages behind me in the order. going first, or in the beginning tier anyway, has the greatest probability of getting streak and winning. in any case i would rather go last 100% of the time because its the safest bet for points. go ahead and calc out the probabilities.
@ honzo i wasnt saying you were being a smart ass at all, i think you are misinterpreting what im saying by being defensive, like im attacking you in some way.
i will break it down in a way that i think is easier to understand for everyone.
there is 3 types of characters;
straight offensive melee characters like saurian/half orc
high Mr high agility melee characters
spellslingers
saurians have a significant edge on most other melee types because of high agility and high strength, but it isnt such a bonus where a ling or d/e/ elf cant win. in this sense the hardcore dps of saurian drake and half orc are in the top percentile of melee builds but only by a small amount 5-10%. higher MR builds like DE ling gobby aren't even at much of a disadvantage going against hardcore dps as hardcore dps is vs magic. magic is still hitting most of the current MR builds 40+% of the time and hitting hardcore dps 80%+. atm hardcore dps isn't even viable in events because the weakness of magic outweighs the benefits tenfold. mages have no problems outside of bad luck because noone is making antimage characters like elf/gnome monk and probably never will because you wouldnt want to be at that mass disadvantage vs hardcore dps. because the real high MR builds cant be used because of melee deficiencies. hardcore melee variants are at a severe disadvantage overall because they have to hit steady and both other build types have high to very high agility aswell. mages have plenty of points to max their defensive stats aswell.
so what im saying is the game is becoming more about goblin(after mr boost) DE and ling melee's vs chanter/necro. noone will take a 90% chance of a loss to any magician for a 5-10% chance to own a ling as nitehawk said. im hoping things can be balanced in a way that those lower end MR builds lose a bit more to hardcore dps, and mages lose more vs MR builds. so on average its a 70% chance to win vs what is weak to you opposed to what it is now.
i fully understand a gnome monk would probably win 95% of the time fighting a chanter, so it isnt just "unaffect scaling" as a problem. I just feel the game would be better off with a balanced hit rate for spells like melee is.(40% with +/- variable) opposed to massive hit rates unobtainable by any melee character.
agility alters hit rate of melee, wisdom should alter hit rate of spells, armor and MR should negatively effect incoming damage respectively. its more dynamic. provides reasons to dabble in different melee classes and point setups, easier to manage, and an overall better system. may take a few changes, namely hardcore dps getting a few more possible wis and a couple stat points, making mages miss them more than 1-2x out of 10 but since they have almost no MR they'd be hit very hard. im sure if the game was balanced to this degree it would be more well rounded. but its not my game, you can do whatever you'd like. i have however, playtested alot of games for gaming industries small and large. its all the advice i can give, take it or leave it. i'm sick of typing these essays and likely wont do so anymore. seems more appropriate to pop up like the jade falcon with a meme, gif, or an emote.
Have a wonderful Valentines Day!
@ honzo i wasnt saying you were being a smart ass at all, i think you are misinterpreting what im saying by being defensive, like im attacking you in some way.
i will break it down in a way that i think is easier to understand for everyone.
there is 3 types of characters;
straight offensive melee characters like saurian/half orc
high Mr high agility melee characters
spellslingers
saurians have a significant edge on most other melee types because of high agility and high strength, but it isnt such a bonus where a ling or d/e/ elf cant win. in this sense the hardcore dps of saurian drake and half orc are in the top percentile of melee builds but only by a small amount 5-10%. higher MR builds like DE ling gobby aren't even at much of a disadvantage going against hardcore dps as hardcore dps is vs magic. magic is still hitting most of the current MR builds 40+% of the time and hitting hardcore dps 80%+. atm hardcore dps isn't even viable in events because the weakness of magic outweighs the benefits tenfold. mages have no problems outside of bad luck because noone is making antimage characters like elf/gnome monk and probably never will because you wouldnt want to be at that mass disadvantage vs hardcore dps. because the real high MR builds cant be used because of melee deficiencies. hardcore melee variants are at a severe disadvantage overall because they have to hit steady and both other build types have high to very high agility aswell. mages have plenty of points to max their defensive stats aswell.
so what im saying is the game is becoming more about goblin(after mr boost) DE and ling melee's vs chanter/necro. noone will take a 90% chance of a loss to any magician for a 5-10% chance to own a ling as nitehawk said. im hoping things can be balanced in a way that those lower end MR builds lose a bit more to hardcore dps, and mages lose more vs MR builds. so on average its a 70% chance to win vs what is weak to you opposed to what it is now.
i fully understand a gnome monk would probably win 95% of the time fighting a chanter, so it isnt just "unaffect scaling" as a problem. I just feel the game would be better off with a balanced hit rate for spells like melee is.(40% with +/- variable) opposed to massive hit rates unobtainable by any melee character.
agility alters hit rate of melee, wisdom should alter hit rate of spells, armor and MR should negatively effect incoming damage respectively. its more dynamic. provides reasons to dabble in different melee classes and point setups, easier to manage, and an overall better system. may take a few changes, namely hardcore dps getting a few more possible wis and a couple stat points, making mages miss them more than 1-2x out of 10 but since they have almost no MR they'd be hit very hard. im sure if the game was balanced to this degree it would be more well rounded. but its not my game, you can do whatever you'd like. i have however, playtested alot of games for gaming industries small and large. its all the advice i can give, take it or leave it. i'm sick of typing these essays and likely wont do so anymore. seems more appropriate to pop up like the jade falcon with a meme, gif, or an emote.
Have a wonderful Valentines Day!
an example:
-pvp spell hit rate set at 75% base (also possible to lower to 70% and make spell penetration work here) void staff average penetration is 5.0625 (eliminate the min/max variance)
-each wisdom opponent has reduces spell hit rate by 2%
-leaves a 55% chance to hit 10 wisdom characters
-27% chance to hit a 24 wis elemental
-a spread of 27 to 55% hit rate which if im not mistaken is really really close to the same spread melee has (19 agi barb vs 24 agility cav)
MR values can be changed to be viable "armor vs spells" lowering damage keeping gnome able to survive more hits than a half orc etc
BOOM! mic drop, +1, thumbs up and all that jazz. jazz hands ...what.
-pvp spell hit rate set at 75% base (also possible to lower to 70% and make spell penetration work here) void staff average penetration is 5.0625 (eliminate the min/max variance)
-each wisdom opponent has reduces spell hit rate by 2%
-leaves a 55% chance to hit 10 wisdom characters
-27% chance to hit a 24 wis elemental
-a spread of 27 to 55% hit rate which if im not mistaken is really really close to the same spread melee has (19 agi barb vs 24 agility cav)
MR values can be changed to be viable "armor vs spells" lowering damage keeping gnome able to survive more hits than a half orc etc
BOOM! mic drop, +1, thumbs up and all that jazz. jazz hands ...what.
because you aren't choosing what you fight going last is a 50/50 chance
You dont choose what you fight in the beginning either lol It's all randomized. I take the names in the room, input them in a randomizer and generate a list. No one picks who they fight ever.
Well, with a randomiser people cant compain about favouritism etc, must make Staffy job so much easier <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
Well, with a randomiser people cant compain about favouritism etc, must make Staffy job so much easier <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />
It does, ever since I started using it things have ran smoothly.
I stopped having people page with a number as well to see who goes first. I just use the randomizer and first person goes first. Made things much quicker.
its random, going last no matter which way it ends up is 50/50 your build is either greater than or less than whatever is fighting you.
now, in all honesty, when you random 12 people and my drakeblood monk is sitting 8th with 3 necro's behind him i could have left before the first match, wouldn't have changed anything. i could possibly beat a necro but not 3 in a row. no chance at either streak or win. i leveled the wrong monk sadly. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" />
now, in all honesty, when you random 12 people and my drakeblood monk is sitting 8th with 3 necro's behind him i could have left before the first match, wouldn't have changed anything. i could possibly beat a necro but not 3 in a row. no chance at either streak or win. i leveled the wrong monk sadly. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_sad.gif" alt=":(" title="Sad" />
There's some luck in koth, it's part of the fun. Ya win some ya lose some homie.
As I said in another post, I think the 25 to 92% MR scaling is a bit extreme. HOs do have the bonus against Lings (though its little atm) and they should have a chance to kill HO. Same goes for Sorcs trying to kill lings. and same for Hos trying to kill sorcs.
I don't think it needs a giant change, just some tweaks. It will also help out if you don't have max INT either if its not so extreme which will help out other classes if you prefer something other then gnome. With that said I also think it needs to be more impacting then AGI formula is. Theres alot more variables that come into play like class and race MR too.
I don't think it needs a giant change, just some tweaks. It will also help out if you don't have max INT either if its not so extreme which will help out other classes if you prefer something other then gnome. With that said I also think it needs to be more impacting then AGI formula is. Theres alot more variables that come into play like class and race MR too.
int shouldn't matter at all. int should be fizzles and a damage stat very similar to strength, strength stat offers more variance because its only damage you can lose a little to balance your stats to preference on half the races. int has no variance whatsoever it must be relatively high currently same as agi. just a few points off and you turn that enemy dark elf into a supergnome.
perhaps you can balance the whole system through MR tweaks. but i find it alot easier to use that wisdom formula i posted up there, and use mr to modify incoming spell damage. because you can make a 23 wis gnome survive the exact number of hits from magic as a dwarf 23 con does in melee. and the hit rates for everything are even up.
basically you would end up with something like: (using the average melee character 21 str/average chanter 21 int)
-test average and let the rest go unless its causing a massive problem
24 con dwarf survives 10.5 hits in melee on average /24 wis elemental survives 10.5 hits versus magic
23 con dwarf/horc survives 9.5 / 23 wis ele/gnome survive 9.5
etc
anyway your game your rules ;P , but i will say 1 thing. my monk will be the only character with no mr i ever train. its all mass mr and mages for me at this point. and apparently most agree. its crazy to me that because a mage slings spells it can have a virtual 40 agility in a sense. i want one <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> no i want 10
perhaps you can balance the whole system through MR tweaks. but i find it alot easier to use that wisdom formula i posted up there, and use mr to modify incoming spell damage. because you can make a 23 wis gnome survive the exact number of hits from magic as a dwarf 23 con does in melee. and the hit rates for everything are even up.
basically you would end up with something like: (using the average melee character 21 str/average chanter 21 int)
-test average and let the rest go unless its causing a massive problem
24 con dwarf survives 10.5 hits in melee on average /24 wis elemental survives 10.5 hits versus magic
23 con dwarf/horc survives 9.5 / 23 wis ele/gnome survive 9.5
etc
anyway your game your rules ;P , but i will say 1 thing. my monk will be the only character with no mr i ever train. its all mass mr and mages for me at this point. and apparently most agree. its crazy to me that because a mage slings spells it can have a virtual 40 agility in a sense. i want one <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> no i want 10
int shouldn't matter at all. int should be fizzles and a damage stat very similar to strength, strength stat offers more variance because its only damage you can lose a little to balance your stats to preference on half the races. int has no variance whatsoever it must be relatively high currently same as agi. just a few points off and you turn that enemy dark elf into a supergnome.
perhaps you can balance the whole system through MR tweaks. but i find it alot easier to use that wisdom formula i posted up there, and use mr to modify incoming spell damage. because you can make a 23 wis gnome survive the exact number of hits from magic as a dwarf 23 con does in melee. and the hit rates for everything are even up.
basically you would end up with something like: (using the average melee character 21 str/average chanter 21 int)
-test average and let the rest go unless its causing a massive problem
24 con dwarf survives 10.5 hits in melee on average /24 wis elemental survives 10.5 hits versus magic
23 con dwarf/horc survives 9.5 / 23 wis ele/gnome survive 9.5
etc
anyway your game your rules ;P , but i will say 1 thing. my monk will be the only character with no mr i ever train. its all mass mr and mages for me at this point. and apparently most agree. its crazy to me that because a mage slings spells it can have a virtual 40 agility in a sense. i want one <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" /> no i want 10
Hmm I'm not so sure about not using INT at all. It can be less effective yes, but I think it should play some part. That is like going in battle with 10AGI and knowing you'll hit someone regardless. I do get that it's too extreme of a change right now but the formula should equate it so that someone with 10 INT isn't piercing though like someone who has 23 INT.
You can say 'but str and agi are different stats, int should just be like str!' but spell classes require a minimum of INT, END, AGI, and WISDOM to be effective in combat, not just STR, AGI, END.
im pretty sure a character is only valid if it has the primary 3 statistics. dmg life avoidance. in the mages case wisdom isnt needed at all in that scenario they only need the same 3 stats int agi end. wisdom in a whole is only used to help versus mages.
int already pierces in 3 ways
-less fizzles
-more damage
-higher spell hit rate
its a triple standard.
imagine for a second if strength affect'd hit rate ,misses, and damage output and pvp hit rate wasnt at 40% half orcs would 2 round everything the same as mages do to them. tbh the half orc thing isnt even the worst, saurians have crap hps on top of no resists lol.
int already pierces in 3 ways
-less fizzles
-more damage
-higher spell hit rate
its a triple standard.
imagine for a second if strength affect'd hit rate ,misses, and damage output and pvp hit rate wasnt at 40% half orcs would 2 round everything the same as mages do to them. tbh the half orc thing isnt even the worst, saurians have crap hps on top of no resists lol.
im pretty sure a character is only valid if it has the primary 3 statistics. dmg life avoidance. in the mages case wisdom isnt needed at all in that scenario they only need the same 3 stats int agi end. wisdom in a whole is only used to help versus mages.
int already pierces in 3 ways
-less fizzles
-more damage
-higher spell hit rate
its a triple standard.
imagine for a second if strength affect'd hit rate ,misses, and damage output and pvp hit rate wasnt at 40% half orcs would 2 round everything the same as mages do to them. tbh the half orc thing isnt even the worst, saurians have crap hps on top of no resists lol.
Well, agree to disagree I suppose. I do agree that MR and INT need far better scaling, but disagree with a few points anyways. I'll be looking into this soon anywho.
there isnt really anything to agree or disagree on. its your choice.
it can be summed up in 1 question. "do you think spells having hit rates above and beyond any possible hit rate of melee is fair?"
i don't care either way honestly, i dont have to use a horc or saurian. its fine either way imo.
left as is its more like a 2 tier system with scaling melee efficiency dropping magical resistance. in that system saurian horc and drake are like niche builds used to hunt other weaker melee variants. basically the same as a gnome monk would be niche to make a mage worthless. it just isnt that 3 tier system that's been mentioned 40+x. instead of a 3 way balance its a 2 way balance of decent MR vs spells with a bunch of majorly flawed niche characters roaming around.
it can be summed up in 1 question. "do you think spells having hit rates above and beyond any possible hit rate of melee is fair?"
i don't care either way honestly, i dont have to use a horc or saurian. its fine either way imo.
left as is its more like a 2 tier system with scaling melee efficiency dropping magical resistance. in that system saurian horc and drake are like niche builds used to hunt other weaker melee variants. basically the same as a gnome monk would be niche to make a mage worthless. it just isnt that 3 tier system that's been mentioned 40+x. instead of a 3 way balance its a 2 way balance of decent MR vs spells with a bunch of majorly flawed niche characters roaming around.
I don't understand this mindset that you need to be a gnome ninja. Halfling bards, goblin berserkers, DE Slayers,Almost any ninja other than saurian, HO, or Drakeblood and even those stand a fair chance. These are just a few classes, not counting elders which are obviously good that wipe the floor with me on Reaper. There is always a chance I could win, but those classes I have fought and consistently kill me in 1v1.
I don't understand this mindset that you need to be a gnome ninja. Halfling bards, goblin berserkers, DE Slayers,Almost any ninja other than saurian, HO, or Drakeblood and even those stand a fair chance. These are just a few classes, not counting elders which are obviously good that wipe the floor with me on Reaper. There is always a chance I could win, but those classes I have fought and consistently kill me in 1v1.
You don't. Any race with 20 or more wisdom right now is pretty much a sure win against you.
the whole 20+ wisdom owns mages thing is a bit skewed. everyone just lumps it into a battle and goes oh my mage lost. why did they lose? taking a DE monk, for instance, resists about 55% and the gnome mage "resists" pretty much the same 55% of the melee the (23 agi vs 21) elf is tossing. alot of the time its HP and luck alone.
elf and gnome are very close to same hps, however you toss a gobby in there instead and the mage hits a few % chance more but has to hit 1-2 more times on average. that is a large difference.
currently the system leaves about half the characters balanced in a sense, the other half are situational. either heavy melee to hunt the balanced melee classes or heavy MR to hunt mages. dont get me wrong the system works and is fun it just isn't perfect.
1v1 isnt always the biggest problem. take for instance if a group of 3 melee characters jump on someone and try to pk them, if everyone is at 23 agi (seems to be the case most often) ill do ninja cuz the math is easier. each hits 2x, 6 hits doesn't even kill the person without multiple roundhouse. if 3 mages jump on anything with lower end MR its like auto-kill. if already seen dozens of group fights, mages are immensely OP in that area of the game.
also on the subject rots poison isn't being removed after death i've seen 3x now that a player gets pked hits temple then dies a second tme immediately to a poison tick lol. i thought it was hysterical at the time but with sickness timers active it might need fixed lol.
elf and gnome are very close to same hps, however you toss a gobby in there instead and the mage hits a few % chance more but has to hit 1-2 more times on average. that is a large difference.
currently the system leaves about half the characters balanced in a sense, the other half are situational. either heavy melee to hunt the balanced melee classes or heavy MR to hunt mages. dont get me wrong the system works and is fun it just isn't perfect.
1v1 isnt always the biggest problem. take for instance if a group of 3 melee characters jump on someone and try to pk them, if everyone is at 23 agi (seems to be the case most often) ill do ninja cuz the math is easier. each hits 2x, 6 hits doesn't even kill the person without multiple roundhouse. if 3 mages jump on anything with lower end MR its like auto-kill. if already seen dozens of group fights, mages are immensely OP in that area of the game.
also on the subject rots poison isn't being removed after death i've seen 3x now that a player gets pked hits temple then dies a second tme immediately to a poison tick lol. i thought it was hysterical at the time but with sickness timers active it might need fixed lol.
No or lower magic is the same thing as going into battle with no armor.would you just go running naked carrying a sword and expect to not get hurt?
If you built your char with no ability in wis then you decided to be a melee only cause almost everyone was melee. Oh my toon has 25 str and hits for xxx dammage,
Build char more suitable to fighting magic classes
After night hawk adjusts magic resis then people can complain cause oh I can kill off this person, or oh that dude is just to powerful
Personally barb need to loose having 3 flurry attacks, a ninja only gets 1 and possible 2 roundhouse if lucky, barb thereform could be overpowered?
Then again isn't that the job of a slayer to be a 1 or 2 hit your dead? It's a assassin, they are supposed to kill instantly .
If you built your char with no ability in wis then you decided to be a melee only cause almost everyone was melee. Oh my toon has 25 str and hits for xxx dammage,
Build char more suitable to fighting magic classes
After night hawk adjusts magic resis then people can complain cause oh I can kill off this person, or oh that dude is just to powerful
Personally barb need to loose having 3 flurry attacks, a ninja only gets 1 and possible 2 roundhouse if lucky, barb thereform could be overpowered?
Then again isn't that the job of a slayer to be a 1 or 2 hit your dead? It's a assassin, they are supposed to kill instantly .