← Forum archive

MR Poll

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

NiteHawk
MR is a bit over the top right now, at it's lowest, against 23 int vs HO w/ 10 wisdom you only have 13% chance to unaffect. I do agree that a HO should die in most cases, but right now they do it with such ease there is no challenge. The maximum is 75.5% which is 23int character vs 23 wisdom gnome sorc.
So the range right now is 13% to 75%. A middle ground right now lets say is a goblin with 17 wisdom, they get 48% chance.

I'm not gonna get crazy with formulas here, but in physical combat the base is 40% normally but 55% in when you are attacking a monster. It is -2/2% per agi lower/higher, and classes can have a dodge/hitrate modifier. Obviously though you also have armor on top of this, which actually works very well at negating a lot of damage actively, and some passively.

When comparing spell classes to heavy dps physical classes, spell classes do less damage as a whole (ignoring the MR right now.). It must also be noted that YOU NEED WISDOM TO HAVE MR. Simply having a class and race doesn't give you amazing MR.

There are a couple things we can do though:

1. Increase the minimum to around 30%-35%, lower the maximum to around 70%. Middle classes would probably sit around 45-55% with moderate wisdom (16-18). Adjust the class/race MR slightly to reflect.


2. Redo the formula completely and make it similar to how AGI vs AGI works. Have a base, then it would be INT vs WIS for it. For example, ignoring class/race bonuses, let us say the base is 60%. Each point difference could be lets say 3%, and you add +3 to the wisdom calculation. EXAMPLE TIME:
-Gnome Sorc 23 int vs HO 12 wisdom.... 23-(12+3)=8.. Now we multiply the point difference modifier, which would be 8*3=24%... So it is 60% MINUS 24%.. He will have a resistance of 36%.
-Gnome Sorc 23 int vs Ling 20 wisdom.... 23-(20+3)=0... 0*3=0... Resistance is 60-0)=60%
-Gnome Sorc 23 int vs Goblin 17 wisdom.... 23-(17+3)=3...3*3=9... Resistance is 60-9=51%
-Gnome Sorc 23 int vs HO 10 wisdom.... 23-(10+3)=10...10*3=30... Resistance is 60-30=30%
-Gnome Sorc 23 int vs Gnome 23 wisdom.... 23-(23+3)=-3... -3*3=9... Resistance is 60-9)=69%

What about lesser sorcs:
-Elf Sorc 21 int vs Goblin 17 wisdom.... 21-(17+3)=1...1*3=3... Resistance is 60-3=57%
-Elf Sorc 21 int vs HO 10 wisdom.... 21-(10+3)=8...8*3=24... Resistance is 60-24=36%
-Elf Sorc 21 int vs Gnome 23 wisdom.... 21-(23+3)=-5... -5*3=15... Resistance is 60-15)=75%

Something like that, but you can see how it works similar to AGI vs AGI instead. I am even thinking we can remove racial bonuses and leave class bonuses only, as the numbers here reflect pretty OK and there would be less guess work and less balance issues. I would probably add 5% more resistances for all to keep the weapon resist, which is about 5% more with a OAD staff weapon. Low wisdom races might be okay in certain situations as long as they pull some stats into wisdom.


3. Make it so Int only does damage/fizzle/duration, but has nothing to do with MR. The only thing that would reflect MR would be the class/race/wisdom. It would be a set value then.. For example:
Half Orc Knight with 10 wisdom might be 34% resistance.
Half Orc Slayer with 10 wisdom might be 30% resistance.
Gnome Sorceror with 22 wisdom might have 67% resistance.
Elf Sorc with 22 wisdom might have 65% resistance.
Gnome Sorceror with 23 wisdom might have 70% resistance.
Gnome Sorceror with 10 wisdom might have 38% resistance.

Kind of like that, purely example and was brought up. So ANY spell incoming on you only checks that. This would mean that someone with 10int would pierce through you the same as someone with 23int, BUT obviously the damage would be far lower anyways so might be OK. This way however I would keep both class/race modifiers. Weapon could still effect resistance, but only weapon itself and for a small amount. This does make elves/etc a little more viable but I'm wondering if its pushing too extreme or not.

--------


For me, I prefer to change it for sure, I like 2 the most, but 3. could work as well, but it would be different though. None of the formulas here or suggestions are set in stone, only made for examples.
Styx
Question if I have a max orc wis barb, shouldn't it be good enough to kill a sorc so I can have my ownage?
Folder
@Styx It should be good enough to have a chance, but it should be an unlikely chance. If a 14 wis orc is anywhere near likely to beat a sorc then a 20 wis DE is going to rip sorcs apart.

Sorcs are good at killing low wis, yes perhaps too good. But they are not at all good at killing high wis. Looking at these numbers when we have sorcs fighting high wis we're looking at 60-75% resist rate. That's higher than any melee miss rate will be. IMO sorcs do need to hit more simply because they hit for less with each attack.

I think upping the base resist is fine, but if we overboard with it sorcs will quickly be shelved as they simply do not put out the damge numbers a ninja/slayer/zerker does. Point is sorcs need to somewhat reliably eat low wis since they are pretty much garbage when fighting high wis. I like that aspect of them tbh, maybe others prefer them just doing moderate damage all the time but I feel the basic idea of high damage to low wis and low damage to high wis is fine.

If it turns into moderate damage on low wis and low damage on high wis then they are more buffbots than real dps. #2 is my pick out of these but I do caution against a huge change.
NiteHawk
@Styx It should be good enough to have a chance, but it should be an unlikely chance. If a 14 wis orc is anywhere near likely to beat a sorc then a 20 wis DE is going to rip sorcs apart.

Sorcs are good at killing low wis, yes perhaps too good. But they are not at all good at killing high wis. Looking at these numbers when we have sorcs fighting high wis we're looking at 60-75% resist rate. That's higher than any melee miss rate will be. IMO sorcs do need to hit more simply because they hit for less with each attack.

I think upping the base resist is fine, but if we overboard with it sorcs will quickly be shelved as they simply do not put out the damge numbers a ninja/slayer/zerker does. Point is sorcs need to somewhat reliably eat low wis since they are pretty much garbage when fighting high wis. I like that aspect of them tbh, maybe others prefer them just doing moderate damage all the time but I feel the basic idea of high damage to low wis and low damage to high wis is fine.

If it turns into moderate damage on low wis and low damage on high wis then they are more buffbots than real dps. #2 is my pick out of these but I do caution against a huge change.


Yeah. I mean max right now is about 75% as I said. but I think this can be lower and then the min be higher. 30% was just an example, it might be lower with 10 wis still. Right now the range is from 13-70% and thats WITH 23int. when you have 20 int it becomes even worse when fighting high wisdom classes by a large amount. That's why I was wondering about option 3. on that matter.

Max could be 70% or 65% with highest MR but that might be too low for 23 wis, it's really tough to say. Once we have a path I can post more details on the change and suggestions for it.
Folder
Right, 20 int sorcs need to be viable imo because people like humans and lings for them. It's fine for 23 int gnomes to be the best casters, but it can't be the only determination.

Basically just tighten up the curve a little on both ends. I really think that's all that needs doing. You obviously have a few methods of getting there but that's the reasonable goal imo.
Folder
Maybe, doesn't change my answer though <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_razz.gif" alt=":P" title="Razz" />.
Terron
i picked 3, but would prefer a variant of #2. i feel int already pierces with damage and fizzle rate only reason i picked 3 tbh. leaving int as any factor other than damage just makes it so everyone wants gnome for power elf for dodge. i agree that 20+ int should be reasonable build

in any case a mage should hit a half orc a max of around 60% and a minimum of 50% and only that often because of the enormous HP, or bring it 100% inline with agility and make horcs put in wis points or get raped. with a max of a 71% hit rate versus 10 wis (same as 24 agi ling cav vs 10 agility)mage would get the 5% with the oad staff or whatever and be at 69% hit rate( 23 int).
Terron
“we often find obstacles and burdens in our way. We may
complain out loud while we walk around them if we choose, or we can lift them and find
out what they mean. Disappointment is usually the price of laziness.” -the Wise King -The Stone in the Road

<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Reaper
Whatever option gives physical a better chance is the one going to be picked. The majority of players use physical classes, and low wis ones at that. So, no point in me even voting. I can't judge or voice opinions on something that hasn't been implemented yet. As unfair and unreasonable as it is for me to say this without even seeing how it works or what is implemented, I just feel put off from the game for some reason.

I feel like mages are going to get a big shaft. Leech heal was already nerfed to being almost worthless again. Now low wis characters are going to have decent MR more than likely, since that is what the masses want. I'm beginning to hear little birds flying around the realm talking about wanting to nerf Stoneskin next. So, after this, probably expect to see that forum post pop up. I have a Slayer, but mages are what I enjoy playing the most. It just feels like they are being overly attacked, and the one thing they do well is being altered. I'm not saying it will be bad, or that I will notice some drastic change that will make them worthless. I just feel discouraged, probably unreasonably so, but discouraged none the less. <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_confused.gif" alt=":?" title="Confused" />
Terron
almost everything is melee. in a world where there wasn't a 40% hit rate for swinging a sword it would be drastic yea. spells don't really have a hit rate cap

this change will make it easier to balance later. all 3 systems to vote on see 10 wis as getting hit 7/10 anyway. the only drastic change is mages will actually hit each other.

in actuality a melee character needs 4 stats to fight mages and mages only need 3 to fight melee. the outlook has been stated to be the reciprocal numerous times.

mages however do not need wisdom to fight melee at all. mages for the most part get xppppx and a +1/ very few melee get pppxpx with a +1.

damage for instance is easy to change because you just amend 1 formula. mr is a nightmare, have to evaluate every race of every class aswell as in generality. putting +20% mr on everything wouldnt work because it is all exponential gain. a gnome would benefit 5x over what a dark elf would and 20x what a horc would, so it would make it even worse.
TheFirstTrupain
What does MR do in this game? Does it lower magic damage received on hit or does it make it so the person unaffects more?
daedroth
What does MR do in this game? Does it lower magic damage received on hit or does it make it so the person unaffects more?


As far as im aware the higher the wisdom the less damage from magic and more chance of unaffects (no damage/effect taken).
Styx
It is pointless to vote and won't, a lot would want change cause they have the max str melee fighter with 10 wis and expecting to kill a chanter.

Would you go into battle naked as a Jay bird, swinging your weapon of choice, and expect to not die?

Magic is not a sword, who here can stop a ball of fire, lighting, etc

Don't worry NH it's a never ending battle until one certain group gets to be overpowered
NiteHawk
It is pointless to vote and won't, a lot would want change cause they have the max str melee fighter with 10 wis and expecting to kill a chanter.

Would you go into battle naked as a Jay bird, swinging your weapon of choice, and expect to not die?

Magic is not a sword, who here can stop a ball of fire, lighting, etc

Don't worry NH it's a never ending battle until one certain group gets to be overpowered


This is not just about MR on lower wisdom, its about higher wisdom. On top of that no matter what a HO is going to struggle against a mage user, No matter what 10 wisdom is 10 wisdom, you'll lack hard on MR. But you wouldn't expect a ling to dodge 95% of the time either. That would be goofy right? I understand wisdom should be more severe than agility, I fully agree here because magic is different then agi/str, and people want to make it very similar, which I disagree with, I know they work differently, I know armor reduces damage alot via passive and especially actively, MR doesn't do it the same way. Magic damage is also lower in general, blahblah etc. Alot of factors that make it different gameplay, and it should be, and will continue to be.

But if AGI is lets say 40% base, and dips between 30% to 50%, then MR could start off at 20 or 25 and go up to 65-70% or so. Depends on what we go with and how it will all play out. But I think magic needs to hit more in general, yes.
Styx
I shall go with what NH thinks works best, then after changes do test dummies ,,, always volunteers ready to die,,, lol

From results test data and formulas etc

ON A SIDE NOTE

Due to the volatile nature of magic, everyone says it's so op, why haven't you suggested reflect ?

Certain class or race or whatever could get reflect dammage of magic or physical with percent of reflect, yes you are hit for x dammage , you reflect x dammage back, that's how to beat a magic user don't ya all know

But this could be broken down into physical also

OR a silence spell, user can't cast maguc..wouldn't that stink as a sorc or cleric lol, and yes you would want the silencer in your group to kill priest first, wouldnt know which to take, if they do and i dont, then should u take this or that but what uf they di thus so, its a 3Rd option, such evil carnage to change the whole mosh exp hehe

Wouldn't it stink being silent with 10 str armed with a stick <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />

OR assy has a oad where the grandmaster gives the volatile 1 time use poison or paralysis poison, ,, it's a oad lol,,, so an assy will kill without mercy

So many fun things that can be thought of muwhaha let the true Kaos begin
JadeFalcon
Damn progressives always wanting to change things. Leave it as it is!

(This has nothing to with the fact that

a) I am leveling a sorc and want to fry you all
b) Find this entire system bonkers. If I cast a fire ball at you, you either get it, or not. Which is a function of your AGI. If I strike a hit, if you have a good armor (AC) you wont fry. If you are wearing clothes (low AC) you fry.
In other words, this shouldnt be different than any other form of combat.

My own base damage should be a function of how intelligent. After all, since I am a genius I will cast a giant fireball.
Fizzle should be (if not already) a function of my wisdom. As I am very wise, i never f*** it up.