MR Poll
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
seems like youre setting yourself up for a lot of work lol... Just increasing MR a hair in the same way as you did with the end stat IE lower wis gets a bigger boost than higher wis, but not a lot of course, seems like it would have worked out nicely. But nobody else agrees <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" /> o well
pimpin' ain't easy
We are at a stalemate.
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
yeah looks like people don't want int to be the triple whammy and they want a balanced spell hits vs wisdom. option #3 does kinda read as a separate issue altogethor. but i like the overall concept.
I chose 3. sounds good I spent a lot of time reading the whole post
I actually prefer hitters, but if this will nerf mages then... that will not be good. From what NH says it is actually going to benefit mages vs high WIS/MR enemies. Which might also be unbalancing if taken too far. However if the changes are merely made for the people whining that their low WIS alts are getting stomped by mages... then yeh... might just be better to remove mages from the game <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif" alt=":D" title="Very Happy" />. I am not voting, I will wait and see what the changes bring. Fairly sure if it becomes unbalanced it can be changed again.
i dont think anyone cares their lizard gets raped by magic. for me its the hit rate. they cast spells at you and miss 2x a week? and no matter how high your agility is you can barely land more than 2 hits per round even fighting elementals. it doesn't have to be so drastic getting hit 6-7x out of 10 stamina is the same end result. fried lizard. ofcourse we could ignore all this and give mages a flat 10 agility when concentrating to cast spells, then itll just be a slugfest.
i see the general thought is people just want their lizard to survive, but looking at the choices chosen on the poll. it looks like a cover-up complaint people are using to keep their high int mages in power.
i see the general thought is people just want their lizard to survive, but looking at the choices chosen on the poll. it looks like a cover-up complaint people are using to keep their high int mages in power.
It should be balanced to where very high wis characters can beat a mage the majority of the time. This way people have reason to lings and humans.
Those lings and humans should lose to orcs and lizards most of the time.
And orcs and lizards should lose to mages the majority of the time, but beat all others most of the time. IMO.
Those lings and humans should lose to orcs and lizards most of the time.
And orcs and lizards should lose to mages the majority of the time, but beat all others most of the time. IMO.
It should be balanced to where very high wis characters can beat a mage the majority of the time. This way people have reason to lings and humans.
Those lings and humans should lose to orcs and lizards most of the time.
And orcs and lizards should lose to mages the majority of the time, but beat all others most of the time. IMO.
Agreed.
Option 3 is 2 points ahead, must see if another stalemate.
I'm waiting to vote so it can be stalemate again, where's the fillabuster muwhah
Edit, int should be set at 22 int since agi and str was set at not plus one if I remember.and post said 23 int
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
I'm waiting to vote so it can be stalemate again, where's the fillabuster muwhah
Edit, int should be set at 22 int since agi and str was set at not plus one if I remember.and post said 23 int
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Nail biting stuff for sure!
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
<img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/popcorn.gif" alt=":popcorn:" title=" " />
Right, 20 int sorcs need to be viable imo because people like humans and lings for them. It's fine for 23 int gnomes to be the best casters, but it can't be the only determination.
Basically just tighten up the curve a little on both ends. I really think that's all that needs doing. You obviously have a few methods of getting there but that's the reasonable goal imo.
I think id go with this. Currently if you are a sorc you might destory low wis characters (under 14) but you stand no chance against anything over say 17 wis characters.
id say might just keep it simple and slightly adjust the current formula a few percent each way. You might stand a better chance with 14 wis. you might not alway beat a sorc with 17 wis. I dont really thing its too far off.
It should be balanced to where very high wis characters can beat a mage the majority of the time. This way people have reason to lings and humans.
Those lings and humans should lose to orcs and lizards most of the time.
And orcs and lizards should lose to mages the majority of the time, but beat all others most of the time. IMO.
Agreed.
I agree with this also! of course elves and gnomes should be badass. but those lower int mages shouldn't be just as powerful.
I agree with you Muja, thats how I picture it.
If in event of stalemate no determination can be made, fillabuster the congress, stop the change . Power to non voting lol
I think I might vote # 1, because I feel kind of sorry for it.
Can we do a write in vote for no change?
I'd rather see it work like agility does, and I don't see why it didn't in the first place. A straight check between caster INT and defender WIS seems effective.
If int wis works like agi then fizzle rates have to be taken into account. Melee attacks never fail they just miss, meanwhile magic can fail to cast and also be unaffected.
If int wis works like agi then fizzle rates have to be taken into account. Melee attacks never fail they just miss, meanwhile magic can fail to cast and also be unaffected.
Fully agree with this too. It is another reason why damage pierces better. However, because its a 50/50 here I might actually try option 3 and if it sucks go to option 2.