← Forum archive

Stamina Max

An archived conversation. New replies are closed.

Zeroun
So what do you guys think about raising the stamina counter since we are only limiting ourselves to one character currently? I think if we are downsizing from 3 to 1 then what about raising max stam to like 5 or 6? I know more balancing issues come in because of backstabs, but what do you guys generally think about this?
Rodeo
Tbh 4 attacks is good regardless of how many chars you can run. Think that's the reason chris gave assassin's more backstab power when using two weapons instead of an extra stam. Cause more melee dependant classes like knights barbs rangers and possibly bards would benifit from extra stam since they don't have the BOOM skill that could be used to round or nearly round someone. Which I dont know how barbs rage come into play but if anything 2 out of those 3 classes could use more stam. Assassin's barbs monks and druids are fine.
NiteHawk
The way I see it is that if people need more damage, then we should add it to the four attacks.

It would be a bit of a pain if people had to constantly tab up and attack 6-10 times because we increased the stamina rather then just simply increasing the damage to balance it out 8) It would also be troublesome to balance skills too as Rodeo said.
thirdchris
I don't know if we're talking about the same thing, but when I saw stamina points, I assumed that's what melee skills would deduct instead of MP. Personally I think it makes more sense for /hide to consume stamina as opposed to it consuming an actual attack. I'd also remove the restriction of having to re-enter a room, 'cause it just never really made sense. Unless you combine that with autosneak so that you're forcing the assassin to exhaust themselves.
Lateralus
Honestly the stamina system for drink? Is a little confusing. Most games it's used differently (it's either attacks or skill points or magic points or whatever) so I wouldn't mind seeing it hidden since it's just for water? Also it doesn't make sense to just have thirst and not hunger although I wouldn't have a prob seeing both of them go away. I do like the RP feature they bring to the game but I'm not sure if it outweighs the annoyance (go back and forth on it)

At the very least I say get rid of the bar on the interface I like how it was hidden in Rok in reality you never know when you are going to get hungry or thirsty anyways.
NiteHawk
Honestly the stamina system for drink? Is a little confusing. Most games it's used differently (it's either attacks or skill points or magic points or whatever) so I wouldn't mind seeing it hidden since it's just for water? Also it doesn't make sense to just have thirst and not hunger although I wouldn't have a prob seeing both of them go away. I do like the RP feature they bring to the game but I'm not sure if it outweighs the annoyance (go back and forth on it)

At the very least I say get rid of the bar on the interface I like how it was hidden in Rok in reality you never know when you are going to get hungry or thirsty anyways.


It's not really stamina, not sure what to call it. If anything can swap the attack bar for the stamina bar around so that the big bar is the attack bar instead. But I prefer having it there visible wise somehow.

Parched.. Is just a random message. I combine food/water into one hunger bar, I just don't know what message to write right now. I didn't want to get overly complex and have two needs, one combine works fine.
Lateralus
Maybe something like nourishment? Idk it's hard to not have two in my mind I mean you are going for an RP aspect by including it but only having 1 kind of negates the RP factor (I have to eat but not drink? I have to drink but not eat?)

I guess you could have the message say you are lacking nourishment? And make all things meals? So everything includes food and drink?

If you are just wanting it for the RP aspect of having to eat and drink I think I'd rather see it work like a heal Hp and mp quickly overtime type thing while out of combat. It would actually be pretty helpful since we are going the solo character route. (I think this covers the RP aspect and is also helpful to the character rather than something that can be harmful if forgotten)

If you want the whole hunger thing so the player has one more thing to remember to do/bring in their bags or they pay a penalty I think you might as well go all in an make it both since RP wise it only makes sense to have both in my mind.

Just kinda thinking out loud take what you will from it.
NiteHawk
Maybe something like nourishment? Idk it's hard to not have two in my mind I mean you are going for an RP aspect by including it but only having 1 kind of negates the RP factor (I have to eat but not drink? I have to drink but not eat?)

I guess you could have the message say you are lacking nourishment? And make all things meals? So everything includes food and drink?

If you are just wanting it for the RP aspect of having to eat and drink I think I'd rather see it work like a heal Hp and mp quickly overtime type thing while out of combat. It would actually be pretty helpful since we are going the solo character route. (I think this covers the RP aspect and is also helpful to the character rather than something that can be harmful if forgotten)

If you want the whole hunger thing so the player has one more thing to remember to do/bring in their bags or they pay a penalty I think you might as well go all in an make it both since RP wise it only makes sense to have both in my mind.

Just kinda thinking out loud take what you will from it.


Healing HP/MP a bit quicker might be a cool idea. I'm still not sure about having both. What does everyone think on that?
Rodeo
I just don't wanna die of hunger and thirst like in nightmist where you can lose ALOT of exp at high levels. The heal hp/mp aspect out of combat seems like a good idea kill a few minstead be at 3/4 hp eat a meal and rest and gain it back. I like it.
Lateralus

Healing HP/MP a bit quicker might be a cool idea. I'm still not sure about having both. What does everyone think on that?



So I can break this off into a diff post but a lot of games use this system and it seems very helpful especially considering not everyone with have an alt healer with them.

So when out of combat you could eat food (which would restore hp) or drink (which would restore sp) quicker per tick for say 1 minute. (any damage, attacking or movement by the character stops the restore and its over).

How it works is it usually just ups your restore rate so if you ate bread it might be 20 restore per tick for 1 minute. So currently i believe you restore 1 per 5 seconds ( 12hp per min) if you ate the bread you would restore 240 over the 1min. So you could get back to leveling and what not quicker basically like a more powerful heal over time potion that can only be used out of combat (almost might have a 5-10 sec start time so you cant just do it right after combat). Drinks would work just the same but for magic recovery. keep in mind the values could be tossed around but its the general idea. You could also have meal type things that could heal both. it really nails the rp aspect of having to eat and drink as well. The cool thing is we have tons and tons of food icons in the folder so it would work nicely.
NiteHawk
I already have incremental (tick based) items that can do that, only bar is to have it stop if you do an action. Depends on how people would feel about it anyways.. It's quite a huge change.
thirdchris
Seems like you might be taking away one of the advantages of being a half-orc if you do increased regeneration. I mean, would anybody really miss it all together if there was no hunger or thirst? Seems kind of like an outdated mechanic that served no real purpose. NH ended up making a bot that automatically nourished everybody who idled in the tavern. If that doesn't indicate it's something the game could do without, I don't know what is.
Lateralus
Seems like you might be taking away one of the advantages of being a half-orc if you do increased regeneration. I mean, would anybody really miss it all together if there was no hunger or thirst? Seems kind of like an outdated mechanic that served no real purpose. NH ended up making a bot that automatically nourished everybody who idled in the tavern. If that doesn't indicate it's something the game could do without, I don't know what is.



Idk while not eating they are still regenerating faster than other races so they will still have an advantage in pvp for sure plus you wont have to eat as much since you are always regening faster.
Rodeo
Well during events and pvp hunger and thirst could mess you up on a slayer or any skill that required you to hit multiple times I a row without doing an action.