Drop Stealing
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
Well 15 seconds is a long time but I kinda like that idea.
Some cool ideas here and I mostly like them, but remember if -everyone- is special then -no one- is special. The playing field is not supposed to be 100% flat, else the game will become boring.
imho i dont think a multiple crafting-item drop idea levels out the playing field 100% in any way.... those who work harder will likely still get more benefits/drops and achieve getting the weapons/gear etc much earlier and in greater numbers etc... the aim is basically to give more ppl a sense of 'fulfilment' and 'accomplishment' so they keep on playing rather than quitting (which is especially important while EO still has the goodwill carried over from ROK nostalgia and is trying to attract new players to stick around)... plus what use is being "special" anyway if almost everyone else has left the game (for whatever reasons of frustration/unfulfilment) and there is no one left to be awestruck by your great "specialness" (or by all the hard work NH and others have put into making the game for that matter)?... a more diversified benefit makes for healthy rivalries... and healthy rivalries maximise entertainment/enjoyment for all involved (this logic works in sport, and i reckon it should work similarly in MUDs)... shrug
And now, for something completely different.
Two rules:
- After the Crimson Dragon dies, the square in it is "locked" for 30 or more seconds. No one can enter it, or leave it.
- The Crimson item ALWAYS drops from inventory
Meaning that if someone did drop steal, he would still have to fight the other people on the square to get out.
This should be easy for NH to implement.
For example, in the situation of 10 Defiance and 1 Silh fighting the Dragon:
- Defiance makes lots of damage, but either the Silh guy gets the KS, or outright dropsteals the item
- The 10 Defiance now have the option to murder the Silh guy. The Silh guy cannot flee. He also cannot get help. If he D/C, he will still.
I think this is a very simple mechanic that stops:
- "unfair" dropstealing by someone that just macro's stuff and runs away
- "lucky" shots, where you arrive and take the last shot, and think stuff is yours: Well, if you are alone, it is. If you aren't.. have a "discussion" with the rest of the folks with you, at the square
I honestly think this is a great idea TBH.
And now, for something completely different.
Two rules:
- After the Crimson Dragon dies, the square in it is "locked" for 30 or more seconds. No one can enter it, or leave it.
- The Crimson item ALWAYS drops from inventory
Meaning that if someone did drop steal, he would still have to fight the other people on the square to get out.
This should be easy for NH to implement.
For example, in the situation of 10 Defiance and 1 Silh fighting the Dragon:
- Defiance makes lots of damage, but either the Silh guy gets the KS, or outright dropsteals the item
- The 10 Defiance now have the option to murder the Silh guy. The Silh guy cannot flee. He also cannot get help. If he D/C, he will still die.
I think this is a very simple mechanic that stops:
- "unfair" dropstealing by someone that just macro's stuff and runs away
- "lucky" shots, where you arrive and take the last shot, and think stuff is yours: Well, if you are alone, it is. If you aren't.. have a "discussion" with the rest of the folks with you, at the square
Edit: "he will still die"
I like this.
Well 15 seconds is a long time but I kinda like that idea.
Some cool ideas here and I mostly like them, but remember if -everyone- is special then -no one- is special. The playing field is not supposed to be 100% flat, else the game will become boring.
imho i dont think a multiple crafting-item drop idea levels out the playing field 100% in any way.... those who work harder will likely still get more benefits/drops and achieve getting the weapons/gear etc much earlier and in greater numbers etc... the aim is basically to give more ppl a sense of 'fulfilment' and 'accomplishment' so they keep on playing rather than quitting (which is especially important while EO still has the goodwill carried over from ROK nostalgia and is trying to attract new players to stick around)... plus what use is being "special" anyway if almost everyone else has left the game (for whatever reasons of frustration/unfulfilment) and there is no one left to be awestruck by your great "specialness" (or by all the hard work NH and others have put into making the game for that matter)?... a more diversified benefit makes for healthy rivalries... and healthy rivalries maximise entertainment/enjoyment for all involved (this logic works in sport, and i reckon it should work similarly in MUDs)... shrug
Everything in moderation friend. My warning is about changing too much and getting to the point where everyone gets participation medals. That doesn't keep people playing much the same way as constant frustration doesn't.
I agree the square locking could make it fun and does make support classes important.
And now, for something completely different.
Two rules:
- After the Crimson Dragon dies, the square in it is "locked" for 30 or more seconds. No one can enter it, or leave it.
- The Crimson item ALWAYS drops from inventory
Meaning that if someone did drop steal, he would still have to fight the other people on the square to get out.
This should be easy for NH to implement.
For example, in the situation of 10 Defiance and 1 Silh fighting the Dragon:
- Defiance makes lots of damage, but either the Silh guy gets the KS, or outright dropsteals the item
- The 10 Defiance now have the option to murder the Silh guy. The Silh guy cannot flee. He also cannot get help. If he D/C, he will still die.
I think this is a very simple mechanic that stops:
- "unfair" dropstealing by someone that just macro's stuff and runs away
- "lucky" shots, where you arrive and take the last shot, and think stuff is yours: Well, if you are alone, it is. If you aren't.. have a "discussion" with the rest of the folks with you, at the square
Edit: "he will still die"
I like this.
I second dis.
And now, for something completely different.
Two rules:
- After the Crimson Dragon dies, the square in it is "locked" for 30 or more seconds. No one can enter it, or leave it.
- The Crimson item ALWAYS drops from inventory
Meaning that if someone did drop steal, he would still have to fight the other people on the square to get out.
This should be easy for NH to implement.
For example, in the situation of 10 Defiance and 1 Silh fighting the Dragon:
- Defiance makes lots of damage, but either the Silh guy gets the KS, or outright dropsteals the item
- The 10 Defiance now have the option to murder the Silh guy. The Silh guy cannot flee. He also cannot get help. If he D/C, he will still die.
I think this is a very simple mechanic that stops:
- "unfair" dropstealing by someone that just macro's stuff and runs away
- "lucky" shots, where you arrive and take the last shot, and think stuff is yours: Well, if you are alone, it is. If you aren't.. have a "discussion" with the rest of the folks with you, at the square
Edit: "he will still die"
I like this.
I second dis.
I think this suggestion has the appearance of being a solution, but is actually counterproductive in the long run because it doesnt solve the root problem (ie that there is only a single benefit/drop that cant be shared out amongst many). Sure it helps people fight it out for that one item and potentially then the more 'deserving' player or guild may eventually get the item... but then the remaining people who participated but didnt get the item dont feel fulfilled at all (eg winning team gets 100% benefit, losing team/teams get 0% benefit)... eventually if you cant win and keep getting 0% benefit then this would still lead to people discouragement-quitting or rage-quitting and pretty soon you have a one guild game (which is totally intimidating to newbies and therefore not really going to grow)... and pretty soon it is a stagnant playerbase with no competition (ie a dead game or at least one heading there quickly)
Basically i dont think its in anyone's interests to see it head there. You need at least some competition from non-dominating guilds/players to keep things interesting (eg its important to keep at least the Def/Sihlo rivalry and encourage more 3rd/4th party guilds to enter into competitiveness).... otherwise say if all the Def players and/or players from other guilds get discouraged and quit... then newbies (or others who trickle back to check out EO due to RoK nostalgia) will quickly realize that the majority of the community are inactive lvl 25s who have come and gone before them and also realize that /gtop pretty much shows like 1 active guild with all the players in it... would that motivate you to start playing? perhaps some might... but most have changed circumstances from Rok 10-15yrs ago now... old Rok players may try EO for nostalgia sake but they also probably now have restricted time investment due to having families, jobs, many alternative forms of entertainment that provide easier gratification etc .. and as for new players ... well GMUDs arent the 'cutting edge' of gaming like they were when Rok first came out... without nostalgia to carry them, if they dont find some kind of fulfilment/competitiveness early on in their experience then they are never going to bother staying around to grind to 25 and enjoy the fullness of the game... In short it would be a sad and boring end if the game became too uncompetitive that people stop playing (kinda like watching a professional team having no opponent to compete with in a sporting match and then playing against any amateurs and children they can find - i mean who seriously wants that?)
I'm not asking for a level playing field. I am saying EO needs a more level playing field and a system (for worldbosses and even other content) that supports that --> because i think EO's greatest need right now isnt new content or whatnot... its retaining/attracting/motivating players to keep playing! Otherwise once the playing field gets too uncompetitive (which leads to inevitable discouragement-quitting from existing players or <lvl25 newbies)... it will be very hard to undo. There's probably no way to lure back a newbie who has tried it, had an unfulfilling experience and decided to move on. And the only way to potentially lure older players back then would be a long advertised character/server wipe to re-level the playing field... and dont think existing active players really want to see that either.
This is why a single item drop/benefit (no matter how you might try to force people to fight for who gets it so that the 'most deserving' person/guild does) is still much less favorable for the game as a whole (especially for a game hoping to attract and expand, rather than becoming a single-guild-dominated glorified chat room)
I feel like, as in every online game ever, there will always be a group of people trying harder than others. They will be online more, they will do more, they will have more. It's part of the experience imo.
I totally get all of what you're saying and I agree with most of it, especially the bit about needing NEW content. Fix the existing content, there's plenty to do right now but most of it is very unfriendly to anything but the most active players.
IMO there could perhaps be some kind of system that combines the ideas here. I very much like the idea of a "locked" square where people have to fight it out. It doesn't really make any sense lore-wise, unless uhh I guess you make up some bullshit about the Dragon circling the area with fire in its death throes. But gameplay wise it could certainly be interesting.
I also like the idea of a system with multiple drops so that more people can get rewards. I don't think that a solo player should really have much of a chance at obtaining the ultimate reward as this entire game is based around grouping, but I can certainly understand the desire to feel like you can gain something out of being solo or in a smaller group.
Going along with that bit about smaller groups, the game NEEDS OaDs that can be done without requiring 6 people to budget an hour of their time. Most OaDs do not get run every day because they flat out require 6 people and take upwards of an hour. Having more options for smaller groups/guilds would, I think, help people feel like they have more to do.
I totally get all of what you're saying and I agree with most of it, especially the bit about needing NEW content. Fix the existing content, there's plenty to do right now but most of it is very unfriendly to anything but the most active players.
IMO there could perhaps be some kind of system that combines the ideas here. I very much like the idea of a "locked" square where people have to fight it out. It doesn't really make any sense lore-wise, unless uhh I guess you make up some bullshit about the Dragon circling the area with fire in its death throes. But gameplay wise it could certainly be interesting.
I also like the idea of a system with multiple drops so that more people can get rewards. I don't think that a solo player should really have much of a chance at obtaining the ultimate reward as this entire game is based around grouping, but I can certainly understand the desire to feel like you can gain something out of being solo or in a smaller group.
Going along with that bit about smaller groups, the game NEEDS OaDs that can be done without requiring 6 people to budget an hour of their time. Most OaDs do not get run every day because they flat out require 6 people and take upwards of an hour. Having more options for smaller groups/guilds would, I think, help people feel like they have more to do.
I feel like, as in every online game ever, there will always be a group of people trying harder than others. They will be online more, they will do more, they will have more. It's part of the experience imo.
I totally get all of what you're saying and I agree with most of it, especially the bit about needing NEW content. Fix the existing content, there's plenty to do right now but most of it is very unfriendly to anything but the most active players.
IMO there could perhaps be some kind of system that combines the ideas here. I very much like the idea of a "locked" square where people have to fight it out. It doesn't really make any sense lore-wise, unless uhh I guess you make up some bullshit about the Dragon circling the area with fire in its death throes. But gameplay wise it could certainly be interesting.
I also like the idea of a system with multiple drops so that more people can get rewards. I don't think that a solo player should really have much of a chance at obtaining the ultimate reward as this entire game is based around grouping, but I can certainly understand the desire to feel like you can gain something out of being solo or in a smaller group.
Going along with that bit about smaller groups, the game NEEDS OaDs that can be done without requiring 6 people to budget an hour of their time. Most OaDs do not get run every day because they flat out require 6 people and take upwards of an hour. Having more options for smaller groups/guilds would, I think, help people feel like they have more to do.
Can agree with most of this --> especially recognizing the desire that solo/smaller group people have to gain something on worldbosses + tailoring current content to the time-poor culture of current games. Basically the system has to be such that it doesnt remove reward from the most active players, but also shares some reward with other also hard working players so they will keep playing. Crafting item drops do that imho. It may mean it takes longer to get the awesome questie sword this way... but what use is the questie sword if there's no rivals left to hit with it at the end of the day.
I look fwd to seeing what NH hopefully does with all this feedback <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
I feel like, as in every online game ever, there will always be a group of people trying harder than others. They will be online more, they will do more, they will have more. It's part of the experience imo.
I totally get all of what you're saying and I agree with most of it, especially the bit about needing NEW content. Fix the existing content, there's plenty to do right now but most of it is very unfriendly to anything but the most active players.
IMO there could perhaps be some kind of system that combines the ideas here. I very much like the idea of a "locked" square where people have to fight it out. It doesn't really make any sense lore-wise, unless uhh I guess you make up some bullshit about the Dragon circling the area with fire in its death throes. But gameplay wise it could certainly be interesting.
I also like the idea of a system with multiple drops so that more people can get rewards. I don't think that a solo player should really have much of a chance at obtaining the ultimate reward as this entire game is based around grouping, but I can certainly understand the desire to feel like you can gain something out of being solo or in a smaller group.
Going along with that bit about smaller groups, the game NEEDS OaDs that can be done without requiring 6 people to budget an hour of their time. Most OaDs do not get run every day because they flat out require 6 people and take upwards of an hour. Having more options for smaller groups/guilds would, I think, help people feel like they have more to do.
Can agree with most of this --> especially recognizing the desire that solo/smaller group people have to gain something on worldbosses + tailoring current content to the time-poor culture of current games. Basically the system has to be such that it doesnt remove reward from the most active players, but also shares some reward with other also hard working players so they will keep playing. Crafting item drops do that imho. It may mean it takes longer to get the awesome questie sword this way... but what use is the questie sword if there's no rivals left to hit with it at the end of the day.
I look fwd to seeing what NH hopefully does with all this feedback <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_smile.gif" alt=":)" title="Smile" />
Sorry for the big block quote, but I want to touch on this idea. Crafting nice items is definitely what would solve this. I'm not saying each mob drops crafting materials (I'll need 4 more vaults if this is the case), but certain mobs could drop essential items that could be combined in crafting. Some of these drops can be very rare and would give the economy a boost in trading as well. Builders would need to implement some challenging areas meant for two or three person parties to get OaD Crafting Materials (essential component of the craft). That way you could solo grind the basic crafting item, then run the Crafting Material OaD for a chance at finishing off the "Crafted OaD" item. The rarity of the drops, the materials required, and the challenge of these OaD Crafting Material areas is completely tweak-able allowing for just the right amount of challenge and RNG luck. It would be a lot harder than putting a team together and clearing a OaD, it may (may not) require several days of farming (may RNGesus's favor shine upon you) for a certain material.
I just don't know how hard it would be to implement and I know NH has a ton to do already, so I totally understand if this is something that takes a backseat for a while. I do feel like we swayed slightly from a Drop Steal conversation into... something else, though.
And now, for something completely different.
Two rules:
- After the Crimson Dragon dies, the square in it is "locked" for 30 or more seconds. No one can enter it, or leave it.
- The Crimson item ALWAYS drops from inventory
Meaning that if someone did drop steal, he would still have to fight the other people on the square to get out.
This should be easy for NH to implement.
For example, in the situation of 10 Defiance and 1 Silh fighting the Dragon:
- Defiance makes lots of damage, but either the Silh guy gets the KS, or outright dropsteals the item
- The 10 Defiance now have the option to murder the Silh guy. The Silh guy cannot flee. He also cannot get help. If he D/C, he will still die.
I think this is a very simple mechanic that stops:
- "unfair" dropstealing by someone that just macro's stuff and runs away
- "lucky" shots, where you arrive and take the last shot, and think stuff is yours: Well, if you are alone, it is. If you aren't.. have a "discussion" with the rest of the folks with you, at the square
Edit: "he will still die"
I like this too.
Also if crafting did come about you would defnietly need some kind of container exclusively for crafting items. Could make it a buyable and that you could still store crafting stuff in your vault until you bought it.
Crafting could easily be done via our auto quest system we have now examples are shard necklace and the new ring quest. You wouldn't need a container or anything special since the actual quest giver keeps up with whatever you give him. That seems simple enough.
When you finish the quest you get to choose from X amount of items.
When you finish the quest you get to choose from X amount of items.
Crafting could easily be done via our auto quest system we have now examples are shard necklace and the new ring quest. You wouldn't need a container or anything special since the actual quest giver keeps up with whatever you give him. That seems simple enough.
When you finish the quest you get to choose from X amount of items.
Didn't think about that, but yes, I like.
To clarify, this doesn't REPLACE things like the Crimson Dragon, it doesn't put a stop to Drop Stealing, it gives a new way to reward hard-working players who don't have the time or ability to party with lots of people due to any number of reasons.
It is definitely curved away from a Drop Stealing conversation.
I like the way this thread has evolved. Proud of you guys.
Crafting doesn't need the AQ system. I mean, we already do crafting with scripts, it's the same thing, just change blank scrolls with scales, and the actual scroll created with an item created.
I disagree with 'Dragon Scales' as a general thing. Crimson Dragon should drop Crimson Scales. All the weapons do something differently. Dragon Scales however COULD be a general drop that is needed for all the items and all dragons drop it, and then crimson scales could be the additional add but I don't really think that's needed. I'd rather just have more crimson scales drop for grabbing.
I don't know how I feel about the locking room. I 'can' do this, but is it the best option? You shift the drop stealing from a thief who was sitting there now to who the largest guild is in the room currently. I think it's better BUT I again see issues with it. Yes Folder, there is always going to be a big clan in all situations but we don't need to cator to them if we can avoid it. They already get bonuses by being large in events and other things.
IF we do go the locking root, part of me feels that locking the room completely is a bad lore idea. Instead, the item should bind the player to the ground for 30 seconds, lets say as he/she works on picking it up and it's heavy or that a special force surrounds them as they get it. I don't really know, but it would be that only the player getting the item is bound. They can still fight/heal though. I only wanna prevent movement, not full para.
This means that you'd actively have to hold the item for 30 seconds to obtain it. So if someone drops it, another has to attempt to pick it up and deal with the 30 second bind. Obviously when you are binded, party moving won't work. This ain't ROK right. The negative with this however is if you drop it and pick it up elsewhere it will bind you for 30 seconds as its a general script and I can't really do flags on items like that. However, I can ensure that if you drop it in a safe area like a city that isn't imposed. I don't see people dropping the scales on the floor anyways, that would probably be stupid.
So to sum up what I'm thinking via what everyone has been talking about for a mix/match system.
World Walker/World Walker Drop Changes
1. Scales would drop instead, more then one. Makes a market.
2. Picking up a scale in a unsafe area will bind you to the room for 30 seconds.
3. Multiple scales are needed to make an item.
4. Instead of having a boss that takes 2 months to kill, it can be more like 1-2 weeks. Because we use scales now, it could take a 2-4 crimson kills to actually make one item. AKA we can balance the items via its HP and amount of scales needed. Obviously these items should be tougher to obtain so we need a time to earn one item. I think it needs to be high as these items are generally 'radiant oads with teeth'. We don't need to reduce the time though, but people might attack it more and it might become more competitive if they see the HP dropping more often then not. What is a good time?
I think we can avoid the weird names and keep them general if we have the bind in a room for 30 seconds bit.
Here is a drop stealing mechanic for general items I want to do, how would people feel about this:
Right now to get an item it unhides you. This is a step in the right direction but maybe we need to be more harsh. How about you should have to unhide first to get an item, which would mean you are doing two actions, which is a delay. Is that a good idea on top to help with drop stealing in general (because obviously in other areas we won't do this dragon scale thing everywhere, would be annoying.)
I think this also makes it so a player cannot spam, they have to TIME their drop steal for when its about to die. They cannot simply unhide randomly so they cannot just spam a get key. It is actually a simple solution to the current mechanic. Obviously you can unhide by talking, but also I will make a simple /unhide command. I feel like this way it is at LEAST on pair with someone killing it. As they have two actions as well and often will not be spamming the get key, though if someone unhidden is, it's to their benefit as they are UNHIDDEN anyways and everyone is aware that they are there.
I disagree with 'Dragon Scales' as a general thing. Crimson Dragon should drop Crimson Scales. All the weapons do something differently. Dragon Scales however COULD be a general drop that is needed for all the items and all dragons drop it, and then crimson scales could be the additional add but I don't really think that's needed. I'd rather just have more crimson scales drop for grabbing.
I don't know how I feel about the locking room. I 'can' do this, but is it the best option? You shift the drop stealing from a thief who was sitting there now to who the largest guild is in the room currently. I think it's better BUT I again see issues with it. Yes Folder, there is always going to be a big clan in all situations but we don't need to cator to them if we can avoid it. They already get bonuses by being large in events and other things.
IF we do go the locking root, part of me feels that locking the room completely is a bad lore idea. Instead, the item should bind the player to the ground for 30 seconds, lets say as he/she works on picking it up and it's heavy or that a special force surrounds them as they get it. I don't really know, but it would be that only the player getting the item is bound. They can still fight/heal though. I only wanna prevent movement, not full para.
This means that you'd actively have to hold the item for 30 seconds to obtain it. So if someone drops it, another has to attempt to pick it up and deal with the 30 second bind. Obviously when you are binded, party moving won't work. This ain't ROK right. The negative with this however is if you drop it and pick it up elsewhere it will bind you for 30 seconds as its a general script and I can't really do flags on items like that. However, I can ensure that if you drop it in a safe area like a city that isn't imposed. I don't see people dropping the scales on the floor anyways, that would probably be stupid.
So to sum up what I'm thinking via what everyone has been talking about for a mix/match system.
World Walker/World Walker Drop Changes
1. Scales would drop instead, more then one. Makes a market.
2. Picking up a scale in a unsafe area will bind you to the room for 30 seconds.
3. Multiple scales are needed to make an item.
4. Instead of having a boss that takes 2 months to kill, it can be more like 1-2 weeks. Because we use scales now, it could take a 2-4 crimson kills to actually make one item. AKA we can balance the items via its HP and amount of scales needed. Obviously these items should be tougher to obtain so we need a time to earn one item. I think it needs to be high as these items are generally 'radiant oads with teeth'. We don't need to reduce the time though, but people might attack it more and it might become more competitive if they see the HP dropping more often then not. What is a good time?
I think we can avoid the weird names and keep them general if we have the bind in a room for 30 seconds bit.
Here is a drop stealing mechanic for general items I want to do, how would people feel about this:
Right now to get an item it unhides you. This is a step in the right direction but maybe we need to be more harsh. How about you should have to unhide first to get an item, which would mean you are doing two actions, which is a delay. Is that a good idea on top to help with drop stealing in general (because obviously in other areas we won't do this dragon scale thing everywhere, would be annoying.)
I think this also makes it so a player cannot spam, they have to TIME their drop steal for when its about to die. They cannot simply unhide randomly so they cannot just spam a get key. It is actually a simple solution to the current mechanic. Obviously you can unhide by talking, but also I will make a simple /unhide command. I feel like this way it is at LEAST on pair with someone killing it. As they have two actions as well and often will not be spamming the get key, though if someone unhidden is, it's to their benefit as they are UNHIDDEN anyways and everyone is aware that they are there.
Walkers Stuff:
... Instead, the item should bind the player to the ground for 30 seconds ...
Drop Stealing:
... How about you should have to unhide first to get an item, which would mean you are doing two actions...
Both of those ideas sound good.
Remember the Fade spell though (with regards to the drop stealing).
Crafting doesn't need the AQ system. I mean, we already do crafting with scripts, it's the same thing, just change blank scrolls with scales, and the actual scroll created with an item created.
I disagree with 'Dragon Scales' as a general thing. Crimson Dragon should drop Crimson Scales. All the weapons do something differently. Dragon Scales however COULD be a general drop that is needed for all the items and all dragons drop it, and then crimson scales could be the additional add but I don't really think that's needed. I'd rather just have more crimson scales drop for grabbing.
I don't know how I feel about the locking room. I 'can' do this, but is it the best option? You shift the drop stealing from a thief who was sitting there now to who the largest guild is in the room currently. I think it's better BUT I again see issues with it. Yes Folder, there is always going to be a big clan in all situations but we don't need to cator to them if we can avoid it. They already get bonuses by being large in events and other things.
IF we do go the locking root, part of me feels that locking the room completely is a bad lore idea. Instead, the item should bind the player to the ground for 30 seconds, lets say as he/she works on picking it up and it's heavy or that a special force surrounds them as they get it. I don't really know, but it would be that only the player getting the item is bound. They can still fight/heal though. I only wanna prevent movement, not full para.
This means that you'd actively have to hold the item for 30 seconds to obtain it. So if someone drops it, another has to attempt to pick it up and deal with the 30 second bind. Obviously when you are binded, party moving won't work. This ain't ROK right. The negative with this however is if you drop it and pick it up elsewhere it will bind you for 30 seconds as its a general script and I can't really do flags on items like that. However, I can ensure that if you drop it in a safe area like a city that isn't imposed. I don't see people dropping the scales on the floor anyways, that would probably be stupid.
So to sum up what I'm thinking via what everyone has been talking about for a mix/match system.
World Walker/World Walker Drop Changes
1. Scales would drop instead, more then one. Makes a market.
2. Picking up a scale in a unsafe area will bind you to the room for 30 seconds.
3. Multiple scales are needed to make an item.
4. Instead of having a boss that takes 2 months to kill, it can be more like 1-2 weeks. Because we use scales now, it could take a 2-4 crimson kills to actually make one item. AKA we can balance the items via its HP and amount of scales needed. Obviously these items should be tougher to obtain so we need a time to earn one item. I think it needs to be high as these items are generally 'radiant oads with teeth'. We don't need to reduce the time though, but people might attack it more and it might become more competitive if they see the HP dropping more often then not. What is a good time?
I think we can avoid the weird names and keep them general if we have the bind in a room for 30 seconds bit.
Here is a drop stealing mechanic for general items I want to do, how would people feel about this:
Right now to get an item it unhides you. This is a step in the right direction but maybe we need to be more harsh. How about you should have to unhide first to get an item, which would mean you are doing two actions, which is a delay. Is that a good idea on top to help with drop stealing in general (because obviously in other areas we won't do this dragon scale thing everywhere, would be annoying.)
I think this also makes it so a player cannot spam, they have to TIME their drop steal for when its about to die. They cannot simply unhide randomly so they cannot just spam a get key. It is actually a simple solution to the current mechanic. Obviously you can unhide by talking, but also I will make a simple /unhide command. I feel like this way it is at LEAST on pair with someone killing it. As they have two actions as well and often will not be spamming the get key, though if someone unhidden is, it's to their benefit as they are UNHIDDEN anyways and everyone is aware that they are there.
How about Thieves/Brigs get a reduction in the bind or immune to it completely, since they lack fighting capabilities for the most part.
Having them immune to it completely makes the system completely worthless. The people who 'are' drop stealing are assassins and thieves.
Give them longer death exh.
Give them longer death exh.
I totally agree with this - but for all 25ers.
Fear is good.