pk ideas thread
An archived conversation. New replies are closed.
I have a small idea (well a guildy did) that could be beneficial and might be easy to implement. What about the pot timer being adjusted by LEVEL. Lower levels (16) can use potions faster cooldown time then the higher your level is it continues to rise in time between pots until it hits 25. This way people being attacked have an opportunity to slam some potions to stay alive. EG. Level 16 5 seconds between potions. Level 25 15 seconds between potions. (I don't know what it is now I'm just making an example)
I have a small idea (well a guildy did) that could be beneficial and might be easy to implement. What about the pot timer being adjusted by LEVEL. Lower levels (16) can use potions faster cooldown time then the higher your level is it continues to rise in time between pots until it hits 25. This way people being attacked have an opportunity to slam some potions to stay alive. EG. Level 16 5 seconds between potions. Level 25 15 seconds between potions. (I don't know what it is now I'm just making an example)
I get you here but this doesn't help. Faster cooldown times won't save you and I don't want that. It can be abused and it's a real weird way of doing things I feel. A level 16 is going to get rounded anyways normally by two level 25ers. I don't think the issue is the death itself, everyones gonna get PK'd. There needs to be a limit or perhaps EXP loss prevention or something.. Though this doesn't solve the mass pking itself for example.
Again it's really hard to balance though. There won't be a /nopk thing, I think that's goofy too for a PK game.
Edit: Deleting 3 posts already.
XP Loss prevention is a good idea. After you get pked x amount of times it turns off xp loss. Possibly the same with dropping gold. This idea very good <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" /> Then the do nothing but pk all day people like tyrargo could continue and be happy and the people who want to play the actual game and enjoy the pve aspects could as well.
XP Loss prevention is a good idea. After you get pked x amount of times it turns off xp loss. Possibly the same with dropping gold. This idea very good <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_cool.gif" alt="8-)" title="Cool" /> Then the do nothing but pk all day people like tyrargo could continue and be happy and the people who want to play the actual game and enjoy the pve aspects could as well.
Theres an issue on how it's dealt with though.
For example, is it clan based, is it an overall thing, etc. It's hard to balance it if its an overall thing, and I don't think it should be either. If one guild kills you 2 times, and another guild kills you 2 times, I don't see that being wrong.
The pkers not going to know if you are losing xp or not (unless they have killed you the x amount of times to trigger it) So it wouldn't matter how many people from how many different guilds kills you, you aren't going to care because you aren't losing xp and they aren't going to know or care they just want the "thrill of the kill" or whatever drops/gold. I mean its tough and I hate to even be talking about it I understand its a pk game nobody thinks I get that and it makes me lol... Its the harassment of certain people constantly by certain people. Maybe we hire a ember online mediator/counselor lol...
We've now developed an interesting situation where people WANT to get PKd so they can go to staff and get someone banned for it.
Lessening the XP loss could be a thing, but end of the day I really think people need to toughen up. IMO Ember would be pretty damn boring without the risk of being killed when you are outside cities, so I don't think we should do anything to curb PKing further. I think the game needs that feeling of danger.
People can group up, they can run (save stam if you feel you must), they can level in lesser traveled areas, they can call for help as needed. Get a 25er guildie to help you out if PKers are hunting. You can do things to minimize how much you are PKd.
Or people can just throw themselves at PKers and try to get them banned, cause that's a thing now I guess <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" />.
Lessening the XP loss could be a thing, but end of the day I really think people need to toughen up. IMO Ember would be pretty damn boring without the risk of being killed when you are outside cities, so I don't think we should do anything to curb PKing further. I think the game needs that feeling of danger.
People can group up, they can run (save stam if you feel you must), they can level in lesser traveled areas, they can call for help as needed. Get a 25er guildie to help you out if PKers are hunting. You can do things to minimize how much you are PKd.
Or people can just throw themselves at PKers and try to get them banned, cause that's a thing now I guess <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" />.
funny thing is nobody wants to get anyone banned they just want to be left alone so they can enjoy the game. and toughen up? cmon... I had one ufc comment once you tried to get me banned for it lol. also everytime anyone logs a 25er after getting pked, the pkers bring entire guild. and yes I admit your guild is much bigger than ours, you win #winning. so we cant bring an army to defend, just cant do it, is not the people to do it!
I'm exiting this conversation right now don't worry. I know when jake comes to argue I just lose and/or get banned.
I do hope this thread can be productive though, at least its in the open now.
I do hope this thread can be productive though, at least its in the open now.
We've now developed an interesting situation where people WANT to get PKd so they can go to staff and get someone banned for it.
Lessening the XP loss could be a thing, but end of the day I really think people need to toughen up. IMO Ember would be pretty damn boring without the risk of being killed when you are outside cities, so I don't think we should do anything to curb PKing further. I think the game needs that feeling of danger.
People can group up, they can run (save stam if you feel you must), they can level in lesser traveled areas, they can call for help as needed. Get a 25er guildie to help you out if PKers are hunting. You can do things to minimize how much you are PKd.
Or people can just throw themselves at PKers and try to get them banned, cause that's a thing now I guess <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" />.
Unfortunately the way I see it is that if the PKers are staying in one area is their call. Just because someone is running around them doesn't mean they need to die. The PKers choose to stay in one area and as long as the person getting killed doesn't agress, that's pretty much life, again they can move. I will make a /ignore that works with all chat though, that would probably be a good idea.
The rules are the rules, regardless of how it's dealt with.
I think it's a bit easy to say they can be defended though. I think if they were to bring 2-3 guys, a larger guild would counter it and kill them. Perfectly fine, but what I'm saying is it's hard to defend when you're the small fry. How do you toughen up if your killed 4 times in 15 minutes? What if that constantly happened to newbies every hour, do you truly think they would continue to play the game if they lost more XP than they made and couldn't step outside without being hunted every hour?
I fully agree that there needs to be a threat, and people crying about one or two deaths, who cares. There SHOULD be danger, there SHOULD be loss, but what I'm saying is, how much loss will make a new player stop playing the game? At what point is it excessive? What if all your guildies kill one guy twice per hour, and you have lets say 15 guild mates, is that fair?
And I'm not making a attack, I'm actually being serious. What is too much? There needs to be some sort of rules. New players cannot be killed endlessly. It's not fair to them if they can never progress. You can go into an arena for a little while, but ultimately that can be boring if you can never leave a city.
We've now developed an interesting situation where people WANT to get PKd so they can go to staff and get someone banned for it.
Lessening the XP loss could be a thing, but end of the day I really think people need to toughen up. IMO Ember would be pretty damn boring without the risk of being killed when you are outside cities, so I don't think we should do anything to curb PKing further. I think the game needs that feeling of danger.
People can group up, they can run (save stam if you feel you must), they can level in lesser traveled areas, they can call for help as needed. Get a 25er guildie to help you out if PKers are hunting. You can do things to minimize how much you are PKd.
Or people can just throw themselves at PKers and try to get them banned, cause that's a thing now I guess <img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_rolleyes.gif" alt=":roll:" title="Rolling Eyes" />.
Nobody wants to get pk'd on purpose, if there's a quest line in a certain town chances are you need to level or complete said quests in that area so really it isn't that hard to find someone.
I don't like to run when someone is trying to pk me unless its to heal so I can actually fight back but when there are two people hunting you in the same area that makes it a bit difficult.
Some of us are still fairly new and are trying to train up different classes, enjoy the game a little bit.
This is very hard when the same people are chasing you around all the time, I did most of the things you suggested, started lvling in GY was pkd so went to another town and was followed there.
The rule says you can pk someone up to 3 times in one hour, that doesn't mean you have to.
The rule says you can pk someone up to 3 times in one hour, that doesn't mean you have to.
Aha, and this is the other side of it. It also doesn't mean they cannot. (Tis why we have rules, if its under this, its life as such. And the reason why we should see about something else so less staff interaction is needed but the threat of being PKed and Loss is still there to a point.)
run for town thats funny when you may be lvling near ark and the pker sits outside the shop bank or temple and attacks you just as you leave and who the hell willing wants to lose 2 mil experience everytime they get killed exspecially if they are say 10 mil from 25 dont worry only comment im making cuz i dont wish to get banned and im sure this post wont be here long
run for town thats funny when you may be lvling near ark and the pker sits outside the shop bank or temple and attacks you just as you leave and who the hell willing wants to lose 2 mil experience everytime they get killed exspecially if they are say 10 mil from 25 dont worry only comment im making cuz i dont wish to get banned and im sure this post wont be here long
I was going to delete your comment but it's only borderline dumb.
Who cares if they are 1mil to level 25 and die to a PKer. That is IMO, life if it was under the rules. Losing XP is life in the game. Again, the amount you should lose, lets say per hour, is up for discussion, or another method of prevention so it's not exactly unfair for the pk'd
There are also other areas people can level in. There is no way one pker can kill someone fast enough if they run past them, even if they are camping right outside. A level 24 or 23 alt isn't going to insta-die to a level 25er.
I feel like one side is going too carebear and thinks the game has to be baby mode, and the other side is going 'I'm going to slaughter the whole world with a rusty butterknife'.
run for town thats funny when you may be lvling near ark and the pker sits outside the shop bank or temple and attacks you just as you leave and who the hell willing wants to lose 2 mil experience everytime they get killed exspecially if they are say 10 mil from 25 dont worry only comment im making cuz i dont wish to get banned and im sure this post wont be here long
I was going to delete your comment but it's only borderline dumb.
Who cares if they are 1mil to level 25 and die to a PKer. That is IMO, life if it was under the rules. Losing XP is life in the game. Again, the amount you should lose, lets say per hour, is up for discussion, or another method of prevention so it's not exactly unfair for the pk'd
There are also other areas people can level in. There is no way one pker can kill someone fast enough if they run past them, even if they are camping right outside. A level 24 or 23 alt isn't going to insta-die to a level 25er.
I feel like one side is going too carebear and thinks the game has to be baby mode, and the other side is going 'I'm going to slaughter the whole world with a rusty butterknife'.
excuse me this morning i turned in a quest and left the shop before i could hit the south button i was killed by a pker that fast also that is an in acurate statement when the pker i have been being annoyed by is backstabbing me for 500+ each hit and i only have say 900 health at 23 or 24 ... and i was refering to who is going to deliberately try and get pked when only 10 mil from 25 ... and yes i have been pked at 1 mil away hell ive even been pked as i was going to guild to lvl but again i am done talking
The rule says you can pk someone up to 3 times in one hour, that doesn't mean you have to.
Aha, and this is the other side of it. It also doesn't mean they cannot. (Tis why we have rules, if its under this, its life as such. And the reason why we should see about something else so less staff interaction is needed but the threat of being PKed and Loss is still there to a point.)
What I meant by that was and I'm going to use an example for this, lets say you and your buddies are going to a dance bar but you can't dance, so you don't but after you have a few beer you forget that you can't dance so do it anyway.
Now when I say you can't dance i mean your really terrible at it and shouldnt.
Never mind that doesnt make any sense, or does it?
Yeah, maybe less exp loss per death or something like that. First death whatever the exp loss is now, 2nd death 75% of that, 3rd 25%?
To me its not about the exp loss as much as not being able to defend yourself at lower levels, maybe this could be fixed with higher hp pots .
Another thing i noticed when lvling a caster, you cant use a hp pot after taking a mana pot and vice versa, maybe there's a way of tweeking that, probably be good for people who have guards /protecting low lvls.
I wouldn't mind an exp loss cut off. I PK a lot in the game, as I did in RoK. I enjoy tracking people, sneaking around, ect.. It is fun to me. I normally won't kill anyone more than once every few hours unless they goad me into it, then I will kill them twice. My point is, maybe exp loss could be time based. For instance you can't lose exp more than once or twice per hour.
I think limiting pking more would be bad for the game, but taking away some of the penalty might be ok. There still needs to be danger, but it doesn't have to be horridly brutal either. There just needs to be a middle ground in there. I think limiting exp loss by the hour lessens some of the overbearing brutality of being killed multiple times, but keeps the same danger, because you only really have an hour before it can happen again.
Personally I would suggest twice per hour, just because normally that's the max I would kill someone anyways. That suggestion is obviously very biased as it fits my play style lol. Anyways just a suggestion.
Also lower levels have fended me off many times by being in a group lvling. Maybe there could be some kind of grouping system(i.e. a way for players within a certain lvl range to find one another or chat.) It's very rare to round someone on a slayer, it does happen, and is when a pk normally works. It is not that common though. When there is a group of at least three lower levels they can usually run me off or outright kill me if I'm not able to flee back into the shadows fast enough lol.
I think limiting pking more would be bad for the game, but taking away some of the penalty might be ok. There still needs to be danger, but it doesn't have to be horridly brutal either. There just needs to be a middle ground in there. I think limiting exp loss by the hour lessens some of the overbearing brutality of being killed multiple times, but keeps the same danger, because you only really have an hour before it can happen again.
Personally I would suggest twice per hour, just because normally that's the max I would kill someone anyways. That suggestion is obviously very biased as it fits my play style lol. Anyways just a suggestion.
Also lower levels have fended me off many times by being in a group lvling. Maybe there could be some kind of grouping system(i.e. a way for players within a certain lvl range to find one another or chat.) It's very rare to round someone on a slayer, it does happen, and is when a pk normally works. It is not that common though. When there is a group of at least three lower levels they can usually run me off or outright kill me if I'm not able to flee back into the shadows fast enough lol.
Ok. I was trying to stay off of this but in regards to your comment NH, How would you like to be followed from area to area? No one has objected the PKing part of this at all, the whole reason it was brought to attention was due to the harassment that is dealt with when someone follows you from area to area and within say 10 minutes of the 3PKs in an hour rule your killed twice more, because they love to follow you when you decide to fight back they log off said character while your hunting them. So this is a suggestion, how about you put in a timer that doesn't allow said person following you to log off immediately after the last PK? I say this, because as I have stated said people will log off just to avoid being hunted back by a 25er.
excuse me this morning i turned in a quest and left the shop before i could hit the south button i was killed by a pker that fast also that is an in acurate statement when the pker i have been being annoyed by is backstabbing me for 500+ each hit and i only have say 900 health at 23 or 24 ... and i was refering to who is going to deliberately try and get pked when only 10 mil from 25 ... and yes i have been pked at 1 mil away hell ive even been pked as i was going to guild to lvl but again i am done talking
If you had 900HP health how did you die to one backstab at 500HP? You must of been moving slow enough for him to attack you a second time. In the end though you did choose to level there too.
Another thing i noticed when lvling a caster, you cant use a hp pot after taking a mana pot and vice versa, maybe there's a way of tweeking that, probably be good for people who have guards /protecting low lvls.
Yeah, thats how it will stay too. It would be a bit too unbalanced otherwise I feel. Higher pots would just benefit level 25'ers though and then in level 25 vs level 25 fights it would go on forever, even more so then it could now. I get where you are coming from but both solutions aren't good ones to prevent anything.
I wouldn't mind an exp loss cut off. I PK a lot in the game, as I did in RoK. I enjoy tracking people, sneaking around, ect.. It is fun to me. I normally won't kill anyone more than once every few hours unless they goad me into it, then I will kill them twice. My point is, maybe exp loss could be time based. For instance you can't lose exp more than once or twice per hour.
I think limiting pking more would be bad for the game, but taking away some of the penalty might be ok. There still needs to be danger, but it doesn't have to be horridly brutal either. There just needs to be a middle ground in there. I think limiting exp loss by the hour lessens some of the overbearing brutality of being killed multiple times, but keeps the same danger, because you only really have an hour before it can happen again.
Personally I would suggest twice per hour, just because normally that's the max I would kill someone anyways. That suggestion is obviously very biased as it fits my play style lol. Anyways just a suggestion.
I agree, I don't want to make it fluff mode, but there does need to be a limit to loss. A person shouldn't lose 10 million in 20 minutes, that's a kick in the teeth and we know people will kill everyone, including newbies. Some sort of middle ground is what I'm after if we do go the XP adjustments route.
Ok. I was trying to stay off of this but in regards to your comment NH, How would you like to be followed from area to area? No one has objected the PKing part of this at all, the whole reason it was brought to attention was due to the harassment that is dealt with when someone follows you from area to area and within say 10 minutes of the 3PKs in an hour rule your killed twice more, because they love to follow you when you decide to fight back they log off said character while your hunting them. So this is a suggestion, how about you put in a timer that doesn't allow said person following you to log off immediately after the last PK? I say this, because as I have stated said people will log off just to avoid being hunted back by a 25er.
You are claiming someone has been killed 5 times in an hour by a hunter but without proof. I'm waiting for proof. I don't believe you here. Stalking and tracking are a part of the game though. Surely you can get a friend to fade you if you really need too. Or run through water areas, as they will lose tracking there (Yes! Water removing tracking is a thing.)
The timer thing really doesn't make any sense to me either. There is a timer when you log off, making it so that you can't log off an alt for more then a few seconds to me is really really odd. It doesn't solve anything. Just makes it an annoyance to anyone who kills someone and has to wait 2 minutes to switch to another character. That's how you make a game painful to play IMO. There is a timer if you log off. Regardless it's 10 seconds in an unsafe area. If you keep attacking them, the timer resets. They cannot log off in an area. So if they are leveling, they can't just log off. You or them. I think this is fair enough when it comes to times.
Random point too, I don't think a loss should ever be 0% either. I have a feeling people would come endlessly, but I would think that it would cause people to troll after the third death by being upset. Unless the PKer's simply like killing them and its not a problem, then it would be free game regardless. But even at it's low, it could still have a low effect.
I.E.
Death 1: 100%
Death 2: 100%.
Death 3: 50%
Death 4+: 5-10%.. or 0% depending on what we feel.
But we're just talking about XP atm, maybe there are other things we can do too that could be better. I'm open for ideas. Just remember, dying is apart of the game and there has to be loss to that.
I.E.
Death 1: 100%
Death 2: 100%.
Death 3: 50%
Death 4+: 5-10%.. or 0% depending on what we feel.
But we're just talking about XP atm, maybe there are other things we can do too that could be better. I'm open for ideas. Just remember, dying is apart of the game and there has to be loss to that.
nh you and ppl in game like to use the term carebear it but i will clerify i dont mind the pking hell i could get pked by 10 ppl i wouldnt have as big an issue where i have the big issue is when the same guy or few guys are attacking me all day everyday from time they log on til time they log off is where my complaint comes in for example last week every hr with in 5 to ten minutes of previous time i was killed or ran from a pker he was showing up again and either killed me or i got away and the next hr same thing all freaking day ... cuz most players that i know like to pk will pk a person then go about their day but there are 2 currently kill or not will keep hurassing a target all day and that is what will hurt the game i know i keep saying i wont respond again for fear of ban but im doing my best to keep my calm yet state my point without names or foul language